EeneyMinnieMoe
Philosopher
- Joined
- Feb 11, 2007
- Messages
- 7,221
Exceptional job, as always, Robert.
The "Skeptic in the Audience" article is one of the best and most devestating I've read on your site. I'm assuming this was Eeny, but whoever it was did a fantastic job of revealing exactly why people like Sylvia et al need to be stopped. This woman (and Montel as well, who, in this article, shows himself to be just as much a fraud as Sylvia herself) is engaging in behavior that can clearly cause long-lasting pysical and emotional harm--and due to her nonsensical medical pronouncements, might actually kill.
I applaud you and your correspondents. You're doing noble work! Keep it up!
Agreed.
And thank you very much.
Good work, RSL. Always look forward to your updates. You should do them daily.![]()
I second that.
Absolutely devastating articles Robert. Hopefully they will lead even more people to question not just SB but all 'psychics' and what they see on television.
Kudos to Eeney. I'm not sure I would have been able to keep my seat and would needed to be physically restrained from keep me leaving.
I agree and I hope so, too.
You have no idea. I was soon asking myself why I ever actually wanted to be there. After about 20 minutes, I couldn't believe I had actually volunteered for what I was doing. Excruciating.
Great articles, Robert, and great job Eeney! Also by the other writer who contributed his/her interesting story about being part of the audience.
I have to say she used to be a lot better about saying what people seemed desperately to need to hear. If Sylvia is going slightly deaf, that might be another reason she's winding up the lecture tour this year. Since hearing should have nothing at all to do with psychic ability, it might be a little hard to explain to the public that your psychic ability doesn't work so good when you can't hear!![]()
Thanks! It got so bad and so many reading were so badly botched, where the answer was almost in the question and she could have just simply said "yes" and not even used cold-reading, that I almost wanted to take over.
Great job, EMM and Robert!
Montel's producers would not have eaten the expense of losing an episode without good reason. They must have truly feared the embarrassment of having Sylvia blatantly exposed by JREF skeptics. After all, look what Randi did in Project Alpha, Carlos, etc.
Thanks! I think so, too. In my opinion, even with the trainwreck readings of the studio audience, there was more than enough to make an episode.
The guests all had successful readings and there were enough readings that she didn't botch. There was no moment or reading that was impressive to me but they could have scrapped together a good enough episode.
EMM's email was great. I remember reading much of the account before and I liked the mention of the odd coincidence that it was also Nancy Williams' show, too.
Thanks! I believe Nancy's was actually a few hours later...and yeah, I'm really pleased to have found out how I singlehandedly rocked Sylvia's boat but I'm sorry Nancy ended up taking the blame for me.
Those were the best articles yet. Despite being anecdotal, I am willing to go out on a limb and say I have full faith in the accuracy of the content.
...
That's only time share, yet anyone with any kind of desire to do something worthwhile in their life would not stay there for a minute. It's degrading for all people involved.
HOW can these people, the camera men, the editors, the producers, Montel, how can they not feel so awfully ashamed working, their careers, in that kind of upsetting and controlled environment? I can't believe anyone could let this go on.
Thanks! I'm very happy to hear that you've gone out on a limb and believed me.
I'm obviously biased but I think my article is one of my four or five favorites on the site. I don't think it's the best stylistically by far but I'm very proud of it for the content and the effect.
Last edited:

. Hold that thought for perhaps someday at one of the TAMs? 