Smoldering Fires vs Diffusion Flames

NYCEMT86

Graduate Poster
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
1,091
After having to define this for RedIbis at the Truthers: what if you are wrong? thread. I figured I might as well go through this with all the truthers on this forum to better understand the fire at the WTC 7.

I am going to refer to the NFPA 921: Guide for Fire and Explosion Investigations 3rd Edition.

Smoldering Fires:

Definition: Smoldering - Combustion without flame, usually with incandescence and smoke. (REF: NPFA 921, Ch 1.3.110)

Smoldering is a relatively slow combustion process that occurs between oxygen in the air and a solid fuel. No flame is present, however the presence of very hot materials is on the surface of which combustion is proceeding. The surface undergoes glowing and charring. The glowing is indicative of a temperature in excess of 1000°C. A smoldering or glowing condition can occur at any point in the fire with the controlling factor being ventilation.

Smoldering during the initial state of the fire:

All structures, objects, and open areas for the most part, have a fuel and an oxygen source available, and in many locations within, the fuel and oxygen are in the ideal proportion to begin reacting. Even though everything is ready, the combustion process cannot begin until some source of heat triggers the process. Because this process is slow, not much air (oxygen) is required, even when the surrounding environment is at a relatively low temperature. The hotter the environment, the less oxygen it takes to sustain smoldering. The replacement of air takes place naturally as the air cycles.

During the smoldering process the oxygen and fuel are not in correct proportions, thus its by-products are the result of incomplete burning. High levels of carbon monoxide (CO) are produced. More than 10% of the fuel mass is converted to CO. The smoke from this type fire tends to condense on walls, windows and other cooler surfaces. These deposits of pyrolysis products will be widely distributed and the colors vary in shades of brown. The appearance can be sticky or wet, thick or dry, or dried and resinous.

Smoldering combustion will continue because of the very high temperatures at the oxidizing surface. As long as these temperatures remain high, the process can continue even in oxygen depleted atmospheres where the oxygen levels are as low as approximately 5%. In post-fire conditions, after the fire department extinguishes the fire with water, hidden areas where the water doesn’t reach can still smolder until the water penetrates it or until the fuel source is consumed.



Diffusion Flame:

A Diffusion Flame is defined as a combustion process in which the fuel gas and oxygen are transported into the reaction zone due to concentration differences.

The vast majority of un-wanted and un-controlled fires are diffusion flames.

During a flaming fire, conditions may exist that decrease the oxygen level below 16%. This causes the combustion process to slow, the flames subside and the temperature begins to decrease.



What is visible in this picture?

Could it be flames?

I hope this has helped.
 
NFPA 921: Guide for Fire and Explosion Investigations 3rd Edition

3rd edition? 3RD EDITION!?!

Just what was in the first two editions that "THEY" felt needed to be changed and hidden from us? Just when was this so called 3rd Edition written? After 9/11 I bet.

Just when will this madness end? Rewriting manuals and textbooks so that your so called "science" trumps common sense in regards to the Official Theory ... It's just deplorable.
 
3rd edition? 3RD EDITION!?!

Just what was in the first two editions that "THEY" felt needed to be changed and hidden from us? Just when was this so called 3rd Edition written? After 9/11 I bet.

Just when will this madness end? Rewriting manuals and textbooks so that your so called "science" trumps common sense in regards to the Official Theory ... It's just deplorable.

HAHA...every 3 years it renews. The 4th should be out this fall. I love the NFPA, they are worst than brady's when it comes to EMT books. The 10th edition had one tiny section add or removed, i am not sure but it still cost me 55 bucks for a new copy :rolleyes:
 
Nice, although it may well be in vain. I've asked Truthers if they've ever read ANY NFPA books or books by folks like Francis Brannigan ("Building Construction For The Fire Service"), and recommended they do so if they hadn't. Their silence was deafening.
 
NYCETM,

You don't say in your description of diffuse flame fires how hot these usually get and if they are the hottest or coolest of the types of fires.

Also, the photo of WTC 7 shows a very small portion of a very large office building. No one is contesting that fires were seen in about 12 or 13 windows. There is not however any photos of a raging fire anywhere else in WTC 7.
 
hot stuff, fire, and ignoring the facts and evidence the ever challenged truthers

NYCETM,

You don't say in your description of diffuse flame fires how hot these usually get and if they are the hottest or coolest of the types of fires.

Also, the photo of WTC 7 shows a very small portion of a very large office building. No one is contesting that fires were seen in about 12 or 13 windows. There is not however any photos of a raging fire anywhere else in WTC 7.
Too bad you were not there that day, the fires were out of control, all day long. Eyewitnesses from all over. Bet you can not find any of them because it will ruin your fantasy.

I have found fires with less oxygen get hotter, I bet that is covered in the book and people could research. Why does the truth movement on 9/11 fail to do real research, any research; why is 9/11 truth unable to do the hard work to learn and understand? Must not be fans of President Kennedy.
 
I have found fires with less oxygen get hotter
counter-intuitively, this is true (wheres your "common sense" now?)

the reason is because in a lack of oxygen materials can become heated beyond their normal autoignition temp without burning, then when they are exposed to oxygen theyll burn at a higher temp than normal, because they were already very hot to begin with
 
Much of what occurred on 9/11 is counter-intuitive. The greatest anomolies may actually be what occured in the pile, rather than the way in which the towers fell.

One of the more amusing phenomena described by debunkers is that hot iron and steam can create a reaction that produces hydrogen, and that this adds to the heat in the pile.

I am rather lacking in engineering skills, but I remember in high school having read about something called a "fire syringe" in which combustable matter and air, pressurized to some number of atmospheres, would cause combustion. I would assume that a diesel engine would be the most common application of this principle, but I have also seen it put forward as a possible way of generating energy from solid wastes, and perhaps making synthetic oil.

Now, given the immense weight of the debris from the towers, could some similar phenomenon also have occured in the pile? I would think that combustion in this manner, rather than conventional burning in air or smoldering would produce some very interesting hydrocarbon by products.
 
There are a few points I’d like to make regarding combustion.

For a given amount of reactants (i.e. fuel and oxygen) the energy released will be a constant value. This is related to, but is not the same as the temperature released in the combustion process.

Theoretically there is no such thing as an upper limit to the temperature at which a combustion reaction can no exceed.

Flame temperatures given in reference books are based on the fuel and air being at STP.
 
NYCETM,

You don't say in your description of diffuse flame fires how hot these usually get and if they are the hottest or coolest of the types of fires.

Also, the photo of WTC 7 shows a very small portion of a very large office building. No one is contesting that fires were seen in about 12 or 13 windows. There is not however any photos of a raging fire anywhere else in WTC 7.


Well it really depends on what is burning to determine the heat energy being released from said burned product. Thats why fire ranges and there is no set temperature.


Approximate Power Usage/Peak Heat Release Rate

Burning cigarette: 5W

Standard “A” Light Bulbs: 15 to 200 W

Burning match: 80 W

Coffee maker, hair dryer, toaster: 500 to 1500 W or 0.5 to 1.5 kW

Burning Coffee Maker: 40 kW

Small Trash Can, Trash Bag Fires: 50 to 300 kW

Burning Upholstered Chair: 80 kW to 2.5 MW

Burning Upholstered Sofa: 3,000 kW or 3 MW

Burning Christmas Tree: 1.6 MW to 5.2 MW

Base Design Fire: 5.3 MW



Dr. Greening, If you don't mind could you make sure my figures are right. It's been awhile and these are from my notes. Thanks.
 
snip . . .
Thats why fire ranges and there is no set temperature.


Approximate Power Usage/Peak Heat Release Rate

Burning cigarette: 5W

. . . snip

Note that NYCEMT86 is listing ranges in watts. This is another importent distingtion that the truthers overlook.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom