Scott Sommers slightly injured by Illuminati

In the Jani Lane Illuminati thread, Scott said in the thread that he made up the most ridiculous conspiracy theory he could think of. After this admission, legions of regular and semi regular posters still continued to spar with him over the details. Why would people do this? Why are they here?


I think SS (OMFG! I just noticed that!) is the living embodiment of Poe's Law. It seems that, even after he tells you he's deliberately parodying the CT mindset, some people have a sneaking suspicion that he's actually serious, and it was the denial of serious intention that was the lie.


Which is what makes his act Secretly Brilliant.
 
I suppose. It just seems odd that folks who debate him when he's being purposefully ridiculous haven't ever noticed that the guy is quite serious and pretty well-reasoned on most topics.
 
...legions of regular and semi regular posters still continued to spar with him over the details. Why would people do this? Why are they here?

I think it is to influence the lurkers. Pro-government conspiracy theorists are very concerned with the appearance of the majority. They create a lot of talk agreeing with themselves. The moderators encourage this by censoring the posts of Truth seekers. I personally have had many posts deleted by the moderators. Now if that's not proof of systematic control by the JREF, I don't know what is.
 
...SS (OMFG! I just noticed that!)...Secretly Brilliant.

So, SS = SB = "Scott Sommers" is Sylvia Browne? :covereyes


(Sorry, couldn't resist. *wink* *laughriot* etc.)
 
Last edited:
In the Jani Lane Illuminati thread, Scott said in the thread that he made up the most ridiculous conspiracy theory he could think of. After this admission, legions of regular and semi regular posters still continued to spar with him over the details. Why would people do this? Why are they here?

Let me posit a serious answer to this question. The attraction of all this is the simplicity it illustrates in the whole conspiracy theory thing. I only have about 10 different things that I say over and over again. I bet I could say them in a random or rotating fashion unrelated to the JREF skeptic posts and still have the same effect. All the 'facts' I state are either made up or copied from another post. I am so practiced at it now that new members can't tell the difference between the game I play and the real thing. But in fact, "practiced" means to me randomly using stock statements as replies to criticisms. I poke fun at the JREF skeptic crowd, but the real problem is figuring out how to reply to people who say the same things over and over and over again.
 
I personally have had many posts deleted by the moderators. Now if that's not proof of systematic control by the JREF, I don't know what is.

It's proof that you contravened the Member's Agreement. That is what it is.
 
Let me posit a serious answer to this question. The attraction of all this is the simplicity it illustrates in the whole conspiracy theory thing. I only have about 10 different things that I say over and over again. I bet I could say them in a random or rotating fashion unrelated to the JREF skeptic posts and still have the same effect. All the 'facts' I state are either made up or copied from another post. I am so practiced at it now that new members can't tell the difference between the game I play and the real thing. But in fact, "practiced" means to me randomly using stock statements as replies to criticisms. I poke fun at the JREF skeptic crowd, but the real problem is figuring out how to reply to people who say the same things over and over and over again.

And it's getting very boring. Goodbye.
 
So, SS = SB = "Scott Sommers" is Sylvia Browne? :covereyes


(Sorry, couldn't resist. *wink* *laughriot* etc.)


My god, how deep does this rabbit hole go?



And it's getting very boring. Goodbye.



Which is actually a pretty good imitation of an actual CTist. Have you actually tried reading anything Robert Prey has written lately? Just stupid repetitions of the same utter bollocks, over and over. Absolutely no sign that he ever even once stops to think about what people have said to him, or about what he's saying.
 
Which is actually a pretty good imitation of an actual CTist. Have you actually tried reading anything Robert Prey has written lately?

There's a useful tip for you in Robert's body of work, Scott; he's got the universal default one-word response for any argument he knows he can't counter, which is to declare it "Baloney." Maybe you could add something similar to the repertoire.

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom