(Split thread) Claim of (personal) proof of psychic powers

But… you wanted more than just a biiiig reaction, you wanted to properly [rule 8] with the skeps a bit. So, cackling with glee, you had SR actually change his mind and see reason! Now, this is something that just does NOT happen! Woos like SRs just don’t do that. It’s not in their nature. To paraphrase Robert Sheckley: it would be the equivalent of finding a palm tree growing in Antarctica, and upon examination, discovering that its fruit are not coconuts, but granny smith apples.


Bolding mine.

PBF, angrybeliever, Miss Anthrope, TBT, ST and others here must have all missed out on your revelation of the immutable truth on the unchangeability of peoples' beliefs.

We should rename this the
JRLet'sNotBotherBecauseNo-OneChangesTheirMindFoundation.

It's not in their nature. Crikey.
 
I think dogjones got it right.. this SR just wanted the attention, and that's exactly what he gets.
 
Bolding mine.

PBF, angrybeliever, Miss Anthrope, TBT, ST and others here must have all missed out on your revelation of the immutable truth on the unchangeability of peoples' beliefs.

We should rename this the
JRLet'sNotBotherBecauseNo-OneChangesTheirMindFoundation.

I agree with the spirit of your post, but I would like to make a distinction. My change over time has led me to the conclusion that there is no evidence for the paranormal or supernatural. It is my understanding that the others listed may not all be in that place, and just like SylviaRox, still believe in such things...just not Sylvia.
 
You do realize this proves exactly NOTHING as a determinant of the credulity of psychic phenomena, yes?

Skepticism, as you should know, has its basis in hardcore science. Repeatable and consistent results, subjectivity as totally removed as is possible. Your above "test" fails. You dropped your candy on this example.

I have no idea how JREF would conduct a test of your friend's psychic ability, but here is mine:

Your friend is put into a room, no windows.

There are 5 rooms across the hall from her room.

Five random persons are selected off the street and each is led to a room.

Somebody opens the door to your friend's room, tells her the people are in place, and asks her to proceed. Absolutely no information about the 5 people is provided (none necessary - she is psychic).

Your friend must do the following:

1. Correctly determine the sex of each person.
2. Correctly determine the hair color of each person.
3. Correctly determine the eye color of each person.
4. Correctly determine whether each person is a child or an adult.

Results must be 100% accurate.

I'd give her a million bucks if she got everything right.

I think several of these are too easy. Child or adult randomly taken off the street? I'd say "adult" would be 100% correct for all 5. The possiblilty that the "psychic" happened to see likely candidates on the street before they're brought in should be considered too, so she should be limited to giving answers to questions that are not physical descriptions.

SR already said the friend gave first and last names, I think that would do it in a blind test. Now we don't know if the names were exactly right, close to, sounded like, etc. which would give us a better idea of what SR considers proof.
 
Last edited:
That person is not going to respond in this thread. It defeats their purpose.
 
I agree with the spirit of your post, but I would like to make a distinction. My change over time has led me to the conclusion that there is no evidence for the paranormal or supernatural. It is my understanding that the others listed may not all be in that place, and just like SylviaRox, still believe in such things...just not Sylvia.


Yep, absolutely noted. I lumped you all in common just because you've all had, as I understand it, some sort of change in thinking. Clearly impossible, of course, because it's not in your nature:rolleyes:

Perhaps the thread you started about the others' beliefs will clarify what's going on there...!

Cheers,
Moufflon
 
For my part, I can't figure out how a person can match up only four out of five appropriate pairings. It's not possible. If you correctly match four pairs, the remaining two elements must be a match, yes? Or did I understand SR's test incorrectly? :confused:

It matters not, really. That "test" is so weak that SR would believe I was a psychic if I correctly told him his fly was open.
 
Bolding mine.

PBF, angrybeliever, Miss Anthrope, TBT, ST and others here must have all missed out on your revelation of the immutable truth on the unchangeability of peoples' beliefs.

We should rename this the
JRLet'sNotBotherBecauseNo-OneChangesTheirMindFoundation.

It's not in their nature. Crikey.

Mouf, you misunderstand - actually it's my fault for not being clear. I didn't mean that woos can never change their minds, or anything quite as far reaching. I meant woos like SR. And by "like SR" I mean the ones who charge in and immediately demonstrate their complete lack of ability to see reason. Go back to the first 7 pages or so of the thread. He responded to none of the reasonable requests for evidence, he persistently ignored evidence that was staring him in the face, called people liars, etc etc. This is not the behaviour of a person capable of changing their mind. And the responses just seem a little... fake. They are formulaic responses, tailored to wind us skeps up.

And suddenly this guy gets rational and changes his mind? Naaaahhhh...! Completely and utterly inconsistent with his character. COMPLETELY. But let's give him the benefit of the doubt and assume he IS capable of changing his mind. It's still HIGHLY improbable that he would suddenly do it here, in public, as the result of losing a rather agressive confrontation with a bunch of skeptics. You have both irrationality and defensiveness to deal with in this situation.

Sorry man, it just don't ring true. I know you want to believe you made a difference and I'm on your side, but humans really don't tend to behave this inconsistently.

I could be wrong.

BUT I AIN'T!

He's an imp!
 
Mouf, you misunderstand - actually it's my fault for not being clear. I didn't mean that woos can never change their minds, or anything quite as far reaching. I meant woos like SR. And by "like SR" I mean the ones who charge in and immediately demonstrate their complete lack of ability to see reason. Go back to the first 7 pages or so of the thread. He responded to none of the reasonable requests for evidence, he persistently ignored evidence that was staring him in the face, called people liars, etc etc. This is not the behaviour of a person capable of changing their mind. And the responses just seem a little... fake. They are formulaic responses, tailored to wind us skeps up.

And suddenly this guy gets rational and changes his mind? Naaaahhhh...! Completely and utterly inconsistent with his character. COMPLETELY. But let's give him the benefit of the doubt and assume he IS capable of changing his mind. It's still HIGHLY improbable that he would suddenly do it here, in public, as the result of losing a rather agressive confrontation with a bunch of skeptics. You have both irrationality and defensiveness to deal with in this situation.

Sorry man, it just don't ring true. I know you want to believe you made a difference and I'm on your side, but humans really don't tend to behave this inconsistently.

I could be wrong.

BUT I AIN'T!

He's an imp!


Dog,

I'm relieved to hear that clarification (and I note your sig line...!). And just to make myself clear, I don't think I made a difference in that thread in the slightest. Other forumities and other threads have, though, I think, and that was my point.

And I note SR's last post over there apparently admitting his impishness: drawn out by your sheer poetry of expression, no less!

I think I'm still of the mind, however, that SR's impery or tollishness - his intentions - are irrelevant to the value of the thread. Had we all called him a troll from the get-go, that thread would be entirely vacuous. As it is, because other forumites took his slander in good faith, as it were, it is filled with fine rebuffs and anti-SB evidence. If SR got a thrill -- and other forumities enjoyed it too, by the way -- all to the good!

Cheers
El Moufferino, if you're not into the whole berevity thing.
 
Coolio, your Moufness.

How is it in Edinburgh right now then? I rather miss EH1 - I lived there for a year in 99!
 
Dog,

I'm relieved to hear that clarification (and I note your sig line...!). And just to make myself clear, I don't think I made a difference in that thread in the slightest. Other forumities and other threads have, though, I think, and that was my point.

And I note SR's last post over there apparently admitting his impishness: drawn out by your sheer poetry of expression, no less!

I think I'm still of the mind, however, that SR's impery or tollishness - his intentions - are irrelevant to the value of the thread. Had we all called him a troll from the get-go, that thread would be entirely vacuous. As it is, because other forumites took his slander in good faith, as it were, it is filled with fine rebuffs and anti-SB evidence. If SR got a thrill -- and other forumities enjoyed it too, by the way -- all to the good!

Cheers
El Moufferino, if you're not into the whole berevity thing.

Exactly right, it's a good possibility that a believer or fence-sitter lurking out there has been interested enough to do somemore reading, learning, understanding and, hopefully, gained some enlightenment.
 
I thought of a series of names (first and last) in my head, and the general appearances of the people described by those names. My friend got them, or came very close, 4/5 times. She is not a psychic, but we forged a psychic connection.

How nice

and I have no such desire to make you cynical folk believe. I am merely contented, and can 'die happy', so to speak.

So why post?
 
[snip]
And no, headscratcher, remarkable claims only require proof if one expects the masses to believe them, and I have no such desire to make you cynical folk believe.
[/snip]

I could see how in principle I could witness something that would to my satisfaction be proof to me without being able to prove it to the world. It has never happened. I have witnessed aerial phenomena with roughly 50 or 60 of my family members that have made believers of people just by reading about. My uncle Bills theory was that it was a drunk Russian. Been hitting the Vodka and couldn't figure out which way was home LOL. Even at age 14 I tried to put basic controls on the observation at the time of the sighting and comparative observation since. I still have no good explanation of the observations. Does that make me a believer? No! At age 10 I tried to read my brothers brothers mind successfully on many occasions. Things like 'Little Rascals'. Does that make me believe? No! Does that make me cynical, hostile, or whatever else label you may choose? No!

You see SylviaRox many of us here want the truth so bad that we are not willing to allow our belief system to dictate it to us as fools. Have you tried to count the assumptions that can go into a seemingly simple belief? Do you know what a dependent or independent assumption is? If you could assume a high likelihood of all the assumptions do you know how fast that likelihood drops with each of those high likelihood assumptions that are identifiable or otherwise?

SylviaRox you call us cynical etc. when it is you that remains so cynical of these tools that have provided the world with the most powerful tools in history for discerning real truths. No we haven't got the whole truth just the tools to weed out the BS and continually add real truth. I pity you your cynicism.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom