StopSylviaBrowne - Email: "What Sylvia Told My Grandma"

Absolutely despicable. She singlehandedly broke up many relationships.

Why do psychics insist on telling people very bad or upsetting things about themselves or their families? Not just Sylvia Browne, allthough she is among the worst, but all sorts of other "psychics".

The one and only time I went to a fortune-teller, I was told I'd never get married and that I'd have children out of wedlock. Incidentally, I actually did fear that I'd be an "old maid" ; the palm reader somehow must have somehow intuited that she was dealing with two insecure 15-year-olds with low self-confidence and instantly zeroed in on that.

Exploiting peoples' weaknesses. Nothing more despicable.
 
Robert is careful to explain that the e-mail is second or third-hand information.

Personally, I don't think she was as "horrible" back then. However, she did say things exactly like this woman reported, even then. In fact, something similar happened to a member of my own family with Sylvia, though I'm not supposed to talk about it. And my family member still believes what Sylvia said. I suppose if you've based half a lifetime of major decisions on the words of a psychic it is very hard to consider the psychic is not real.

So, regardless, careless statements thrown out, even if not intentionally cruel, can have cruel and tragic consequences. I'm glad this correspondent shared her grandmother's experience.

To the best of my knowledge, Sylvia claims she gets no help from Francine with her readings and describes her psychic ability as pretty much just saying the first thing that pops into her head, though I have heard her claim to see deceased loved ones standing behind people.
 
Arguing about it is fun, but not much point since we have few real facts to debate.

And yeah, I think she is a vomitous cow that gives no milk :)
 
Apparently, Francine resides in the backside of Sylvia's nether regions, because that is where she seems to be pulling her information from.


I really think this would have made an exceptionally accurate and helpful book review on Amazon.
 
I agree that SB has no psychic abilities and that she shouldn't say hurtful things.
I just wonder what the exchange was between and SB and Grandma. I've heard it said lots of times when you get a cold reading that you readily grasp the things that strike a chord with you while you shuffle the ones that miss into your mental waste paper basket.

The way I see it SB has no right to tell anyone something like that. I could have a friend who's partner was cheating on her and I knew this first hand but I still wouldn't tell her. (I've actually been in that situation and I couldn't say anything). So a total stranger spouting this out after taking your precious money is the lowest of the low.
 
Is it part of Sylvia's "shows" in front of audiences to give someone a negative reading? The true believers would look at the negative readings as further proof of her abilities...no one could be so cruel if they were a fake.

Robert, at the Excalibur show you attended, did anyone get the negative reading?
 
Is it part of Sylvia's "shows" in front of audiences to give someone a negative reading? The true believers would look at the negative readings as further proof of her abilities...no one could be so cruel if they were a fake.
Not everyone's life is coming up roses all the time (to coin a phrase).

The occasional "negative" reading makes her seem more real, more believable. If she had nothing but good news, all the time, over time it would become unbelievable.
 
Not everyone's life is coming up roses all the time (to coin a phrase).

The occasional "negative" reading makes her seem more real, more believable. If she had nothing but good news, all the time, over time it would become unbelievable.


True, but I think it is enough when you say someone's missing 9 year old daughter is a sex slave in Japan, or something to that effect.
 
That's what I suspect: she gives negative readings for, yes, no other reason than variety.

This is also the reason she makes some missing children and adults dead, some living, some living but brainwashed, some living but amnesiac, some living but having run away and abandoned their spouses and children and some living in sexual slavery in Japan. :mad:

Unbelievable.

And, to a lesser extent, she gives negative readings for a dramatic effect.

That and the fact that when you zero in on and exploit someone's insecurity, loneliness, suspiciousness, uncertainty or paranoia, they are very likely to believe you. In fact, it helps creates the illusion of psychic powers, since you seem to be so psychic about their life and state of mind.
 
Last edited:
That's what I suspect: she gives negative readings for, yes, no other reason than variety.

This is also the reason she makes some missing children and adults dead, some living, some living but brainwashed, some living but amnesiac, some living but having run away and abandoned their spouses and children and some living in sexual slavery in Japan. :mad:

Unbelievable.

And, to a lesser extent, she gives negative readings for a dramatic effect.

That and the fact that when you zero in on and exploit someone's insecurity, loneliness, suspiciousness, uncertainty or paranoia, they are very likely to believe you. In fact, it helps creates the illusion of psychic powers, since you seem to be so psychic about their life and state of mind.
Part of her "psychic draw" is disclosing unknown secrets.

Or put another way, it is called "entertainment"...where you make things up that can not possibly be disproved, especially to those that just blindly believe the crap SB spews (now THAT is quite the visual).
 
Part of her "psychic draw" is disclosing unknown secrets.

Or put another way, it is called "entertainment"...where you make things up that can not possibly be disproved, especially to those that just blindly believe the crap SB spews (now THAT is quite the visual).


Disgusting. Absolutely disgusting. If she hadn't already pulled that "your father is not your father" stunt, I'd hardly believe someone could do something so despicable for "entertainment".

Besides the fact that she's trampling on the good name of someone who can't defend her- or himself and destroying their spouse's and children's good memories of them, she's humiliating these poor people by "revealing secrets" to them in front of hundreds of people, all for a cheap thrill.

Edit: Robert, if you talk to your correspondent again, could you forward my sympathies?
 
Last edited:
Disgusting. Absolutely disgusting. If she hadn't already pulled that "your father is not your father" stunt, I'd hardly believe someone could do something so despicable for "entertainment".

Besides the fact that she's trampling on the good name of someone who can't defend her- or himself and destroying their spouse's and children's good memories of them, she's humiliating these poor people by "revealing secrets" to them in front of hundreds of people, all for a cheap thrill.

Edit: Robert, if you talk to your correspondent again, could you forward my sympathies?
Disgusting it is.

The "your father was not your father" for example; short of exhuming the body and performing DNA testing there is NO way to prove SB was wrong.

Or in this case...there is absolutely nothing to prove this affair didn't happen. Even if grandpa were alive and denied it...so?

This type of deception is, in my opinion, a key tool in the perfect scam.

I'd venture to guess she discloses makes up stuff like this rather frequently in her shows/appearances.
 
Disgusting it is.

The "your father was not your father" for example; short of exhuming the body and performing DNA testing there is NO way to prove SB was wrong.

Or in this case...there is absolutely nothing to prove this affair didn't happen. Even if grandpa were alive and denied it...so?
This type of deception is, in my opinion, a key tool in the perfect scam.

I'd venture to guess she discloses makes up stuff like this rather frequently in her shows/appearances.

This is particulaly true in this case because she happened to get a hit on a name. Even if grandpa was around to defend himself, the obvious response would be: "Well, if she's not psychic, and she didn't know what you've been up to, how did she know so-and-so's name?"

The woman is beneath contempt.
 
I check here every day to see if there is a new article up SSB and am always excited when there is. I find my reaction strange because the articles almost always make me depressed, and this one is one of the most depressing I have read.
I think that SSB is one of the most important sites on the web. I tell everyone I know about it and am happy to report that at least one believer I sent there has changed her mind. Not only does she not think Sylvia Browne is psychic, but she no longer believes in psychics at all!
 
I check here every day to see if there is a new article up SSB and am always excited when there is. I find my reaction strange because the articles almost always make me depressed, and this one is one of the most depressing I have read.
I think that SSB is one of the most important sites on the web. I tell everyone I know about it and am happy to report that at least one believer I sent there has changed her mind. Not only does she not think Sylvia Browne is psychic, but she no longer believes in psychics at all!

You should join the SSB mailing list.
 
Nothing really to add here, just more outrage. Breaking up a close friendship, tearing a family apart, defiling the memory of a deceased loved one ... par for the course, I guess.
 
Haha, maybe you are right.

Perhaps I just have trouble believing that anybody could believe in that sort of crud to such an extent. Although obviously they do.
 
Please keep up the good work Robert, I recently sent you an e-mail giving my support. I just wish I had another story to tell. :(
Thanks, db. I'm glad you DON'T have another story to tell.

Fortunately, thanks to your hard work, she is being exposed for the fraud she is, and hopefully these stories will become fewer and fewer until she is nothing more than a bad memory. Good job.
Thanks, Empress!

Hmmm, okay this is probably a true story, and I'm certainly not supporting Sylvia, but I have trouble feeling outraged about it unless there is some sort of evidence to confirm it.

[...]

Sorry to be so skeptical.
No need to be sorry at all.

This email, like most of the others on my site, is totally anecdotal. I put them on the site, and generally add the "this is just one person's opinion" disclaimer at the top. With this one, I also added that it was second or third-hand information.

For all we know, none of this ever happened. Grandma might have made it up. The email author might have made it up. Hell, as far as you know, I might have made it up.

Wehenever I get an email like this, I verify anything in it I can. With this one, there was nothing to verify. I do try, both through reading the email, and through follow-up emails with the author, to see if it passes my "sniff test" (which is funny, as I am anosmic).

I put accounts such as this one on the site not because they are concrete evidence of anything. I put them up in an attempt to show some of the human side of the harm that Browne does, and I leave it to the reader to decide how much credence, if any, to give them. Anecdotal or not, for many people, these email articles are the most compelling thing on the site, and are what makes them really look at the evidence in the meatier articles, which do have verifiable evidence in them.

Robert, at the Excalibur show you attended, did anyone get the negative reading?
None that I recall, corey. Definitely nothing of this magnitude.

Edit: Robert, if you talk to your correspondent again, could you forward my sympathies?
Will do.

I check here every day to see if there is a new article up SSB and am always excited when there is. I find my reaction strange because the articles almost always make me depressed, and this one is one of the most depressing I have read.
As My Better Half says, you might want to subscribe to the site updates mailing list!

I think that SSB is one of the most important sites on the web. I tell everyone I know about it and am happy to report that at least one believer I sent there has changed her mind. Not only does she not think Sylvia Browne is psychic, but she no longer believes in psychics at all!
That's great!!

Perhaps I just have trouble believing that anybody could believe in that sort of crud to such an extent. Although obviously they do.
More people than you'd ever imagine, Jonquill.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom