Of what use is it to to you to know the "intrinsic worth" of a company, even if there is such a thing, if no one else agrees with you that it's worth that? Aren't you assuming that, over the long term if not necessarily the short term, everyone else will in fact end up agreeing with you, so that you'll eventually be able to sell your stock for what you think it's worth?
Yes, this is the basis of the quote above: "In the short-term the stock market is a voting machine, in the long-term it is a weighing machine."
Please note that efficient market theorists will disagree strongly with what follows. So be it.
The market does not act rationally in the short term (I assert). Forget the stock market, and just focus on a business. Say I own a restaraunt that has $100,000 in profits every year. What would you pay to own 50% of that business? Answer that in your own mind, taking into account that you can earn 6% or so risk free in bonds, and that there is no guarantee that my business will continue making those profits.
Now, every day I come to you and offer you a price for that 50% stake. You can either buy, sell, or do nothing.
Say I offer a price of 20M. Would you take that offer? Probably not. Say I offer you a price of 100K. Would you take that? Probably. The return on that is 50%, which gives a huge margin of safety should my business not do as well in the following years. So, we can put the fair price of the 50% stake at somewhere between 100K and 20M.
There's more to it than that. I'd look at profit on investment - say I spend 10M to open another restaurant, but it will also only earn 100K. that's a poor return, and it's probably not a good business model. But say I can open a new place for 200K. That's a return of 50% - a great investment. Again, this is simplified enormously, but thats the idea. I would ask why this restaurant can make 50%. If it can make 50%, why can't it's competitors? If I have no answer for that, it's probably a fluke, or competitors will be moving in to take that profit. If I have an answer for that, well then, I know what I'm going to buy. If it is a great francise, with the ability to make greater profits than its competition, people will eventually wise up and buy the stock.
So, the arguments goes, if you see an underpriced stock, eventually the market will recognize and reward you by increasing the stock price.
Warren Buffett bought the Washington Post when all of its assets were valued at 400M, but the total stock price was only 50M. He wasn't cagey - he didn't value it at 400M while the rest of the analysts were saying it was worth 40-60M. Read analysts' opinions, and they put it around 400M. Yet everyone was scared of the market, pessimistic about the earnings potential, despite the fact that DC was basically a one paper town, and the company owned very lucrative media companies. So, Warren bought and bought and bought. Compare the stock price then and now. Warren profitted hugely, and now the stock price more or less reflects the intrinsic value of the company.
Efficient market theorists hold that all known information is already priced into stocks. I just don't buy it. Look at the trends of prices - in any short term period they just do not correlate to the long term business prospects of a business. How can a company lose 5-10% of it's value in a few days, short of very negative news such as happened with Enron, et al? It can't, yet the stock price can change that much or more in a short period of time.
There are also factors that cause a stock to be sold or bought that are unrelated to it's value. Many institutional investors are bound to strict rules - they can't own stock or bonds that have a credit rating less than X, they can't own a stock in the S&P 500, etc. So, if a stock goes off of the S&P 500, there is a massive sell, but the company itself may be very sound. The sellers may
dearly wish they could own the stock, but cannot due to the rules they are bound to. So, the price drops. Over time, as cash becomes available and people see the price is low, the price raises back up to a fair value.
Another example of fear: Eddie Lampert and Sears. When he acquired Sears and Kmart Kmart was bankrupt. People didn't think much of the future of these companies. Stock prices were very, very low. Eddie has turned these two into cash cows - he's sitting on 5+ billion in cash. Look at the stock prices today. There was
tons of intrinsic value in those companies, once you stopped focusing on per store earnings growth and started focusing on per store profits. Sales are down, profits are way up. Back at the restructuring, the two companies reflected an enormous value in real estate holdings - something Eddie has barely capitalized on yet. So, prices back then were based on fear - fear that the companies would fail, or that Eddie could not unlock the intrinsic values in the company. Now we have a more difficult valuation - what is the value of that 5 billion in cash in Lampert's hands? What is the value of the real estate holdings he is sitting on? What is the value of the fact that he recently got permission to invest it without needing to check with the board of directors, or report it to the SEC? Is that value built into the stock price, or not?
Efficient markets says the value
is built into it. If SHLD was running at $5 or whatever, it was there because no one knew what the future of SHLD would be. Could be, but Lampert very clearly explained what he was going to do with SHLD, and how he was going to get value out of the company. I say people are fearful, and greedy, and exhibit a herd mentality. In the long run value is impossible to ignore, but in the short run it is far easier to run with the pack. People were buying internet stocks. Prices were soaring. Do you get in or not? If you got in, on the basis of greed and following the pack, you got spanked, hard. If you looked at intrinsic value - low or negative profits and a steeply rising stock price with no business model predicting future profits, you stayed far, far away. Lampert has said what he is going to do with the future of SHLD. What's the value? What's Lampert's management skill to make that occur? What's the value of the fact that Lampert has the majority of his personal wealth invested in SHLD, and that he will be compensated not on stock options, or the other mickey mouse compensations schemes used by CEOs, but on the stock price alone? Does the stock price currently reflect that value, or not? You decide.
This is just what I think. I recognize I haven't proven my case, just stated it. I think there is a
lot of irrational behavior in the market, and not enough cash on hand for rational investors to immediately take advantage of that irrational behavior. I could be wrong. I'm betting against Nobel lauretes from Chicago. I'm also betting for people like Graham, Buffett, Berkowitz, Lampert, people who have made quite satisfactory gains in the market. I'm okay with that.