StopSylviaBrowne - Emails: Psychic Baiting Browne & Skeptic in the Audience

Exceptional job, as always, Robert.

The "Skeptic in the Audience" article is one of the best and most devestating I've read on your site. I'm assuming this was Eeny, but whoever it was did a fantastic job of revealing exactly why people like Sylvia et al need to be stopped. This woman (and Montel as well, who, in this article, shows himself to be just as much a fraud as Sylvia herself) is engaging in behavior that can clearly cause long-lasting pysical and emotional harm--and due to her nonsensical medical pronouncements, might actually kill.

I applaud you and your correspondents. You're doing noble work! Keep it up!


Agreed. :) Robert did an exceptional job, too. As always.

And thank you very much.

Good work, RSL. Always look forward to your updates. You should do them daily. :D

I second that. :)

Absolutely devastating articles Robert. Hopefully they will lead even more people to question not just SB but all 'psychics' and what they see on television.

Kudos to Eeney. I'm not sure I would have been able to keep my seat and would needed to be physically restrained from keep me leaving.

I agree and I hope so, too.

You have no idea. I was soon asking myself why I ever actually wanted to be there. After about 20 minutes, I couldn't believe I had actually volunteered for what I was doing. Excruciating.

Great articles, Robert, and great job Eeney! Also by the other writer who contributed his/her interesting story about being part of the audience.

I have to say she used to be a lot better about saying what people seemed desperately to need to hear. If Sylvia is going slightly deaf, that might be another reason she's winding up the lecture tour this year. Since hearing should have nothing at all to do with psychic ability, it might be a little hard to explain to the public that your psychic ability doesn't work so good when you can't hear! :rolleyes:

Thanks! It got so bad and so many reading were so badly botched, where the answer was almost in the question and she could have just simply said "yes" and not even used cold-reading, that I almost wanted to take over.

Great job, EMM and Robert!
Montel's producers would not have eaten the expense of losing an episode without good reason. They must have truly feared the embarrassment of having Sylvia blatantly exposed by JREF skeptics. After all, look what Randi did in Project Alpha, Carlos, etc.

Thanks! I think so, too. In my opinion, even with the trainwreck readings of the studio audience, there was more than enough to make an episode.

The guests all had successful readings and there were enough readings that she didn't botch. There was no moment or reading that was impressive to me but they could have scrapped together a good enough episode.

EMM's email was great. I remember reading much of the account before and I liked the mention of the odd coincidence that it was also Nancy Williams' show, too.

Thanks! I believe Nancy's was actually a few hours later...and yeah, I'm really pleased to have found out how I singlehandedly rocked Sylvia's boat but I'm sorry Nancy ended up taking the blame for me. :o

Those were the best articles yet. Despite being anecdotal, I am willing to go out on a limb and say I have full faith in the accuracy of the content.

...

That's only time share, yet anyone with any kind of desire to do something worthwhile in their life would not stay there for a minute. It's degrading for all people involved.

HOW can these people, the camera men, the editors, the producers, Montel, how can they not feel so awfully ashamed working, their careers, in that kind of upsetting and controlled environment? I can't believe anyone could let this go on.

Thanks! I'm very happy to hear that you've gone out on a limb and believed me. :)

I'm obviously biased but I think my article is one of my four or five favorites on the site. I don't think it's the best stylistically by far but I'm very proud of it for the content and the effect.
 
Last edited:
I know what you mean. I mainly inserted the comments into the "Skeptic in the Audience" article as breathers. I wanted to add section headings as well (for the same reasons), but it didn't lend itself to that.

Yeah. :o When I sat down to write it, I had actually intended to be a few paragraphs long...but it sort of kept growing and growing and I kept finding more and more to add.

But I didn't want to leave anything out and you've had longer articles on your site and I was sure that Brownians, fence-sitters and skeptics alike would be willing to read every word and the space and time would be well spent for them.

As it is, it's short for a three hour-or-so experience. If I were to have even faithfully enough written down everything that I saw and heard, Robert would still be reading it. I mean, she must have given individual readings to what, somewhere in the vicinity of 200 people?
 
Great articles, especially the "skeptic in the audience" one. Eeney's account was very thorough and at parts, gutwrenching. I realize that there are so many desperate people there hoping for real help and comfort but until I pondered that that would be almost the entire audience it hadn't hit me how very heavy and sad the atmosphere would truly be.

About Montel's show going away I am rather surprised. When I tune in to the Sylvia Wednesday's I see all the commercials touting how caring and what a difference Montel has made for over 16 years and it seems they are trying to keep his show at the top (if it is there, I don't know). And they are really pushing his "Living Well" series of books and videos. I wasn't expecting to see him take down his shingle, so to speak. But I can't help but :D:D:D
 
Great articles, especially the "skeptic in the audience" one. Eeney's account was very thorough and at parts, gutwrenching. I realize that there are so many desperate people there hoping for real help and comfort but until I pondered that that would be almost the entire audience it hadn't hit me how very heavy and sad the atmosphere would truly be.

Thank you Minarvia, that means alot.

Take my word for it, don't plant yourself at one of those things. You'll regret it very quickly. Not only is it one of the most depressing events you can imagine, but it's also excruciatingly boring. Cold reading is only "cool" if you either believe in psychic powers or if the person performing it is very good at it. Otherwise, it's an endless and very slow Q and A.

I'm actually amazed at Jon Ronson for sticking it out for 5 days (is that right?). If I were alone and in the middle of the ocean with Sylvia Browne and her "clients", I'd have jumped ship the first day.

As a matter of fact, reading the other one, I now regret I didn't make a scene and get myself thrown out.

Edit:

I submitted my account to the webmaster of BadPsychics.com and he put it up as a front page article few days ago. I forgot to ask him to withhold my name and he didn't think of it himself and I guess the cat's out of the bag now. Safe to say I won't be asked back to another Sylvia Browne Wednesday now.

Note to self: I must compare notes with Rebecca, since I think either she or someone writing on her blog once planted themselves at a Sylvia Browne lecture.
 
Last edited:
Since I've already broken a nearly ten year long record of lurking around these forums I might as well post some long overdue praise. :)

To Mr Lancaster.
Ever since the start of your StopKaz site I've been keeping an eye on your efforts. And over the years you've stood as a firm, rational and well spoken counterweight against the nearly unopposed claims of two well known and influential "psychics". To completely honest I don't know what I've come to admire the most when it comes to your work.

Your sheer mental endurance is something I greatly envy, because I'm sure there have been moments your project has felt like a thankless chore, especially considering the relentless endorsements from those who chose to believe the claims of Kaz and Sylvia.

But all things considered I think what I've come to like the most it is the humble and honest way you've chosen to approach those that doubt. You always welcomed opposing views, stating over and over that solid, verifiable, evidence is all that's needed to change your mind. And that is the genius of it, no? For if they actually possess the powers they claim to wield providing such proof would require very little effort indeed.

You have my thanks, for what it's worth, as an inspired science journalist and greatly entertained reader. Though it might feel like a small candle in a long night, it shows well the nature of candles and how make them shine.

To EenyMinnieMoe.
After reading "A Skeptic in the Audience" I think it's safe bet that your bloody amazing, full stop. If I could reach through the lengths of the net and hand you a cold beer and/or a cookie I would, because you earned them. Heck! You've earned a whole box. That session must have felt like... well I have no idea what to compare it to really.
 
Last edited:
To EenyMinnieMoe.
After reading "A Skeptic in the Audience" I think it's safe bet that your bloody amazing, full stop. If I could reach through the lengths of the net and hand you a cold beer and/or a cookie I would, because you earned them. Heck! You've earned a whole box. That session must have felt like... well I have no idea what to compare it to really.

Thank you :blush:. Hold that thought for perhaps someday at one of the TAMs? :D

It was like...no, I can't compare it to anything, either. My worst days at least favorite job don't compare.

I'd throw some credit back at Robert. It was his site and his efforts that inspired me and gave me the drive in the first place and all of my work would be useless if he didn't provide a forum.

And as thankless and depressing as my work can sometimes be and as awful as it is to have to constantly soak my head in Sylvia Browne, I remind myself that he's the one who's had to watch Montel every week for the past year! Not to mention read all of her books and spend all his free time on her.

That was you doing the baiting???? :eye-poppi

Oh no, I was the "Skeptic in the Audience". :o
 
Great articles, Robert. It was an honor to shake your hand this weekend, and your talk was informative, inspiring, and hilarious!

Eeney, thanks for that detailed account. I've considered using my TV connections to try to get into the Montel audience on Sylvia days, but honestly I don't know if I could sit through that without screaming obscenities.
 
Last edited:
Excellent articles as always RSL.

There is just one small thing. If you were the reason they stopped filming Montel then doesn't that mean you have shot yourself in the foot? How else will you get new information on SB?
 
Great stuff, Robert!

It's too bad that "psychic baiting" won't get past the editors. I think the only way to make it work would be to make your own video. Show what you plan to ask the psychic (say, about your non-existent uncle Merv); go to the Montel show and ask the question (and get the answer); then show the clip on your video. Just a thought.
 
Great stuff, Robert!

It's too bad that "psychic baiting" won't get past the editors. I think the only way to make it work would be to make your own video. Show what you plan to ask the psychic (say, about your non-existent uncle Merv); go to the Montel show and ask the question (and get the answer); then show the clip on your video. Just a thought.

This would not be true if your uncle Merv did exist and everything you said was right. But your response to anything she said would be to say something like 'right' or 'Is that so?' Neither confirming nor denying what she said. It would also be OK to ask for more details. Say nothing that is either a lie nor say anything that says you are a skeptic.

When you are shown on TV then send the clip to Robert with your comments. He will know what to do. I think Robert said this somewhere.
 
Interesting read.

I am struck by an underlying theme that resonates in both pieces, namely, the lack of good faith on the part of Browne's "enablers." It is one thing for Browne to try to sell her drivel as useful knowledge. It is another to enable her to do that. Montel and company would seem to be classic enablers.

The typical defense of an enabler is good faith. "It's not my business to put a stop to it," is an old stand-by excuse of an enabler, as are "I just let the information get out and let the people decide for themselves," "She's just trying to help," and "This is not hurting anyone."

The stories in these two articles, if true, stab the notion of good faith right in the heart.

These stories suggest strongly that Montel and company are not merely enablers, but accomplices, if not full-fledged co-conspirators, in a deliberate and conscous attempt to deceive others and to acquire wealth.

Excuse me while I spit.
 
Last edited:
EMM: I am amazed you managed to sit though that. Just reading some of the accounts on SSB makes me shake my head and laugh. I can't image sitting there, looking amazed for 3 hours. :boggled:

As for the "psychic baiting," I almost jumped out of my chair and cheered when I read
Indeed, I DID have a roommate who worked at the World Trade Center on 9/11, but SHE was out of town on business, HER office was below the impact zone, and furthermore SHE was sitting right next to me during the entire taping, alive and well.

:D
 
EMM: I am amazed you managed to sit though that. Just reading some of the accounts on SSB makes me shake my head and laugh. I can't image sitting there, looking amazed for 3 hours. :boggled:

You have no idea. After about fifteen minutes, I couldn't believe I had actually wanted to and volunteered to be there. You couldn't make me do it again if you paid me by the minute.
 
ALL:

It looks as thought the Tuesday Feb 19th Montel may be the one wich Eeney attended, and described in the email within the "A skeptic in the audience" article.

The commercial for the episode has Browne saying "Who here lost a Kevin?", which is something Eeney described.

By the way, Eeney: Clean out your PM box!
 
It took them, what, a year or so to finally air that episode? Something seems odd about that. I thought for sure it was never going to see the light of day for some bizarre reason known only to the paranoid Browne camp.
 
I just got your email, Robert. I turned on the tube right away and, damn it all, I won't be able to be home when it airs!

I'm guessing someone will be taping it? Granted that it even is the one I saw...
 
Thanks, Lisa. Only, was it an episode where she hawks Psychic Children? Because if not, then it can't be mine.

If it's too much trouble to upload it or send me a DVD, I could read the transcript when it's added to Lexis Nexis.
 
Oh, it's definitely your show, Eeney. She was pushing Psychic Children, there was a segment with a woman seeing an angel, the slightly confused woman with a dark haired man with wavy hair, a dead Kevin (off the top of my head). I'm very curious to hear your account of the aired episode.

The dead Kevin, for example, aired with Sylvia probing the audience, and it looked like several raised their hands (or maybe had them raised to ask a question?). One woman was asked to go to the microphone and Sylvia said something about a head/face injury, the woman acknowledged that, and they agreed he was annoying and that he had a small dog. But I didn't catch if he was an uncle or cousin, since you said one woman had an uncle but Sylvia couldn't get any good hits, but the cousin Kevin worked better. I get the impression they edited out the first woman entirely, and made it seem like it was a perfect display by Sylvia.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom