X
Slide Rulez 4 Life
- Joined
- Oct 17, 2007
- Messages
- 4,127
Hi Architect:
No sir. Building fires burn at around 800 to 1000 degrees and failure requires 2795 degrees to melt structural red-iron steel. This video does a wonderful job of showing these readers the difference. Dr. Steven Jones also does a good job here. The energy from any building fire is carried away from the fuel source to the cooler areas of the steel-frame network more quickly than the fire can cause proximal supports to reach failing temperatures. No sir. Open air fires have never caused the catastrophic failure of any steel-framed skyscraper and never will, because that is very much impossible.
GL,
Terral
Terral, look at the image below. It's from this site.
The man is forging a Katana. If you look, you will see that one end of the steel is red-hot. The other end is not. In fact, the other end is probably cool enough to touch. But it's just come out of his forge! Obviously, then, heat does not travel through steel fast enough to prevent a large temperature gradient.
Your argument of heat transferring so fast that the whole building would have had to be heated to a critical temperature is wrong.
Which means, if you consider yourself an intellectually honest person, you should remove that from your argument and by extension all points that depended upon it.
And before you go into a rand arguing how I have to post my own thesis to counter yours instead of showing you the errors in yours, let me explain something you seem to have missed:
The people on this forum are not going to let your "thesis" pass by without critically examining it. The idea of posting such a thing is to see if it stands up to scrutiny, not just to have it out there for people to read. So far, your "thesis" has failed to meet any reasonable standards of accuracy. We are pointing this out, because we do not want you wasting your time with such delusions nor influencing people who may lack the requisite knowledge to spot the areas where you are wrong.
You posted the thing, now you have to defend it.
Now, I think this off-topic drift has gone on far enough, so, with a gigantic and much-resisted lurch, I'm going to attempt to drag it back to the OP:
I don't suppose Richard Gage has stated how he came to his "dissapearing mass" conclusion, has he? Or has he just hoped nobody asks?
Last edited:

