Robert...interesting, but IMO not as compelling as most of your material...though not because SB is psychic....It seems to me one way to get at the issue better is to differentiate between her use of her "psychic" abilities. By this I mean there is nothing psychic about predicting presidents. Indeed, plenty of non-psychics do it all the time (the blogs, the pundits, etc.). Their skill and analysis vary of course, but it is all based on opinion, knowledge of current events, trends, etc. Does she do better than an average pundit? Does she do better than what national polling at the time she makes a prediction suggests?
I guess my point is that she is, in fact, more vulnerable here than here, possibly, than with her very wrong other psychic predictions. It takes no skill to opine on politics. It takes no special talent. Every citizen practically has an opinion, and it seems to me. Not everyone has an opinion or idea about the whereabouts of a missing person. It is easier to fake psychic ability if the person might not ever be found...or you predict their dead and lo and behold they end up dead.
The fact that anyone would give any credibility to a psychic prediction about politics is BS, obviously. What it seems to me needs to be pointed out is that unless she is giving margines... Bush will beat Kerry by 230,000 votes or 2% of the vote....she is doing nothing that any informed citizen does. Cook and Rothenberg (I know, using polls and math, predict margines). The question is why doesn't she predict numbers or states?
Not sure if I'm making sense, but the banality of her electoral ability surpasses, IMO, the gall of her trying to predict what hapened to a missing person or even some unclear future event.
BTW...why would her psychic ability lead to predictive abilities about general events or future events. It seems to me that her psychic claim is that some spirit angel thingy is hanging about people she encounters and whispers in her ear what happens to them or their loved ones, etc. There is a "connection" if you will with a warm body that, arguably, would have a psychic, spiritiual, emotional connection with the object of the prediction.
What is that connection with telling the future? Does she make any claims about how that occurs? What she and Edwards and VanP, etc. all do seems to me to be disconnected from predicting the future...and no one seems to push on why a psychic connection with a live person or dead person would lead to a braoder vision of general or even specific future events (not involving someone who isn't directly in front of her to get a vive from...)...
In other words, I could see her shaking Obama's hand and predicting he'll be president -- "I feel the power move in you..." but it is the remote thing that seesm particularly empty even for the BS explainations of her power that she usually gives.
Great work...keep it up.