I also agree with you, RSLBH, that we'll probably never know.
However, I'm not sure why people think ex-Sylvia Browne believers cannot come up with a fairly intelligent sounding argument like this. OK, well maybe I can understand why Sylvia Browne might be a factor here. But still. I used to be a believer; should my feelings be hurt??
At any rate, I wouldn't describe this person as tongue in cheek so much as maybe coming across a bit holier-than-thou. It IS a bit holier-than-thou to think you can come in and presume to set everyone straight. It's kind of funny, too, and if she's sincere, which I think she is, you have to admire her gumption for even trying.
At any rate, I dealt with all sorts of Browne fans as a minister, and I still think she's what she says she is - a person who had read 25 of Sylvia's books over the years and had gone to look into the hypnosis certification when she stumbled on all the other web sites and landed smack in the middle of all the controversy.
She also mentions, by way of having been a believer, that she'd even recently looked into finding a study group in her area. I used to be a study group liaison and there was in fact only one active study group in this part of the state at that time, so I can easily imagine that she might not have found one.
Her comment to Robert, starting with "Am I to believe...??" sounds to me like the way you'd talk to a small child who just stole a handful of cookies, has crumbs all over, and is denying it. It's like she's saying, "Come on, let's be real here, let's at least play fair." (Little did she know it's true, but I can understand why she might be surprised by that.)
Then the thing about Browne's theme being humanitarian. Sylvia says everyone has 2 major life themes and hers are humanitarian and loner. I'm not sure how many skeptics, researching for an e-mail like this, would have been aware of something like that and included it so casually.
Anyway, to me overall her letter does sound like it's from someone who started out a believer (against her own better judgment, she seems to be saying, having been put off by Sylvia's style in the beginning), and now has become skeptical and is taking the time here to elaborate on why.
I also get the impression she's reached the point where she doesn't believe, based on Sylvia's side of things, that Sylvia CAN defend her position anymore, but that she holds out a little hope.
Last, I think at the end she is not being wholly sarcastic about the psychic impressions. I think it's a mix of both.
So, she is right about some of it, but she's also wrong. For example, I agree about Chris not utilizing a psychic bone in his body but I don't think he's disillusioned. My understanding is that he likes the money and perks a whole lot, too.
Anyway, just my thoughts.