Ah, what the hell, I'm bored. I'll do a fisking of Sylvia's performance:
Reading #1:
Brown: This lady over here. You've never met me before, have you? [the woman shakes her head "no."] There is a young male in your life that has very, very puppy dog eyes.
So we have a person in her life who is (1) young, (2) male, and (3) has "puppy dog eyes." We never get confirmation on any of these, which means they're probably misses. We can't say for sure, of course, but that's the nature of cold reading: avoid giving the subject a chance to say "no."
Brown: You know what I mean? The eyes droop down at the corners... He is going to come back into your life and then leave your life and come back into your life. This looks like a direct connection to you. He's kinda slender, he's athletic-looking, he has sort of large bones. Ummm, and this is going to cause you a great deal of problems. Do you understand what this is about? Do you understand what I'm saying?
A flurry of stuff here. First, there's the "explanation" of "puppy dog eyes" as being "eyes [that] droop down at the corners." I'm not sure that this is what that phrase means to most people, but I'll give Sylvia the benefit of the doubt and say that it is. Either way, the subject still does not pick up on this.
Second, this person is "
going to come back into your life and then leave your life and come back." The subject will later say that there is a person who
has come back and forth in her life, but is that really a hit? Note that this is a prediction of the future, not a description of something that's already happened -- meaning, of course, that it's unfalsifiable.
Third, this man is "kinda slender, he's athletic-looking, he has sort of large bones." I have no idea what it means to have "large bones." That's usually a euphemism for someone who is heavy-set, in which case it contradicts her claim that he's slender. Sylvia really is covering all the bases here. If the subject is thinking of a man who's slender, she can claim a hit. If she's thinking of a man who's heavy, she can claim a hit on "large bones." If she's thinking of a man who's neither slender nor heavy, she can claim a hit on "athletic-looking."
Fourth, "this is
going to cause you a great deal of problems." Again, note the future tense.
Finally, there's the "Do you understand what this is about? Do you understand what I'm saying?" Sylvia is fishing for feedback here. A lot of people will nod or say "yes" at this point because, yes, they do understand what she's saying, and not because the "reading" is accurate.
Woman #1: Uh-huh. Yes I do.
Brown: And what part?
Woman #1: Umm... The... person coming back and forth and cause problems.
Brown: Who is that to you?
Woman #1: [pause, shakes her head] I think it's somebody I know, I've met recently.
Brown: That keeps coming back and forth. [the woman nods her head "yes."]
Sylvia's fishing has sort of worked, here, in that the subject has picked up on part of the long monologue Sylvia just gave. The subject
thinks that Sylvia is referring to somebody she's met recently who is "coming back and forth and caus[ing] problems."
This is a pretty questionable "hit." First, the subject doesn't sound very sure ("I think it's somebody I know"). Second, the "coming back and forth and causing problems" was supposed to be a prediction for the future, not a description of the past.
And note all the misses! The subject's use of the word "person" suggests to me that the individual she's thinking of is not a man, let alone a young man. No hit on "puppy dog eyes." The subject doesn't even pick up on the "kinda slender, he's athletic-looking, he has sort of large bones" cue. It's no wonder that Sylvia moves on at this point, because this subject isn't helping her out enough.
Summary of reading:
There is a person in the subject's life who is: (1) young, (2) male, (3) has puppy dog eyes (that droop in the corners), (4) is slender, athletic-looking, and/or has sort of large bones.
This person (5) is going to come in and out of the subject's life, and (6) cause problems.
(1) and (2) are so general as to apply to virtually everyone. After all, who doesn't have a young male in his or her life, whether it's a friend, boyfriend, brother, son, nephew, etc.?
(3) is a little more specific, but if the subject has a young male in her life who she loves, she may well believe he has "puppy dog eyes."
(4) is so broad and contradictory that it would cover almost any person.
(5) and (6), as stated above, are non-falsifiable predictions of the future. But they serve a useful purpose for Sylvia in that she may be able to turn them into "hits."
Sylvia was probably expecting the reading to go differently; she probably thought she'd get hits on some of (1) through (4), but the subject didn't take the bait on those. Fortunately for Sylvia, the subject turned Sylvia's predictions of (5) and (6) into descriptions of the past, so Sylvia was able to claim some semblance of victory and move on to a more pliable subject.