Roland Emmrich is making a movie on The Battle of Midway

https://variety.com/2017/film/festi...g-midway-world-war-2-battle-movie-1202442458/

:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp

And in more recent news, he has cast Woody Harrerlson as Nimitz:
:eek::eek::eek::eek::eek:

So now the guy who gave us such masterpieced of Historical Accuracy as "The Patriot" and "Anoymous" tackles World War 2.

Be afraid. Be very Afraid.

The 1976 film has it's flaws, but it will be masterpiece compared to this certain to be POS.
Maybe he can get some help from Michael Bay. I heard there might be some 'splosions!
 
I don't think you're being fair to him....

After all, he also directed 10,000 BC.

Good catch.

Although I did not see it, I also heard Emmerich film on "Stonewall" (the 1969 riot that touched off the Gay Rights movement, not the Civil War General) was not exactly a monument of historical accuracy.
Emmerich is getting desperate. He had not made a successful film since "2012"" and his previous film "Independence Day:Resurgance" was a huge bomb(when many thought a sequel to ID4 would be a surefire hit). I suspect this will not be the big turn around he needs.
 
I want to see a very realistic depiction of the battle:

In which none of the characters know what's going on, most of them don't even know where they are themselves, much less where the enemy is, and sometimes they attack their own forces. The pilots sit in really loud cockpits and there is no radio banter due to radio silence. Just hours and hours of screaming loud engine and wind noise.

Then they can't figure out what actually happened until days or weeks or years later. If ever.

Somehow, they don't make movies like that. :rolleyes:



At least we can probably guarantee that one of the major named characters will be Gay.
 
Last edited:
As to the timing for another jingoistic piece of propaganda, I actually think it's quite clever.
 
Oh well, at least we can all be thankful that it won't be JJ Abrams sitting in the director's chair. With him there, history would just be ignored...

1. It would take place in WWI not WW2.
2. The Japanese would win the battle.
3. The combat aircraft would be jet powered.
 
Oh well, at least we can all be thankful that it won't be JJ Abrams sitting in the director's chair. With him there, history would just be ignored...

1. It would take place in WWI not WW2.
2. The Japanese would win the battle.
3. The combat aircraft would be jet powered.

Maybe he could add in some extra spice.....with all the Japanese characters being played by Americans of Korean and Chinese descent and the Americans will be all women wearing ripped uniforms.
 
Could be worse, it can always be worse.

You could get a director with a real love for the material, who takes the time to get the costuming right, the look of the battlefield right and who shoots some wonderful action sequences - then frak the whole thing up by filling the 1.5 hour gap between the great action scenes with a period love story...

Paul Gross, I'm still bitter about Passchendale.

I'm still waiting for the Great Canadian War Movie - its not like we don't have some decent material to draw on - Chateauguay, Batoche (hell that one could be done from the perspective of both sides and be awesome and Canadian), plenty of stuff from WWI, Leo Major in WWII, etc. It's just that we keep doing the morally ambiguous (Hyena Road) or focus on the cock-ups (Dieppe).

Sorry for the derail...
 
Oh well, at least we can all be thankful that it won't be JJ Abrams sitting in the director's chair. With him there, history would just be ignored...

1. It would take place in WWI not WW2.
2. The Japanese would win the battle.
3. The combat aircraft would be jet powered.

JJ Abrams is busy working on his Nazi Zombie movie Overlord, out this fall.
 
Emmerich also brought us Universal Soldier, Stargate, Independence Day, and White House Down (one of the better Die Hard sequels). And even most of his misses have been serviceable summer popcorn flicks.
 
Emmerich also brought us Universal Soldier, Stargate, Independence Day, and White House Down (one of the better Die Hard sequels). And even most of his misses have been serviceable summer popcorn flicks.

Emmerich is harmless if he sticks to Sci Fi or out and out action.
But when it comes to History he is simply horrible.
Just view "Anonymous" for an example.....

Or Mel Gibson and his incredible semi automatic Muzzle loading rifle in "The Patriot"....
 
Could be worse, it can always be worse.

You could get a director with a real love for the material, who takes the time to get the costuming right, the look of the battlefield right and who shoots some wonderful action sequences - then frak the whole thing up by filling the 1.5 hour gap between the great action scenes with a period love story...

Paul Gross, I'm still bitter about Passchendale.

I'm still waiting for the Great Canadian War Movie - its not like we don't have some decent material to draw on - Chateauguay, Batoche (hell that one could be done from the perspective of both sides and be awesome and Canadian), plenty of stuff from WWI, Leo Major in WWII, etc. It's just that we keep doing the morally ambiguous (Hyena Road) or focus on the cock-ups (Dieppe).

Sorry for the derail...

I keep on waitng for Peter Jackson to do his endlessly talked about "Dam Busters" movie....
 
https://variety.com/2017/film/festi...g-midway-world-war-2-battle-movie-1202442458/

:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp

And in more recent news, he has cast Woody Harrerlson as Nimitz:
:eek::eek::eek::eek::eek:

So now the guy who gave us such masterpieced of Historical Accuracy as "The Patriot" and "Anoymous" tackles World War 2.

Be afraid. Be very Afraid.

The 1976 film has it's flaws, but it will be masterpiece compared to this certain to be POS.

I am definitely afraid... but I did kinda like both "The Patriot" and "Anonymous" while completely understanding the historical inaccuracies of them. I also enjoyed the recent biopic about Churchill even though the problems were myriad. So who knows, just sit back and enjoy Woody Harrelson as Nimitz?
 
"Masters Of The Air" seems to be in limbo.

Oh. That's disappointing.
Just finished the book during the holidays, but hadn't found the time for looking this series up yet.
I guess, I won't then.

Any idea about the reason of this?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom