StopSylviaBrowne - Email: Linda Rossi

Wonderful article, again, but I too found the sarcastic "Hell, just showing us proof of Sylvia Browne's Master's Degree in English Literature would be a start" to be unpleasantly jarring.

It's because you've spent so much time and effort in your other articles being very determinedly businesslike and unemotional, in an effort to underscore the point that this isn't "personal"--you don't have a personal vendetta or grudge against SB, she didn't come over to your house and shoot your dog, you're not a disgruntled "ex"--so this sudden appearance of a very emotional and unbusinesslike comment breaks the flow, and makes the reader wonder whether she's starting to "get to you". ;) "Is this the first crack in the normally imperturbable RLS facade? Are we about to see an Internet slanging match, blog vs. blog, dueling website pistols at dawn?" Etc.
 
I think the 'hell....' comment would be fine for the JREF forum, but for the SSB site it did seem out of place. It just didn't have the RSL tone to it and seems like an edit someone else made to the article.

I don't think the word 'hell' is profane either, but some religious people who are questioning Browne might, and if a profanity puts them off visiting SSB, then it's not a good thing to have it there.
 
For what it's worth, I did find it a little out of place and I believe my eyebrows raised a bit, but I read it as extreme exasperation. I rather enjoyed it, too. But then, I'm not entirely against the idea of an article littered with words that would break the JREF forum's rule 10. Maybe that says something.. ;)
 
Yeah, but as far as I understand this mumbo-jumbo, Francine is not his spirit guide. Sylvia's not going to be able to pass Francine off to her son liek her Lee Press-On collection. Making an imaginary being mentor to a movement is problematic if you've already said that she's your personal imaginary being.

RSL, please continue calmly provoking SB and Rossi into idiocy like this letter.

I think the gift she was referring to was "scamming trusting people out of their money"--

and I suspect personal spiritual guides are transferable... or heck, he'll be channeling his mummy when she dies. Even woo evolves.
 
I think it's excellent RSL. It is interesting how critique of Sylvia Browne or her "church" is spun as an attack on the believers... lots of religions seem to do this, because then the victims end up fighting against the ones who might help them.... It reminds me of Rossi and all her god talk and how Randi is godless. It's disturbing the way your shining the light on the dishonesty is spun into an attack on believers and the almighty. But I guess she's had eons of history to learn from the best of gurus and the flocks they deflock.
 
For what it's worth, I did find it a little out of place and I believe my eyebrows raised a bit, but I read it as extreme exasperation. I rather enjoyed it, too. But then, I'm not entirely against the idea of an article littered with words that would break the JREF forum's rule 10. Maybe that says something.. ;)

Oh, don’t get me wrong…I have no issue with #@%^&*! profanity :)

As I said, it just hit me as sounding frustrated, or as you note “extreme exasperation”...almost to the point of quitting. NOT that I think that’s the case…it just seemed so out of place, that was my first thought/reaction.

Gosehawk said it better then I did....

In re-reading, I can see where it was intended to draw emphasis/attention to the various lies SB (et all) spew…but that first thought/reaction still lingers.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom