September Clues

Translation*

Wahhh that's too hard of a question!!!
Here's my proof:

And to think.......this is all that is left of this real person...:(

I just talked to a friend of mine that lost his wife (also my friend) in the south tower. He's on his way up from NJ, he tells me he really needs to hang out.

I'm a bit concerned considering he remarried three years ago, I'm clearing my schedule, Wish me luck. (there is no "I want to cry smilie")

Thanks for all the well wishes. :)

He's OK.

He started getting depressed because he hasn't been thinking about his first wife. So, about a week ago he pulled out the tape he made on 9/11.

I've talked about this tape before but for those who don't know, his wife worked on the 80th floor of the south tower. That morning he was talking to her on the phone, video taping the north tower burning. He was walking from Battery Park when UA 175 flew over his head. Captured on the video is the plane and his reaction when the connection to his wife went dead.

I had thought that he buried the video in the small box that is at her grave (no trace of her was recovered). Apparently he was going to but at the last minute changed his mind.

Well, to make a long story short(er), about 6 months ago he and his new wife remodeled their family room. Since 9/11 there was always a picture of his first wife and a small stuffed animal on one of the shelves. After the remodel the picture did not get put back. Well my friend (being a guy) festered about this thinking it was because his new wife didn't want it there and had thrown it away. Now, had he actually talked to her about it he would have found out she had a mirrored shelf made that she was going to surprise him with on 9/11.

Fortunately for me his new wife can read him like a book (but respects his private thoughts about his first wife) and called and forewarned me. Naturally, I busted his cookies about jumping to conclusions, and reminded him why he was remarried to the wonderful person she is. (and we drank large amounts of beer)

We ended up watching the video together. I hate that ******* tape. :(

I think he's finally decided to do what he originally planned to do with the tape. He and his new wife are going to put it with his first wife for safe keeping. :)

I also know a few other people that witnessed it first hand. :(
 
Last edited:
No one here has evidence?

Evidence has been presented, SC has been debunked by other 911 Truthers. Even Alex Jones thinks you guys are disinfo agents sent to discredit him and the rest of the truth movement.

Not sure what you consider to be evidence if what you've been shown isnt enough for you. SC demonstrably lies to you, and yet you keep acting like its still valid.
 
Last edited:
Thanks beachnut. wasn't too hard once you got over your bias of new people was it?

Getting angry at random people shows a lack of critical thinking, it's a waste of energy.

Now for a question that will most likely enrage you as you seem to enrage when people doubt your belief system,

How can we establish this radar data is genuine?

It's a legit Q.
No it isn't. Its a reverse burden of proof logical fallacy. Simon Shacks extraordinary claims need extraordinary evidence. Your move.

Simon shack just asserts with no evidence whatsoever. "could have" Is not an argument.

Your assertions are therefore soundly dismissed.
 
How about CGI being impossible because of the sound of the aircraft? There is no way they could have inserted the sound into all of New York. Even IF they did the graphics there would have been no way to do the sound. It's not an option.
 
Seriously? This vicsim douchebag is still posting?

I'll amend my earlier post, his first sentence in this thread was a lie.
 
...
Here is the show below.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aWl8mUSDIwU
...
Does anyone have some real evidence this movie is bunk?
It is like you never watched the video. Got Physics?
that any plane will not crash through a steel building. 4:56 September Clueless
Bunk - but if you don't agree this is bunk, you don't understand physics.

Your video is self debunking, not sure why you can't step up and show it is bunk.

The video has no clue what a gyro stablilized camera does.

The video makes fun of the dead. How nice.

The video implies the aircraft parts are fake. What an idiot.

The video has no clue what an engine looks like after a 470 or 590 mph impact - the idiot who did the video can't do physics.

The video is not bunk, it is delusional propaganda from an idiot.

It is hard to believe you can't refute any part of the video. Was your purpose to make fun of JREF, yourself? Are you using Balsamo Pilots 4 Truth logic to form questions and then reject the answers with more questions. He can't do physics, and has no clue what happen on 911 like the video you can't debunk, or pick anything from the video to debunk. Why can't you be specific?

I keep forgetting this thread is a joke to you - you bring up a video which disrespects those who died no 911, and you can't refute it. That would be frustrating, not able to understand what is wrong in the video. Good luck.
 
How about CGI being impossible because of the sound of the aircraft? There is no way they could have inserted the sound into all of New York. Even IF they did the graphics there would have been no way to do the sound. It's not an option.

The lead plotters 74' Camaro had an awesome set of subs in the back. The demolition charges were planted so the towers would crush it when they collapsed, destroying the evidence.
 
c'mon people, no one has dirt on this sc movie?


The dirt on the SC movie is that it makes an argument that is utterly unconvincing to almost everyone.

The evidence for this is its five years of failure to convince anyone, not even the vast majority of 9/11 conspiracy theorists.

Faced with that proven fact, that the SC argument is utterly unconvincing, the evidence for it and against it is irrelevant. The court never convened, because no charges were ever filed, so no one is giving evidence or hearing it. Your own opinion about SC is even more irrelevant. Any attempt to act on that opinion pits you against the unavoidable fact that you are championing an unconvincing argument. An opinion that you cannot convince anyone to agree with is useless. Whether you keep it or discard it makes no difference.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
You can't prove a negative. You can only prove a positive.

If something (CGI) didn't happen, there is no proof it didn't happen, because there was nothing to leave evidence. But they should have proof it did happen, IF CGI did happen.

Their whole "proof" that it's CGI and faked is just their say-so and ignorance.

They have no evidence of government programs to create graphics of 9/11.
They have no emails between government departments hinting at the "Plan".
They have no whistleblowers.
They have no documented RFID chips that prove witnesses were mind-controlled.

You should be asking, "Where's THEIR evidence?"
 
A hint to all those debating cecil - here is his first JREF post:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8515710#post8515710
cecil1 said:
I do not believe a conspiracy is going on, but I happen to take this particular stance when it comes to the happenings in this world.

Question: Society’s chaos and disorder frighten me. Shouldn’t we all band together to bring some sense to this warring world?
Answer: Saving the world and helping other people is one of the biggest hoaxes ever perpetrated on unsuspecting mankind. It took an awakened and highly evolved human being, Vernon Howard, to expose this gigantic falsehood to deluded humanity.
Wiki on Vernon Howard. Scan it at least.

cecil1 goes on:
cecil1 said:
...
They tempt you to take sides, to adopt a viewpoint and to fight an enemy. Of course, you are now “right” and they are “wrong”. You have found an identity as a “good” person and they are labeled as the “bad” people.
...
It's an interesting point of view. keep this in mind when you you debate cecil. I think he is trying to set you up for some gotcha.
 
No, not a troll, IMO. Just - different. Coming from a spiritual angle. "Love" is a big word for cecil, no imsight can come without "love". Something like that.
 
No, not a troll, IMO. Just - different. Coming from a spiritual angle. "Love" is a big word for cecil, no imsight can come without "love". Something like that.

I see that, and I think I even may even get it, but it has no place in a rational debate
 
I see that, and I think I even may even get it, but it has no place in a rational debate

When oh when has any discussion about 9/11 'conspiracies' had anything to do with rationality? It's the modern day equivalent of a discussion about how many angels can dance on the head of a pin.

Some (like no-planes, vicsims, etc) end up in a brackish, backwater pool of WTF while others turn into mighty circular rivers of unending stupid.

But they all share a common origin flowing from the headwaters on the heights of ignorance, misunderstanding and dyspepsia.

Fitz
 
Isn't "mighty circular rivers of unending stupid" Dante's tenth circle of Hell?
 
When oh when has any discussion about 9/11 'conspiracies' had anything to do with rationality? It's the modern day equivalent of a discussion about how many angels can dance on the head of a pin.

Some (like no-planes, vicsims, etc) end up in a brackish, backwater pool of WTF while others turn into mighty circular rivers of unending stupid.

But they all share a common origin flowing from the headwaters on the heights of ignorance, misunderstanding and dyspepsia.

Fitz

They need to switch to diet dyspepsia.
 
What's with all of the no-planers lately? Is that all that's left of truthers?



^^This...been there, bought the t-shirt, wore it painting the house, and turned it into a dust rag. I love how he asks for links that debunk SC, then doesn't even bother to read them, or bring up any of the points made in those threads...then he moves on to asking us for evidence. Next, we can expect him to drop the reasonable guy routine and go full-troof, followed by a meltdown.

I'll take my million now.
 
I watched thaty movie in a room full of friends and all my friends loled at that sc busted video.

It didn't offer direct evidence that simon shack is full of it, If sc is not even worthy of discussion why are the sc forums filled with people interested in it?

So if anyone has some direct evidence that the SC is false let's have it, or not, I just wanted to see what the JREF crowd has in the way of real evidence. I'm starting to doubt anyone here has any...

It's perfectly rational to lie to cover your ass, rational isn't it?

I prefer truth over rational, thanks for stating what you think JREF site is.

Any evidence?
What evidence could there be of the nonexistance of a video cgi software that can insert images real time into live production as this scenario claims?
answer is that proving the negative here is not possible so your continuing demands for that which could not be possible also continues to be ridiculous

In 2001 Sony's Vega nle, Final Cut nle, Leitch's Velocity nle, Avid nle would all require the video first before being able to insert a cgi image in order to make it appear that the plane crashed in this way.
Edit points ,aka keyframes, on a timeline are determlned by scolllng frame by frame then the overlay is inserted at the various edit points and rotated, sized, faded in/out etc. This takes time to get even halfarsed correct.
One could make assumptions about where cameras will be, what their focus , zoom and aperature settings , and in he case of nonstatic mounts, movement of the camera, might be and create an overlay based on that, to insert over live video, but your chances of making something ridiculous are huge and your chances of making something close to what you desired are miniscule.
It will not help your cause to have a plane appear twice the size of a 767 come into view then wink out of existance a 100 feet before it reaches a point 50 feet above the roof height of the tower and be brighter than the rest of the scene.
So unless and until someone can demonstrate an ability to do what was claimed was done using tech of the time period, SC remains a work of fiction.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom