StopSylviaBrowne - Email: Face to Face w/Browne & Montel: John Slayton Reading

You're very welcome! I'm so pleased to finally have made it to the site!

I've been to Missouri but I've never heard of the "Kaw" or the jewelry chain before...I was in St.Louis, though, not Browne's hometown. Wonder why she'd relocate the crime to Kansas City. :confused:

You know, I don't know what it is but in person she doesn't appear as cold and dismissive as on TV. When I see her on Montel, her behavior sends me through the roof but in person, she's less offensive.

I don't know why. Maybe it's because you see she's just a bored and none too bright or interesting average Joe just trying to do her job and using detachment to get through it. It's hard to even get really angry at her; she herself hardly seems like evil incarnate even though you know she does evil things.

It's only later thinking about it that you get boiling mad at what she does.
 
You know, I don't know what it is but in person she doesn't appear as cold and dismissive as on TV. When I see her on Montel, her behavior sends me through the roof but in person, she's less offensive.

I don't know why. Maybe it's because you see she's just a bored and none too bright or interesting average Joe just trying to do her job and using detachment to get through it. It's hard to even get really angry at her; she herself hardly seems like evil incarnate even though you know she does evil things.

It's only later thinking about it that you get boiling mad at what she does.


The banality of evil.

Great work as always, RSL.
 
Frankly I was a bit surprised that she didn't say John Slayton had been killed by two Hispanic "hobos". Or "indigents".
 
Honestly...I've got questions about this. If someone is seeking to 'debunk' Sylvia Browne, they should hold themselves to the highest standards of accountability and accuracy.

I'm sure that the email letter in question is real; however, it would seem to me that there are very legitimate reasons to question its veracity. Some questions I'd have:

1) Is the author of the email a believer in psychics, who is simply branding Sylvia as a fraud because Sylvia didn't come through for her? Or is she someone who did this out of the desperation of the moment, and intends this email to reflect on all such fraudsters, not just Sylvia?

2) Is there any verifiable documentation that her claims are true...for example, that Sylvia's staff demanded payment? There are CONSTANT calls for Sylvia to provide documentation for her claims...why should it be okay to make claims about her without similar documentation?

I could read this email two ways. One way is the way that Robert obviously intends...a distraught woman who in desperation turned to a potential source of help, who coldly turned her down. But the other way is that of a woman who, in a time of desperation, turned to Sylvia for help, and for whatever reason did not get the help she wanted. In return, she exaggerated her claims, and set out to get revenge on Sylvia, whether what she said was true or not.

Now please...I am NOT some secret shill for Sylvia. Read my posts in these forums, that should be abundantly clear. I detest her, and believe that she is a complete and utter, total fraud.

But I do see a tendency of people here to accept uncritically any claim made against Sylvia Browne, a complete suspension of the standards of "proof" and "documentation" that they so frequently call on Sylvia for.

If there is in fact documentation to back up the claims in this email, that's great...and it should be made apparent. If not, I fail to see how this can be held as 'proof' of anything. It could be true; it could be false.

There is more than enough undeniably true information about Sylvia to thoroughly discredit her; and I think the focus should be on that.
 
2) Is there any verifiable documentation that her claims are true...for example, that Sylvia's staff demanded payment? There are CONSTANT calls for Sylvia to provide documentation for her claims...why should it be okay to make claims about her without similar documentation?

As with any testimonial, one must decide for oneself if the story is credible and the author reliable.

Ms. Bradley's story seems credible to me. The demand for money is consistent with what others have said about Sylvia and her people. Unless the phone call was recorded there is likely to be no documentation.

In return, she exaggerated her claims, and set out to get revenge on Sylvia, whether what she said was true or not.
It's certainly possible that Ms. Bradley is out for revenge, but wouldn't you think she would have more important things to worry about?

But I do see a tendency of people here to accept uncritically any claim made against Sylvia Browne, a complete suspension of the standards of "proof" and "documentation" that they so frequently call on Sylvia for.
I don't think anyone here would accept any claim about Sylvia Browne. That's an unfair accusation. The charges that have been leveled by Robert Lancaster, EeenyMinnieMoe et al have been based on nothing but careful research & reasonable observation.

If not, I fail to see how this can be held as 'proof' of anything. It could be true; it could be false.
I don't think the e-mail was offered as "proof" of anything. It's perfectly admissible evidence, however. Certainly it could be true or false. As I've said, it's up to the reader to decide whether they buy Ms. Bradley's story or not.
 
Last edited:
Wolfman - I agree in part, in that unverified first hand accounts are less then crediable. It should be considered, along with other evidence, as to SBs "powers" and real intent.
 
As always, very nice work! [Edit: Also, hats off to EMM!]

On Iva Bradley's e-mail: her story at least fits in with things that we know for sure (that Sylvia's office tells callers of along waitings lists, that she does charge for missing person's cases, etc.) I'd be far more inclined to accept what she says at face value than anything that comes from SB or her minions.

On the Slayton case, I appreciate, Robert, that you put that bit in there emphasizing that the reading as a whole was utterly useless to solving the murder. One way of looking at her hits and misses would be to say she got two of 8 correct (leaving off the "already known" and the "unknown" items). As you point out, the two "hits" were extremely high probability guesses (that he was murdered, and that the murders would one day be caught--the latter one, by the way, could never be marked "wrong" but only "unknown" or "right".)

In fact, I'd call the entire reading a great big zero for one. She was simply glaringly wrong.

Also, I don't watch the show very much, so I imagine seeing these things in real time as opposed to reading the transcripts makes her echoing statements somewhat less obvious.

From the transcripts, it looks downright silly: "He was also carrying diamonds on him. Are you aware of that?" after the woman just stated that part of what he was doing on this trip was buying diamonds. What chutzpah!
 
As with any testimonial, one must decide for oneself if the story is credible and the author reliable.

I agree completely, however RSL has been pretty meticulous in the past about stating this explicitly with other unverified testimonials. I was surprised he hadn't done so with this one.

It's certainly possible that Ms. Bradley is out for revenge, but wouldn't you think she would have more important things to worry about?

Some people can get obsessed with some strange things and I don't see any reason to eliminate that from consideration with this email.

I don't think anyone here would accept any claim about Sylvia Browne. That's an unfair accusation. The charges that have been leveled by Robert Lancaster, EeenyMinnieMoe et al have been based on nothing but careful research & reasonable observation.

I don't disagree, but a statement that it is an unverified testimonial would be due diligence in my opinion.

I don't think the e-mail was offered as "proof" of anything. It's perfectly admissible evidence, however. Certainly it could be true or false. As I've said, it's up to the reader to decide whether they buy Ms. Bradley's story or not.

I have to be honest: the article does have an air of taking the email as a reliable account. I don't find the claim hard to believe either, but that doesn't make it true. Even if it isn't being offered as proof, it shouldn't have the appearance of being offered as proof either.
 
You're very welcome! I'm so pleased to finally have made it to the site!
:)

I've been to Missouri but I've never heard of the "Kaw" or the jewelry chain before...I was in St.Louis, though, not Browne's hometown. Wonder why she'd relocate the crime to Kansas City. :confused:
There are Helzberg Diamonds stores in St. Louis as well. But I don't know how long they have been there.

You know, I don't know what it is but in person she doesn't appear as cold and dismissive as on TV. When I see her on Montel, her behavior sends me through the roof but in person, she's less offensive.
You've said that before. Wish I could have been there with you, so I'd know if this were true for me as well. Somehow I doubt it, but hey - I'm a skeptic!

Great work as always, RSL.
Thanks, Dave.

Frankly I was a bit surprised that she didn't say John Slayton had been killed by two Hispanic "hobos". Or "indigents".
Or at least that they were "dark-skinned."

I'm sure that the email letter in question is real; however, it would seem to me that there are very legitimate reasons to question its veracity.
I understand your concerns, and to a degree, share them. This is one reason why there are far fewer "email articles" on the site than there might otherwise be.

While I would hope that it is obvious that an email in an article is simply one person's opinion, I have been intending on doing for some time is to write a standard disclaimer to run in all of the email articles.

Here are most of the email articles so far. Have you had the same problem with each of them, or just with this most recent one?

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_clutchedbytheclaws.shtml
http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_requestforrefund.shtml
http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_doofrane.shtml
http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_formerbrownefans.shtml
http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_askmontel.shtml
http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_liedtobybrowne.shtml
http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_eastwest.shtml
http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_duped.shtml

If there is in fact documentation to back up the claims in this email, that's great...and it should be made apparent. If not, I fail to see how this can be held as 'proof' of anything. It could be true; it could be false.
The email is not being offered as "proof," but as one more piece of a huge puzzle. I leave it to the reader to decide whether or not it fits. I'll reread the article this evening in light of your criticism, and see if there is anything I would change or add to it.

There is more than enough undeniably true information about Sylvia to thoroughly discredit her; and I think the focus should be on that.
And for the most part, that is where the focus is. But I do allow for first-hand accounts, such as Iva Bradley's. They would be admissible in a court of law, and a jury would have to decide how heavily to weigh them. it's the same with these articles, and readers of the site.

I don't think the e-mail was offered as "proof" of anything. It's perfectly admissible evidence, however. Certainly it could be true or false. As I've said, it's up to the reader to decide whether they buy Ms. Bradley's story or not.
Exactly.

As always, very nice work!
Thanks!

I agree completely, however RSL has been pretty meticulous in the past about stating this explicitly with other unverified testimonials.
Well, thanks for saying so, but I just skimmed through all the email articles I mentioned above, and
I only noticed one such time, when I say something like "This is of course, one person's opinion."

Even if it isn't being offered as proof, it shouldn't have the appearance of being offered as proof either.

This is why I am considering a generic disclaimer for the email articles.
 
My two cents about this is that emails are unverifiable but I find it easier to believe that they are real than that all of these people would be completely inventing this stuff for you.

Enspecially since all of what they reported certainly sounds like Sylvia Browne.
 
Well, thanks for saying so, but I just skimmed through all the email articles I mentioned above, and
I only noticed one such time, when I say something like "This is of course, one person's opinion."

I can't quite put my finger on it, but for some reason this particular article struck me as putting a bit more stock in the claims of an email. It may be the conclusion which is bugging me:

"Iva Bradley practically begged Browne for much-needed help, and Browne was cold, uncaring, dismissive, and above all, was of no help whatsoever."

It sounds as though you are accepting her claim that it really did happen and that Browne really did react that way.

My $.02 on the other examples you listed:

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_clutchedbytheclaws.shtml

Other than suggesting it was an expensive lesson, this one is simply relaying an account without drawing any conclusions.

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_requestforrefund.shtml

This one is supported by a tape of the telephone call and various correspodence.

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_doofrane.shtml

In this one you are quite critical of the claim that Browne or Dufresne had anything to do with it, and, except for providing it as a warning about this type of scam, doesn't draw any conclusions based on the content of the email.

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_formerbrownefans.shtml

These are provided as examples of people who have become critical of Browne through SSB. A disclaimer saying these are the opinions of the authors is unnecessary since they are being offered as opinions.

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_askmontel.shtml

"So - according to this woman - "

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_liedtobybrowne.shtml

"According to one woman who wrote to the site,"

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_eastwest.shtml

"The email which follows is the account of one person"
"This email is, of course, just one person's opinion. And it proves nothing about Sylvia Browne's psychic ability, or lack thereof."

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_duped.shtml

Other than comparing the account to a classic cold reading, it doesn't really draw any conclusions, except possibly why people who have been disappointed with Browne's readings don't step forward.

This is why I am considering a generic disclaimer for the email articles.

I don't know that a generic disclaimer is necessary. It certainly can't hurt, but I would have been happier with the article in question if the conclusion was simply prefaced by "If the account is true, it would appear that ...."

Just my opinion....
 
Robert, if you get any more emails from people asking you why you never post Browne's successes, please tell them you have a hard-woking researcher who follows up on every missing person and homicide case shown on Montel possible, using every Montel episode available and after some 50 or more cases, has yet to find a single one where Browne was successful.

The only cases Browne has to her credit that your researchers can find (and they've looked!) are a) unverifiable cases b) cases where she proved completely useless, including a mountain of cold cases and one were she was so vague it's hard to even prove she was right or wrong but even then you can say she's wrong c) cases where she was proven dead wrong.
 
I agree in part, in that unverified first hand accounts are less then crediable. It should be considered, along with other evidence, as to SBs "powers" and real intent.
I think Robert's reverse chronological reporting is starting to hit is limits. Sections that clearly show Sylvia Browne being spectacularly wrong are beginning to drown in sections that are less important no matter how interesting.

Robert, the way it is now the "Articles" page has 3 sections that all organise the information in the same way; most recent on top. Wouldn't it be a good idea to make the middle section a section for "Highlights" that present the information that is most important? The things that Sylvia got most spectacularly wrong. Minor issues, such as whether she tells the truth about her smoking or Novus Spiritus dogma wouldn't then have the same priority to the reader.

For personal accounts by people who wrote to you, you could think of starting a "Testimonials" section.
 
You know, it might be the missing persons cases that have the most impact and get the most attention but I could name about 10 things Sylvia Browne does that are just as harmful or almost as harmful. From inventing messages from people living and dead to leading people into a fantasy world with past life regressions and reincarnations to advice for mental illnesses to the way she bilks so much money from Novous Spiritus members.

It's sad to realize there hasn't even been an article on the site analyzing her medical mumbo jumbo or past life regressions or predictions for the future yet.
 
Sections that clearly show Sylvia Browne being spectacularly wrong are beginning to drown in sections that are less important no matter how interesting.
Yes, I have planned on redesigning the Articles index for some time now.

It's sad to realize there hasn't even been an article on the site analyzing her medical mumbo jumbo or past life regressions or predictions for the future yet.
Yes, articles on these subjects have been planned since before the site went up.

The problem is time. SSB isn't my job, and has to take a back seat to a number of other priorities in my life, such as earning a living, paying bills, being with my family, and on and on.

As it stands, there has been an awful lot going on in my life for the past few months. So for the most part, the articles which have gone up are the ones which I can produce in the least amount of time. The articles which contain a transcript, where all I have to write is the Background, Analysis and Conclusion sections, are what generally take the least amount of time, particularly when the transcripts and related articles have already been found by others for me. Same for the Email articles.

Unfortunately, redesigning the Articles section will take time. More time than I have to spare right now.

An article on her predictions will take a lot of research, to do it right. That equates to a lot of time. Same for an article about her medical "diagnoses."

So, for now, those have to be back-burnered.

Know that I am every bit as anxious as you guys to see these things on the site. Probably even more so.

But don't hold your breath. These things will happen as time and my schedule allows.
 
About John Slayton, I gotta wonder if Sylvia thought he drove over the entire state of Missouri on his daily rounds or perhaps if the "hobos" had decided to hijack his car and transport him clear to Kansas City after killing him...cause there's no place closer to the river than that. :confused:
 
As soon as my lottery numbers come up, you'll have life-time funding.
Cool, now my odds are two in a jillion! :)

About John Slayton, I gotta wonder if Sylvia thought he drove over the entire state of Missouri on his daily rounds or perhaps if the "hobos" had decided to hijack his car and transport him clear to Kansas City after killing him...cause there's no place closer to the river than that. :confused:
Well, Slayton's home was a city pretty near the center of the state, about as far from St. Louis as KC, so it's entirely possible that his rounds took him to both, though I doubt both in the same day.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom