So much for "Subpoena Power"...

So then why doesn't Rove just simply lie instead of looking like he's trying to run from something?

You're asking why he doesn't intentionally incriminate himself for no reason instead of letting paranoid CTers who do way too many drugs think he is trying to run? Gosh, that will be a mystery for decades I suppose.

While I am sure you kids enjoy pretending that they won't speak under oath because they are guilty of something, the rest of the world already understands why the presidential administration/cabinet members (all of them, not just the current ones) don't testify under oath. unforuntately it's not as exciting as these conspiracy spy games you kids play up in the tree fort.
 
BZZT! So close.. but Clippy doesn't appear to be a truther.

Clearly, because no true Scotsman truther would claim that subpoena power would be decisive. Fraudulently eliminating the evidence that disproves your thesis, for no other reason than that it disproves your thesis, is Conspiracy Theory 101 stuff.

Dave
 
Time and again, we are told by Truthers that if they were given a new investigation and granted subpoena power, they would get Bush and Cheney on the stand and break 'em...

But today, former White House advisor Karl Rove ignored a Congressional subpoena in a case involving suspicion of undue political influence.

Good luck getting a President and Vice-President to show up and admit to to the murder of 3,000 people, Truthers.
IIRC Rove can still be found in "Contempt of Congress." So he hasn't got out of it yet.
 
Last edited:
IIRC Rove can still be found in "Contempt of Congress." So he hasn't got out of it yet.

Granted. But the point I was making was that if a low-level member of the administration would risk contempt, or any other potential criminal charge, to avoid testifying over a relatively insignificant matter, there is no possibility of Bush or Cheney responding satisfactorily to a subpoena related to their involvement in a 9/11 conspiracy.

A point, of course, which escapes the likes of deep44, who'd rather spend his time playing semantic games and "collecting" JREF posts he has deemed personally offensive.
 
avoid testifying over a relatively insignificant matter, there is no possibility of Bush or Cheney responding satisfactorily to a subpoena related to their involvement in a 9/11 conspiracy.

Just so I have you correctly, are you saying that in relation to 9/11 framing a political opponnent based on forced testimony from someone who had to write down his pre-planned testimony is 'insignificant'?

I don't want to derail, just clarify.
 
IIRC Rove can still be found in "Contempt of Congress." So he hasn't got out of it yet.

Who's going to arrest him? The Justice Department already ruled that it isn't legal to subpeona him. It's very common for people to get outraged at the Executive Branch of the government when it oversteps its' legal bounds. I wonder if people would do the same if the Legislative Branch would do the same.
 
This has been said a lot about the Truthers ,but has to be said again:
What kind of mentality are we talking about that beleives that Bush,Cheney and co are responsible for the cold blooded murder of 3'000 innocent people but that Bushco would have moral qualms about commiting perjury?


...or "disappearing" any other person subpoenaed for that matter?

BZZT! So close.. but Clippy doesn't appear to be a truther.


Well, in all fairness... you also think 9/11 doesn't appear to be a terrorist attack by Islamic fundamentalists, so I guess we can forgive you for not digging a little deeper before rubbing that egg on your face.
 
Last edited:
You're asking why he doesn't intentionally incriminate himself for no reason instead of letting paranoid CTers who do way too many drugs think he is trying to run? Gosh, that will be a mystery for decades I suppose.

So let me see if I follow clueless. A subpoena has absolutely no power because the person being subpoenaed can simply lie. But that same person will fight the powerless subpoena tooth and nail because they don't want to incriminate themselves?
 
So let me see if I follow clueless. A subpoena has absolutely no power because the person being subpoenaed can simply lie. But that same person will fight the powerless subpoena tooth and nail because they don't want to incriminate themselves?

It appears that no, you don't follow. I would gently suggest that you re-read the thread, or at least the posts to which you are purporting to respond.
 
Why? Can't some people respond for themselves?


Can't someone else who actually understands the topic respond to your question on a public forum? You, after all, weren't asking for personal information from Jonnyclueless. There's no indication that only he could provide the information you're asking for.

Besides, if it turns out that LashL is wrong, Jonnyclueless can clarify when he returns.
 
Last edited:
Can't someone else who actually understands the topic respond to your question on a public forum? You, after all, weren't asking for personal information from Jonnyclueless. There's no indication that only he could provide the information you're asking for.

Besides, if it turns out that LashL is wrong, Jonnyclueless can clarify when he returns.

LashL wrong? It's kind of hard to be wrong when you don't commit to actually saying anything isn't it?
 
So let me see if I follow clueless. A subpoena has absolutely no power because the person being subpoenaed can simply lie. But that same person will fight the powerless subpoena tooth and nail because they don't want to incriminate themselves?

It appears that no, you don't follow. I would gently suggest that you re-read the thread, or at least the posts to which you are purporting to respond.


Because it seems apparent to me that you have misinterpreted the portion of Johnnyclueless' post that you cited (while studiously ignoring the rest of his post). It appears that you are not only trying to put words in his mouth, but that you are also trying to then garble them in a most peculiar way.

That is why I suggested that you re-read the thread or at least the posts to which you purported to respond. You might find that doing so assists you in comprehension.

Can't some people respond for themselves?

I have no doubt at all that Johnnyclueless is perfectly capable of responding to your post, and he will probably do so in due course, but this is a public discussion forum which, by definition, means that you ought to expect that members will post if, as, and when they wish in response to any posts they wish.

If you have a problem with that, then perhaps you should consider confining yourself to private chatrooms and personal e-mail rather than posting on a public discussion forum.

Moreover, if your post was intended to elicit a response solely from Johnnyclueless, unfortunately, your poor writing and poor punctuation skills prevented you from making any such intention clear.
 
Last edited:
Because it seems apparent to me that you have misinterpreted the portion of Johnnyclueless' post that you cited (while studiously ignoring the rest of his post). It appears that you are not only trying to put words in his mouth, but that you are also trying to then garble them in a most peculiar way.

That is why I suggested that you re-read the thread or at least the posts to which you purported to respond. You might find that doing so assists you in comprehension.

Oh is that why? Well it's hard to argue with an expert on garbling things.

I have no doubt at all that Johnnyclueless is perfectly capable of responding to your post, and he will probably do so in due course, but this is a public discussion forum which, by definition, means that you ought to expect that members will post if, as, and when they wish in response to any posts they wish.

Oh I'm sure he will respond eventually also. But like your response I just don't have any confidence it will support anything put forth in the op.

If you have a problem with that, then perhaps you should consider confining yourself to private chatrooms and personal e-mail rather than posting on a public discussion forum.

Moreover, if your post was intended to elicit a response solely from Johnnyclueless, unfortunately, your poor writing and poor punctuation skills prevented you from making any such intention clear.

I'm still waiting for someone to support the claim that subpoenas are useless because anyone could just lie. Will you be addressing that anytime soon or are you just going to continue to babble about public forum ethics?
 
"Meanies"? Don't flatter yourself - try "immature children".

Says the guy who is taking time out of his day to collect and record the posts of his adversaries to look for bad things.


That's NOT immature?


As for the US Government conspiring to murder 3,000 innocent people - unlike you, I understand the concept of a false flag attack. So if the US Government did play some role in planning the attack, or allowing it to happen, they were in acting in what they believed were the best long-term interests of the US and its citizens.

What would you suggest I do to prevent the US Government from acting in the best long-term interests of the US and its citizens?

Unlike you, I understand that before presenting an idea as a claim, you should follow that idea to its logical conclusion.

In this case, you are saying it is a GOOD thing that the government is covering up 9/11. You are, AT THE SAME TIME, calling for a new, public investigation to determine whether the government is covering up 9/11.

If you believe that the government has a noble motive for concealing the details of 9/11, then why are you trying to investigate 9/11? Wouldn't you be destroying the government's noble plans?
 
Who's going to arrest him? The Justice Department already ruled that it isn't legal to subpeona him. It's very common for people to get outraged at the Executive Branch of the government when it oversteps its' legal bounds. I wonder if people would do the same if the Legislative Branch would do the same.
While the Senate cannot compel the DoJ (part of the Executive Branch) to act against a member or former member of the Executive Branch under the rules of "seperation of power," they can have the Sergeant-at-Arms arrest the person found in contempt and hold them in a cell at the capitol. However, this is unlikely to happen. More likely Senate Rules authorize them to direct the Senate Legal Counsel to file a civil action against the person found in contempt. The federal district court would then issue another order for a person to comply with the Senate process. If the person then refuses to comply with the Court's order, the person may be cited for contempt of court and may incur sanctions imposed by the Court (the Judicial Branch). The civil procedure can only be used against Executive branch officials "in certain limited circumstances." It's been used against Sec. Morton and Sec. Kissinger in the 70s, Rita Lavelle in the 80s (she served 5 months in prison), Janet Reno in the 90s, and is currently being used against Harriet Miers and Josh Bolten.
 
<snipped childish insults>

I'm still waiting for someone to support the claim that subpoenas are useless because anyone could just lie.

<snipped further childish insults>


That's odd. The exchange that you and I were having was about Johnnyclueless' post #41 and your misinterpretation of it. Johnnyclueless did not make the claim that "subpoenas are useless because anyone could just lie".


That said, personally, I do not think that subpoenas are useless. A proper and legally valid subpoena can compel the attendance of a witness before a court of competent jurisdiction, for instance. It is simultaneously true, of course, that anyone - whether subject to a subpoena or not - could lie. In other words, while a proper and legally valid subpoena can compel a person's attendance, it cannot compel a person to be truthful if the person chooses not to be.

I also see the utility of proper and legally valid subpoenas in circumstances where a witness wishes to testify but does not want to appear to be doing so voluntarily. In such circumstances, the subpoena gives such a witness the ability to say, "Hey, I didn't want to testify but I was legally required to do so," and such a witness then obtains the benefit of the buffer, so to speak, that he was seeking.

So, while a proper and legally valid subpoena is, therefore, not "useless", its utility is limited by the circumstances of any particular case.
 
What is very obvious here, Karl Rove feels he is above the law. How can anyone defend that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom