Skeptigirl's Magical Mythery Tour of Peru

Skeptic Ginger

Nasty Woman
Joined
Feb 14, 2005
Messages
96,955
This thread is describing what I found on my Peru extension of the Galapagos cruise. I set out to see a few of Peru's in/famous places of woo. If there is actually much to discuss here the mods can split the thread if need be. Mostly I just wanted to share the fun I had.


Here's a link to the photos that go with this story.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/30443314@N02/

First stop, Ica Peru to see the infamous Ica Stones. I had heard of these stones and planned a stop in Ica to see them. They are a fairly well known hoax, though the perpetrator is unknown. Could be the doctor who found them had them made or was fooled by someone else. The good Dr has since passed on. His daughter now owns the stones and the "museum".

Images
More images
Even more images

It turned out to be quite fascinating. I was lucky to find the place open since the 'museum' does not have regular hours. It consists of two rooms next door to each other in an old colonial building in Ica, Peru. An older woman was the acting caretaker. No one was there except me and the taxi driver.

It looked like something out of an Indiana Jones movie. In one room was an old desk with books and notebooks of all sorts 'research' like materials. I expected to see a couple stones on a shelf or two. Instead there are thousands and thousands of these engraved stones. They are on shelves, in cupboards and drawers and on the floor. The images range from people riding dinosaurs like the Flintstones to some explicit gay sex. There are hearts and guts being cut out (didn't look like surgery to me) and people slaying dinosaurs.

Someone went to an incredible amount of trouble for this hoax. Great fun seeing them. I only have one correction for the SkepDic entry:
Skeptics consider the stones to be a pathetic hoax
In no way are these stones "pathetic". Elaborate hoax is a much better description.



Second stop, the famous Nazca Lines. No explanation of this site needed, I presume, but here are some good sources of information and images:

Wiki
The Nazca Lines Revisited: Creation of a Full-Sized Duplicate
Nazca Lines and Culture
Explaining The Nazca Lines

And some images.

Sadly my pictures of the images did not show up well from the 4 seater plane I got to fly over the lines in. So I included a couple pictures showing the fact these lines are marked out on a very very large flood plain. It is fairly obvious considering the importance of water and the lack of it in this region that rain rituals had something to do with these lines.

It was also rather obvious flying over these lines and getting real perspective on them, the straight lines and trapezoids are indeed very large. The figures, however, are not as big as the images one typically sees. The "astronaut" is quite small. The other figures consist of what look to be ritual walking paths back and forth just as other ritual walking paths are found elsewhere in Inca ruins.

In the museum in town, I'm pleased to say the 'guide' was interested in telling us no ETs were involved and it is an insult to his ancestors to hear people make claims suggesting they were not capable of making the lines.

In another town, Arequipa, I went to see one of the "ice Mummies" which were ritually sacrificed children (again with those wonderful god beliefs :rolleyes: ). Turns out the evidence from the site those mummies were found shows evidence ~2,000 people walked up to the top of the volcano (we are talking 20,000+ foot peak here) during the sacrifice ritual. The Incas were really into their procession or walking rituals.



Third stop on the Mythery Tour was the meteorite crater near Puno, Peru on the Bolivian border. I'm going to venture to say I'm one of the few people who would take the time to go see this place other than the initial interest it sparked when the actual meteorite fell. And I'm going to stick my skeptical neck out here and make a bold statement. Some of the scientists were wrong about the cause of the mysterious illness. This story and my claim need a bit more explaining.

I love this one because it was full of myths from the first day, sparked conspiracy theories and ended with some facts and still a tad of fiction. Watch this video news brief on the initial event.

The story progressed: Scores ill in Peru 'meteor crash'
Peru - 'Meteor' Crash Leaves Crater 30 Meters In Diameter

Then came the sleazy meteorite hunters who managed to get in, buy the meteorites at a cheap price from the locals and get out of the country before the government caught them: Meteorite Crater Guarded by Peru's Police after U.S. Citizens Attempt to Traffic it Of course, I'd have bought them too. ;)

The site was declared a national heritage site and there were attempts to preserve it. But it's a mud hole, not much more and the money fell through to build a roof over it. There will probably be little left in another year.

An actual meteorite was recovered from the crater. Scientists did get to analyze it despite the fact a dealer grabbed up the specimens.

A meteorite that smacked into the Peruvian highlands last September may have punched holes into long-held theories about how such meteorites, called chondrites, interact with Earth's atmosphere.

The conspiracy theories
Conspiracy theories in the comments.

So, to review some of the initial myths, it was claimed the water in the crater boiled. Meteorites are not hot enough to do that. It would have had to have been a huge impact if friction as the meteor fell was going to do that. The water seeping into the crater was likely mistaken for boiling.

But what about the disagreement I have with the scientists? It's about these conclusions:
Peruvian scientists probe fumes from meteorite crater
'Toxic' fumes from Peru meteorite crater

No way. It had to be your run of the mill hysteria. Look at the pictures. The crater appears large in a couple of them, but it was more like 30 feet, not 30 meters. Look at the background. The houses are miles apart. The town is a few miles away. Any 'dust' or gases be they arsenic or sulfur would never have been concentrated enough to cause hundreds of people to become ill. Even the people who went to the crater right after it was formed would have at most been exposed to tiny traces that had yet to dissipate.

Nope, too small, too wide open of an area. The symptoms were no doubt consistent with hysteria, not actual acute inhalation poisoning. The scientists were just being nice and didn't want to accuse the villagers of ignorance.



So that's it. That's the Magical Mythery Tour of Peru. Of course I also saw the Galapagos with everyone else and Machu Picchu. I saw Lake Titicaca and an active volcano in Banos Ecuador as well as lots of other sites in Peru. I saw much of the Peru countryside, rode the very scary night bus on the coastal cliffs from Nazca to Arequipa and took the train from Puno to Cuzco. And I got to see an Andean Condor fly. :D
 
Last edited:
Thanks for sharing. It sounds like a wonderful adventure. I doubt I'll ever make that trip, so I'll live vicariously through you for a while.

:)
 
Wow, What a great adventure! I can see you made the most of your passage to South America. I want to go to ALL those places, including the Galapagos!

Thanks for sharing with us.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom