Sound of WTC 7 collapsing

[leftysergeant]

Is this video genuine? Is the sound altered? It is, so far, the only clear sound I have on the collapse of WTC 7. It is, unfortunately, not of the entire collapse. It does not include the initiation.

If it is genuine, it might be compared to the Ashleigh Banfield tape to compare the background nosies.

I have been involved in a discussion of the Banfield tape and pointed out that the only sound heard is of the collapse, and no cutting charges.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SIbqaybkbWI

 

[phunk]

Is this video genuine? Is the sound altered? It is, so far, the only clear sound I have on the collapse of WTC 7. It is, unfortunately, not of the entire collapse. It does not include the initiation.

If it is genuine, it might be compared to the Ashleigh Banfield tape to compare the background nosies.

I have been involved in a discussion of the Banfield tape and pointed out that the only sound heard is of the collapse, and no cutting charges.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SIbqaybkbWI

Don't see any reason to believe the sound is altered, but unfortunately it looks like the camera stopped and they hit record again when the collapse started. None of the build-up to the collapse (like the penthouses collapsing) is in the video.

 

[1337m4n]

"I told ya that sucker was gonna go!"


Truthers: How did he know?

 

[leftysergeant]

Truthers: How did he know?

That was, of course, a predictable question that they raised on YouTube. My response was to the effect that he had seen two other burning buildings do the same thing, and saw part of one of those buildings fall on it, and that the fire department has said it would happen.

 

[GregoryUrich]

That was, of course, a predictable question that they raised on YouTube. My response was to the effect that he had seen two other burning buildings do the same thing, and saw part of one of those buildings fall on it, and that the fire department has said it would happen.

Why aren't the guys in the video asking, "Man, what were all those explosions?"?

ETA: What's the Banfield tape?

 

[Shrinker]

Wow, how annoying is that guy?

 

[peteweaver]

At six seconds there's a jerk. The upper penthouse collapse is omitted.

The vid has been doctored.

 

[GregoryUrich]

Wow, how annoying is that guy?

Is that the jerk Pete is talking about?

 

[phunk]

At six seconds there's a jerk. The upper penthouse collapse is omitted.

The vid has been doctored.

Or, more likely, the guy didn't sit there recording for hours waiting for it to fall, and grabbed the camera when he saw the collapse starting.

 

[Thunder]

video is a fake. sound added to suggest a "controlled demolition".

 

[~enigma~]

video is a fake. sound added to suggest a "controlled demolition".

What sound suggests a CD?

 

[1337m4n]

What sound suggests a CD?

"I told ya that sucker was gonna go!"


(actually, if anything that suggests that the collapse was, contrary to the claims of Truthers, quite predictable, but I'm just throwing out whatever's on the top of my head)

 

[Quad4_72]

The guy commentating was actually intelligent. He saw how damaged the building was and knew it was gonna collapse. He also commented on why they did not go in and put the fire out. Then again, MANY people at ground zero predicted that it was going to collapse.

 

[Walter Ego]

What's the Banfield tape?

Ashleigh Banfield was an MSNBC reporter broadcasting live from several blocks away from WTC7 when it collasped.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U8950hcKZXw

The interesting part of the video is anchor Brian Williams saying, "What we feared all afternoon has happened."

 

[Grizzly Bear]

Ashleigh Banfield was an MSNBC reporter broadcasting live from several blocks away from WTC7 when it collasped.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U8950hcKZXw

The interesting part of the video is anchor Brian Williams saying, "What we feared all afternoon has happened."

And lo behold... not one explosion heard during the entire report... not one, no bang, no sounds, just the collapse

 

[Alzke]

And lo behold... not one explosion heard during the entire report... not one, no bang, no sounds, just the collapse

You can't even hear whatever made them turn around the in first place. Proves..nothing.

 

[Walter Ego]

You can't even hear whatever made them turn around the in first place. Proves..nothing.

If you turn up the volume, you can hear a faint rumble just before Banfield reacts. The point, however, it that if WTC7 was controlled demolition you would have heard very loud explosions before the collapse.

 

[Shrinker]

You can't even hear whatever made them turn around the in first place. Proves..nothing.

It proves there was no loud bang. You might as well concede that, since AFAIK no truther has ever claimed there was a loud bang at the start of the collapse. Unless you wanna step up....

 

[leftysergeant]

You can't even hear whatever made them turn around the in first place. Proves..nothing.

Ermm..Actually, in this case lack of evidence is evidence. The lack of an element of CD which which should be obvious is evidence arguing against CD.

No BIG BA-BOOM, no CD.

 

[Tweeter]

The problem with that theory lefty is that mysteriously they stop filming at the exact moment of demolition. So we really dont get to see or hear what happens. This video reminds me of the one with the lady filming from her apartment and some how she misses the plane coming in. Just some more coincidences to add to the pile.