Should there be an age limit for Capital Punishment?

As the parent of a 4 year old I think 4 is a good age to start..... oh. you mean an upper age limit? Hey he's 81, cant someone just sneak up behind him and yell really loud or something?

I would note that all of the above is said in jest as I am against capital punishment. However if you were to ask me tomorrow WRT the 4 year old.......
 
Aside from the fact that I don't believe there should be capital punishment at all, I don't think it's possible to pinpoint an exact number where it's not really worth bothering anymore. It is pretty silly though. I mean, with the amount of time it takes to process these cases, it's pretty likely he'll be dead before they even get a chance to give him the death penalty. It also probably doesn't mean quite as much anymore.
 
No, there should be an additional penalty if you're older, as the death penalty won't seem as significant. They should be killed *more*....
 
As the parent of a 4 year old I think 4 is a good age to start..... oh. you mean an upper age limit?
I have a 2.5 year old. Don't make me suffer.

Seriously, when I read the thread title, I assumed lower age limit, too. For that, I would like to second applecorped's recommendation of 100. If you're 101 and on death row, fry, you MF. Everyone else can sit and rot until they're old enough.
 
Nothing like talking to myself.

(How old am I?)

(I'm 57.)

(When did that happen?)

(A couple weeks ago.)

Obviously, 56 should be the upper limit, though a month ago I'd've said 55 was. This was not "flip-flopping," but a genuine reappraisal based on changing data, ie: my birthday.
 
http://www.metro.us/boston/boston/article/898521--whitey-bulger-will-bulger-face-death-penalty

Whitey Bulger - 81 - could face the death penalty for his crimes. Should there be an age limit for the death penalty? :confused:

I would say there is already a practical maximum age limit on the death penalty, at least the way it works in the US. If Bulger is sentenced to death, it is very likely that he will die of natural causes well before the appeals process runs its course.
 
Are you seriously suggesting that some people are too old to die?

For a second I thought he was suggesting an age that you should not be allowed to live past!

As for the TAH I say no one should receive capital punishment.
 
Theres no need for limit - judge should decide on his own.

And by the way Bulger is so evil i dont think any punishment will be enough for him.
 
I think we should execute Mr. Bulger as quickly as possible. Not because of anything that he has done, but because of the racial imbalance of current executions in the US and the PR coup of executing a guy named Whitey.
 
For a second I thought he was suggesting an age that you should not be allowed to live past!

As for the TAH I say no one should receive capital punishment.

I believe that capital punishment is appropriate in many cases, but I do not trust any justice system to properly mete it out. I would prefer the entire matter be left in trustworthy hands, by which I mean mine. Anybody else having that kind of power makes me uncomfortable.
 
As much as some criminals just deserve to die for the wrong they have done, there are too many people wrongly convicted to justify the death penalty. The USA for one is not good enough at ensuring people are actually guilty before passing sentence.

Ranb
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom