"Russia conspired with the European Trump'

No, it's going to be more like what we've just seen with the UK ambassador to the US. As the (very much) senior partner in the relationship, the US gets to say whether the ambassador stays and the UK is so weak that we comply.

I suspect that the trade negotiations will go much the same way. The US will naturally put America first in setting terms and the UK will have the options "take it or leave it". We will take it and it's likely that the trade deal will have implications for UK law.

Contrast that with the EU where the UK has considerable influence in setting the rules, various opt-outs should we choose not to adhere to a particular rule and where membership of the EU allowed the UK more leverage compared to negotiating alone.

by entering a bilateral agreement with a much larger partner, the UK would lose economic and negotiation power.

Ah, gotcha. Your definition of "sovereignty" seems too broad to be of any use to me, but I'll try to keep in mind that this is the kind of thing you're talking about when you use the term.
 
It's the same Brexit proponents use.

If you say so.

It seems to me that under the EU arrangement, Brussels can impose rules on the UK from outside the UK's own governing authority.

A sovereign nation negotiates on its own behalf, and decides for itself what deals to enter on what terms. It is a ceding of their sovereignty to agree to let some other governing body, outside of their authority, make these kinds of decisions for them.

The American colonies gave up a substantial amount of their sovereignty, when they chose to unify under a central government. The main motivations for this were the increased negotiating power and military security of such a union.

If Hawaii were to secede today, it would probably have to accept very unfavorable trading terms from places like Japan, China, and Australia. But the way I think of sovereignty, unless it actually formally subordinated its government to another government, it wouldn't be giving up its sovereignty.

I think it obscures useful discussion, to conflate a weak trading position with an actual loss of sovereignty.
 
No, it's going to be more like what we've just seen with the UK ambassador to the US. As the (very much) senior partner in the relationship, the US gets to say whether the ambassador stays and the UK is so weak that we comply.

I suspect that the trade negotiations will go much the same way. The US will naturally put America first in setting terms and the UK will have the options "take it or leave it". We will take it and it's likely that the trade deal will have implications for UK law.

Contrast that with the EU where the UK has considerable influence in setting the rules, various opt-outs should we choose not to adhere to a particular rule and where membership of the EU allowed the UK more leverage compared to negotiating alone.


Hell, I am an American and I am worried about the loss of Amereican Soverignity to Russia because of Trump's constant ass kissing of Putin. His occasional tiffs with Putin are just for show, shold not be taken seriously.
 
If you say so.

It seems to me that under the EU arrangement, Brussels can impose rules on the UK from outside the UK's own governing authority.

Except that's not how it works.
It's our own governing authority that negotiates those rules with the rest.

These are not imposed by an external entity in any way.
That's the twisted version certain "journalists" have been pushing for years...one of whom is quite likely to be our next PM.
 
Greece: we don't like austerity policies that are harming our nati-

Germany: **** you! Austerity harder or else!
Your point being?
Because this has nothing to do with the EU-UK relationship.
The UK isn't part of the Eurozone and didn't seek loans and guarantees it could never get on the open market.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom