I may be reading him wrong.
If I have, I'm sure he'll set me straight.
My former boss was a Buddhist who had been through AA. (He had gone against his will after some legal troubles related to his drinking. He never thought he was an alcoholic, but they assured him that he was, based on several different things.)That's what I find interesting. I wonder what they think of the "Higher Power" tenet of the program.
I guess maybe he never really was an alcoholic, or maybe it's possible for some alcoholics to learn to control it. But it's certainly possible to quit drinking without a higher power. In fact, I'd go so far as to say that it's more important that you accept the power within yourself than to give the power to an outside source. Give the control back to the drinker, instead of taking it away from them. But that's just me.
(My father was an alcoholic my whole childhood and never did quit. Haven't seen him in over 30 years. Don't know if he's alive or dead.)
If I'm not mistaken, the core of AA is the recognition of the higher power.
If you reject that premise, how to you attribute any help AA may be offering you?
(The only problem I have is if it's court imposed, which personally I feel is against the basic tenents of AA.)
2) You cannot change anything anyone does but yourself. You wouldn't believe how difficult this is to learn.
....When they told him about the "higher power" bit, he argued that he didn't believe in a higher power. They told him it didn't have to be a god, that it could be whatever he wanted it to be. Didn't make sense to him, but he got on with it.
Decided early on that he didn't buy any of the "I'm an alcoholic, so I can never drink again" stuff. He felt like that was allowing the alcohol to control him instead of him controlling the alcohol (something for which I've always admired him). Last I saw him, he'd been out of the program for many, many years and was always, as long as I'd known him, able to drink socially and then stop.....
........I finally found sobriety through AA. I don't believe in god so obviously I didn't believe any mythical being was going to remove my desire to drink.
What AA does provide though is support of other individuals who've learned how to live without alcohol.
God didn't help me....but a lot of other human beings did.......
What I'm wondering is how one who rejects the "Higher Power" tenet can continue with the rest of the program successfully.
Can the other 11 points work without #3?
In that case, your friend rejected both the Higher Power as well as the "I'm an alcoholic" tenet. He was able to then muster the ability to control his drinking.
What I'm wondering is how one who rejects the "Higher Power" tenet can continue with the rest of the program successfully.
Can the other 11 points work without #3?
Alcoholics CAN go for long periods of time without drinking. It's a myth that alcholism involves a low level of will power. Some alcoholics-to prove they are in control-will exert that will power and abstain from alcohol for weeks or even months. The problem is--they're miserable. The desire to use and the obsession is still there. It's often referred to as "white-knuckling"..for good reason.