StopSylviaBrowne - Email: "My Reading With Sylvia's Son Chris"

UH. OK. I hate to bust your bubble there Mr. Lancaster. But it clearly states in the email that she was aware of and read your SSB site at the same time she was waiting for her $450.00 phone call. Not only that but listening to Sylvia on the radio and waiting who knows how long on the phone to speak with her on the air.
That should tell you everything you need to know about how effective your SSB site really is.
Nothing written in your site swayed her belief in the dynamic duo one tiny bit.
It wasn't until she had enough first hand contact with them to realize that maybe something wasn't right.

Well, no – her email "clearly states" nothing of the sort. Nowhere does it mention her having any knowledge of Robert's site before her phone call with Dufresne. You seem to have some reading comprehension deficiencies to add to your bag of ... erm ... problems.


email said:
October 2006 finally came and I received a call from Sylvia's office to set up a day and time for my reading with Chris ... When the day came I waited, and waited, and waited. ... Finally, 5 minutes before the end of my two hour window the phone rang. It was a woman from Sylvia's office. She explained that I'd have to reschedule my reading as Chris had an emergency at home ... I rescheduled anyway since they already had my $450. I would wait two weeks. As my day was once again approaching, I came home to find a message on my machine that Chris would not be available to do my reading on the scheduled day and would, once again, need to reschedule. Third time is a charm. The day was finally here. I will now describe how my reading went and what Chris told me.

So, we are not told how long the correspondent had to wait for her second rescheduling. Unless it was considerably longer than the first delay (which she surely would have mentioned) then the reading took place in November 2006.

The first article on Robert's site was added on 27 November 2006.

So, it really would not be possible for Robert's correspondent to have seen the site before her call with Dufresne (leaving aside the fact that she didn't make that claim – you invented it).

Your statement is utterly false, Brattus. What is this about?


Brattus said:
(paraphrasing)
Sylvia Browne's victims are to blame, because they CHOSE to give her their money! They WANT SB to have it!, or alternatively they are gullible, naive or plain stupid
No.

There are a number of reasons, very much more subtle, which some of us would take the trouble to explain to you if we thought there was any chance you were interested in learning.

Brattus said:
(paraphrasing)
... and therefore I am so superior.
No.
 
Everyone has forgotten this http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_thankyoufromsoccermom.shtml
I am frequently asked by people who follow this site whether I believe that the site is really making a difference.

One of the several ways I know that the site is definitely having an impact is through the emails I receive almost daily from people who tell me that the site has helped them to make up their minds about Browne.

These emails are always very satisfying to me, as they show me that the site is doing its job: giving people information about Sylvia Browne, from which they can come to their own conclusion.

In this article I will share some correspondence from one such person.

No need to be upset about Brattus' posts. You should laugh at its stupidity, the ignorance it shows, not to mention the name calling.
 
UH. OK. I hate to bust your bubble there Mr. Lancaster. But it clearly states in the email that she was aware of and read your SSB site at the same time she was waiting for her $450.00 phone call. Not only that but listening to Sylvia on the radio and waiting who knows how long on the phone to speak with her on the air.

That should tell you everything you need to know about how effective your SSB site really is.

Nothing written in your site swayed her belief in the dynamic duo one tiny bit.
Nope, that isn't clear from the email at all.

Here is apparently the timeline of events in the email:

1. A couple of years before July 2006 - buys some Browne books.
2. Jul 2006 - Talks to Browne on the radio show.
3. Jul 2006 - Calls and schedules reading with Dufresne
4. Oct 2006 - Was asked to pick a date/time
5. Later - Scheduled appointment cancelled
6. Two weeks later - 2nd appt rescheduled
7. Later - has phone reading with Dufresne.
8. Mar 2007 - Talks with Browne again on radio show.

The SSB site consisted of nothing but a "COMING SOON" page (still viewable at www.StopSylviaBrowne.com/oldindex.htm) until November 27, 2006, which it opened with three articles.

So she could not have seen the site until after #4 in the above timeline, and it is not clear whether she had seen it even after #8, as all she says regarding when she first saw the site is "I stumbled on your web site quite some time ago."

But for the sake of argument, let's say she had access to reading the entire web site, as it exists today, before making her first phone call.

So what? I have received emails from others who told me that they were angered by what was on my site, but chose not to believe it until they had an experience with Browne or Dufresne, after which the site started making sense to them. They could see the cold-reading techniques, where they had not before. Would they have noticed them if they hadn't read the SSB site? Perhaps, perhaps not.

Sorry Brattus, my bubble doesn't burst that easily.

I was very impressed with your StopKaz site, very well done.
Thank you.

But after reading your SSB site I can come to no other conclusion than it is merely a self indulgent seeking of attention from your groupie base on this forum.
I see. Well, you are certainly welcome to any conclusion you wish. I can no more prove that conclusion wrong than I can other conlusions others have come to, such as that I am jealous of Browne's wonderful abilities, or that I am secretly a minister who dislikes Browne revealing "the truth" about Jesus, or that I am another psychic who is trying to steal Browne's client base.

You've even gotten so desperate for something to write about you have an article concerning whether SB smokes cigarettes or not.
The article is about whether Browne lies or not. The cigarettes are merely evidence of that. There are fans who think that Browne speaks nothing but the truth. If showing her in an obvious lie will help some of those people to re-examine other things she has said, the article has done its job.

But that really doesnt matter because no matter what you write about your JREF groupie base will lavish praise upon the great RSL and his stopping of SB.
I see.

Truth is though you haven't even slowed her down.
And you came to this conclusion how? She has certainly slowed down since the site went up. How much of is because of the site? There is no way of knowing.

Here is something which I mentioned during my presentation at TAM5.5, but which I may not have mentioned on the forum: I have been told that people working Browne's office say that emails to the office have slowed down from "thousands every month" to "a handful every month," and that the people in the office blame it squarely on SSB.com. How accurate that is, I have no idea. But it was interesting to hear.

If she was some kind of master cold reader or master showman I could then kind of understand a little how some people might get sucked into her BS.

But she half asses it at best. She is horrible at what she does.
Agreed.

Yet these people believe her because she is on TV and the radio.
This is indeed how she sucks in a lot of her fan base. And the fact that she is no longer a weekly guest on the Montel Williams Show is another indicator that - whoever or whatever is responsible - she is indeed slowing down.l But back to your point...

This is not all SBs fault here and that's how you and your groupies pimp it off.

These people are NOT mugging victims! They are not victims at all!
They are victims, Brattus. You and I have been through this before.

They CHOSE to give her their money!
Yes, but under false pretenses. If you CHOOSE to give your money to a car dealer for a Porsche, only to find later that there isn't even a CAR, should the cops say "Hey You're not a victim! Brattus, you CHOSE to give your money to that dealer!"

They WANT SB to have it!
Well, that's not even logical. When I pay an attorney for his or her services, or pay the grocery store for my food, it's not because I WANT them to have my money. It is because I want in return what I have been promised for that money. The people who pay Browne $750 for a twenty minute phone reading do so not because they necessarily want her to have the money. They do so because they want what they have been promised in return. And they do not receive it.

Sylvia Browne can not sell anything unless someone is buying!
The same can be said of any con-artist. Does that somehow transfer the blame to the people who were taken in by the con?

If your site were truly what it claims to be then you would have a section about being gullible, naive or plain stupid.
Oh? First, tell me what my site "claims to be." Next, start your own site in which you tell people how "gullible, naive or plain stupid" they are, and see how many are helped by it.

You say you are waiting for just one thing that shows SB has psychic powers and you will post it on your site. That's not the truth though is it?
Where exactly do I say that? I say (repeatedly) that if anyone has any examples of readings for missing/murdered people that she has gotten largely correct (whether through psychic means or not), to please let me know, and I will research it and write it up for the site. Is that what you are talking about?

You KNOW that SB has no psychic powers.
I would certainly bet on it, though from a purely skeptical point of view, I would not say that I "know" it.

You KNOW you will never see that one thing ever.
Again, give me a quote because I am not sure what you're referring to.

That's why your SSB site is nothing more than preaching to the choir.
Then why do so many people contact me and tell me that they no longer believe in Browne after they read the site? Are they all lying to me? Because I hear from people who tell me this almost daily.

If you truly created the site for more than you and your groupies then you would fully understand that these are very very stupid people you are writing for.
I think that sentence falls under "false dichotomy," Brattus, and it is wrong on several counts.

I have corresponded and spoken with many people who believe (or once believed) in Browne's scam, and I assure you, they are not "all very stupid people". You are dealing in your own prejudiced stereotypes, Brattus.

And believe me, if I had created the site for the enjoyment of skeptics (which is what I assume you mean by "the choir"), then it would be very different in tone and content.

You can't offer up facts and just expect these idiots to draw their own conclusions.
Again, I hear almost daily from people who you would evidently categorize as "idiots" who have read the site and come to the conclusion that Browne is a fraud.

They believe Sylvia Browne has real psychic powers because she is on TV. That should tell you everything you need to know about the type of people your dealing with.
There are going to be "true believers" who would not change their mind about Browne regardless of the evidence. But there is a whole spectrum of belief between that extreme and those who are on the fence about Browne. And the site seems to work for many who at various points on that spectrum.

You need to spell it out for them. You can't give them a choice. They already made the choice to believe in SBs powers anyway.

You need to come out with it on the home page. Sylvia Browne is a fake! That they might be able to understand but I doubt it.
Again Brattus, if you want to put together that web site, please do. I will even link to it. But that is not the site, nor the approach, that I have decided on.

And it's odd that you liked the StopKaz site, because that is where I first learned to use the very approach you seem to dislike now.

Here's what I would like to see though. One piece of prove from you that someone anyone came to not believe in SBs powers after reading your SSB site. That this person full on believed everything Sylvia and was just surfing the net and came upon your site and your site alone changed their thinking.

Testimonials from your JREF groupie base doesnt count either.

They will say anything to protect their new Daddy.
I see.

Well, read this article and see if it meets your criteria: http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_rosannamontage.shtml

You throw the phrase "critical thinking" around like you own the copyright on it.
Wow. I didn't realize that.

Googling for the phrase on the SSB site, I find I used it... zero times.

Searching this forum for posts by me where I use both the word "critical" and "thinking," I find... eight posts, in some of which the phrase is in a quote from someone else.

No wonder I lost the copyright...

Well here's something to critically think about.
And I have.
 
Last edited:
By the way, a note to my groupies:

Before my last concert, I noticed that the bowl of M&Ms in my dressing room contained some dark brown and light brown ones, when I have specifically told you people again and again to remove them, because they remind me of Browne!

Not only that, THEY DON'T EVEN MAKE THE LIGHT BROWN ONES ANYMORE, UNLESS YOU SPECIAL ORDER THEM!!

Next time, I'M TRASHING THE PLACE!!!!

Some freakin' groupies... :mad:
 
By the way, a note to my groupies:

Before my last concert, I noticed that the bowl of M&Ms in my dressing room contained some dark brown and light brown ones, when I have specifically told you people again and again to remove them, because they remind me of Browne!

Not only that, THEY DON'T EVEN MAKE THE LIGHT BROWN ONES ANYMORE, UNLESS YOU SPECIAL ORDER THEM!!

Next time, I'M TRASHING THE PLACE!!!!

Some freakin' groupies... :mad:

Absolutely hilarious. :D :D :D And very good rebuttals and responses.

You may not have any groupies but I hope you know I'll always be your Number 1 Fan. :)

(Other than Susan and your children, of course!)
 
March 30, 2008

Dear Mr. Lancaster:

I'm deeply sorry, sir. I understand your position clearly. If you want me to turn in my "Rockin' the Skeptics '08 Tour" t-shirt and "Event Staff" light-weight wind breaker, I will. I can only ask for your forgiveness and tell you how deeply ashamed I am.

I do not know, off hand, who was supposed to take care of the M&Ms, but I take full responsibility for the gross negligence. I assure you the necessary steps are, even now, being taken to rectify the situation. I promise you those in charge of removing the dark brown M&Ms will be dealt with very severely.

I also promise you that security will be increased tenfold at your next venue. Intelligence reports suggest the light brown M&Ms were inserted by a third party that slipped in undetected. A new fingerprinting system is being ordered, at no cost to you. Tapes of the security cameras are also being checked at this very moment.

Again, my most humble apologies, sir.

Yours faithfully,

K. Trout

cc: JR, RSLBH, Groupies
KT/jd
 
Well, I admit Brattus' post seemed particularly aimed at me and the other ex-NSer types, and I wouldn't want to post on a forum where I was specifically unwelcome, so it was nice to read the responses of others who disagree. At least I hope they do.

RSL,

Your response was great and actually made me laugh.

I'll take full responsibility for the M&M issue, so long as I never actually have to call you "Daddy." :rolleyes:

ExM
Senior Groupie
(and Former Idiot Who Formed Own Conclusions Based on RSL's Web Site and Past Experience)
 
You may not have any groupies but I hope you know I'll always be your Number 1 Fan. :)
Okay, now you're scaring me. I'm picturing Kathy Bates saying the same thing to James Caan... :boxedin:

I can only ask for your forgiveness and tell you how deeply ashamed I am.
I'm hoping we can put the whole ugly incident behind us, Trout. Just make sure it doesn't happen again.

I'll take full responsibility for the M&M issue, so long as I never actually have to call you "Daddy." :rolleyes:
No problem there, ExM. :boggled:

Would "Mummy" be OK?:boxedin:
Uhhhhh.... No. :eye-poppi
 
I really appreciate what Mr. Lancaster does.
I'm an ex-SB fan - I read her books for the same reason a lot of folks do: in emotional pain, had nowhere to turn, and they helped at the time. I was raised to believe in the supernatural and other woo-ish things, so had no problem accepting that what SB claimed she could do was possible.
Now, because I'm a pretty savvy and smart chickadee, I began to notice the vast inconsistencies in her books pretty quickly (I figured she was just old and had a bad staff), and once I got a hold of one of those Novus Spiritus, Journey of the Soul books you can only by from her I had to say to myself "Now, this is utter garbage...wtf??? A cataclysm? That's not even original!" And all the bizarre and gross hypocrisies (sp?) of Novus Spiritus really disgusted me immediately. I guess I was one of the few that actually took her at her word when she said "Don't just believe me, go research stuff for yourself" - I did, and discovered not one piece of evidence she uses supports anything she says.
Then I found the SSB site and all the evidence, presented in such a cool and collected manner, really was the last nail in the coffin. So he helped me tremendously.
I don't regret it or feel like I am hopelessly stupid - you could say SB and her crap helped me develop into the skeptic I always wanted to be, deep down inside...and since her mistakes and lies are so glaringly obvious, it has been a good time...it is what it is.
So thanks Mr. Lancaster! I look forward to each new article and I'll be emailing you with anything I think can help.
 
Welcome, Hawthorne. Your post was nicely said. Your point about being raised "woo" making one more vulnerable to the claims of one such as Sylvia Browne is a good one. It would be interesting if more people would post here with stories like yours.

Alas, RSL, you may not have any groupies, but you've got the support of a group of people who think you've done a great job with the web site. There are also other skeptical web sites that I enjoy and would support if new articles were linked to here from time to time. In fact, linking to here is a good idea.

And I will not call you Mummy either. Or Uncle Bob. :D
 
I really appreciate what Mr. Lancaster does.
I'm an ex-SB fan - I read her books for the same reason a lot of folks do: in emotional pain, had nowhere to turn, and they helped at the time. I was raised to believe in the supernatural and other woo-ish things, so had no problem accepting that what SB claimed she could do was possible.
Now, because I'm a pretty savvy and smart chickadee, I began to notice the vast inconsistencies in her books pretty quickly (I figured she was just old and had a bad staff), and once I got a hold of one of those Novus Spiritus, Journey of the Soul books you can only by from her I had to say to myself "Now, this is utter garbage...wtf??? A cataclysm? That's not even original!" And all the bizarre and gross hypocrisies (sp?) of Novus Spiritus really disgusted me immediately. I guess I was one of the few that actually took her at her word when she said "Don't just believe me, go research stuff for yourself" - I did, and discovered not one piece of evidence she uses supports anything she says.
Then I found the SSB site and all the evidence, presented in such a cool and collected manner, really was the last nail in the coffin. So he helped me tremendously.
I don't regret it or feel like I am hopelessly stupid - you could say SB and her crap helped me develop into the skeptic I always wanted to be, deep down inside...and since her mistakes and lies are so glaringly obvious, it has been a good time...it is what it is.
So thanks Mr. Lancaster! I look forward to each new article and I'll be emailing you with anything I think can help.

Well said, Hawthorne. And, I might add, I know where you're coming from. I, too, was raised to believe in woo. Particularly in ESP - telepathy, clairvoyance and the like. It was so ingrained in me that I am still open to the possibility of ESP - just not the way SB, JE, UG or JVP claim to have it. Past unexplained experiences leave me now seeking other explanations. So far, a few alternative answers have hurt me to my soul.

But I digress. Welcome, Hawthorne. You are in a good place.
 
March 30, 2008

Dear Mr. Lancaster:

I'm deeply sorry, sir. I understand your position clearly. If you want me to turn in my "Rockin' the Skeptics '08 Tour" t-shirt and "Event Staff" light-weight wind breaker, I will. I can only ask for your forgiveness and tell you how deeply ashamed I am.

I do not know, off hand, who was supposed to take care of the M&Ms, but I take full responsibility for the gross negligence. I assure you the necessary steps are, even now, being taken to rectify the situation. I promise you those in charge of removing the dark brown M&Ms will be dealt with very severely.

I also promise you that security will be increased tenfold at your next venue. Intelligence reports suggest the light brown M&Ms were inserted by a third party that slipped in undetected. A new fingerprinting system is being ordered, at no cost to you. Tapes of the security cameras are also being checked at this very moment.

Again, my most humble apologies, sir.

Yours faithfully,

K. Trout

cc: JR, RSLBH, Groupies
KT/jd

:wackybiglaugh::big:


Oh, my! (Takes a breath.) I laughed so hard I started coughing! You are too funny, KT! Too, too funny!
 
Well said, Hawthorne. And, I might add, I know where you're coming from. I, too, was raised to believe in woo. Particularly in ESP - telepathy, clairvoyance and the like. It was so ingrained in me that I am still open to the possibility of ESP - just not the way SB, JE, UG or JVP claim to have it. Past unexplained experiences leave me now seeking other explanations. So far, a few alternative answers have hurt me to my soul.

But I digress. Welcome, Hawthorne. You are in a good place.

Thank ya, ma'am!
 
and thanks ExMinister!

I think a lot of SB's "true believers" are afraid - if SB, their "spiritual leader" is wrong that means that they are wrong, their whole belief system is false, and that is hard pill to swallow.
 
I think a lot of SB's "true believers" are afraid - if SB, their "spiritual leader" is wrong that means that they are wrong, their whole belief system is false, and that is hard pill to swallow.
Unlike others who are just silly with their hostile rants and not worth getting mad about, I think it takes a brave person to take that step. Kudos to you, and others who have done the same.

As to the others, keep in mind they are all talk and little action. They talk of things like accountability, yet won't admit when they are wrong....they trash other folks efforts, yet take no action of their own, they leap to baseless conclusions, etc. Sure, on the surface their comments may hurt...but when you take into account who is making them, well....just they come off as just plain silly. That said, maybe one day they will take that brave first step in admitting they were wrong too....not likely, but never say never :)
 
Last edited:
Well I must be psychic myself. I just knew it would take the next one or two post to accuse me of being a SB supporter.
I have no connection with SB at all. Why would I? She's an old con artist. A very bad one at that.
But the times of whatever is NOT what my "rant" was about at all.
It's about accountability. Stupid is as stupid does. I have no doubt the woman has changed her way of thinking about SB. But no thanks to SSB site. She offered her story only after she knew she was conned by SB and company. She reached that conclusion on her own after dealings with them.
I'll bet you didn't even read my entire post.
No one dare say anything bad about SSB or RSL on this forum because then they are in league with the devil.
Hey I know the truth hurts but don't shoot the messenger.


So you apparently know how effective SSB is or is not, based entirely on the experience of one person?

Impressive.

ETA: Didn't notice the second page of posts, I'm late to the party, as usual...
 
Last edited:
Welcome, Hawthorne. Thanks for sharing that and very well said.

And glad you liked it, RSLBH. I'll be here all week, and don't forget to tip your waiter!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom