StopSylvia: an old email to Browne and Me

Maybe I am being naive here, but I think it is from an ex-believer. For one thing, how many skeptics would have known to send an email to Vera and Michael in Sylvia's office?

I know, for whatever it's worth, I really think so too. Also she mentions having looked into the hypnosis certification training. That is run by Vera. Normally people would not include Vera in a letter of this type since she would have nothing to do with whether it reached Sylvia (that is Linda's job), so it sounds like she did so having probably dealt with her through the hypnosis center.
 
Last edited:
Maybe I am being naive here, but I think it is from an ex-believer. For one thing, how many skeptics would have known to send an email to Vera and Michael in Sylvia's office?

Possibly someone who has followed your posts and threads here, or is well-versed on your site? Or both? This person knows the "lingo," but I just sense a tongue-in-cheek as they use it. Perhaps they were bold enough to even call Sylvia's office and ask who was in charge. I think it's a skeptic, acting like a disillusioned believer.
 
Good point. Whether it's a skeptic in disguise or an ex-sylviaphile the tone is only a few degrees shy of mocking. It certainly isn't a friendly and helpful letter to Sylvia.
 
Possibly someone who has followed your posts and threads here, or is well-versed on your site? Or both? This person knows the "lingo," but I just sense a tongue-in-cheek as they use it. Perhaps they were bold enough to even call Sylvia's office and ask who was in charge. I think it's a skeptic, acting like a disillusioned believer.

Even so, if they had called, they would have been instructed to address the email to Linda Rossi, not Michael and definitely not Vera.
 
I know, for whatever it's worth, I really think so too. Also she mentions having looked into the hypnosis certification training. That is run by Vera. Normally people would not include Vera in a letter of this type since she would have nothing to do with whether it reached Sylvia (that is Linda's job), so it sounds like she did so having probably dealt with her through the hypnosis center.

And a skeptic, doing research for their "cover," would not have looked into the hypnosis training or study groups? I dunno, Ex-M. I'm finding it a bit suspicious that the author of the email is claiming to be from an area of the country where Sylvia does not have a study group, too. I'm sure there are many, but all a skeptic would need is one.

edit: About there not being a study group - if they were a "believer" in a town where there is a study group, wouldn't they have become known to other believers? I'm not making my point very well. I wonder if we'll ever really know more about this person.
 
Last edited:
It just sounds to me like someone who feels duped. It could be faked "believerisms" too. I'm not sure we can discount all believers as not intelligent to make the arguments that were made.

In the end, you're right Better Half - without further correspondence this is all really just idle speculation. Still, it's fun playing detective! (And I can believe either possibility - skeptic playing believer or duped believer feeling bitter)
 
It just sounds to me like someone who feels duped. It could be faked "believerisms" too. I'm not sure we can discount all believers as not intelligent to make the arguments that were made.

In the end, you're right Better Half - without further correspondence this is all really just idle speculation. Still, it's fun playing detective! (And I can believe either possibility - skeptic playing believer or duped believer feeling bitter)

I agree---I can imagine that, after 25 years of falling for this crap hook, line, and sinker, I'd be pretty snarky towards Sylvia once I'd put it all together and realized it's a crock. I know it's a stretch, y'all, but try to imagine yourself in an ex-believer's shoes.

Also, a lack of critical thinking skills does not necessarily make a person stupid. Most people aren't trained to question what they're told by persons of authority. I believed in all kinds of dumb crap until it occurred to me that my Mom might have been wrong about some stuff. Some of the smartest people in the world are religious in spite of the lack of proof. Sometimes a desire to believe can override the critical thinking skills of even the most superior intellect.

The person who wrote this letter strikes me as someone who's managed to see through Sylvia, but still wants to believe in a whole lot of other nonsense. After all, Sylvia is not the only self-proclaimed psychic in the world, unfortunately. The person who wrote the letter may still believe in the others. Maybe s/he has a close family member or loved one who s/he firmly believes is psychic. Are you really going to call your beloved great-granny a liar? Wouldn't it be easier to believe that Sylvia's a fraud, but great-granny really has psychic visions?
 
I also agree with you, RSLBH, that we'll probably never know.

However, I'm not sure why people think ex-Sylvia Browne believers cannot come up with a fairly intelligent sounding argument like this. OK, well maybe I can understand why Sylvia Browne might be a factor here. But still. I used to be a believer; should my feelings be hurt?? ;)

At any rate, I wouldn't describe this person as tongue in cheek so much as maybe coming across a bit holier-than-thou. It IS a bit holier-than-thou to think you can come in and presume to set everyone straight. It's kind of funny, too, and if she's sincere, which I think she is, you have to admire her gumption for even trying.

At any rate, I dealt with all sorts of Browne fans as a minister, and I still think she's what she says she is - a person who had read 25 of Sylvia's books over the years and had gone to look into the hypnosis certification when she stumbled on all the other web sites and landed smack in the middle of all the controversy.

She also mentions, by way of having been a believer, that she'd even recently looked into finding a study group in her area. I used to be a study group liaison and there was in fact only one active study group in this part of the state at that time, so I can easily imagine that she might not have found one.

Her comment to Robert, starting with "Am I to believe...??" sounds to me like the way you'd talk to a small child who just stole a handful of cookies, has crumbs all over, and is denying it. It's like she's saying, "Come on, let's be real here, let's at least play fair." (Little did she know it's true, but I can understand why she might be surprised by that.)

Then the thing about Browne's theme being humanitarian. Sylvia says everyone has 2 major life themes and hers are humanitarian and loner. I'm not sure how many skeptics, researching for an e-mail like this, would have been aware of something like that and included it so casually.

Anyway, to me overall her letter does sound like it's from someone who started out a believer (against her own better judgment, she seems to be saying, having been put off by Sylvia's style in the beginning), and now has become skeptical and is taking the time here to elaborate on why.

I also get the impression she's reached the point where she doesn't believe, based on Sylvia's side of things, that Sylvia CAN defend her position anymore, but that she holds out a little hope.

Last, I think at the end she is not being wholly sarcastic about the psychic impressions. I think it's a mix of both.

So, she is right about some of it, but she's also wrong. For example, I agree about Chris not utilizing a psychic bone in his body but I don't think he's disillusioned. My understanding is that he likes the money and perks a whole lot, too.

Anyway, just my thoughts.
 
It's not that I think Sylvia Browne fans are unintelligent. It's just that I found a "Neener neener you're to scared to answer these questions" undertone in the letter.
 
It's not that I think Sylvia Browne fans are unintelligent. It's just that I found a "Neener neener you're to scared to answer these questions" undertone in the letter.

I agree with you.

Nobody could argue your intelligence, Ex-M. Well stated. Almost persuaded me . . . if it weren't for that pesky psick-ick feeling I get about the (as Dragonrock puts it) "neener neener" tone. Something just ain't right there.
 
Regarding the reply I sent - as shown in post #10 of this thread. A little more about the three "positive Browne emails" I mentioned...

The first refers to the woman whose correspondence with me was discussed in the article Email: Rosanna, a montage - still one of my favorite articles on the site.

The second was odd. The woman sent me a hate-filled, obscenity-laced email saying that Browne had correctly predicted where the woman's missing father could be found. When I replied asking for any sort of evidence - even a newspaper clipping that her father had been found, not even mentioning Browne - she got even angrier, but supplied no evidence. I eventually tired of asking for evidence only to be cursed at, and told her that I would publish her initial email to me if she wanted, or, if she preferred, she could resend it rewritten in a calmer tone. She replied that she would resend it, and I never heard from her again, despite sending some reminders.

My correspondence with the thrd was VERY interesting, and would have made for a very educational article.

She wrote and said she was very angry with me for creating the site. she had a phone reading with Browne where Browne had known some specifics about the woman's future that there was no way she could have known without being psychic. For example, she said, Browne had told her that she would move to Washington, DC - and she ended up moving there!

I asked her if she had a tape of the reading. Not that I thought she was lying, but I had learned that people never remembered their readings accurately - something which phony psychics rely on. I said that perhaps she had said something which Browne had picked up on.

The woman became extremely offended at this, and said "No, the first thing out of Sylvia's mouth when she picked up the phone was "What's this about you moving to Washington, DC?" so the woman felt there was no way Browne could have "picked up on" something the woman had said to her. She finally agreed to dig out the tape and send it to me.

I listened to it and transcribed the first few lines back and forth. As best as I can recall, it went something like this:

Browne: Hello, this is Sylvia.
Woman: Hi Sylvia, this is [name].
Browne: What's this I'm seeing about a move?
Woman: A move?
Browne: Yeah, a move.

Note that up until this point, "a move" is vague enough that it could mean anything. A move in residence, career, romance... anything. A cold reader throws something vague like this out, hoping that the sitter will supply the connection between the vague statement and something specific in the sitter's life, which happens here:

Woman: To Washington DC? Because my husband thinks he may be getting a promotion, and that's where his company's headquarters is.
Browne: Yeah, that's what I'm seeing.

And the husband did get the promotion, and they did move to DC, and the woman honestly remembered the conversation with Browne as Browne answering the phone and saying "What's this about you moving to Washington DC?" It probably made for a better story to tell her friends, anyway. And I bet that, after repeated retellings, it was what she believed had happened.

I emailed the brief transcript back to the woman, along with my comments, and she was floored. I asked her permission to publish her emails, along with the transcript (and perhaps the audio) of the reading on the site, saying that it was a perfect example of the difference between a reading and the memory of the reading. I don't think she ever replied.

But whenever someone tells me about some incredible reading they have had, I ask for a recording or transcript, and tell them about that woman.
 
That would make a fantastic article. I think that is probably a major reason people swear by certain psychics, and I'd be willing to bet that very few people understand it.
 
That would make a fantastic article. I think that is probably a major reason people swear by certain psychics, and I'd be willing to bet that very few people understand it.

I would bet so too. there were many times when people in JVPLand would tell me JVP or another medium) had known something and I would start to tell that story, and someone would say "stop trying to promote your Sylvia site!" They just wouldn't accept it. And some claimed to be mediums themselves, and would say "I knew this or that about the sitter - how do you explain that?" and would balk when I would say I needed a recording or transcript to theorize intelligently about it. "you see, you have no explanation!"

Having an article showing it so clearly would be helpful.
 
Robert,

I just read your article with "Rosanna" - fantastic work! I wasn't that familiar with all your work (I still am not, but I'm looking forward to working my way through the rest of it). Good on you for what you've been doing, and good on "Rosanna" for allowing you to upload that page!

It's good to see people doing the right thing just for the sake of it being the right thing, and the time you've invested in it is greatly appreciated. Thanks!
 
Thanks, Spoons! Yes, as I said, the Rosanna article is one of my favorites. Her gradual turnaround was very gratifying. I hope you enjoy the rest of the site!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom