StopSylviaBrowne: "Chris DooFrane" and Money-Cleansing Scheme

No. Do you know of any prior cases where this applied?
Specifically, no.

My concern comes from my experience as a director of security and in conducting in-house investigations.

Notebooks used while investigating are a sensitive item. I might take perfect notes of my investigation on pages 1 through 17, but if on page 18, which also has case-related notes, I scribbled the number to Great Local Pizza Place and the info about my kid's school problems that my wifed called me about, then the opposing side questions the integrity of the notes.

If I keep my pizza and kid notes on a totally separate page in the same notebook, the same objection applies though to a lesser degree. If I tear out those irrelevant pages because I know they aren't relevant, then I raise the spectre of objections about the possibility I have destroyed relevant evidence that supports the other side.

As I said, I am not a lawyer. I do not intend to get drawn into a large debate about this nor to do research to satisfy you. I raised a possible concern to RSL. He says he is not concerned. That's fine by me.
 
If Sylvia ever decided to take legal action, it would be smarter to place the names of each article in a hat and draw out a random article to use to claim unfair bias than it would be to use this article as an example. I dunno what American civil court is like, but you'd have to be pretty daft (or biased yourself) to miss all the times where it states that the reader shouldn't assume any link between Sylvia and the scam.
American civil law is not about what is smart or scientific or even true. It is about what each side can convince either the judge or the jury is legal or illegal, biased or unbiased.

For my last word on this topic: We all know someone who says all the right things about how they are fair and honest and how they really like us and would never talk about us behind our backs but who, in reality, are the exact opposite of how they portray themselves.

RSL is not this way, nor is his site, but I suggested that inclusion of that article could open him up to the accusation.

That's it.
 
Robert,

I think your site is an excellent example of how such a site should appear.

Congratulations!

M.
 
As I said, I am not a lawyer. I do not intend to get drawn into a large debate about this nor to do research to satisfy you. I raised a possible concern to RSL. He says he is not concerned. That's fine by me.
I understand, Garrette. You were expressing a concern, not filing a legal brief.

And again, I appreciate your bringing it up. Please don't hesitate to bring up other concerns in the future. I am interested in hearing them, whether or not any precedents in jurisprudence are cited. :)

I think your site is an excellent example of how such a site should appear.

Congratulations!
Thanks, Mooch!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom