RNC Spent $150,000 to "Spruce" up Palin

Status
Not open for further replies.
It was childish when they complained about Edwards' haircut, Hillary's cleavage, or about Reagan's dye jobs too.
If any of those had been purchased by the RNC for $150,000, I bet there'd have been some questions asked.
 
McCain-Feingold:

SEC. 313. USE OF CONTRIBUTED AMOUNTS FOR CERTAIN PURPOSES.
(a) PERMITTED USES-

...
(b) PROHIBITED USE-



(1) IN GENERAL- A contribution or donation described in subsection (a) shall not be converted by any person to personal use.

(2) CONVERSION- For the purposes of paragraph (1), a contribution or donation shall be considered to be converted to personal use if the contribution or amount is used to fulfill any commitment, obligation, or expense of a person that would exist irrespective of the candidate's election campaign or individual's duties as a holder of Federal office, including--

(A) a home mortgage, rent, or utility payment;
(B) a clothing purchase;
(C) a noncampaign-related automobile expense;
(D) a country club membership;
(E) a vacation or other noncampaign-related trip;
(F) a household food item;
(G) a tuition payment;
(H) admission to a sporting event, concert, theater, or other form of entertainment not associated with an election campaign; and
(I) dues, fees, and other payments to a health club or recreational facility.'

.
.
.
Sec. 323
'(a) NATIONAL COMMITTEES-

'(1) IN GENERAL- A national committee of a political party (including a national congressional campaign committee of a political party) may not solicit, receive, or direct to another person a contribution, donation, or transfer of funds or any other thing of value, or spend any funds, that are not subject to the limitations, prohibitions, and reporting requirements of this Act.

'(2) APPLICABILITY- The prohibition established by paragraph (1) applies to any such national committee, any officer or agent acting on behalf of such a national committee, and any entity that is directly or indirectly established, financed, maintained, or controlled by such a national committee.
 
$150,000 for clothes for a six week campaign is $25,000 a week in clothes. That averages to a $3600 wardrobe a day if she never wore the same thing twice. How?

Seriously, how? Is she wearing designer chimpanzee fur coats?
 
Reporter: "Gov. Palin, just how many $5000+ dresses do you own?"

Palin: "Uhhh... I'll have my staff get back to you on that."

;)
 
The good news for Palin is that she's got a great future endorsing designer clothing after she loses in November. I'm thinking a new line from Yves St. Laurent, something like "La Mère Hocqueè"
 
$150,000 for clothes for a six week campaign is $25,000 a week in clothes. That averages to a $3600 wardrobe a day if she never wore the same thing twice. How?

Seriously, how? Is she wearing designer chimpanzee fur coats?


Ask your SO/girlfriend/ female friends.
 
Ask your SO/girlfriend/ female friends.

The girls I know who wear the nicest clothes make them themselves, or get up early in the morning to comb thrift shops. (I got Florshiem shoes with no wear in my size for $12, whoo-hoo!) I guess that's impossible, however, since I don't live in REAL America. It's very REAL America to spend an outrageous fortune of someone else's money on clothes.

By the by, I didn't pull that "chimpanzee fur coat" example out of no where. One girl I know (not my friend, but my friend's sister) found one at a thrift store and looked up the original price from the designer's name and such stiched into the lining when she was struck by how odd the fur felt. It turns out it was some $5000 or so chimpanzee fur coat she got for $20.

Mind you, I think it's a revolting garment but that's what I think of when I think of garments worth a minimum of $3600.
 
It is a simple fact of political life that you have to present a good appearance. It is a simple fact of our culture that women have to spend more on their appearance than men. With so much important stuff to talk about during this election, this kind of sniping is pointless and childish.

It was childish when they complained about Edwards' haircut, Hillary's cleavage, or about Reagan's dye jobs too.

I agree with you about the non-Palin stuff you mentioned. Although to my eyes Edwards already seemed like a popinjay and that haircut was more evidence along that line to me.

The Palin clothes purchase is much more problematic I think. As I noted above the shear size of it is problematic, the fact that clothes were purchased for other family members is problematic and given her other documented ethical lapses it is particularly problematic.

And now based on jberryhill's post it looks like the purchases were flat out illegal.

If I had been a McCain supporter, would this have been enough to keep me from voting for McCain/Palin. It might have been. Even in my old knee jerk, vote-Republican days I would have been unhappy with the Palin pick. This might have been enough to at least get me to vote for the Libertarian candidate.

One of the most significant reasons for the failure of the Bush administration is the out of control cronyism that dominated it. These kind of Palin ethical lapses suggest to me that a vote for Palin would be a vote for a continuation of the unethical governance that has gotten the US into the mess that it's in.

The good news for Palin is that she's got a great future endorsing designer clothing after she loses in November. I'm thinking a new line from Yves St. Laurent, something like "La Mère Hocqueè"

I mentioned previously that the clothes might turn a profit for the RNC. It would be tacky, but the RNC could easily auction them off for more money than they were purchased for and there is the opportunity for tie ins with the clothing manufacturers. At the very least the charities that get the clothes could sell them for significantly more than used clothes usually go for.

ImaginalDisc brought up an angle that I hadn't thought about. If the plan was always to give them to charity, when did they plan to do that. Was she going to turn into the grundge VP after she got elected and she wasn't going to need her fancy duds? Or was the idea that she could afford her own clothes once she was the VP?

One interesting aspect of all this that doesn't seem to have made the news yet is who at the RNC approved this? By what process does the RNC dole out $150K for somebody's personal use. This situation has the potential to lead to some messiness over at the RNC headquarters.
 
Last edited:
I agree with you about the non-Palin stuff you mentioned. Although to my eyes Edwards already seemed like a popinjay and that haircut was more evidence along that line to me.

Eh, (Fair disclosure, I am a Dem,) that never seemed like an issue to me. It seems reasonable to me that a politician running for major office would spend a few hundreds dollars on his or her hair. $400 for a house call from a top hair dresser who normally makes $150 an hour isn't relatively exorbitant.

ImaginalDisc brought up an angle that I hadn't thought about. If the plan was always to give them to charity, when did they plan to do that. Was she going to turn into the grundge VP after she got elected and she wasn't going to need her fancy duds? Or was the idea that she could afford her own clothes once she was the VP?

What, I made a point? Whew, gotta lay of the coffee.
 
.....now based on jberryhill's post it looks like the purchases were flat out illegal.....

It would seem your reading skills or judgment is impaired....
if the contribution or amount is used to fulfill any commitment, obligation, or expense of a person that would exist irrespective of the candidate's election campaign or individual's duties as a holder of Federal office, including--

(A) a home mortgage, rent, or utility payment;
(B) a clothing purchase;
​
Let's talk about the relative ethics of the two political parties after D-Louisiana Jefferson is behind bars, after Delay explains the origin of the $171k to his girlie girl, and after we discuss Barney Frank's girly boy from Fannie Mac.

By the way...has it occurred to you these "campaign clothes" might be Ebayed, like the Governor Palin's jet?

I don't suppose you'd care to discuss the substantive aspects of Palin's record as Governor, instead of the latest smear?
 
Last edited:
I agree with you about the non-Palin stuff you mentioned. Although to my eyes Edwards already seemed like a popinjay and that haircut was more evidence along that line to me.

Edwards had the best platform, I thought. He might have been a dandy, but I can't see that as a big deal. Still, the Dem's dodged a bullet there.

I The Palin clothes purchase is much more problematic I think. As I noted above the shear size of it is problematic, the fact that clothes were purchased for other family members is problematic and given her other documented ethical lapses it is particularly problematic.
It is problematic, but Republicans are more forgiving of clothes horses than Dems. Nancy Reagan in particular was one of those who pretty much never wore the same dress twice. Her wardrobe was subsidized by big contributors too, although she did donate many of the outfits to charity. But it is very much a double standard. Dems are supposed to be the party of the people (although intellectual elitists) and they would kick up much more of a fuss about this.

And now based on jberryhill's post it looks like the purchases were flat out illegal.
I may be wrong, but I thought McCain-Feingold was no longer in effect. I believe McCain caught some flap for not supporting it when it came up for renewal.

If I had been a McCain supporter, would this have been enough to keep me from voting for McCain/Palin. It might have been. Even in my old knee jerk, vote-Republican days I would have been unhappy with the Palin pick. This might have been enough to at least get me to vote for the Libertarian candidate.
I don't know if it will have a significant effect on the numbers. They've piled so much straw on that poor camel's back, that it was broken long ago for most independents and undecideds. Only a few Unrelenting Elephants are left standing. Certainly (and rightfully) the Powell endorsement dwarfs this in terms of poll shifts.

One of the most significant reasons for the failure of the Bush administration is the out of control cronyism that dominated it. These kind of Palin ethical lapses suggest to me that a vote for Palin would be a vote for a continuation of the unethical governance that has gotten the US into the mess that it's in.
In fairness, most administrations have had problems with cronyism. Carter's is the only one in recent history that tried to be ethical, and look where that got them.

One interesting aspect of all this that doesn't seem to have made the news yet is who at the RNC approved this? By what process does the RNC dole out $150K for somebody's personal use. This situation has the potential to lead to some messiness over at the RNC headquarters.
True, this may have loud repercussions within the party. Can you imagine being a Republican running for Congress in an already-difficult election, and being refused for some campaign support money? They're bound to say, "Why the hell did you spend it on her damn clothes?"

Who knows, we may even see a few party shifts in the next few years, a reverse of what we saw in much of the South in the seventies and eighties.
 
I don't suppose you'd care to discuss the substantive aspects of Palin's record as Governor, instead of the latest smear?
What were they again? As I recall, she spread the wealth by making the oil companies pay larger access fees. She signed the biggest budget increase in history. She helped continue the trend of getting Alaska more pork and earmarks than any other state. She got a law passed to allow arial wolf-hunting. She also managed to make such poor decisions that she wound up getting an ethics citation by a panel composed mostly of her own party.

Go ahead. Focus on her record as Governor. It won't help.
 
It would seem your reading skills or judgment is impaired....
if the contribution or amount is used to fulfill any commitment, obligation, or expense of a person that would exist irrespective of the candidate's election campaign or individual's duties as a holder of Federal office, including--

(A) a home mortgage, rent, or utility payment;
(B) a clothing purchase;
​
Let's talk about the relative ethics of the two political parties after D-Louisiana Jefferson is behind bars, after Delay explains the origin of the $171k to his girlie girl, and after we discuss Barney Frank's girly boy from Fannie Mac.

By the way...has it occurred to you these "campaign clothes" might be Ebayed, like the governor's jet?

You made two points. One that I might not have understood and one that is plain stupid. First the stupid one:

Apparently, your idea is that Republicans remain above reproach unless they have committed a more serious ethical breach than all other Democrats. So the defense for any Republican crime is to find some Democrat that has done something worse and use that as proof that the Republican is pure. This idea seems like such nonsense that it hard to believe that any one could actually believe it, but apparently when the partisan juices are running strong the idea has traction with some people.

Your second point might be correct. I don't understand it. You seem to believe that the law that jberryhill cited proves that Palin's clothing allowance was legal or at least that the law doesn't necessarily make Palin's clothing allowance illegal.

I think your point here might be that Palin would not have had a requirement to wear fancy clothes unless she was campaigning and so the clothing allowance was legal. I think there is something to that idea and if the allowance had been for $15K instead of $150K it seems like it might have been a fairly easy case to make. However, given how large the allowance actually was and its use for other family members I don't think the case that this was a legal use of campaign funds is all that clear. I think there are a lot of Republican donors right now who aren't too enthused about Palin's clothes, regardless of whether it was legal or not.
 
It is a simple fact of political life that you have to present a good appearance. It is a simple fact of our culture that women have to spend more on their appearance than men.


I don't disagree ... but $150,000? Nuh uh.

But to be fair, some of that went to the kids and the First Dude. They must all have been running around nekkid in the Alaska Governor's Office.
 
The girls I know who wear the nicest clothes make them themselves, or get up early in the morning to comb thrift shops. (I got Florshiem shoes with no wear in my size for $12, whoo-hoo!) I guess that's impossible, however, since I don't live in REAL America. It's very REAL America to spend an outrageous fortune of someone else's money on clothes.

Tradeing time for cost is generaly posible. Palin however doesn't really have the time. Neither do the other three but the have a number of advantges. Being male means that the standards for what they have to wear are pretty fixed. While it is posible to spend large amounts of suits a couple of thousand dollars will get you a suit that will fit in anywhere (outside a white tie event anyway). They also don't have an issue with outfit clash. Palin probably can't wear anything too close to what is in hillary's wardrobe and there isn't really a female equiv of a suit (her image means she can't just wear a suit) she can fall back on.

Then there is a the question of image. Obama trying to appear to be a regular guy in in his late 40s in smart clothing. As images go that one isn't going to be too hard for him. McCain and Biden are probably trying to look younger than they are (and again in smart clothing) but McCain generaly looks fairly young for his age and biden's hair transplant appears to be effective.
Palin's image is as glamorious and yes pretty. The first doesn't come cheap. The second can do but she cannot risk haveing an off day which is where the expense kicks in again.
 
I am betting if Hilary had won the nomination, she would have had a similiar bill.
Sorry, but this is a petty issue. I am no fan of Palin....just check my posting history, but if the GOP wants to spend it's money that way, that's there business.
I agree it looks bad for Palin,but she looked bad enough already.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom