Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

The Two Prices Of Silver - Fake And Real

LOL

The silver bears are back to irreverently explain why trying to play the silver market instead of hording physical silver is going to get you in trouble:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u9LcKcXpCDE

The bears make the point that going forward there will be two prices for silver:

The physical delivery price and the fake spot price.

The spot price is an artifact of manipulated silver contracts in the spot and futures market for silver.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spot_price
Depending on the item being traded, spot prices can indicate market expectations of future price movements in different ways. For a security or non-perishable commodity (e.g. silver), the spot price reflects market expectations of future price movements. In theory, the difference in spot and forward prices should be equal to the finance charges, plus any earnings due to the holder of the security, according to the cost of carry model. For example, on a share the difference in price between the spot and forward is usually accounted for almost entirely by any dividends payable in the period minus the interest payable on the purchase price. Any other price would yield an arbitrage opportunity and riskless profit (see rational pricing for the arbitrage mechanics).

In contrast, a perishable or soft commodity does not allow this arbitrage - the cost of storage is effectively higher than the expected future price of the commodity. As a result, spot prices will reflect current supply and demand, not future price movements. Spot prices can therefore be quite volatile and move independently from forward prices. According to the unbiased forward hypothesis, the difference between these prices will equal the expected price change of the commodity over the period.


Let's see if the bears' take on things is actually playing out in the real world:

2010 American Silver Eagle Coin 1oz Uncirculated
$64.95

NEW Buffalo/Indian Head Nickel Art Coin 1 TROY OZ .999 SILVER BULLION
$55.95

Sunshine Mint 1 oz (.999) Fine Silver Bar - Eagle Design
$62.99

2011 Canadian Silver Timber Wolf 1 Troy Oz Coin
$61.95

2010 China Panda Series - 1 Ounce Silver Coin
$67.19

----------------------------------------------------------

spot price of silver:
$41.66

----------------------------------------------------------

yep, looks like the bears are "spot on" - get it? spot on? hahahahaha I crack myself up.
 
Last edited:
Zero Hedge has a few more things to add:

http://www.zerohedge.com/article/an...r-brings-total-comex-physical-multi-year-lows
One would think that following the total "annihilation" (as it has already been pegged by some) in silver over the past few days, that Comex would promptly reverse its "temporary" reclassification of Registered into Eligible silver, or so the believers in Comex holdings claim. Which is why to our surprise we noticed that today, the Comex announced that the ongoing inverse reclassification from Registered into Eligible continues, with Scotia Mocatta seeing another 186 thousand ounces of physical silver moving into that dark pool known as "eligible" holdings.

http://www.zerohedge.com/article/and-now-todays-mini-silver-flash-crash-same-time-same-place
Just like yesterday and the day before, 6:30pm is now the official precious metal "bang the afterhours" launch time. As we predicted minutes ago, silver just got taken to the cleaners on what is now an apparent attempt to push silver around in the no volume part of after hours trading, in the 6-7 pm no man's land. We expect an imminent rebound after this latest attempt to trigger stop losses, probably those around $40, fails. If it succeeds in pushing silver below $40 it is very possible that the metal can promptly trade down to the mid $30s as a result. And while banging the close has been investigated by the CFTC for years (resulting in some modest smacks on the wrist recently for the ex-Moore trader who did this with impunity), we are confident it won't be before 2015 that the CFTC's commissioners investigate this particularly odd behavior in silver and gold. By then it, of course, won't matter.

http://www.zerohedge.com/article/now-daily-margin-hikes-silver-slv-etf-itself-next
Following relentless margin hikes in silver on various exchanges, here are some thoughts on what may happen as the "regulators" do everything in their power to bring down commodity prices down as the broader population increasingly creates their own gold (and as the case may be silver) standard.
 
You have this thing about silver. Have you actually made a few bad decisions on the stock market with this commodity? Is that what has made you so mad about so-called market manipulators?
 
You have this thing about silver. Have you actually made a few bad decisions on the stock market with this commodity? Is that what has made you so mad about so-called market manipulators?

I don't think it is necessary to call them "so-called" any longer.
 
So are you actually comparing apples to apples with your numbers at the end there? I would expect that 'coins' with stamped symbols and pretty pictures are naturally going to be more expensive than just raw silver in bulk.

I don't get what those numbers are trying to prove.
 
So are you actually comparing apples to apples with your numbers at the end there? I would expect that 'coins' with stamped symbols and pretty pictures are naturally going to be more expensive than just raw silver in bulk.

I don't get what those numbers are trying to prove.

coin prices are traditionally a few dollars over spot, not 20 dollars.
 
coin prices are traditionally a few dollars over spot, not 20 dollars.


Couldn't the percentage at a lower value be "a few dollars", while the same percentage at a higher value is "20 dollars".

For instance (don't quote these numbers) when silver was 7$ an ounce, "a few dollars" would be nearly 50 percent. At 40$ an ounce, 20 dollars is 50 percent.

You have to show us what the percentage increase was then and what it is now...... not the dollar amount.
 
Certainly when I was in the coin business (or more specifically my family was, I used to work there in the summers), fancy silver (and gold) coins traded at a considerable premium over their face value.

The fact that people are charging silly money for coins only demonstrates that they think that someone is willing to pay silly money for coins.
 
What, owning shares of the South Sea Company land in Florida dot-com stocks real estate silver wasn't an easy, risk-free way to riches?

I'm shocked, I tell you. Shocked.

Say, would you be interested in the remainder of my silver?
I'll throw in some nice tulip bulbs for free.
;)
 
Certainly when I was in the coin business (or more specifically my family was, I used to work there in the summers), fancy silver (and gold) coins traded at a considerable premium over their face value.

The fact that people are charging silly money for coins only demonstrates that they think that someone is willing to pay silly money for coins.

The coins quoted are not rare collectors coins.

They are bullion coins which are traded primarily on their metal content. I even included a bullion bar for comparison.

I know this because *shock* - I own several of them and follow the market closely.



They do not normally trade for 20.00 over spot.
 
Last edited:
We expect an imminent rebound after this latest attempt to trigger stop losses, probably those around $40, fails. If it succeeds in pushing silver below $40 it is very possible that the metal can promptly trade down to the mid $30s as a result.

I love it when people make brave predictions like this one.

Translated: Gold may go to about $40. If it does, then it may either go up or down from there.

Thanks - there's so much one can do with that "prediction". ;)
 
There is no risk.

We know the Bernankistan will not cease printing money.

Ergo, there is no risk in metals.


silver back over 47 today while gold hit all time highs.

Silver has broken 49 today and is on track to break its all time high.

What's the price now, michaelsuede? I followed your updates, but you've not posted one for a few days.
 
The spot is 39.

However, as the bears point out, the current price for real physical on ebay and amazon is faaaaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrr above that and the spread is widening.

silver eagle selling for 54.75 just a few seconds ago.

1 oz bar selling for 56.00

The spot price reported on the COMEX is no longer valid.

Of course, I hold physical, not junk ETF contracts that are going to be deemed worthless in the near future.

Half of this thread is dedicated to me bashing the SLV for engaging in fraud.
 
Last edited:
Since the price seemed mostly speculation driven, this could turn out to be quite a fall.
Moneyweek says it could go to mid 20s.

Interesting to see where it goes.
 
So, was I right? Silver is a bubble? Did I finally predict something, or was it too obvious?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom