Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

In which case, we will have to wait and see whether the price of silver shoots up as a result of a shortage of physical gold.

How long would it be fair to wait to say whether or not it is going to happen ?

I wasnt making any inference to silver price, just that western investors perception of gold is quite different to those who buy most of it.
 
I wasnt making any inference to silver price, just that western investors perception of gold is quite different to those who buy most of it.

I didn't think you were. I was referring back to Muldur's post but was very unclear about the way that I did it.

Muldur said:
Could we see silver shoot up as the continuing problems with the gold supply force people out of gold and into alternatives?

I personally don't have a clue. If the silver price has not shot up (let's say it's still under $30) in:

- a week
- a month
- three months
- a year

can we say that it isn't.

Given that there seems to be a sense of immediacy about the alleged shortage of gold how about we say that if the price of silver is under $30 this time next week then the shortage of gold hasn't forced people into silver ?
 
Could we see silver shoot up as the continuing problems with the gold supply force people out of gold and into alternatives?

Sure, we could.

And if you're a betting person, or feel you have some insight others lack, buy up a bunch, either physical or futures, and ride the price up*.

But given that the information you went on to post is freely available, I still hold that it's already factored into the current price of silver, which itself factors in people's expectations of future moves.

BTW, I'm one of those in physical possession of what gold and silver I do own.


*If you do that, what would signal a price at which to sell?
 
Last edited:
http://goldsurvivalguide.co.nz/more-warnings-about-physical-gold/

Apparently this is not to be discussed as a policy issue, as my thread about the Fed vs Germany was banished to Conspiracy Theory when it is not "Theory" but documented FACT.

It's an opinion piece based on anecdotes:

First Jim Rickards reported that a Swiss bank refused to deliver roughly $40 million of gold bullion to a wealthy client for 30 days, and only finally physically delivered his gold when the client brought in his lawyers and threatened to take his story to Reuters and other syndicated financial news networks.

So a third hand story where, as a consequence of the circumstances the story can never appear in the press.....

Later in the week, James Turk reported that he is aware of another individual who has been trying to take physical possession of approximately $550,000 of silver for two months now from a Swiss bank with zero luck.

Another metal-maniac reporting a second-hand account


The plural of anecdote is not evidence.
 
It's an opinion piece based on anecdotes:

So a third hand story where, as a consequence of the circumstances the story can never appear in the press.....

Another metal-maniac reporting a second-hand account

The plural of anecdote is not evidence.

you know I'd like to be able to argue with you here, don't you? :)

unfortunately you are correct, and metals reporting suffers a lot from this.
 
you know I'd like to be able to argue with you here, don't you? :)

unfortunately you are correct, and metals reporting suffers a lot from this.

Stop being reasonable dammit :mad:

Can we have a five page derail over some tiny point that has no relevance to the main point at hand instead ? :D
 
Stop being reasonable dammit :mad:

Can we have a five page derail over some tiny point that has no relevance to the main point at hand instead ? :D

ask Scrut to come and contribute a standard incendiary and clueless one liner to set people off then? ;)
 
It's an opinion piece based on anecdotes:



So a third hand story where, as a consequence of the circumstances the story can never appear in the press.....



Another metal-maniac reporting a second-hand account


The plural of anecdote is not evidence.

And pay no attention to the Fed behind the curtain keeping Germany from inspecting its own gold reserves... Which, again, is documented FACT, not "anecdote" or "speculation", but confirmed FACT.
 
And pay no attention to the Fed behind the curtain keeping Germany from inspecting its own gold reserves... Which, again, is documented FACT, not "anecdote" or "speculation", but confirmed FACT.

That's debatable. The Germans have been given access to a proportion of their gold reserves but not unfettered access to all of it. I don't know why they haven't been given access to inspect all of it but conspiracy theories aside it could relate to one or more of the following:

  • Whatever arrangement the Germans have with the U.S. doesn't extend to gicing Germans access to the facility to inspect their gold (or there's a significant lead time).
  • The U.S. do not want to give foreign nationals access to their strategic gold reserves for reasons of national and/or commercial security
  • The amount of gold they are storing for the Germans is simply too large to easily move to a location where the Germans can inspect it
 
I didn't think you were. I was referring back to Muldur's post but was very unclear about the way that I did it.



I personally don't have a clue. If the silver price has not shot up (let's say it's still under $30) in:

- a week
- a month
- three months
- a year

can we say that it isn't.

Given that there seems to be a sense of immediacy about the alleged shortage of gold how about we say that if the price of silver is under $30 this time next week then the shortage of gold hasn't forced people into silver ?

Well, it's been a week now and silver has traded in the $23.50 - $24.50 range. If a shortage of gold is going to force people into silver, it hasn't happened in a way that has caused the price of silver to change significantly.
 
That's debatable. The Germans have been given access to a proportion of their gold reserves but not unfettered access to all of it. I don't know why they haven't been given access to inspect all of it but conspiracy theories aside it could relate to one or more of the following:

  • Whatever arrangement the Germans have with the U.S. doesn't extend to gicing Germans access to the facility to inspect their gold (or there's a significant lead time).
  • The U.S. do not want to give foreign nationals access to their strategic gold reserves for reasons of national and/or commercial security
  • The amount of gold they are storing for the Germans is simply too large to easily move to a location where the Germans can inspect it

Double talk and gobbledygook.

It's the GERMANS' gold. Not the Fed's. They should have complete and unfettered access to it at any time they choose, and if they want it all back tomorrow, then the Fed's response should be an immediate and unreserved "come and get it, we'll have it ready for you".

If you went to your bank and asked to inspect your safety deposit box and they started hemming and hawing about "it isn't the right time", "we can't let just anyone into the vault", etc you'd pitch a fit and you know it.

And you'd be right to do so. You're paying the bank for a service (storing your valuables). You didn't sign away your property rights to them.

Same with a bank deposit. It's YOUR funds, not the banks'. And if they told you "come back Tuesday" upon you asking even for a statement of account, you'd be more than justified in thinking "WTF?"
 
Last edited:
Double talk and gobbledygook.

It's the GERMANS' gold. Not the Fed's. They should have complete and unfettered access to it at any time they choose, and if they want it all back tomorrow, then the Fed's response should be an immediate and unreserved "come and get it, we'll have it ready for you".

If you went to your bank and asked to inspect your safety deposit box and they started hemming and hawing about "it isn't the right time", "we can't let just anyone into the vault", etc you'd pitch a fit and you know it.

And you'd be right to do so. You're paying the bank for a service (storing your valuables). You didn't sign away your property rights to them.

When I used to have a safe deposit box at the Yorkshire Bank in Barnard Castle, I wasn't allowed access to the vault to collect it myself, they would bring the safe deposit box to me in a private room. In some cases I did have to wait for a few minutes while they brought the box up and/or a private room came free.

That kind of thing is perfectly feasible for a small metal box, much less so with several tons of gold. I have no idea of the terms of the contract Germany have with the fed with respect to access to fed facilities to inspect the gold.

If the Fed are in breach of contract - i.e. the contract stipulates that the Germans should have immediate (or reasonable) access to inspect all their gold - then I think Germany should make a big deal about it. We don't know what the terms of the contract are and I see no reason why the fed should have to incur the costs of an inspection that they may not be contractually obliged to provide.


Edited to change.......

Same with a bank deposit. It's YOUR funds, not the banks'. And if they told you "come back Tuesday" upon you asking even for a statement of account, you'd be more than justified in thinking "WTF?"

It depends on the type of account. I have a deposit account where they send me annual statements. I can request an additional statement but it will take several days to arrive and I have to pay a fee. It all comes down to the contract signed.

In the case of the Germans it the contract they signed allowed them to inspect all the gold (subject to whatever notice) then if the Fed is preventing them from doing this they should kick up a row. If their contract makes no stipulations or allows only for partial inspections then they haven't got a cause for complaint, the Fed is sticking to the contract.
 
Last edited:
Every safe deposit box I've ever had in the US required two keys to access.

I had to go to the physical location of the box to see my key and a bank's master key inserted simultaneously to remove the box. Only then could it be carried to a private room.

BTW, I'm missing all the pretty charts with the lines and the squiggles and the letters and moving averages and trend lines on them.

I NEED TO KNOW WHAT THE FUTURE HOLDS!!!

Kevsta, where are you???
 
Every safe deposit box I've ever had in the US required two keys to access.

I had to go to the physical location of the box to see my key and a bank's master key inserted simultaneously to remove the box. Only then could it be carried to a private room.

BTW, I'm missing all the pretty charts with the lines and the squiggles and the letters and moving averages and trend lines on them.

I NEED TO KNOW WHAT THE FUTURE HOLDS!!!
Kevsta, where are you???

I have consulted my relative strength Fibonacci wave pivot-point reversion algorithm. This analysis indicates the price of silver is poised to fluctuate.

Please speculate accordingly.
 
That's good to know.

When my broker opens, I plan on buying a bunch of physical silver while simultaneously selling it short.

Can't lose, right??! ;)
 
Every safe deposit box I've ever had in the US required two keys to access.

I had to go to the physical location of the box to see my key and a bank's master key inserted simultaneously to remove the box. Only then could it be carried to a private room.

But you would be allowed access to the box. Which is more than the Germans are getting.
 
When I used to have a safe deposit box at the Yorkshire Bank in Barnard Castle, I wasn't allowed access to the vault to collect it myself, they would bring the safe deposit box to me in a private room. In some cases I did have to wait for a few minutes while they brought the box up and/or a private room came free.

That kind of thing is perfectly feasible for a small metal box, much less so with several tons of gold. I have no idea of the terms of the contract Germany have with the fed with respect to access to fed facilities to inspect the gold.

If the Fed are in breach of contract - i.e. the contract stipulates that the Germans should have immediate (or reasonable) access to inspect all their gold - then I think Germany should make a big deal about it. We don't know what the terms of the contract are and I see no reason why the fed should have to incur the costs of an inspection that they may not be contractually obliged to provide.


Edited to change.......



It depends on the type of account. I have a deposit account where they send me annual statements. I can request an additional statement but it will take several days to arrive and I have to pay a fee. It all comes down to the contract signed.

In the case of the Germans it the contract they signed allowed them to inspect all the gold (subject to whatever notice) then if the Fed is preventing them from doing this they should kick up a row. If their contract makes no stipulations or allows only for partial inspections then they haven't got a cause for complaint, the Fed is sticking to the contract.

You can yammer on about "contract" this and "reasonable terms" that or what the frak ever, but the fact remains that if you went to the bank and asked for your cash and they told you to come back tomorrow, let alone years from now (which is the case with the Fed and Germany's gold) you would pitch a fit and be 100% justified in doing so.

Why are so many people so willing to put up with an unelected, unaccountable, unoverseen Fed that seems to think it has God-like powers to do as it pleases?
 
But you would be allowed access to the box. Which is more than the Germans are getting.

The Germans have been given access to some of their gold. To date they have not been access to all of their gold. We don't know what they are entitled to under the terms of their contract with the Fed.
 
You can yammer on about "contract" this and "reasonable terms" that or what the frak ever, but the fact remains that if you went to the bank and asked for your cash and they told you to come back tomorrow, let alone years from now (which is the case with the Fed and Germany's gold) you would pitch a fit and be 100% justified in doing so.

Apples and oranges.

What are the terms of the contract, how (if at all) are the Fed in breach of that contract, why are the Bundesbank and German government (apart from one crank politician who likes to visit the gold in the Bundesbank periodically) so apparently inconcerned ?

Why are so many people so willing to put up with an unelected, unaccountable, unoverseen Fed that seems to think it has God-like powers to do as it pleases?

Because it has done a decent job ?

Because the alternatives would hamstring the economy ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom