Romney: Discuss Wealth Distribution Only in Quiet Rooms

hgc

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Jun 14, 2002
Messages
15,892
Does anyone want to know why Mitt Romney will never be elected President? Listen to this gobsmacking snippet from an interview with Matt Lauer. Lauer is pressing him to explain how it is that any discussion of wealth distribution is a matter of "envy." His response is to not only to press further with the bogus "class warfare" construct, but to insist that such topics are not appropriate for political campaigns or public discussion.

http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2012/01/without-comment-romney-lauer-and-the-1/251283/

Lauer: Are there no fair questions about the distribution of wealth without it being seen as envy, though?

Romney: You know, I think it's fine to talk about those things in quiet rooms and discussions about tax policy and the like, but, the President has made this part of his campaign rally everywhere [...] he goes we hear him talking about millionaires and billionaires and executives and Wall Street. It's a very envy-oriented and attack-oriented approach.


You can forget the "I like being able to fire people" quote, which is at least somewhat defensible when used out of context.* If this quote is played back in commercials by the Obama campaign or Obama supporting superPACs, it cuts deeply.

* By the way, that quote is ripe for further discussion in its proper context.
 
TRANSLATION:"When someone suggests that the republicon ecconomic model does not work becausae it parasitizes the wrking class, w3e all need to stick our fringers in our ears and sing while some republicon elder takes the offending working schlub aside to explain that he doesn't matter, and that he should kiss the boss' ass and thank him for the wretched minimum wage job he created to replace that nice manufacturing job that Mittens just sent to China."
 
"but, the President has made this part of his campaign rally everywhere [...] he goes we hear him talking about millionaires and billionaires and executives and Wall Street."

And this, in part, is why you will lose the general election to him, Mr. Romney.
 
Quiet room discussions = back room deals.

The great unwashed need to shut up, sit down, and be greatful for whatever the elite are willing to provide.

Contrast Mitt's quote with, "I like the noise of democracy" --James Buchanan

BTW: It isn't about envy. It's about fairness and the lives of people.
 
The whole point of class warfare is to yammer loudly about it. I don't understand his point.

If he was brighter, he could at least make a spirited defense of the natural meritocracy of freedom-based capitalism and how it raises everybody up, and faster at that, than more "redistri...

Well, he's not even bright enough to get that far, so I wash my hands of him. He's another McCaine, the next good ol' boy idiot in line to be nominated.
 
Last edited:
If he was brighter, he could at least make a spirited defense of the natural meritocracy of freedom-based capitalism and how it raises everybody up, and faster at that, than more "redistri...
I'm a capitalism fan (see user name). I will likely remain so. There is simply too much evidence that capitalism has benefited humankind in ways that were simply unforeseeable in the past. Modern medicine, space exploration, labor saving devices and increases in productivity to make it possible for many if not most people in industrialized nations to have things like computers, TVs and access to modern medicine.

But that brings me to your statement. I don't believe capitalism does that. I believe capitalism can do that. Further, capitalism is capable of causing so much misery and environmental harm if its unbridled.

Otherwise I agree with you. :) I'd love to know what you think.
 
Most liberals are also fans of capitalism. Certainly the President is. I think where liberals and conservatives part ways is over the subject of unregulated capitalism. Conservatives have this idea that the market corrects social ills. You hear them say things like "if a company pollutes the water, people are free to buy from a competitor who doesn't. If they don't choose to pay more for pollution-free products, the market has spoken". This is imbecilic. Markets can be and are manipulated. Maybe that polluter has cornered the market. Maybe the cost of cleaning up is so high that a competitor couldn't compete if he tried to be responsible. The only possible choice in that scenario is dirty water or forced regulation.

I'm a fan of capitalism. I'm also a fan of a commons that belongs to all of us that includes clean air and water, and a chance to succeed and live under a minimum standard.

Those two should not be mutually exclusive, but for modern Teabaggers, I may as well have just suggested a Marxist takeover complete with gulags.
 
It is too often true that the only way to oppose a reasonable argument is to extend it past all logical sense.
 
Most liberals are also fans of capitalism. Certainly the President is. I think where liberals and conservatives part ways is over the subject of unregulated capitalism. Conservatives have this idea that the market corrects social ills. You hear them say things like "if a company pollutes the water, people are free to buy from a competitor who doesn't. If they don't choose to pay more for pollution-free products, the market has spoken". This is imbecilic. Markets can be and are manipulated. Maybe that polluter has cornered the market. Maybe the cost of cleaning up is so high that a competitor couldn't compete if he tried to be responsible. The only possible choice in that scenario is dirty water or forced regulation.

I'm a fan of capitalism. I'm also a fan of a commons that belongs to all of us that includes clean air and water, and a chance to succeed and live under a minimum standard.

Those two should not be mutually exclusive, but for modern Teabaggers, I may as well have just suggested a Marxist takeover complete with gulags.
:) I couldn't agree more.
 
Capitalism is, in essence, merely one of the ways in which wealth is redistributed. It does not create wealth. It can merely bring labor and pre-existing resources together and to move resources or finished goods from one point to another in exchange for other resources or goods.

All those resources thus traded are extracted from a common pool of resources which we allow designated parties to extract in one way or another. Normally, capitalism works well, within legtal limits, because it is, theoreticly, possible for everyone to participate profitably in either trade or production.

Problems arise when capitalism over-steps its rightful boundaries, and wealth, rather than being distributed throughout the market, to the benefit of all, is gathered into fewer and fewer hands, and the masses find fewer opportunities to enter into commerce or production. At this point, those who control the wealth can either submit to some restructuring of the ecconomy or run the risk of being killed and eaten.

Mittens has, like a true vulture capitalist, opted to restructure the ecconomy ,ut in a way that does not really open a lot of opportunities in either trade or production. His suggestion that the foreclosure process by expedited would give the vulturesike himself an even bigger stake in the national wealth, and all the power that goes with it, to the point of dividing America into dozens of private fiedoms of land owners and renters. Serfdom is not far behind.

He wants discussions of wealth distribution kept subdued so that the peasants do not realize what the vulture capitalists are doing to them.

If capitalism contnues down the road that "people" like Bain Capital have chosen for us, I suggest laying in a good stock of poultry seasoning. Unseasoned vulture don't taste all that great.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom