StopSylviaBrowne: Browne & "The Mentalizer"

Nice story.

'The Mentalizer' is simultaneously the best and worst name for a magician ever.
 
I enjoyed the article but, honestly, shouldn't this guy have excercised a little more sense? He appears on a show that promotes woo-woo, appears with a psychic that validates him as paranormal and plays along with her act, passes himself off as having paranormal powers to an audience that believes in it...and then is surprised that they believe him?

I mean, we all make mistakes and I realize that the world of woo is probably different where he comes from but come on. Doesn't he have an agent? Doesn't he check what shows he appears on?! Two Google searches would have told him all that he needed to know.
 
Being English, I know near f-all about Sylvia Browne.. maybe she's a terrible charlatan, but how does everyone here propose to 'STOP' her?
Do none of you ever worry that you might be spending too much of your time and effort, in what is a pretty short life, in pretty vain attempts to perhaps somewhat stymie a possibly fraudulent little old lady with a strangely deep rasping voice?
 
Being English, I know near f-all about Sylvia Browne.. maybe she's a terrible charlatan, but how does everyone here propose to 'STOP' her?
Do none of you ever worry that you might be spending too much of your time and effort, in what is a pretty short life, in pretty vain attempts to perhaps somewhat stymie a possibly fraudulent little old lady with a strangely deep rasping voice?

Yes, that did occur to me from time to time. Why spend so much time and effort on just this one charlatan, enspecially when there already is so much hard evidence against her.

And then I discover yet another despicable and fraudulent lie of hers, from telling an Iraq War widow she'd have a healthy son when the poor woman was carrying a daughter that was born prematurely and died to most likely accusing an innocent man of murder and it reminds me why I started on this project in the first place and why it needs to be done.
 
Thumbs up on the story from me, too!
Thanks, Brown!

Just as a side note, as the token ex-minister thought I'd clarify that Sylvia has always maintained that Francine doesn't help her in the reading room at all.
Thanks for clearing that up!

Nice story.
Thanks, Teek!

Supoib. Way to go again RSL.
Thanks, sinclair!

Being English, I know near f-all about Sylvia Browne.. maybe she's a terrible charlatan, but how does everyone here propose to 'STOP' her?
Do none of you ever worry that you might be spending too much of your time and effort, in what is a pretty short life, in pretty vain attempts to perhaps somewhat stymie a possibly fraudulent little old lady with a strangely deep rasping voice?
Hi, Plumjam. Very few of the people here are spending much time in this effort. Whether we "stop" Browne or not, an awful lot of people are getting educated along the way.

By the way, spend some time reading the site. It might help you to understand why I've chosen to do what I am doing, and you'll most likely remove the "possibly" from your description of Browne.
 
You won't find many magicians/mentalists who say what they do is illusions before or during their act, as it would break the illusion.
Yes, you do. Most that I've seen (and know) refer to their tricks as "illusions".


RSLancastr said:
If you'll notice, that particular episode was aired almost two years ago. I dont know if that format was ever tried again. Browne seemed to make for a pretty surly co-host.
Shows you how attentive I am. You said the date it was broadcast in the article, and it didn't register--and then I assumed it was something that aired recently. :blush:

Good to know he didn't go back on Montel.
 
Being English, I know nearly nothing about Sylvia Browne.. maybe she's a terrible charlatan, but how does everyone here propose to 'STOP' her?
Do none of you ever worry that you might be spending too much of your time and effort, in what is a pretty short life, in pretty vain attempts to perhaps somewhat stymie a possibly fraudulent little old lady with a strangely deep rasping voice?

It could be her powers are stopping a person from being a skeptic. She does have supernatural powers, so they exist. Until that person reads www.stopsylviabroene.com (or some such thing) and finds out she has less power than she claims.

It is not a matter of stopping her. It is a matter of draining away her supporters. Then her replacement will not have so many supporters. There will be more skeptics and fewer woos.

NB Quote changed into proper English.
 
Am I the only Israeli in the world who does not bend forks and spoons? I am starting to think that I might've missed that class... :(
 
Being English, I know near f-all about Sylvia Browne.. maybe she's a terrible charlatan, but how does everyone here propose to 'STOP' her?
Do none of you ever worry that you might be spending too much of your time and effort, in what is a pretty short life, in pretty vain attempts to perhaps somewhat stymie a possibly fraudulent little old lady with a strangely deep rasping voice?

I'm English too, and I knew nothing about Sylvia Browne until I followed a link from a post on JREF to Robert's site.

I read a couple of articles at random and it was interesting, but not in any gripping way - I thought, much like you that it seemed like a lot of effort. then I read the Shawn Hornbeck and Opal Jo Jennings articles, and my opinion was totally changed. No effort can be too much - this is a sick and disturbing woman who doesn't merit the profile she has been given in any way at all. She preys on the weak, the vulnerable and the desperate - like any scammer does.

I don't have faith - never have, but I do believe that if we have a purpose in this world, it is to help each other. Sylvia Browne is not helping anyone except Sylvia Browne. She doesn't need to be attacked - the truth is it's own weapon, and Robert make the truth available. It is definately worth it.
 
Yes, you do. Most that I've seen (and know) refer to their tricks as "illusions".

So does Segev in genereal. I'm talking about magicians who are just about to do their act. I've seen many such appearances by magicians where they just do their usual routine and then go home. There was no reason for Segev to say it's an illusion, because he never claimed that it wasn't. He was there as a mentalist, a person who creates illusions. Montel was saying the word "tricks" a couple of times during the segment. When people were a bit confused about it later on, Segev made it clear that he indeed only does illusions and he doesn't have any powers. Which makes it obvious that he's honest about what he does, and wasn't his intention to confuse anyone.

I think you are looking for something that isn't there.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom