StopSylviaBrowne - Browne's Money: Part 1

Yep. Which is why I suggested some months ago that as soon as the well starts to run dry, she will pack it up and "retire". I believe I suggested the Vegas gigs were the last sweep of the money-rake (plus it gives her a chance to win more on the crap tables - and that's an ironic name if ever I heard one!). And now Montel has been canned, expect the announcement...

ETA: Point being that Randi's public challenge in 2001 had little or no effect because it was, inversely, publicity for her. The only downside would have been taking up the gauntlet - public failure would have injured the income stream. SBB had more effect - it exposed her sordid little operation for what it really is, thus definitely jeopardising the cash-cow. Any personal differences of opinion on running GSB or "gnosticism" or who was married to who were irrelevant. But it will only be when the income stream actually peters off that she will really pack it in and retire - I'm betting out of reach of the IRS, to the Caymans or somewhere.
 
Last edited:
Is it at all telling that as I read the last line "I will be investigating these and other related matters in future articles in this series." I heard a 60 Minutes-type ticking in my head?

(I mean, back when 60 Minutes actually did important investigative journalism, of course.)
 
I've always thought her claim of giving 20 readings per day was a marketing ploy. I don't think she could do more than 12 per day, blocking off a half-hour on the calendar for each - 20 minutes on the phone plus 10 minutes for a smoke.

That's true. Also, how many times have we heard someone say they had an appointment for a phone reading 2 years out, but were thrilled to get a call much sooner than that owing to a cancellation? (I always wondered about that--how would you get bumped 6 months up the waiting list because of a cancellation? Seems to me there would be many thousands of people still ahead of you.)

As I said, she's lying about something--either how many readings she does, or what kind of lifestyle she has. Most likely, she's lying about both.
 
Last edited:
Mr. Randi once received a letter from a person who had previously believed in Sylvia Browne's abilities but became suspicious of her because of the huge amounts of money she charges. He bitingly replied that he's not suspicious of her just because she charges alot for what she does- hospitals charge alot of money, too.

It's true that whether or not she makes alot of money is in no way an indicator of her lack of powers but the money is important because it gives motive. It's generally a big clue that you're being lied to if whoever you're talking to stands to personally profit.

I'd be much more inclined to believe that someone's honest and legitimate if they don't give the impression they are after the money first- someone like Doris Stokes being the exception. For instance, the first and only time I went to a palm reader, I had no idea what cold-reading was but a major red flag and tip-off that I was being taken was the way the palm reader practically snatched my five dollars from me and kept pressing my friend for a more expensive reading.

Whenever someone is primarily after your cash, you should smell a rat. As in all BS, just follow the money.

An honest and legitimate psychic? UH? Is someone gearing up for a 2 year wait or what?
Do you really think people will stop believing in SB because they think she's only in it for the money?
Spirit Guides. Mind reading. Talking to the dead. Seeing the future.
LOL! A little something like truth and common sense won't even slow them down.
 
An honest and legitimate psychic? UH? Is someone gearing up for a 2 year wait or what?
Do you really think people will stop believing in SB because they think she's only in it for the money?
Spirit Guides. Mind reading. Talking to the dead. Seeing the future.
LOL! A little something like truth and common sense won't even slow them down.

I wasn't talking about psychics, I was talking about trying to determine if someone is being honest with you.

I meant to say that $ does not neccessarily = BS but, in general, $ <-> BS.
 
Last edited:
I wasn't talking about psychics, I was talking about trying to determine if someone is being honest with you.

I meant to say that $ does not neccessarily = BS but, in general, $ <-> BS.

I see. My bad. I understand now. Sorry!
 
I wonder if she even writes her own books or uses a "ghost-writer" (sorry), meaning some other person writes them for her. Might be worth investigating. If it could be proven that she isn't really authoring all her own garbage it could point out another area where she's a lying #^%#%#$.
 
I think it's been shown that she hasn't lifted a pen or touched a keyboard to write a single thing. A number of erstwhile followers have noticed that 80% or more of most current books by Browne are pretty much identical content as the previous ones. That is, the cut-and-paste is only a few twiddles of new filler around the edges plus a title.

It's simply selling the same thing a number of times to the same dumb suckers.
 
I wonder if she even writes her own books or uses a "ghost-writer" (sorry), meaning some other person writes them for her. Might be worth investigating. If it could be proven that she isn't really authoring all her own garbage it could point out another area where she's a lying #^%#%#$.

That's a can of worms I personally wouldn't open. Many, many popular science books (beloved by skeptics and others) are ghost-written. It's extremely common.
 
That's a can of worms I personally wouldn't open. Many, many popular science books (beloved by skeptics and others) are ghost-written. It's extremely common.

I haven't read any of her books but I've read the many inconsistencies that Robert has pointed out regarding what she says about her past and differences between books about how she came to know her spirit guide, etc. I thought she claims to write all these books herself but she can't remember what she said from one to another.

I understand that ghost-writing or co-authoring a science book (or even an autobiography) is common, she just seems to be so prolific and with all the other stuff she supposedly does, where does she find the time? Guess I'm just ruminating.
 
I haven't read any of her books but I've read the many inconsistencies that Robert has pointed out regarding what she says about her past and differences between books about how she came to know her spirit guide, etc. I thought she claims to write all these books herself but she can't remember what she said from one to another.

I understand that ghost-writing or co-authoring a science book (or even an autobiography) is common, she just seems to be so prolific and with all the other stuff she supposedly does, where does she find the time? Guess I'm just ruminating.

In fact, she tried to defend against this accusation in one of her mor recent books (can't remember which), saying that she has all of her hand-written manuscripts to prove it. I had heard rumors from the office that at least two of her books were written by someone there. It's common knowledge around there that Mary Simonds compiled/wrote the JOS series, but these were taken directly from SB's own taped lectures.

Aside from that, everyone knows how hard it can be to remember lies. If you listen to her trance tapes, you see that Francine had this same problem.

It seems to me like she doesn't even care if she keeps her stories straight. I'd think at least she'd go back and read her earlier material just to try to be consistent.
 
Last edited:
.....
It seems to me like she doesn't even care if she keeps her stories straight. I'd think at least she'd go back and read her earlier material just to try to be consistent.

I think that about sums it up as far as just about everything she does, from writing to readings.
 
I haven't read any of her books but I've read the many inconsistencies that Robert has pointed out regarding what she says about her past and differences between books about how she came to know her spirit guide, etc. I thought she claims to write all these books herself but she can't remember what she said from one to another.

I understand that ghost-writing or co-authoring a science book (or even an autobiography) is common, she just seems to be so prolific and with all the other stuff she supposedly does, where does she find the time? Guess I'm just ruminating.

It is a can of worms, but actually a very fascinating one. And I'm not saying that 'just because scientists do it then we can't criticise Browne for doing it', but we must be careful to be consistent in our condemnation.

In fact, my personal opinion is that no-one should have ghost-writers. It's a marketing scam. You are buying a book based on your liking of the person who wrote it and your faith in their opinion/ability to interpret data/whatever. When in actual fact they are just using their name to make a buck.

Similarly, record companies sometimes pay songwriters for the entire rights so that the artist can claim on the sleeve notes that they wrote the song. Suddenly that artist has more credibility than before.

I can't name any names, sadly, but there's a very popular Biologist whose books sell extremely well. At an event a few years back he was introduced to a woman and was quite rude to her. When she tried to speak to him later he said snappishly "who are you again?" and she looked at him squarely and replied "I wrote your last book".

True story.

Another example - a range of best-selling self-help books (with the celebrity author's face on the cover of them all) have made him a fortune. He didn't, of course, write a word of them.
 
Last edited:
It is fairly clear that Sylvia's books are not written by herself, but she doesn't use a ghost writer (funny for a psychic) either.

She merely sits with her "co-author" and talks, with a tape recorder next to them. It is the "co-author"'s job to transform the material into something that looks like a book.

That's why there are so many inconsistencies in her books: It is merely stream-of-consciousness.

Lots of books are written this way, e.g. memoirs. It's an accepted method these days, unfortunately.
 
It is fairly clear that Sylvia's books are not written by herself, but she doesn't use a ghost writer (funny for a psychic) either.

She merely sits with her "co-author" and talks, with a tape recorder next to them. It is the "co-author"'s job to transform the material into something that looks like a book.

That is actually what ghost writing is. Well, there are lots of forms of ghost writing, but that's one of them.
 
That is actually what ghost writing is. Well, there are lots of forms of ghost writing, but that's one of them.

Yep. Sylvia is definitely involved in each project, but there is no way she can do all those readings, projects, lectures, etc, and write...what, 40? books, too.

ETA: It could very well be that the ghost writer simply gets the tapes from her lectures and sermons.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom