Computers, GIGO, and Psychics
I don't think there's any such thing a "true" psychic, and that all phone readers, tarot readers, card readers, palm readers, stool readers, tea-leaf readers and the like are simply cold readers.
Because they are simply cold reading, these so-called psychics can only go with the available information or educated (or lucky) guesses. But their fall-back in the case of something similar to this woman's is what we in the computer world call "GIGO" -- Garbage In, Garbage Out.
Charles Babbage said:
On two occasions, I have been asked [by members of Parliament], 'Pray, Mr. Babbage, if you put into the machine wrong figures, will the right answers come out?' I am not able to rightly apprehend the kind of confusion of ideas that could provoke such a question.
While I can appreciate this concept, to me the mark of an experienced professional is a good bull**** detector. Go to a lawyer with some tall tale and she'll quickly find the holes in it. Go to a doctor complaining of mysterious symptoms, and after a round or two of unsuccessful treatment the doctor is likely to become skeptical that you're really suffering from them.
My understanding of the line the psychics give their marks is that their props--cards, tea leaves, crystal balls, whatever--are supposed to reveal the hidden truths. I'm not sure what Sylvia and Chris claim is the source of their ability to reveal that which is hidden, but to me it seems like it should be good enough to pick up the fact when a person talks about "losing the one I loved almost most of anything in this world," that prop or power should be able reveal she wasn't referring to her husband.
Failure to do that is pretty good evidence the prop doesn't work. Occam's razor then tells us the best explanation is cold reading.