Yeah, that's in
your society

I've only met one guy in my life who was circumsised (he was from the USA) and I thought it was kind of icky

I guess it's all about what you are used to. It's not common in Sweden.
I thought that most doctors agreed on these days that circumsision have no added health or hygiene benefits at all?? I must read up on this

In any case, on the behalf of our Swedish guys, most of them have not dirty dicks!
(sorry for derailing further)
I'll respond to you, Fran, because you're civil.
My stepkids are both uncircumcised, at the wishes of their father. They are notorious about not cleaning properly, and I have to regularly take a direct hand helping out (eww), because their mother thinks it's inappropriate for her to do so. One has had three skin infections around the head, due to lack of proper hygiene.
My own circumcised kids have never had that problem - not once.
Granted, this is one anecdote only, and only serves to illustrate that parents need to be more diligent in teaching their kids proper hygiene... but that's been my experience.
Prior to meeting my stepkids, I had a brief relationship with an uncircumcised man, whose member I found nauseating. It pretty quickly killed any intimacy, and he (an adult!) had a very foul-smelling member - mainly because he found it hard to keep it properly cleaned (in the field).
My experience so far has been that removing the foreskin does nothing to harm the male, and helps by making it easier to keep clean. Certainly, there's no loss in sensation, no loss in function, no loss in sexual desire or enjoyment, no loss in any conceivable way. I'm rather glad to be circumcised!
Of course, some people are also against piercing a child's ears for much the same or similar reasons, which I am also not against. I have no problem at all removing an unnecessary part of the body, or decorative piercing. I'm not even against tatooing children or extending earlobes, as is prevalent in some tribles.
What I am against are clearly harmful mutilations, such as clitoral removal, neck extension, forced limitation of foot growth, etc. These cause irreparable harm. Circumcision does not.