Should Ahmadinejad be allowed to speak at Columbia University?

I don't understand how this relates to what I have said unless you're saying that Atheism is illegal. I have not heard that Atheism is illegal in the U.S. or Israel and so your question is irrelavant.


I thought I had made myself clear on this:



and regarding the war in Iraq, do you consider what the united states is doing in Iraq as murder?
I've also said this:

so don't ask me if X,Y,Z etc. are in my taboo list or not because rewriting the law is not my purpose here. I'm giving my reasons to a general subject.


You missed what I had written:

Freedom of religion or lack of it should not be illegal. The same applies to science.

But you are saying things that are taboo should not be discussed in public as it might offend someone. Atheism and freedom from religion is believed to be taboo for a large portion of our society. Should we be allowed to discuss it?

And who decides if what is illegal is wrong, dumb or no longer valid? You? me?
If I think making murder illegal is dumb should I actively act or advertize it publicly?

Yes, if you think making murder illegal is dumb, you should be able to discuss it as much as you want. If

Well, the idea is considered taboo by certain societies. According to you, ideas that society considers taboo should be outlawed. So why shouldn't it be outlawed?

You're conflating freedom of speech with freedom of action. They're completely different things.

Taboo does not equal illegal. In fact, I think that often times taboo equals woo...but that's a discussion for a different thread.
 
egslim said:
Freedom of speech allows only the expression of opinions. So it allows you to argue why murder should be legalized, not to commit it. And in case of euthanasia of the painful and terminally ill one can actually make a good argument in favour.
I said before that I am for expressing opinions but at the house which is responsible for making the laws and not on t.v. or at a university.
 
but I don't make the rules in Iran. Of course I wished it was legitimate for them to speak proactively about Israel but if it is outlawed then who am I to say what they should or shouldn't do. It's their country and their laws. If it was illegal in Israel to speak freely then I wouldn't be living here.

Then being able to speak freely about things, even taboo things, is a good thing? No matter what country you're in?
 
O.k. people, I have to go now. I hope we have agreed on some things and agreed to disagree on others. That's the beauty in discussions. I can only hope I have made myself clear on some subjects and that my thoughts will not be misinterpreted (if they do I realize it can happen so no hard feelings).
Take care.
I'll be probably be back tomorrow sometime.

Bye bye
Yair
 
Taboo does not equal illegal. In fact, I think that often times taboo equals woo...but that's a discussion for a different thread.

Er, yes, I'm aware of this. That was a rhetorical question addressing this poorly-thought-out idea:


In my opinion, what is considered taboo in society should not be legally advertized or given freedom of speech.
 
I said before that I am for expressing opinions but at the house which is responsible for making the laws and not on t.v. or at a university.
I see. And I disagree.

Living in a democracy means it is the people who are responsible for making the laws. Indirectly, through elections, but still. Hence in a democracy the whole country is the house which is responsible for making the laws.
 
Er, yes, I'm aware of this. That was a rhetorical question addressing this poorly-thought-out idea:

Crap, I meant to preface the statement with something like "exactly" and address it to Yairhol...sorry.
 
It started already. The University President came out with an opening speech ripping on Ahmadinejad, who is now telling the students how he doesn't appreciate it.
 
It started already. The University President came out with an opening speech ripping on Ahmadinejad, who is now telling the students how he doesn't appreciate it.
Was the intro something like this?

"Ladies and gentlemen, today's speaker needs no introduction. He's the President of Iran, and a right prick. Without further ado, take it away, Mahmoud the Dude! :cool: "

DR
 
The questions begin...

ETA: my gosh, this is like Denialism 101
 
Last edited:
I particularly like the "I'm just asking questions" defense to his Holocaust Revisionism Conference.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom