Rhetoric and debating tactics / skills (split from: Why do anti depressants make som)

RandFan

Mormon Atheist
Joined
Dec 18, 2001
Messages
60,135
Your post that I was responding to was making assertions about the diagnostic process, was it not? My response was assuming that you were making such assertions, and was pointing out that two individuals so far have pointed out from separate perspectives (and separate capacities) that the diagnostic process is quite different than what you assert.
I apologize but I honestly don't understand your complaint. You seem to be saying that you (GreNME) are right and I (RandFan) am wrong and that's that. In other words, you believe that a.) your assertion and b.) Gurdur's assertion is enough to establish that you are correct. Is that it? If so why? Is it because 2 against 1 establishes your assertion as fact?

Because they directly contradict what you were asserting as if it were fact.
?

In all honesty I find this very odd coming from someone who posts on the JREF forum. With all due respect. Contradiction is not argument. Please see argument clinic.



No, I'm serious. If you haven't watched then watch it. Then tell me why contradiction isn't of any significant value. Please forgive me for being condescending but this is rudimentary for anyone debating at the JREF forum.

Since all you have done as well is make assertions (which you define as not arguments), I maintain that the authority I am placing to my posts is at least equal to yours.
But there is a real difference, I've made an argument for my position. I've not simply asserted something. My argument is based on skepticism and the scientific method.

Again, at the risk of being condesending.

Do you know what the scientific method is?
Do you know what skepticism is?
Do you know why this might be important as it relates to psychiatry?

Again, your assertion is incorrect. The anecdotal diagnoses I referred to in my post happened between five and ten years ago (there are two distinct dates involved), and even then some of the tests were already decades old. You are simply making claims that are not based in fact.
I'm not sure what your anecdote is supposed to prove. I use anecdotes to illustrate points. You seem to think that your anecdote proves something. You've not made that clear. What do you think your anecdote proves and why? Do you understand the limits of anecdotal evidence?

I am telling you that your assertions regarding what is involved in psychiatric diagnosis within this thread have thus far been incorrect.
Ok, but why are they incorrect? Don't you see that you are simply gainsaying?

I beg your forgiveness but I have to be honest here, this is a bit bizarre simply because I'm not used to having to point out such obvious mistakes in argument.

Gainsaying is not argument. Saing "no it's not" is not really an appropriate rebuttal. You are wrong is not an appropriate rebuttal in a skeptics forum.

So, are we going to actually have a conversation where we clarify what our points are and work from there, or is this going to escalate into a contest of who can name the most textbook fallacies in others' posts and who can claim to have more friends in the field?
I was not the one who started the appeal to authority. I only responded in kind.

Yes, I would very much like to have a productive discussion. However, it is crucial to the discussion that we avoid fallacy. If I may and at the risk of patronizing, please take a moment to read the following.

Constructing a Logical Argument

I would very much appreciate if we could avoid fallacies like appeals to authority and special pleading. Please stick just to logical argument. And by all means call me out when I engage in fallacy. Being human I'm not above making mistakes. It's not a contest to list fallacies. It is just that valid logic isn't simply the best way to arrive at the truth it's that it's the best way to be confident that you have arrived at the truth.

If I have patronized then please accept my apology but like I told you before, I don't encounter this degree of fallacy here. Usually a few reminders is enough to get most sincere participants back on track.
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry, but that last post didn't seem to have anything to do with your original statements I've taken issue with and instead are some sort of explanation of the ins-n-outs of rhetoric. You may not be meaning to come off as condescending (and somewhat ignorant), but despite your best intentions that is exactly what you are achieving. However, I am of the opinion that you deserve the benefit of the doubt that you are not intending to come across as condescending or assuming you are going to teach me about things I already know.

I tell you what: let's take a step back, deep breath, and clarify each other's points to a degree that we both agree where each other is coming from.

Is that agreeable to you? If not, feel free to let me know. However, I would like to point out that at this juncture we'd otherwise be talking right past each other.
 
I'm sorry, but that last post didn't seem to have anything to do with your original statements I've taken issue with and instead are some sort of explanation of the ins-n-outs of rhetoric. You may not be meaning to come off as condescending (and somewhat ignorant), but despite your best intentions that is exactly what you are achieving. However, I am of the opinion that you deserve the benefit of the doubt that you are not intending to come across as condescending or assuming you are going to teach me about things I already know.

I tell you what: let's take a step back, deep breath, and clarify each other's points to a degree that we both agree where each other is coming from.

Is that agreeable to you? If not, feel free to let me know. However, I would like to point out that at this juncture we'd otherwise be talking right past each other.

I really would very much like to have a discussion and avoid talking past each other. However my post was important and I don't think it helpful to simply dismiss it. The subject of the post is very much the crux of why JREF is here in the first place.

Let's do this thing right.
  • My post was not about rhetoric.
  • My post was about logically valid argument.
  1. Do you understand the difference between the two?
  2. Did you watch the argument clinic?
  3. Did you read the post about constructing a logical argument?
This isn't meant to be anything other than an attempt to move the discussion forward. It would be best if we avoid sophistry and stick to rational argument.

Fair enough?
 
What I am willing to do is address what you originally stated and explain to you why and how I felt that it was incorrect and misstating the actual psychiatric diagnosis process. What I am unwilling to do is play pedantic games using the names of logical fallacies as if they were cards to throw at the person with whom you disagree.

So, in light of this, on with the clarifications:

Back in post # 34 you state the following:

No, not really, no. That would be like a doctor observing you why you told him that your leg hurt. It's not as helpful as you might think. The doctor might have a pretty good idea that your leg is broken based on the observation but he will still send you down to get an x-ray. And trust me on this, a broken leg is far simpler than neurological/psychological pathology.

But, for the sake of argument, let's go with your premise, the doctor follows you home to observe you for two weeks... ok, well we know that doesn't happen so we will stick with the short amount of time that you are actually in the doctors office aware that you are being observed, the doctor observes your behavior, comes up with a hypothesis and falsifies it by... hmmm, I think we have found a problem with your theory. At best he/she gives you a prescription and then monitors your response to the medicine.

That really is bass ackward but sadly it's the best we have.

From what I gather of this post, you are stating that the entirety of psychiatric diagnosis consists of observation in the short time a patient is in the doctor's office and the descriptions of the problem by the patient to the doctor. It is due to this impression that I am taking exception to your posts. Before I respond, however, I would like you to clarify, in your own words and preferably in a succinct manner (for the sake of brevity, that we may get on to actually supporting our views). If the impression that was given is not indeed your view it would be helpful in progressing the discussion along toward a reasonable conclusion.
 
What I am unwilling to do is play pedantic games using the names of logical fallacies as if they were cards to throw at the person with whom you disagree.
I'm not interested in playing a pedantic game. I'd like to know if you even know what logical argument is. Why is that such a difficult question?

From what I gather of this post, you are stating that the entirety of psychiatric diagnosis consists of observation in the short time a patient is in the doctor's office and the descriptions of the problem by the patient to the doctor.
No.

I'd be happy to clarify. Could you answer my questions? Is that so difficult?
 
Last edited:
I'm not interested in playing a pedantic game. I'd like to know if you even know what logical argument is. Why is that such a difficult question?

I urge you: don't play this game. Regardless of how logical you feel you are being, you are providing a distraction from the original conversation. If you refuse to come at this with good faith and instead demand I pass some test of competency to have a conversation with you, then you will be accorded the same consideration in return and the conversation is over. This is precisely what I attempting to avoid here. This is the last time I'm going to bother addressing you on this matter.

No.

I'd be happy to clarify. Could you answer my questions? Is that so difficult?

I await your clarification.
 
I urge you: don't play this game.
Dude, they are simple questions. I could understand your response if you answered me and I continued in that vain. If continue to press you on logic and argument then it would be fair for you to accuse me of playing a game. As it is I don't even know if you understand the difference between logic and rhetoric or if you even know what a logicaly valid argument is.

Part of the problem of this discussion is that you have engaged in fallacy.

This is NOT a game and accusing me of such calls into question your acting in good faith. My question is not unfair. Look, try me. Answer the questions and see how it proceeds from there. Wouldn't that be a fair response. If I keep it up then you can say "see, you are acting in bad faith".

Just answer those two questions and I won't bring it up again. No game.

Of course, if you do engage in fallacy I'm going to call you on it. I'm sorry but this is a skeptics forum. It's important to me.

Learn the rules and follow them.

Fair enough?
 
Last edited:
BTW, what's the point if you are not going to debate in a logically valid fashion? I don't get that.
 
BTW, what's the point if you are not going to debate in a logically valid fashion? I don't get that.

I am asking you to clarify your point (look carefully and you will see which rhetorical methodology I'm applying). That is more logical than the alternative, which would be to continue under the impression that your post originally gave me. You say that your point was different, so I am giving you the benefit of the doubt and asking you to clarify. I am not implying that you think this is a game, and if you continue to take colloquialisms literally (instead of, as I am suggesting, asking for clarification) this conversation is going to continue back to its path of us speaking past each other.

So, again, I ask you: if I have misunderstood your original point as to the state of psychiatric medical diagnoses, please clarify so that I may better understand what it is you were saying instead of holding the misleading impression I got from your original post.
 
People who don't know what is happening to them. I have worked with doctors who were about 95% at making a preliminary diagnosis that would stick. I have known doctors that couldn't bat 25%.
David,

I'm curious, what is the basis for your percentages? How did you control for your own confirmation bias? Just because you think someone is 95% right isn't exactly a scientific conclusion. Sylvia Browne thinks she is right 95% of the time.

This is part of the problem. Correct me if I'm wrong but aren't you begging the question? You assume that the diagnosis is correct because the therapy seems to work, right? Isn't that circular?

Please tell me that you don't reject logical argument also.
 
I am asking you to clarify your point (look carefully and you will see which rhetorical methodology I'm applying). That is more logical than the alternative, which would be to continue under the impression that your post originally gave me. You say that your point was different, so I am giving you the benefit of the doubt and asking you to clarify. I am not implying that you think this is a game, and if you continue to take colloquialisms literally (instead of, as I am suggesting, asking for clarification) this conversation is going to continue back to its path of us speaking past each other.

So, again, I ask you: if I have misunderstood your original point as to the state of psychiatric medical diagnoses, please clarify so that I may better understand what it is you were saying instead of holding the misleading impression I got from your original post.
I'm trying I really am.

I'm not sure why you are making this so difficult. A couple of answers and we could have moved on by now and you would have your answer.

My questions aren't unfair. Look, I will make this easy. I'll reduce it to a single yes or no question and we can move on. You will either answer it or you won't. If you answer no or don't answer the question then we will part ways. But do me and yourself a favor. Don't answer yes if you really don't know.

Do you know what a logically valid argument is? Yes or no?

That's it. Answer it and we will move on. I will respond to your query in the very next post, assuming of course that your answer is yes.
 
I'm sorry, you do not get to control the conversation just because you want to make some kind of point (I've already tried to be civil).

Have a great weekend.
 
I'm sorry, you do not get to control the conversation just because you want to make some kind of point (I've already tried to be civil).

Have a great weekend.
In what why have I not been civil? I've been polite. I've not engaged in personal attacks. I've not been rude. I was sincere when I thought my suggestions were potentially patronizing and condesending and I appologized if they were.

You have engaged in fallacy and when I pointed out the importance of logical argument you said I was making a point about rhetoric. I think most would agree my concerns were valid and my question more than fair. How such a simple question could possibly control a conversation is beyond me.

Best of luck to you.
 
... You have engaged in fallacy and when I pointed out the importance of logical argument you said I was making a point about rhetoric. I think most would agree my concerns were valid and my question more than fair.

No to all of that, RandFan. The original point was you made assertions -- positive claims -- about actual clinical practice, claims which were simply untrue. Various references and first-hand experience were offered to you, you refused them.

RandFan, skepticism does not mean indulging in making claims for which you have no proof at all, as you did. And that is the source of contention here. Perhaps you would be better off learning not only a bit about psychiatry, and actual clinical practice, but also learning a good deal about skepticism and logic yourself, and why you should have proof at hand for your positive claims.
 
Last edited:
Randfan, do you think Ayn would have allowed a chump argument like this to get this far? Stop the girly boy talk and have at him.

I'm going to personally pull your Objectivist credentials if you don't.
 
No to all of that, RandFan. The original point was you made assertions -- positive claims -- about actual clinical practice, claims which were simply untrue. Various references and first-hand experience were offered to you, you refused them.

RandFan, skepticism does not mean indulging in making claims for which you have no proof at all, as you did. And that is the source of contention here. Perhaps you would be better off learning not only a bit about psychiatry, and actual clinical practice, but also learning a good deal about skepticism and logic yourself, and why you should have proof at hand for your positive claims.
I would honestly love to discuss this with you but we are just talking past each other. You clearly haven't paid any attention to anything I've said. You've not rebutted any of my arguments and have not made any of your own.

If you have something of substance to say then I would happily respond. I sincerely would like a discussion but you are going to have to avoid the fallacy and read what I write. If you want to start from the beginning that would be fine.

Let me know.
 
Randfan, do you think Ayn would have allowed a chump argument like this to get this far? Stop the girly boy talk and have at him.

I'm going to personally pull your Objectivist credentials if you don't.
:) I'm trying to be the kinder gentler RandFan.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom