Seen 'The Secret' and want to appear on Oprah?

One of my peeves about this whole New Age wealth movement is all the carpetbagging and 'life coaching" preying on the economically disfranchised with promises of 'abundance,' especially if they will buy the books, tapes, and expensive seminars.

My previous roomate was into The Millionaire Mind and just lost money as a result. Meanwhile the hucksters who sell these illusions keep raking in the bucks from the ignorent who buy into them.

No that the ignorant are merely victims. Greed is the hook.
"The Secret" is getting some flack from other quarters of the New Age movement for it's decidedly and crassly materialistic emphisis. "You can have it all, and therefore be happy."

Yeah, I don't see them as being any different from the likes of Sylvia Browne, $cientology, Amway, 20 Surefire Ways to Win at the Track, etc.

It's almost a misnomer to refer to such cons as "New Age" -- they're as old as the hills.

M.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, I don't see them as being any different from the likes of Sylvia Browne, $cientology, Amway, 20 Surefire Ways to Win at the Track, etc.

It's almost a misnomer to refer to such cons as "New Age" -- they're as old as the hills.

M.
Yeah - reminds me of the old con trick, the one where you see a smallad in the newpaper that says "Want To Be Wealthy Like Me? I Can Tell You How! Send £X to....."
So you send off your cash. And get a sheet of paper that says "Place the following smallad in newspapers....."
 
Just got this email:
Go on, I dares you... I double-dares you! :D

Oh yeah, the website: The Secret. Pile of steaming new age carp....

Someone at work gave me a copy of The Secret on DVD. Yuck! Watched the first 15 minutes until I got the gist then fast forwarded through the rest. I like the special effect that shows your attitude bursting out of your brain like a (quantum mechanical) shock wave. Lots of idiotic ideas easily refutable. I like the guy who bought a house, spent a year remodeling it, then seemed astonished that he "got his dream house" he drew in a fantasy a few years ago. Duh! I also like the idea that if you worry about being in a traffic jam, it will cause a traffic jam! Geeze! Afterwards, I argued with the coworker who gave it to me, who tried to claim that the video did not promote superstition.

Me: Why did it bring up quantum mechanics?
Him: Why not?
Me: It's irrelevant to positive thinking.
Him: We're all regulated by the laws of quantum mechanics.
Me: But they have no relevance to our daily lives and how wishing something can make it true.
Him: But our minds emit quantum mechanic brain waves that affect the world we live in.
Me: That's superstition.
Him: Bye (walks away)

I'm sending my copy to Randi.
 
Last edited:
[shame facedly]
Mama Mortis seems to have bought into this line of crap thinking. I was forced to listen (I did't have to watch as I was cooking dinner) to that Oprah show. [/shamed]

I agree with the previous posters who said that a positive attitude does help with success. Rare is the pessimist who actually gets somewhere. When I was a pagan, I realized that my magick's biggest help to my life was that after going through all the trouble of performing a ritual, you start looking for confimation, some omen that says you're on the right path. This is the same kind of thing.

Think happy, get rich. Visualize yourself healthy. It's a load of crap.
 
The Secret:

A flashy restatement of the popular New Age "Law of Attraction,"

To wit (or less than a wit): whatever you desire will come to you by believing, imagining, and affirming it's yours and maintaining a positive attitude about obtaining it.

The formula doesn't include the Old Age fuddy-duddy element of hard work and effort to attain your goals, but says it's all in the power of the mind to shape reality on the quantum level.

It's all quite feelgood and 'inpirational' till it just doesn't work. At what time you are simply accused of not having a positive attitude.

For many this formula is a more palatable beleif than praying to a deity to give you what you covet. But it is in the end merely superstition.

You sir are a complete legend... that was an awesome post
BRAVO BRAVO *stands and applauds*

Hahahahahahahhaha, that was such a cool answer
 
I wanted a Nintendo DS, and I imagined having it, and the next thing you know, I am spending some of my money and purchasing one.

I am visualizing myself enjoying a tall glass of porter right now.

I am guessing that people who believe in synchronicity are all over this one.
 
What you're describing is very much the theory behind Cognitive Behavioral Therapy which is the most common type of therapy practiced by today's psychologists and has a good success rate. In this respect, your thoughts and how you perceive things really can shape your feelings and experiences.

That being said, the whole "the universe will respond to my positive thoughts" is complete twaddle.

I really like CBT, and was a little disappointed in the movie because of its classification of Good and Bad Emotions. Our thoughts do build our emotions - emotions are like shortcuts to how we think about certain situations. Studying CBT in graduate school, it became clear that no emotion is good or bad, but any emotion in excess can be detrimental to the well-being of a person. Yes, even love, ask Romeo and Juliet about that.

Scratch that - it's not excessive emotion, but emotional states that are counter-productive to a person, that a person self-judges as detrimental and a problem. CBT is a great way of untangling those emotional responses and making them more appropriate, acceptable, and manageable.

And people with positive attitudes do get lucky breaks from the people they meet, because people like to meet people with positive attitudes. Yes, some like to rain on parades, but most people see someone with a positive attitude and protect it. Sometimes it seems like so little good happens in the world, and that one smiling person can lighten everyone's load.

But then again, the Secret isn't completely interested in a person's well-being. It's setting up a secular religion. It cloaks itself in some quantum science talk for the modern ear, and it deals with some real emotional truths, and every person in that video means well by the people they are speaking to, but it's another modern try at creating the next world religion. I say secular, because some old Christian bias is seeping through, but it's the New Age version of intelligent design. It IS intelligent design. And when the odds start going better (and the confirmation bias starts kicking in) for the new positive attitude the Secret has instilled, you come back to the Secret's website, buy the T-shirt, and start purchasing DVDs to distribute. That's the art of the crafting a new religion - be as benign as possible, but make sure the acolytes come back with the coin.
 
Having now watched The Secret myself, I have to say that, once you get past the overdramatic tosh that the movie opens with, it's actually very uplifting. But, not necessarily for the right reasons. It's uplifting in the manner of a technicolour pep rally.


After I'd watched the movie, I emailed Joe Vitale (because I didn't want any ill feeling between us) and told him I'd watched the movie and actually enjoyed its overall positive nature and I'd been pleasantly surprised, given the exchange of views at the movie forum, that nobody had said anything totally daft like in What The Bleep.

I had a really friendly reply from Joe's PA and she wrote if I had any questions to just ask. I'd learned not long before watching the movie that there were two versions. I had the second version. Esther Hicks had been in the original version, but she dropped out, supposedly for some contractual reason, and the movie was re-edited. So I wrote back to Joe Vitale's PA and asked her if the reason why Esther Hicks withdrew from the movie and Abraham-Hicks was never explicitly mentioned in the remade version even though the movie was all about the Abraham-Hicks perception of reality was to remove anything that Michael Shermer or James Randi could have a go at. Channelling, for example.

I never heard from her again. Oh well ...

So, interesting to see The Secret turning up in the latest edition of the Swift. I look forward to reading Mr. Randi's observations in due course.
 
Ugh...I had the distinct misfortune of viewing this at the in-laws home last month. I didn't intend to watch it, but my attempt to escape what can only be described as "What the Bleep"-level inanity was cut short by a pressing need to have me fix the computer in their living room...the same room the TV is in.

I only caught bits and pieces of the movie, but here is the gist of it far as I could discern: think happy and good stuff will happen.

Now, I agree with this from a thoroughly pragmatic viewpoint - if you have a goal, you're more likely to accomplish it if you focus on it with a positive attitude. You're more likely to work harder towards that goal, and to seize opportunities you might not seize if you are obsessed with feeling gloomy.

However, the problem is that the movie didn't focus on that aspect of things. Instead, the impression I got was that these people believed that you could actually manipulate the very fabric of reality around you just by having happy thoughts (even absent any other direct action).

After the movie, my stepmother turned to my wife and said: "You know, that's totally true. Your sister decided two years ago that she would get a PT Cruiser, and she thought positively, and she put it out into the universe, and she got a PT Cruiser."

It was very difficult to bite my tongue and hold back the obvious retort - that she got that ugly honkin' excuse for a car because she worked for it, her credit is good, and their household income is above average.

Sort of a case of missing the forest because you can't see through all those bloody trees!



That reminds me of something Joe Vitale wrote at his blog recently about how he'd attracted some super expensive car into his life and I'm reading that and thinking "Joe, you're a fricking multimillionaire - all you did was think about buying it and you went down to your local showroom and bought it!" :)
 
Oprah has had two shows on this so far with more promised in the future. It is basically another rehash of Creative Visualization mixed with her "there is no such thing as luck" belief. And if anyone criticizes it, they are condemning themselves to mediocrity with their negative thinking.
 
I've found myself to be a very lucky person. The worst case senarios I worry over very rarely happen. Things even work out OK when I've had a bout of "wallowing in negativity."

This is what cracks me up the most. My experiences completely contradict this "secret". My entire life I've been negative and sometimes extremely negative about situations and they manage to work themselves out with a positive outcome. And I'm a perfect example of those type of people who dwell on things. Do they happen? NO! In fact, the more positive I am about situations, the less they are likely to happen...

l can see it now, to patch-up faults in their belief they'll refer to people like me as "A person whose law-of-attraction has reverse polarity".
 
I put the Secret to the test this week. I tried to attract some free pineapple into my life. I visualized the pineapple coming to me. What it would taste like, what it would smell like, how it would look, how it would feel to eat it. And lo and behold, when I got my grocery delivery, they made an error in filling my order and sent me a bag of grapefruits by mistake which they told me I could keep.
 
I put the Secret to the test this week. I tried to attract some free pineapple into my life. I visualized the pineapple coming to me. What it would taste like, what it would smell like, how it would look, how it would feel to eat it. And lo and behold, when I got my grocery delivery, they made an error in filling my order and sent me a bag of grapefruits by mistake which they told me I could keep.

Well it clearly worked, but the calibration is a bit off. Need to get your Chakras realigned.
 
I put the Secret to the test this week...

Monday I woke up late for work and partially tried it so I could make on time. Sure enough, there was barely any traffic and I made it to work on time. Amazing. I discovered that I have the power to make it President's Day so I could make it on time. I wish I would've known about the "secret" when Seattle had a nasty ice over and it took me 4 hours to get home...
 
Why do I have a bad feeling about "The Secret"? If one doesn't think about potential misfortune, one doesn't plan for it. As a programmer, I know that not planning for disaster is seems to invite it. (More likely, if you have planned for in, the damage can be reduced, and it seems smaller in perspective.) Maybe I'm reading too much into the whole "self-help" idea, but there seems to be some potential for problems here.
 
Why do I have a bad feeling about "The Secret"? If one doesn't think about potential misfortune, one doesn't plan for it. As a programmer, I know that not planning for disaster is seems to invite it. (More likely, if you have planned for in, the damage can be reduced, and it seems smaller in perspective.) Maybe I'm reading too much into the whole "self-help" idea, but there seems to be some potential for problems here.

Welcome to the JREF Forums, Grayfalcon!
And welcome to my peeve topic.

Before this drivil was packaged as "The Secret," I was continually treated to variations on the theme by friends of New Age persuasion. They would tell me I musn't think of the possibility of a negatave outcome or something going wrong. Such thoughts, they said, gave energy to the feared outcome and created it. For just the carefulness and planing you mention, I was told, "You think too much."

IN actuality, my consideration of what you might call the possibility of the worst possible outcome, and what they called my "wallowing in negativity," didn't attract the bad outcomes.

"The Law of Attraction" is pep talk fodder. The pumpkins turned into carriages kind of thing. But people buy into it as their new found faith and it eventually leaves them worse off.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom