Should prostitution be legal?

should prostitution be legal?

  • yes

    Votes: 166 87.8%
  • no

    Votes: 7 3.7%
  • maybe

    Votes: 10 5.3%
  • on planet X all we do is screw.

    Votes: 6 3.2%

  • Total voters
    189
I know that feminists are generally anti-legality of hookers as they feel the women are always being degraded by prostitution.


Actually, I see things as exactly the opposite:

The illegality of prostitution is evidence of the inequality of women.

We live in a capitalist society where one uses one's labor in exchange for money (and the things it buys). Women have generally earned less than men - prohibited from working long ago, then prohibited from working if married, then relegated to only certain jobs and now derailed from career advancement by the "mommy track." Women still earn about 3/5 of what men make in America.

A balance has been found, however, by God or Darwin or somebody. Women manage to live as long or longer than men in as good health and as good comfort and security. How do they do it? If they cannot labor to make money to buy stuff, how is it that they have access to as much stuff as men?

I would argue that capitalism creates a grey market for sex. Women are selling their companionship, their child-rearing skills and their sexual favors to men for a share of their man's income. Make no mistake - it's a good deal. And women get a lot out of it. They get companionship for themselves, a sexual partner to enjoy, and children to love. And they are built to want and enjoy these things just like men are.

Prostitution undoes this system. Prostitution makes stark and bare what is now hidden away in deep psycho-social animal parts of the brain. Prostitution says, "Let's cut through the bull and trade sex directly for money."

Is there a reason this shouldn't be allowed? I think so. Prostitution creates the danger that men will think sex for money is a better deal than sex and companionship and children for sex, companionship, children and money. It makes clear that sex is a tool women need to establish some power over their own lives.

Legalizing prostitution won't lessen women. That prostitution exists at all is evidence that women already have less.
 
Here's a question.

Man and woman meet up. Man pays for woman's meal. The two go and have sex. They don't end up in a relationship, it was a one-time deal.

Difference between this and prostitution?
 
Here's a question.

Man and woman meet up. Man pays for woman's meal. The two go and have sex. They don't end up in a relationship, it was a one-time deal.

Difference between this and prostitution?

For the night?

Between $800 and $1500.
 
Would you be surprised if I told you that Sir Joh was a member of the National party and was very conservative and religious?

I know all about Joh Bjelke-Petersen - he was a bloody Kiwi! Another export we were glad to get rid of.
 
Not safe for work

www sexwork com (you can add the .'s)

A lot of probably biased info.
 
I'll take Everclear.

Ouch! I'm guessing you mean this stuff:

In the United States, Everclear is a brand of grain alcohol (ethanol), available at concentrations of 95% alcohol (190 proof) and 75.5% (151 proof

Everclear is usually mixed into an alcoholic beverage, and is highly flammable.

Darwin award contenders like this stuff, eh?
 
Prostitution undoes this system. Prostitution makes stark and bare what is now hidden away in deep psycho-social animal parts of the brain. Prostitution says, "Let's cut through the bull and trade sex directly for money."

Is there a reason this shouldn't be allowed? I think so.

I am against gravity - it causes me all kinds of harm when I lose my footing. But we are obliged to face reality sometimes - the problem with this reasoning is that not allowing it (gravity or prostitution or drugs) does not stop it, or likely even slow it down.
 
I am against gravity - it causes me all kinds of harm when I lose my footing. But we are obliged to face reality sometimes - the problem with this reasoning is that not allowing it (gravity or prostitution or drugs) does not stop it, or likely even slow it down.

But if we find something distasteful, we should naturally ban it. It's, like, law.
 
Is there a reason this shouldn't be allowed? I think so. Prostitution creates the danger that men will think sex for money is a better deal than sex and companionship and children for sex, companionship, children and money. It makes clear that sex is a tool women need to establish some power over their own lives.

That's selling men short. Sure people get married for all sorts of reasons but I still believe the primary reason is love. Men have feelings too, I read about it in a magazine.
 
I still believe the primary reason is love.


I remember hearing that love is a trick a woman and her baby play on a man to keep him from taking off for Vegas. And every time I hear it I think, "Man, I have got to get to Vegas."
 
Is there a reason this shouldn't be allowed? I think so. .
And therefore it should be illegal? There's lots of things I think shouldn't be allowed, maybe we should criminalize them too - fat women in thong bikinis, ugly people on TV and I really don't like the bad music I hear on the radio. Are there any other behaviours consenting adults might engage in that have no direct effect on you that you feel qualified to prohibit? I'm thinking all laws should be based on whether or not people think they should be illegal or not - the old "there should be a law against that" crowd. Sadly, there are those who think the role of law should be to protect our rights to live our lives as we see fit so long as we aren't interfering with someone else's right to do the same. Bastards. Where do they get off telling me I can't tell other people how to live their lives!
 

Back
Top Bottom