Stop Sylvia Browne - Email: "My Sister Margaret and Me"

Fyi - I have a couple Photoshopped pics on display at home myself. One in particular where my brother was missing from the family photo and I added him to it (fairly undetectably, I might add.)

I also intended no disrespect to the man in the picture with my observation.
 
Okay, eagle-eyed ones:

I heard back from Peter. The image was indeed photoshopped, but it was the only pic of him and his sister he had on his hard drive when he emailed me.

He has now sent me a couple of other photos of him with his sister for me to choose from. I will be replacing the current image with one of these, and adding another picture as well. I hope to do this tonight.

Thanks to all for their concern.

Warheit, I just might take you up on your offer of expertise sometime - thanks!
 
Okay, eagle-eyed ones:

I heard back from Peter. The image was indeed photoshopped, but it was the only pic of him and his sister he had on his hard drive when he emailed me.
...

We rock.

And I just noticed that sometime in the last week I passed 5000 posts (at least, on this incarnation of the Forum), and I think most of those were from work. Maybe I should pay more attention to my job for the time being...
 
"A: As of this writing (November of 2006), I have read one (Adventures of a Psychic) and am in the process of reading another (Prophecy). I have over a dozen more on my shelf."

How about adding a sentence along the lines of: Since most of what Sylvia writes is repeated ad nauseum from one book to the next, having read one book is the equivalent of having read at least 20 of them. Next question?

:D
 
Awful :( It'd be tragic if it wasn't just so uncaringly mendacious.
 
Then there are further problems.

In the email, Peter says this: I showed Sylvia a picture of my 33-year-old sister and said,

The photo caption says this: In loving Memory of Margaret [last name]: September 2nd 1966 - June 16th 2002

I don't have an advanced degree, but I fairly certain that 1966 + 33 = 1999.
Sorry, I missed this question earlier. And yes, I had noticed this as well.

Margaret was born in September of 1966.

Browne was at the book store in January of 2001.

This would mean that Margaret would have been 34 years old, and had only been so for a few months. For someone to have said she was 33 when she had actually turned 34 five months earlier, does not strike me as difficult to believe.

Did he misquote himself in the email? Or did he properly quote himself, but got her age wrong when he spoke with Browne? Or did he mistype the birth year, and she was actually born in 1965? I decided it was not worth asking Peter about.
 
The image at the top of the article has now been replaced with another. Also notice the new section at the boom of the article, with an added bonus picture.
 
Interesting that Sylvia just can't seem to smile with her eyes. The pictures of Peter and his sister are so sad. How horrible to lose your sister so young.

PBF, I'm sorry about your friend, too.
 
Sorry, I missed this question earlier. And yes, I had noticed this as well.

Margaret was born in September of 1966.

Browne was at the book store in January of 2001.

This would mean that Margaret would have been 34 years old, and had only been so for a few months. For someone to have said she was 33 when she had actually turned 34 five months earlier, does not strike me as difficult to believe.

Did he misquote himself in the email? Or did he properly quote himself, but got her age wrong when he spoke with Browne? Or did he mistype the birth year, and she was actually born in 1965? I decided it was not worth asking Peter about.
I can buy that.

I find two things rather telling in this thread:

1. Skeptics, even those highly supportive of a particular position, are still skeptical of claims in regard to that position.

2. When skeptics advance claims (like RSL's to start this thread), the claims generally stand up to scrutiny. Where issues are pointed out, they get checked and--as in the case of the photo--revised to reflect reality.

Well done, Robert, as usual.
 
Beware, readers, the added "bonus picture" is quite gross. :sour:
You'd think I would have built up a tolerance to it by now.

I haven't.

Interesting that Sylvia just can't seem to smile with her eyes.
They are usually quite dead. When she does manage to smile with her eyes, it doesn't even look like her.

I can buy that.
Whew!

I find two things rather telling in this thread:

1. Skeptics, even those highly supportive of a particular position, are still skeptical of claims in regard to that position.

2. When skeptics advance claims (like RSL's to start this thread), the claims generally stand up to scrutiny. Where issues are pointed out, they get checked and--as in the case of the photo--revised to reflect reality.
I'm always open to criticism, here and elsewhere. I truly appreciate it that people here are both watching my back, and keeping me honest, as it were.

They let me know when they think someone is trying to sneak one by me, and they let me know when they think I am not being fair, logical and clear.

These are both invaluable services, and I can't say enough how much I appreciate them.

Well done, Robert, as usual.
Thanks, Garrette.
 
I can buy that.

I find two things rather telling in this thread:

1. Skeptics, even those highly supportive of a particular position, are still skeptical of claims in regard to that position.

2. When skeptics advance claims (like RSL's to start this thread), the claims generally stand up to scrutiny. Where issues are pointed out, they get checked and--as in the case of the photo--revised to reflect reality.

Isn't it awesome? :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom