Question: How can you get shingles more than once? Wouldn't you produce antibodies the first time?


As I understand it recurrence is fairly rare, but not way way rare, and worse if you're older and worse if you're a woman. Some years ago a friend of my mother's, an older woman, had it several times. As to how, I'm not entirely sure of the mechanism, but the chicken pox virus, though it apparently does immunize you for life against chicken pox, does not actually go dormant, an kind of settles into your system, so it can re-emerge from time to time again.
Yes, so the answer is that you can get shingles more than once for the same reason you got it the first time: You got antibodies after you had chickenpox, but the varicella-zoster virus is still there, dormant, and, for whatever reason, the antibodies no longer keep the dormant virus at bay.
Strange and nasty business.
Definitely nasty but not all that strange. It's far from the only virus that stays in your body and may be reawakened if your immune system is compromised. Google mentions the following:
Herpes simplex (HSV1 & HSV2)
The chickenpox/shingles (VZV)
Epstein Barr (EBV)
Cytomegalovirus (CMV)
HIV
As for the mechanism(s) and where they hide:
Virus latency (Wikipedia)
I had shingles twice, the first time in my late forties when it coincided with (at first) undiagnosed food allergies. For the same reason (I suspect), it didn't disappear completely until the food allergy was diagnosed and I learned to stop eating peanuts and shellfish.
The second time was in my late fifties, probably due to stress.
Even though it's rarer still to get shingles
three times, I got the two Shingrix shots two years ago (still not free in

, ~ DKR 2,000 ($300), IIRC).
A friend of mine, who had shingles when she was young, has just had it again, and this time it lasted for almost a year, with debilitating facial pain, and severely affected vision. It really didn't seem much fun, so yes, do get the vaccine
In the permanently immunocompromised, e.g. the very old, shingles may be a permanent and very unpleasant condition.