Seeing is believing

Tricky said,
Sounds to me like you are using the same equipment as the others there and having very similar results. I fail to see how dowsing has made you more successful than the non-dowsing miners.


I'll try to answer these questions.
The guys behind me cleaned their dredge box quickly through a smaller sluice box at the end of the day on a small rapids behind where they were dredging so did I if you paned it all down it would take hours.
I watched them do it and they watch me do mine.

You can tell or show people what you’re getting because there is a respect and pride and an written or unwritten law not to jump directly in front of another dredge.
The law could be called in at that point.
Plus you would muddy up or muck the other guy’s visual capabilities, not a nice thing to do.
Even though they were behind me I was on the other side of the creek.
I wish I could take pictures right now it would be easier to show you.
They got nothing I got at least something.
I told them to take over my spot they were happy to do so at least they can break even and still buy gas and maybe hit a pocket that's a little better, but it wont be much better.
If those guys move into my spot then they were telling me the truth.
I'll let you know.

I'm going to a place that is much better but I had to mine that spot as I waited for permission to go to the next better ground.

To day I should make good profits.

Why should you believe me because a quarter and a penny weighs about 7 grams so I didn't do so well either.

Dowsing is telling me I will go broke there.

The difference they are going broke and I am breaking even and leaving.

There are variances, James showed me that in Florida.

If I try the test leaving the background interference I will fail hence I have to have a neutral place which means the ground below where the test will take place has to be clear of all interference and I have to stay focused on the ground below me.
If I don’t things like the Kelly mine about a mile away from here will give me a false reading.
It's a matter of where you aim the tip of the stick.

Tricky said,

What do you need books for if you have dowsing? Sounds to me like dowsing doesn't help unless you already know what you are doing.

You mean why?
If the gold is on the inside of a turn the line can go for a half a mile, that's a lot of walking. Sometime during the day I need to pull some out, speed is of the essence. Were in that half a mile do I put the dredge in to pull a profit?

It is an immense challenge to get a quantity that pays because the river or the creek is immense in width let alone length.

If you stand in the creek and look at the amount of ground you can tell that the odds are against you.

You could mine a one mile piece and never run out of ground and within that mile twenty years could go by and you would still have a couple of years to go.
If you went to an 8-inch dredge it might take 15 years. The numbers are a little exaggerated but you get my drift.
Not only that but it, the gold might not even be there.

I am trying to give you an Idea of what it's like.

If dowsing helps with cutting off some of that time which I believe it does then it does help, and for me it does.

Hitting targets here is easy to do, knowing which ones pay that's a whole different ball game.
James requires 7 out of ten hits in the blind test, I require one or two really good ones every day.


Tricky said,
Yes, you can say that, but you can't show that. Even your own comments here seem to indicate that dowsing doesn't make a significant difference between your results and those of non-dowsing miners. If it really worked, you should be doing much better. But you're not. What do you think that means?

It means that for about fifteen years that I have been gone that the ground here has been hit hard by many other dredgers with many machines.
And that's what I have been told so I use that information too.
To even get what I have been able too is a miracle especially in the last two or three days.
Today it will change and I do need more gold. The ground that I'm going to hasn't been hit by any dredgers , so supposedly I should do better, way better.

Tricky asked,

Then why did you agree to a test inside a building? Why didn't you request to take it outside the first time?

The test can never be done in Florida let alone an office, after all what is Florida and what's under it?

Next he asks,

Why did your power seem to work during the open test?

You can see the targets you would have to be blind to not tell which cup they were in.
It was the next part of the test were you couldn't see the target 7 out of 10 hits for the money that counted hell those odds are better than any lottery.
I had a better chance of random luck then any ghost hunter because dowsing to me isn't even paranormal in my viewpoint.

Like I said it made me under stand now, what exactly it will take to prove it with out a doubt.

Next,
You have never given a coherent answer to any of these questions, other than telling us you lied when you told Randi your power was working at the first test (though you never told that to Randi, and didn't mention a thing about it until weeks later.)
I never lied I don’t know what all the variables are either but now I know more, but not all not yet.
They where working and it's not a power or some mystical force, it's not paranormal, that's why I think I have a chance.


Lets say you all are wrong, and that I win the million-dollar challenge.

Answer this what do you suppose that this could lead to, let me give you an example that goes like this.

Tiny amount of electrical input, for an unstoppable force or more output per input.
Movement of 4 pennyweight of heavy gold upward that defies gravity that's being attracted to an electrical field from another source.
Input your bodies electrical field, crunch the numbers.


Finally tricky asks this,
And you never answered my question as to why you can't simply dowse for background noise and use that as a baseline, then measure the difference in background vs. sample placement. Instead, you continue to manufacture pre-fabricated excuses.

That's exactly what I thought I could do, that didn't work even the smallest of E.M.I. can be read, so how much comes from a ballast in a florescent light I have no Idea. But I can tell you if it were muscles under my skin then why instead of pointing down did it all of a sudden point upward and deify gravity.
We are taking about 4 pennyweights of gold defeating gravity with an input of about One thousand of a volt and how many amps does the body put out?

Any bodies on this forum know the correct numbers on that please interject those figures now.


In the field here it will pick up every speck, but here they can be removed and hopefully demonstrated that target when introduced can be spotted each try.

Think why am I here, I need your skeptical logic to be absolutely sure of what I am about to do.

Think about Benjamin Franklin I kind of feel like him trying to prove a point.
I'm holding on to that kite string in an electrical storm with a key attached to it making my self-a possible lightning rod and not sure what the out come will be.
Will any body here try that to get their picture on a hundred-dollar bill.
I'm not sure that I want to but what the hell!!!
 
If Edge can search for specific bits of gold in the middle of a gold field, what the hell is wrong with Florida that's so unspeakable as to interfere with searching for gold? If Florida is one solid gold bar then I think Edge should have shared that with us earlier.

As for the stick moving, YOU move it as the stick has no muscles of it's own and it's not effected by electromagnetic interference of even quite startling strength. I doubt anyone can give you exact figures on how much EMI it would take to cause a stick to leap upwards, but I'm guessing it's more than a human being could safely survive. If you believe the stick is moving itself in reaction to a source why not move a lump of gold or an EM source close to it on the ground without holding the stick. If you nonsense is true then the stick will be repelled like a magnet, yes? Hell no.

Maximum strength, weapons-grade baloney is what this is, Edge.

"I tune in my stick to find specific items" <> "lights interfere with my stick!"

"I can find gold exactly, tell depth, amount, etc" <> "I can barely find enough to buy gas by dredging like everyone else"

"I have proven myself over 15 years" <> "I cant go near Florida, dowsing doesn't work there now!"

"I will take the JREF test, easy money" <> "Ink on a book interferes with my sticks powers!"

Self delusion and avoiding the realities wont win you $1, let alone $1,000,000. Wake up and smell the coffee Edge, look at the hard facts and not what you'd like them to be.
 
Real briefly it took all day yesterday to get set up I moved on to the only line I could and today it started to pay, but not much.
Lots of variables with this too.
I can’t get to it till I run and make a hole to be able to dump tailings into, tomorrow I should achieve that and tie into the only line available, and after all two other friends of mine were there first.
The guys that I gave my spot to that don’t dowse jumped right into my old spot.
Tomorrow I will know if I will pick up 4 to 5 pennyweights a day.

I will do a double blind test before I contact J.R.E.F. and let you know if I fail or not.
If I fail on neutral ground I’ll admit that it can’t be done.
Then I’ll buy a metal detector.

Tomorrow I will work the ground for 6 hours or so and that will be a good amount of time to pull 4 or 5-pennyweights.

After that it will be about 12 days or so till can clear the spot to do the test.
 
Most of this is just rambling, so I'll only address specific points.
edge said:
Dowsing is telling me I will go broke there.
How can you tell that without dowsing the whole area? Perhaps you are using more mundane skills, like knowing what constitutes good mining area, a.k.a. experience.

edge said:
There are variances, James showed me that in Florida.
I don't think he showed you a single thing, because you completely missed the main message. "Variances" is just another word you've thrown out to cover for the fact that you cannot explain the physics of dowsing. What kind/frequency of EM waves does gold send out, Edge?

edge said:
If I try the test leaving the background interference I will fail hence I have to have a neutral place which means the ground below where the test will take place has to be clear of all interference and I have to stay focused on the ground below me.
If I don’t things like the Kelly mine about a mile away from here will give me a false reading.
It's a matter of where you aim the tip of the stick.
More babble. If you aim the tip of the stick directly at a cup (or coffee can) containing a significant lump of gold, less that a three feet away, which has no overburden, wouldn't you expect a significant response? Why in the world would a mine that is a mile away be a significant interference with a target that was not only thousands of times closer, but probably a lot more pure?

If your dowsing works in the field, then it must be able to discriminate gold-bearing rocks from other rocks which are right next to you. If it can't do that, then it is useless.

So tell me, can you dowse if there is a jewelry store within a mile of the area? How about a rap singer?

edge said:
If dowsing helps with cutting off some of that time which I believe it does then it does help, and for me it does.
Ah, you've hit on the essential fact. You believe it helps. Even though there is no demonstrable evidence, you believe it, and that is all it takes.

edge said:
Hitting targets here is easy to do, knowing which ones pay that's a whole different ball game.
James requires 7 out of ten hits in the blind test, I require one or two really good ones every day.
And you got how many on your first test? One? Even if your power was working a little bit you should have been able to beat the number expected from pure chance.

edge said:
The test can never be done in Florida let alone an office, after all what is Florida and what's under it?
South Florida is on a carbonate platform. If you were looking for a place with no interferance from metal-bearing rocks, you'd be hard pressed to find a better place.

What do you think is under Ft. Lauderdale?

edge said:

You can see the targets you would have to be blind to not tell which cup they were in.
It was the next part of the test were you couldn't see the target 7 out of 10 hits for the money that counted hell those odds are better than any lottery.
I had a better chance of random luck then any ghost hunter because dowsing to me isn't even paranormal in my viewpoint.
May I remind you from your first test...
Randi said...
(1) The performer has the opportunity to try out the setup, and make any necessary changes, adjustments, or re-locations that he thinks are needed. Mr. (Edge) changed the location of the ten cups on the floor many times before the "open" detection trials were completed, and finally declared his total satisfaction with the placements, and with the conditions.
...
(5) After the "blind"test is done, following the "open" series, the performer cannot offer the excuse that his powers were not working at this time. (Edge) obtained 100% results during the "open" test, quickly and positively, showing that he was quite able to use his powers.
You got twenty out of twenty in the open test, Edge. With that kind of accuracy, the lottery would be a piece of cake.

edge said:
Like I said it made me under stand now, what exactly it will take to prove it with out a doubt.
Just do what you say you can do, Edge. That is all it will take. If you can't dowse a lump of pure gold that is three feet from you, then you can't find gold by dowsing at all. All of your excuses just serve to make you look more and more like a fake.

edge said:
I never lied I don’t know what all the variables are either but now I know more, but not all not yet.
You did lie. You told Randi that you were "totally satisfied" with the conditions. Either that or Randi is lying in the report of the test.

edge said:
They where working and it's not a power or some mystical force, it's not paranormal, that's why I think I have a chance.
It had better be paranormal, or you don't qualify for the test. For example, if you found the targets with a metal detector, it would not qualify. However, the fact that there is zero evidence for the "physics" of dowsing gives you the benefit of the doubt so JREF counts it as paranormal. If you think there is a physical basis, then fine. Use it. All that matters is that you do what you say you can do.

edge said:
Lets say you all are wrong, and that I win the million-dollar challenge.
If you win, we will all admit we were wrong. If you lose, will you admit you were wrong? You certainly didn't the first time. Nothing I have seen from you suggests that that a trivial thing such as total failure would convince you to abandon your delusions.

edge said:
Answer this what do you suppose that this could lead to, let me give you an example that goes like this...
Yes, if it worked, it would certainly be a breakthrough. But let's not put the cart ahead of the horse here. First show us it works, then we'll assess the potential ramifications.

edge said:
That's exactly what I thought I could do, that didn't work even the smallest of E.M.I. can be read, so how much comes from a ballast in a florescent light I have no Idea. But I can tell you if it were muscles under my skin then why instead of pointing down did it all of a sudden point upward and deify (sic) gravity.
But it didn't do this during the twenty "open" tests? Why do you suppose that is? And of course, the idiomotor effect can cause you to move the stick either upward or downward. No need to defy (or deify) gravity.

But if you are now going to use EM fields as excuses, what is to keep you from claiming that the presence of radio waves in the air all around us are fouling you up? Our whole planet is saturated with electromagnetic energy. Where do you think you can go to escape it? You are manufacturing one excuse after another.

edge said:
We are taking about 4 pennyweights of gold defeating gravity with an input of about One thousand of a volt and how many amps does the body put out?
LOL. You really are rambling now. For an object in equilibrium (like a dowsing stick) a tiny little force can move it. Like the force in your own hands reacting to the idiomotor effect. So what makes more sense, Edge, that your hands which are actually in contact with the rod, are making it move, or that some unknown object buried beneath rock is making it move? Do you think your hands are perfectly steady, Edge?

edge said:
Think about Benjamin Franklin I kind of feel like him trying to prove a point.
I'm holding on to that kite string in an electrical storm with a key attached to it making my self-a possible lightning rod and not sure what the out come will be.
Franklin knew that lightening existed. He observed that it was much like a spark of static electricity. He was simply trying to show the nature of lightning.

By the way, Ben never flew that kite. He simply described the experiment. He would have been an idiot (and probably dead) if he had actually conducted it.

See, here is the difference between you and successful inventors and scientists. Their stuff works.
 
I´ll write it again:

The last dowser I saw is still running for his life after using his "powers" to help a group of (very rough) informal miners to find a gold vein. For a price, of course. Not to mention the money they spent trying to find it.

You can guess -without dowsing- how successfull he was.
 
None of you has even tried an experiment?

I'm pulling 4 times the gold I was but not as much as my friends.
They have the two-heavy lines and I have the outside line which is good but not as good.
We will have two really good spots coming up and then on to a new place.
The new place I should hit big and a huge quantity.

Gold in a plastic pan when dried and rubbed around in the pan jumps and repels it's self through static electricity.

Very freaky...

What's being observed by myself is that I'm picking up a static charge that the gold and other metals are holding or, a depression in the field that the metal's are executing as they collect.
The more there is the stronger the force.....

Try the experiment.

I’m getting about 2-4 pennyweights a day and it’s an everyday hunt to maintain that amount.

Florida on top of what you described also has atoms of all the metals in it, it is a giant sand bar.

:cs:
 
Edge, throw a couple of half-hitches and rest for a spell

Were you ever out in the Great Alone,
When the moon was awful clear,
And the icy mountains hemmed you in
With a silence you ‘most could hear?
With only the cry of a timber wolf,
And you camped there in the cold,
A half-dead thing in a stark-dead world,
Clean mad for the muck called gold?

From The Shooting of Dan McGrew, by Robert W. Service

Edge ole pard, you wouldn’t be the first man driven loony by gold. (Shall I say, driven over the EDGE? Har har! I crack me up!) I’ve known prospectors, quite a number, and they mostly occupy the middle to high range on the Daffy Duck Scale. Their ideas, their theories, their convictions and hunches and systems are definitely in the crackpot style, i.e., there are entirely too many nuts among their raisins; they’re just a bunch of damned cranks. This probably comes from years of talking almost entirely to themselves.

Which is what I mean by the Great Alone.
 
edge said:
what's being observed by myself is that I'm picking up a static charge that the gold and other metals are holding or, a depression in the field that the metal's are executing as they collect.
The more there is the stronger the force.....

Try the experiment.
I am going to ask you again Edge, how does your bit of stick detect this EM field you think is there? We dont have a problem with metals in the earth altering the magnetic field a little, we have a problem with your twig being a magnetic anomaly detector. I'm pretty sure you could walk over the biggest undiscovered nugget around and your bit of wood wouldn't twitch if you personally didn't know the gold was there.

And we dont need to experiment, not only does the theory say it wont happen but you tried and failed already.
 
Welcome back Edge, and good luck on your re-test.
I was skeptical the first time this nutbar came around.

This time, I'm skeptical and bored.
 
sackett
That’s a good one.
But it isn't so isolated as to drive a person wild or loony here.
After all we do have cars nowadays.
I'm not the only miner that dowses for gold here.
You will never find all of the gold in the ground and just finding the stuff in your immediate area is a challenge.


Correa Neto, It's not a scam It’s not sheer illusion.
I don't charge any one for my opinion on what's in their location.
As I stated I have just put two miners back on track, such as it is in that area.
Try the experiment.
It will read deeper into the walls of your mineshaft than a metal detector, keep in mind that if you have iron pyrites running in the rock that it may pick that up too.

James wants accuracy and that's what I’m trying to accomplish by having the ground scraped.
The guy that will do that for me will charge a hundred dollar bill.
Before he will do that I will have to get a plan of operation,
That costs twenty dollars.
That is the first thing that I will do in the next few days.

Welcome back Edge, and good luck on your re-test.
I'm sorry that you are bored.

I'm skeptical too, but at least try to do the experiment and then tell me you are bored.

I am going to ask you again Edge, how does your bit of stick detect this EM field you think is there? We don’t have a problem with metals in the earth altering the magnetic field a little, we have a problem with your twig being a magnetic anomaly detector. I'm pretty sure you could walk over the biggest undiscovered nugget around and your bit of wood wouldn't twitch if you personally didn't know the gold was there.

How would I know the gold is there? I don’t have x- ray vision , and even if the books say it should be on an inside turn on the creek it isn’t always there.
Hell I have seen a few places where it’s on the out side of a turn and that was discovered in 1994 by another dowser and me.
I can eliminate the organic and use copper.
It doesn't have to be a twig.

No way would it miss the biggest nugget, there is no way in one season that you could even come close to walking all the ground here to check.

How in the world would I know what's under boulders and rocks I can't see through them.

I told you that my next move with the dredge would be to a better spot where I will hit big time, which will happen in the next day or two.
This confirms or will confirm my ability to tell the difference between a little bit and a large quantity.

James wants accuracy that's where the Payloader will come into place.
When I have positive results from that experiment I will apply for the test.

There is more to this part of the country than just mining and I like doing those things.

Like hunting fishing cutting firewood, but I look forward while the season is here, to be able to dredge and dive with air and be under water, it's a whole different world when you’re there.
Not to mention the fact that I get to make some money while I’m diving too.
I will let you know about the big score this weekend probably Saturday.
I have already dowsed the spot and know.

:D
 
Edge, what is the problem? One moment you say your divining apparatus (since twig is only one choice) is far more penetrating than a metal detector, the next you say you cant see through rocks and boulders. You're claiming you can effectively 'see' through the rocks to find gold and other minerals with your divining sticks, are you not?

Is that not the whole point of this nonsense, that you can not only detect stuff but tell exactly which stuff it is by tuning your fork, tell us how deep it is and how much of it there is there? At one point you even claim that iron pyrities can 'interfere' with the detection process, giving a false positive. If you can do all this why are you completely unable to find gold in a gold field any better than anyone else?

No, you cant walk everywhere with your 'apparatus', but the other miners cant walk anywhere and detect gold, whereas you claim you can. How is it you are not simply walking around until you get a strong detection, then mining out the gold you positively know to be there? Shall I tell you why? Because divining absolutely does not work, and you are living proof of that. You have found next to nothing, rely on the same textbooks that others do and fabricate excuses each time you fail. Face facts man, you've spent so much time waving a stick about like some sort of Tricorder that you dont want to give it up because you might look more foolish realising it's garbage. Put the stick down and walk away.
 
Obviously Kevin you can't follow a story when it's told.
You know nothing about mining.
Let me put it this way, It works my next experiments have taught me a lot.
When I go to the creek and it has not been dredged, you stand there and you can't look through the overburden, therefore you know nothing except what the books have written as to where to find the gold.
Then you check for the stringers or lines of gold under the rocks, OVERBURDEN, by dowsing for it.
Can you see through the overburden? No.
Now the difference is that the apparatus can detect which line or, STRINGER is, the heaviest and where the pockets or cracks in the bottom are holding quantity.

You then discover it was right, but not without checking other lines of gold.
The results are that it was right again.
This leads me to the next step, Today I will get the paper work necessary to get the plan of operation, and file it tomorrow.
Then I will, after the ground is scraped clean, try to do the test exactly as it was performed at
Fort Lauderdale.
I'll let you know how that turns out.
I got the gold that was there, in my line at the new spot and I am quite pleased with my series of experiments, I was able to tell when it petered out and when it picked up in quantity.
 
5 will get you 10

edge said:
sackett
That’s a good one.
But it isn't so isolated as to drive a person wild or loony here.
After all we do have cars nowadays....

It's not geographical isolation that I'm talking about.

(Five will get you ten that Edge still doesn't take my point.)
 
edge said:
Obviously Kevin you can't follow a story when it's told.
You know nothing about mining.
Let me put it this way, It works my next experiments have taught me a lot.
When I go to the creek and it has not been dredged, you stand there and you can't look through the overburden, therefore you know nothing except what the books have written as to where to find the gold.
Then you check for the stringers or lines of gold under the rocks, OVERBURDEN, by dowsing for it.
Can you see through the overburden? No.
Now the difference is that the apparatus can detect which line or, STRINGER is, the heaviest and where the pockets or cracks in the bottom are holding quantity.

You then discover it was right, but not without checking other lines of gold.
The results are that it was right again.
This leads me to the next step, Today I will get the paper work necessary to get the plan of operation, and file it tomorrow.
Then I will, after the ground is scraped clean, try to do the test exactly as it was performed at
Fort Lauderdale.
I'll let you know how that turns out.
I got the gold that was there, in my line at the new spot and I am quite pleased with my series of experiments, I was able to tell when it petered out and when it picked up in quantity.
If you're yet to "scrape the ground clean", then how the hell do you know the gold exists... "in quantity" or otherwise? Counting our unhatched chickens again, are we?

Edge... you're the most successful failure the world has ever seen.
 
edge said:
Obviously Kevin you can't follow a story when it's told.
You know nothing about mining.
Correct, I know nothing about mining, and you're not helping any since no terms are explained and your grammar and writing are somewhat lacking. Also my name is actually Kenny, assuming you were talking to me, so you might want to brush up on your reading too.

As for divining, what makes you think anything has changed since the last time? I re-read the account of what happened during the test and your stick appears to be able to pick up bronze ink, aluminium, manganese-brass alloy and quartz from considerable distance, yet you failed. Has wandering through a gold-field earning subsistence wages made you better at divination somehow, and if so how? What has changed since you last sat the test and completely failed to detect anything?
 
Kenny 10 Bellys said:
Correct, I know nothing about mining, and you're not helping any since no terms are explained and your grammar and writing are somewhat lacking. Also my name is actually Kenny, assuming you were talking to me, so you might want to brush up on your reading too.

As for divining, what makes you think anything has changed since the last time? I re-read the account of what happened during the test and your stick appears to be able to pick up bronze ink, aluminium, manganese-brass alloy and quartz from considerable distance, yet you failed. Has wandering through a gold-field earning subsistence wages made you better at divination somehow, and if so how? What has changed since you last sat the test and completely failed to detect anything?
He's moved three thousand miles to wander through a completely new played out gold field.

Too bad his dowsing rod won't detect french fries, at least then he could find a McDonalds at which to earn himself a reliable, if not respectable, wage.
 
Tricky said:

You got twenty out of twenty in the open test, Edge. With that kind of accuracy, the lottery would be a piece of cake.


Edge, I wonder if you'd care to respond to this point-- if there was something interfering, why did the open test go so well for you?
 
The open test is open, to prove it works, you see the target it's not hidden.
During that time I knew I would have a hard time as I was picking up interference in between the target also.
The closed test is the one that counts, you know, for the money.
I still needed to see the structure of the whole test.
That my friend is what will make me get it right, to know what made me fail at the closed test.
But I knew before the closed test that I was going to have a problem.
The reasons for scraping the ground is to get rid of all the interference then introduce the target.
There should be no mistaking it.
Neutral ground can be achieved on a small scale here, I need about a thirty by thirty square foot area to do the test in.
 
edge said:
The open test is open, to prove it works, you see the target it's not hidden.
During that time I knew I would have a hard time as I was picking up interference in between the target also.
Did you mention that at the time?
 
Edge...

Hey hey...

I was just posting about you the other day...

I can remember your posts about how you claimed that a screwdriver melted in your hands...amazing...

Why can't you do that for the challenge instead of dowsing again..

But, apart from that, you did post some excellent examples of 'UFOs' in ancient art...And backed it up with good, understandable theory..


Good to see you back...and i'm glad to see you haven't given up on what you believe...

DB
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom