So did they find thermite or not?

A photo is here showing one of the steps necessary in the formation of Jone's thermite; NIST NCSTAR 1-3C WTC investigation, appendix D on page 442 Figure D-1.
 
One could even question the validity of their samples. I don't think any were collected directly after 9/11 (or on that day) or do we even know how they were collected. The truthers love this paper though because they are ignorant enough and love to bow to authority that they don't even check the veracity of what is "reported". Just looking at the spectra was enough for me to be rolling on the floor laughing at their conclusions.
 
My guess is probably not. But that's just a guess, I already know how truthers are capable of lies, myths, and downright stupidity. This specific claim is one I've never been able to get to the bottom of because I don't understand much about the subject.

I hear claims again and again that thermite was found in WTC dust. Exactly what is present in the dust that has the "truth" cult so convinced that thermite was there? Just chemicals or elements consistent with thermite? I keep hearing about the Iron-rich microspheres? Are there any reasons for thermite to be there other than to be used in state of the art hush-a-bombs?

The paper that I keep running into on the internets:

http://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/archivos_pdf/activethermitic_911.pdf

I'm sure anyone who's researched the cult mythology has seen that paper. I don't have any technical knowledge of chemistry. I only have a basic knowledge of physics and mathematics, still finishing up diff eq in school.

Plus, if they used this thermite, then why do truthers use the "lateral ejection of debri" canard all the time? And the crumbling of the building? How does thermite do that? My guess is, it doesn't. But like I said, I'm not an expert.:rolleyes:

Thermite is an incindiary from what I've read, meaning it would have cut the steel, and that's how the high priests of the cult often describe it.

Thermite would not have pulverized or launched debri into the air- which Richard Gage often sites as evidence for his controlled demolition cockamamie.

Well, since thermite is a mixture of rust and aluminum and an aluminum plane hit a building a steel frame, you think they just might have found some aluminum and some rust there?
 
A photo is here showing one of the steps necessary in the formation of Jone's thermite; NIST NCSTAR 1-3C WTC investigation, appendix D on page 442 Figure D-1.

I don't understand what you are getting at. Care to elaborate?

Figure D-1 is captioned "Formation of a black scale between paint and steel after exposure greater than 650°C. Paint readily spalled".

I think this implies that black scales form by heat. I don't read this as implying that heat >650°C would be necessary for spalling. Simple corrosion of the underlying material might do, or impact forces during the collapse.

Also, you need to keep in mind, that the "highly energetic red-grey chips" that Harrit, Jones e.al. looked at (samples a-d) are very likely not primer paint from WTC steel. They are a different material than the one shown in that Figure D-1. They are very likely another paint or primer, spalled from some other surface. Which paint and which surface has not been determined yet.
 
One could even question the validity of their samples.

Yes, one could, but I think that would be one of the weakest objections to be had against the paper. I, for one, am confident that the material is what they claim it is - dust that had settled from the dust clouds of the WTC collapses. Some contamination is possible due to improper handling, but if they find characteristic grains in all four of them, then the assumption that they all come from the same WTC event is pretty reasonable.

I don't think any were collected directly after 9/11 (or on that day) or do we even know how they were collected.

The paper details that on pp. 8f: The first was collected by hand about ten minutes after the second dust cloud settled. The second on the morning of 9/12, the third early afternoon of 9/12, and the fourth about a week later. The authors explain where and how they were collected and stored.

The truthers love this paper though because they are ignorant enough and love to bow to authority that they don't even check the veracity of what is "reported". Just looking at the spectra was enough for me to be rolling on the floor laughing at their conclusions.

Care to elaborate? What's wrong in their interpretation of the spectra?
 
Well, since thermite is a mixture of rust and aluminum and an aluminum plane hit a building a steel frame, you think they just might have found some aluminum and some rust there?

To be honest, they did not just find some rust here and some aluminium there; they found all three required elements together in a fairly homogenous material, suggesting (I think correctly) that this material was manufactured with all the measured constituents in there on purpose.
They just misidentify the chemicals: They think they found elemental aluminium, but that is not actually supported by the data. Instead, the data points towards aluminiumsilicates, which make no sense at all in thermite.
 
Care to elaborate? What's wrong in their interpretation of the spectra?

All sorts of things. Namely that they basically say all three smalls are one thing yet all spectra vary in peak size positioning, etc. I look at the spectra and immediately I see spectra that mostly have the same components but nothing tells me they are the same source or even what they claim they are. I don't even remember if they had a control in there.

I have to admit I haven't given a really good read but what I have read just leaves me scratching my head.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom