Richard Gage just keeps getting dumber

Hi Architect:




No sir. Building fires burn at around 800 to 1000 degrees and failure requires 2795 degrees to melt structural red-iron steel. This video does a wonderful job of showing these readers the difference. Dr. Steven Jones also does a good job here. The energy from any building fire is carried away from the fuel source to the cooler areas of the steel-frame network more quickly than the fire can cause proximal supports to reach failing temperatures. No sir. Open air fires have never caused the catastrophic failure of any steel-framed skyscraper and never will, because that is very much impossible.

GL,

Terral

Terral, look at the image below. It's from this site.

1516271537_a4bd7046bf.jpg


The man is forging a Katana. If you look, you will see that one end of the steel is red-hot. The other end is not. In fact, the other end is probably cool enough to touch. But it's just come out of his forge! Obviously, then, heat does not travel through steel fast enough to prevent a large temperature gradient.

Your argument of heat transferring so fast that the whole building would have had to be heated to a critical temperature is wrong.

Which means, if you consider yourself an intellectually honest person, you should remove that from your argument and by extension all points that depended upon it.


And before you go into a rand arguing how I have to post my own thesis to counter yours instead of showing you the errors in yours, let me explain something you seem to have missed:

The people on this forum are not going to let your "thesis" pass by without critically examining it. The idea of posting such a thing is to see if it stands up to scrutiny, not just to have it out there for people to read. So far, your "thesis" has failed to meet any reasonable standards of accuracy. We are pointing this out, because we do not want you wasting your time with such delusions nor influencing people who may lack the requisite knowledge to spot the areas where you are wrong.

You posted the thing, now you have to defend it.


Now, I think this off-topic drift has gone on far enough, so, with a gigantic and much-resisted lurch, I'm going to attempt to drag it back to the OP:

I don't suppose Richard Gage has stated how he came to his "dissapearing mass" conclusion, has he? Or has he just hoped nobody asks?
 
Last edited:
Now, I think this off-topic drift has gone on far enough, so, with a gigantic and much-resisted lurch, I'm going to attempt to drag it back to the OP:

Just like a typical sabreur.........
 
Just like a typical sabreur.........

SABREUR!?!?! :jaw-dropp

How dare you?! :a2:

[dignified] I am a foilist! [/dignified]



.... mutter mutter sabrist mutter lousy mutter .....


:mad:
 
Last edited:
Epee for Ever!


Foil....sheesh....right of attack...PAH!......body only?! Phooey......
 
Terral you are clearly an expert on fires. Please can you review this video.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/player/nol/new...news=1&bbcws=1

It is the aftermath of a fire that occurred yesterday. Please stop the video at 00:31 and take a good look at the beam. After you have done so, in your own words explain what happened to this beam.

I like reading expert opinion and look forward to reading yours.

Inidentally I am no fire expert, I don't claim to be,I rely on experts like you to tell me. All I see is a steel beam that as been in a fire and is now bent. So what caused it? Did it buckle through the heat ? Maybe something fell on it? You tell me, you being such an expert.
 
Last edited:
However, the noise of ‘many bombs’ was eliminated from the WTC equation, BECAUSE the inside-job bad guys used Thermate ‘cutter charges’ to ‘sever’ MANY steel connections ‘rather than’ using TNT.

So.....the WTC was blown apart but we couldn't hear it because of thermite?

It sounds just as retarded coming from you as it does from Richard Gage.
 
So.....the WTC was blown apart but we couldn't hear it because of thermite?

It sounds just as retarded coming from you as it does from Richard Gage.
We were all so blinded by the light...I mean the thermite glow that we suffered from temporary boom specific hearing loss :D
 
I would not trust Richard Gage to do the math for the structure required for the simple residential wooden deck I'm building.
 
Agreed. I would not have hired Richard Gage to design or build my cottage deck, never mind the cottage addition that I had done last year.
 
Last edited:
While I don't agree exactly with Gage's quote, I think it is safe to say the the pile-driver, or, falling upper block, was destroyed (or atleast broke apart) before it hit the ground.

Everybody, repeat after me:

Mass

Does

Not

Go

Away

Just

Because

It

Breaks

Into

Pieces


Say it with me now...ready? 3...2...1...



By Gage's logic, a tornado can't possibly do any damage because it's not a single solid mass.
 
Last edited:
No sir. Building fires burn at around 800 to 1000 degrees and failure requires 2795 degrees to melt structural red-iron steel.
This is flatly untrue. Failure does not require steel to melt. Not only does steel lose strength at temperatures far below the melting point - sometimes enough to cause structural failure due to overloading - it also expands at high temperatures, which can cause structural failure from loads being changed from compression to tension or vice versa.
This video does a wonderful job of showing these readers the difference. Dr. Steven Jones also does a good job here.
Steven Jones, who identified a chunk of concrete with rebar sticking out as some sort of peculiar metal slag? That Steven Jones?

In any case, some of us do not confuse YouTube with education. As a firefighter, I've been trained in building construction and collapse aspects related to fire. I've seen numerous examples of steel-framed buildings collapsing due to the effects mentioned above. These were ordinary building fires and the steel in these buildings did not melt.
The energy from any building fire is carried away from the fuel source to the cooler areas of the steel-frame network more quickly than the fire can cause proximal supports to reach failing temperatures. No sir. Open air fires have never caused the catastrophic failure of any steel-framed skyscraper and never will, because that is very much impossible.
Arrant nonsense. Terral seems to think steel structural members are some sort of thermal superconductor. That is fantasy; if such was the case no large steel structure would require fireproofing at all. In fact, such "open air" fires ( which in itself is grossly incorrect terminology) have killed many firefighters operating on steel-trussed roofs and in steel-frame buildings.

Why do people insist on repeating these very basic and gross errors with such conviction and self-assurance? It's not like correct information, in terms a layman can understand, has been out there for years in easily-accessible formats. There's simply no excuse for it.
 
So, Terral, if building fires are incapable of causing structural steel to fail, the why do they bother to fireproof it?

If an open air fire can not cause a failure of a steel framed building, then why did the steel framed portions of the Windsor tower collapse?

Bumped for Terrel
 
I've seen numerous examples of steel-framed buildings collapsing due to the effects mentioned above. These were ordinary building fires and the steel in these buildings did not melt.

I saw one do it about a month ago, in that case a storage warehouse. We were heading home after my Cousin's wedding and spotted a huge fire. I have some photos of it, though many weren't any good. About 10 mins after we got there, and just after the fire crews, the entire front of the building collapsed, luckily the fire crews had just arrived and were surveying the situation so no one was hurt, but it shows how fast steel can heat up and weaken to the point of collapse.
 
Epee for Ever!


Foil....sheesh....right of attack...PAH!......body only?! Phooey......


:duel
^ finally found the sucker.

Just for you, Eeper.

I must admit, I occasionally fence epee. I fence sabre once in a while, too. If you don't slum it occasionally, you'll never know how good you have it.

(I realize it's off topic, but it's more interesting than arguing with Terral (again) over the same unsupportable hooey he's promoting in every one of his threads. And besides, I think it's been pretty well established that mass cannot dissapear.)
 
No Sir. 1000 Degree Fires Simply Do NOT Melt 2800 Degree Structural Steel
Terral gets on my case because I call all of his posts dumber than dirt! He is mad because I can see his errors without looking it up, or thinking about it (or posting supporting material). So I just say his posts are dumber than dirt. Excuse me please dirt. This post I will not say Terral's posts are dumber than dirt, I will reply to each wrong thing I can find! In just a part of one sentence from one post. A look at why I think his posts are dumber than dirt, but this time pointing out the WRONG stuff in a small part and why it is prohibited in time and space to list all of the WRONG in all of Terral's error packed posts!! Remember you would also have to include all the errors included in his mega links of stupid web sites, and how he used the information wrong. Stand by for woo posting maximum WRONG in minimum time and space. Holly maximus stupid!
…. Building fires burn at around 800 to 1000 degrees and failure requires 2795 degrees …. GL, Terral
List of WRONG by Terral:
1. Building fires can be as high as 1300 degree C (look it up Terral)
2. Did not state degree in F or C. (it gets worse)
3. Stated the office fires in C and the temperature of Steel failure in F. (dumb)
4. Mixed the temperatures as propaganda or ignorance. (take your pick)
5. States failure of steel takes 2750 degree (wrong) at this temperature steel melts. Failure comes much lower.
6. Failure of steel occurs at temperatures much lower. (look it up Terral)
7-10+. must ding him for making up a lie about steel and fire. Because the failure of steel is complex, but occurs quickly in fire. So whereas Terral will use a truther web site for information and mess it up; the real information of steel is more complex related to strength in fires. By being too simplistic and missing the many aspects of steel and fire in just part of one sentence, the number of WRONG to assign is open!

List of right by Terral:
1. His name.

Terral,
I would analyze more of your post but it would take many paragraphs, several charts, many photos, and expose you as being ignorant on steel and fire, or what ever topic you are posting on so far.

Examples of things you do not understand could include simple things like:
An unprotected, conventional steel joist system will fail in less than 10 minutes under standard laboratory fire exposure test methods, while a conventional wood joist floor system can last up to 15 minutes.
This is why they fireproof steel!
Or on the technical side of steel in fire and strength, from NIST.
On the other hand, temperatures of steel members that lost fireproofing were found to be higher than 600 °C and often higher than 800 °C. Reductions in modulus of elasticity, yield strength, and ultimate tensile strength of steel in the WTC towers were found to be 13 percent, 20 percent, and 10 percent at 400 °C, and 35 percent, 92 percent, and 80 percent at 700 °C, which shows that steel loses its strength significantly at 700 °C. In addition, creep in steel becomes very large when the steel is exposed to temperatures higher than 500 °C under high stress.
Do you understand this or will you make up lies about it? Will you dismiss NIST because you lack knowledge on fire and steel as demonstrated in just part of one sentence in your post?

Such bad research and posting so much wrong information, demonstrates how badly informed you are on a broad range of 9/11 topics; which you contort with ease. Not one post is correct on 9/11, as you SPAM internet forums exposing your lack of knowledge on 9/11! Failure to find any coherent conclusions. You failed to get information correct available in the public domain.
 
Last edited:
Oy! The stupid! It burns.

The video link on YouTube proves nothing. Every one of the witness accounts of an "explosion" refer to the actual collapse of the building. Most of the people commenting on what they saw did not describe individual explosions, just the massive rumble that we all hear in anything with audio. The young fire fighter with the dirty face was talking about getting his gear together and starting down, then experiencing a massive explosion. This is clearly just after the collapse of the south tower. Chief Pfeifer, in the lobby of the north tower, described the collapse as an "explosion." You basicly have nothing here, Terral.

And Gage should be ashamed of himself for entering a series of lies into the congressional record, like pools of molten steel, and thermite as an accelerant in the pile. It could not have acted as an accelerant in the pile. When the pile formed, there could not have been any coherent mass of thermite to burn.

The boy's an idiot, pure and simple, and the licensing authority for architechts in California should really consider pulling his ticket.
 
Guys - back on topic, please. :)
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero
 
Oy! The stupid! It burns.

The video link on YouTube proves nothing. Every one of the witness accounts of an "explosion" refer to the actual collapse of the building. Most of the people commenting on what they saw did not describe individual explosions, just the massive rumble that we all hear in anything with audio. The young fire fighter with the dirty face was talking about getting his gear together and starting down, then experiencing a massive explosion. This is clearly just after the collapse of the south tower. Chief Pfeifer, in the lobby of the north tower, described the collapse as an "explosion." You basicly have nothing here, Terral.

And Gage should be ashamed of himself for entering a series of lies into the congressional record, like pools of molten steel, and thermite as an accelerant in the pile. It could not have acted as an accelerant in the pile. When the pile formed, there could not have been any coherent mass of thermite to burn.

The boy's an idiot, pure and simple, and the licensing authority for architechts in California should really consider pulling his ticket.

I took a look at the recently revised California Architects Practice Act (go to the pdf) and found a few interesting things. You should check out 5583 (Fraud in Practice of Architecture), 5584 (Negligence or Willful Misconduct) and 5585 (Incompetency or Recklessness). I have not looked at the AIA yet.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom