Self Contradiction Anthropogenic Global Warming Denier Arguments

I'm rather disappointed. You generally read more closely than that. Of course it's getting warmer.
But if it is getting warmer at a rate that is not predicted by the model(s), then perhaps a model that failed to predict is not a good predictor. That doesn't say anything one way or the other about GW, or even AGW, really. It says something about the accuracy of the model, though.

Using a failure of the model to predict as evidence for the conclusions of the model is amusing. It reminds me of Calvin and Hobbes:
"You know how Einstein got poor grades when he was a kid?"
"Yes?"
"Well, mine are even worse!"

I think you were asking for worst case, what is their accuracy? It's getting hotter, they predicted it would get hotter.

If you want more detail

http://ipcc-wg1.ucar.edu/wg1/Report/AR4WG1_Print_Ch08.pdf
 
I think you were asking for worst case, what is their accuracy? It's getting hotter, they predicted it would get hotter.

If you want more detail

http://ipcc-wg1.ucar.edu/wg1/Report/AR4WG1_Print_Ch08.pdf

It seems to me that either the observed temperatures are within the margin of error of the model, or they are not.
If they are within the range, then the temperatures cannot be said to be unpredicted.
If they are outside the range, then the model isn't working as well as expected.

Neither of these situations has much to do with the actual validity of GW or AGW, nor would either completely invalidate the model. But using the inaccuracy of the model to support the accuracy of the model seems funny.

"It's getting late."
"Oh, really? How do you know?"
"The clock just struck thirteen!"
 
Can I expect an answer to my queries to be forth-coming? Especially the last two.

edit to add: I'm glad you now seem to agree that warmer will keep us away from having an ice age anytime soon.

In actuality it has been theorized that increased fresh water from the melting ice caps may disrupt the salinity current responsible for maintaining the temperate climate of the northwestern USA. The result of global warming (regardless of the cause) may be another ice age. At any rate dependence on a nonrenewable polluting energy source is probably not a good idea.
 
I'm rather disappointed. You generally read more closely than that. Of course it's getting warmer.
But if it is getting warmer at a rate that is not predicted by the model(s), then perhaps a model that failed to predict is not a good predictor. That doesn't say anything one way or the other about GW, or even AGW, really. It says something about the accuracy of the model, though.
It says something about the ice model. Not about the atmospheric one.

They are different models, which interact somewhat; this will require some revision of the atmospheric model, but not until the heat has a chance to get into the ocean for a while, and then get back out into the atmosphere. Likely the underlying cause was that the ice wasn't as thick as they thought. Most likely the timing of the atmospheric model will be revised downward, and most likely it will still be within the error bars. But we'll have to see. I'm sure the players are doing that now.

Using a failure of the model to predict as evidence for the conclusions of the model is amusing. It reminds me of Calvin and Hobbes:
"You know how Einstein got poor grades when he was a kid?"
"Yes?"
"Well, mine are even worse!"
Discussing atmospheric and ocean and ice models as if they are all one and the same thing is also amusing, when one is weighing in on a thread that concerns climate science. I suggest you might want to do a bit more research the next time.
 
It says something about the ice model. Not about the atmospheric one.

They are different models, which interact somewhat; this will require some revision of the atmospheric model, but not until the heat has a chance to get into the ocean for a while, and then get back out into the atmosphere. Likely the underlying cause was that the ice wasn't as thick as they thought. Most likely the timing of the atmospheric model will be revised downward, and most likely it will still be within the error bars. But we'll have to see. I'm sure the players are doing that now.

Discussing atmospheric and ocean and ice models as if they are all one and the same thing is also amusing, when one is weighing in on a thread that concerns climate science. I suggest you might want to do a bit more research the next time.

Again, I'm disappointed. I'm not commenting on the science at all, because this thread isn't about the science.
This thread is about the cheerleaders -- on both sides of the issue.
I'm amused, that's all.
 
Again, I'm disappointed. I'm not commenting on the science at all,
Climate models are accurate predictors of global warming.
The North pole is melting faster than predicted.
So the news stories are wrong, and the arctic melting is not happening faster than predicted, simply because the error range is so large?

Is there any size error on the warm side that would indicate an error in the model?
'Nuff said.

because this thread isn't about the science.
:bounce2 You noticed! :bigclap

This thread is about the cheerleaders -- on both sides of the issue.
I'm amused, that's all.
:cheerleader2 :cheerleader1

waitaminnit...

Lessee...

"Self Contradiction Anthropogenic Global Warming Denier Arguments"

Nope.
 
It seems to me that either the observed temperatures are within the margin of error of the model, or they are not.
If they are within the range, then the temperatures cannot be said to be unpredicted.
If they are outside the range, then the model isn't working as well as expected.

Neither of these situations has much to do with the actual validity of GW or AGW, nor would either completely invalidate the model. But using the inaccuracy of the model to support the accuracy of the model seems funny.

"It's getting late."
"Oh, really? How do you know?"
"The clock just struck thirteen!"

Did you read the link? Which part of it do you have a problem with?
 
Number 2.

CO2 is present in the atmosphere in very small proportion to other gases, so it can't have an effect on global climate.

CO2 is an amazingly effective fertiliser.

Which is it? Something it is amazingly powerful, or lacking in power?
It doesn't seem to me that this is an inconsistency, as it's comparing apples and oranges. Accepting both propositions as true for the sake of the argument, the concentrations at which CO2 can effectively stimulate plant growth may be vastly different than the concentrations at which CO2 can cause climate change. Diffuse sunlight can ruin a whole batch of photographic film without being powerful enough to generate enough photovoltaic effect to run a pocket calculator, much less heat a room. A small amount of nerve gas in the air can kill all the sheep in a field, while all the grass in the field stays green.

Is diffuse sunlight powerful, or lacking in power?
Is nerve gas powerful, or lacking in power?
 
It doesn't seem to me that this is an inconsistency, as it's comparing apples and oranges. Accepting both propositions as true for the sake of the argument, the concentrations at which CO2 can effectively stimulate plant growth may be vastly different than the concentrations at which CO2 can cause climate change. Diffuse sunlight can ruin a whole batch of photographic film without being powerful enough to generate enough photovoltaic effect to run a pocket calculator, much less heat a room. A small amount of nerve gas in the air can kill all the sheep in a field, while all the grass in the field stays green.

Is diffuse sunlight powerful, or lacking in power?
Is nerve gas powerful, or lacking in power?

You are reading to much into the argument. The argument is that it's only a trace gas, so it can't do anything. That's it. However, CO2 science also calls it an amazingly powerful serial fertilizer. The only claim was that a trace amount of gas can't do anything, purely beause it is a trace gas.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom