smartcooky
Penultimate Amazing
1. All three bullets that injured RFK were fired 1-3 inches from the entrance holes, not 1-3 feet.
Wrong. This cannot be gleaned from the autopsy (the relevant documents that relate to RFK's three gunshot wounds are linked at the bottom of the post for anyone wishing to read them in full).
Wound 1 Entry Characteristics (refer document rfkaut2.png):
"In conjunction with the wound of entry, the right external ear show, on the posterior aspect of the helix, an irregularly fusiform zone of dark red and grey stippling about one inch (2.5cm) in greatest dimension"
Wound 2 Entry Characteristics (refer document rfkaut2.png):
There is no apparent charring or powder residue in the adjacent and subjacent tissue
Wound 3 Entry Characteristics (refer document rfkaut3.png
There is a thin marginal abrasion rim without evidence of charring or apparent residue in the adjacent skin or subjacent soft tissue.
From "Working Stiff: Two Years, 262 Bodies, and the Making of a Medical Examiner" by Judy Melinek, M.D., and T.J. Mitchell
Definitions
Fouling: Soot, residue of completely burned powder, dust-like, wipes off
Stippling (tattooing): Unburned powder and debris, causing punctate (studded with tiny holes) abrasions on target. Larger and heavier so travels farther. Does not wipe off.
Range of Fire:
Contact: muzzle of gun touches target
- Tight: fouling in tissue, muzzle stamp
- Loose: fouling on skin and in tissue, searing
Close: <15cm Stippling & Fouling
Intermediate: 15 - 75cm StipplingDistant: >75cm Neither
The description of the entry point of RFK's fatal head wound (#1) is that it shows "stippling" not "stippling and fouling". Nowhere in the autopsy is there any mention of fouling, therefore, the range of fire is not 1 inch, but is in fact 15 - 75cm
The description of the entry wound of the other two wounds (#2 and #3) is that it shows neither evidence of stippling or charring, therefore, the range is greater than 75cm.
Your assertion that all three shots were fired from less than one inch is completely debunked.
Also, your previous assertions that the fatal shot must have been fired from directly behind RFK is also wrong.
Wound 1 Anatomical Summary (refer document rfkaut1.png)
ENTRY: Right mastoid region (just below and behind the right ear)
DIRECTION: Right to left, slightly back to front upward
Slightly back to front upward means that the wound trajectory was almost but not quite transverse, certainly much, much closer to transverse than from directly behind, and on a slight upward trajectory not a steep upward trajectory. Given that Sirhan Sirhan (5ft 5in) stood a full 4" shorter than RFK (5ft 9in) this fit in well with the scenario that RFK turned away when shot at.
Your assertion that the fatal shot was fired at a steep upward angle is completely debunked.
2. The other two bullets + a bullet that traveled through RFK’s jacket was in a steep upwards trajectory, from behind.
This is debatable. Firstly, while the autopsy notes appear to show this, there is in fact a serious contradiction in them.
a. Wound 3 Anatomical Summary (refer document rfkaut1.png)
BULLET RECOVERY: .22 caliber bullet from the soft tissue of the paracervical region at level of 6th cervical vertebra
b Wound 3 Characteristics (refer document rfkaut3.png)
The wound path is directed medially to the left, superiorly and posteriorly through soft tissue of the medial portion of the axilla and soft tissue of the upper back terminating at a point at the level of the 6th thoracic vertebra.
One of these has to be wrong. C6 is just above the nape of the neck, while T6 is bang between the shoulder blades and good 8" to 10" lower. Even if we assume that C6 (the higher location for the end of the wound tract and the place where the bullet was found) is correct, it still doesn't account for observations made by eye witnesses.
Also, the entry wounds were measured at autopsy with RFKs arms down by his sides, but eye-witness accounts have him raising his right arm after the first shot, and that changes the dynamics of the situation, and the implications of the autopsy.....
... it raises the relative position of the entry wounds, and significantly lowers the upward angle of the shots.
Sirhan Sirhan was maybe three steps away. With an arm raised high in the air he surged forward, reaching for RFK, who continued to look in the opposite direction. Sirhan got off his first shot at point blank range... somewhere between 15 and 75cm ( probably closer to 15cm) He fired again as RFK threw his hands in the air and fell at the feet of Vincent DiPierro.
Your assertion shots #2 and #3 were at a steep upward angle is debatable. Your assertion that they were fired by someone other than Sirhan, standing behind RFK is completely debunked.
3. Juan Romero, the busboy who shooked RFK’s hand just before the event testified that the shots began just after when RFK continued walking facing forward in the direction of Sirhan.
That might be so, but it is clear from other witness testimony that RFK was looking away, his head turned.
Many of the the 12 eyewitnesses who were close to RFK when he was shot stated that Sirhan was anywhere from 3 to 12 feet away from RFK. However, Dan Moldea established the majority of the 12 witnesses gave estimates of muzzle distance based only on the first shot and did not see Sirhan lunging at the Senator. Vincent DiPierro clearly saw this happen as he has often stated. "It would be impossible for there to be a second gun," Di Pierro told reporter Ron Kessler in 1974, “I saw the first shot. Kennedy fell at my feet. His blood splattered on me. I had a clear view of Kennedy and Sirhan." DiPierro recently stated, “…Sirhan… was three feet away but the muzzle of the gun (in his outstretched arm) couldn’t be more than 10 to 13cm away from his head.” According to DiPierro, Sirhan managed to stretch his arm around Karl Uecker who was escorting Kennedy through the pantry. Uecker was facing away from RFK when Sirhan reached around him to place the gun at RFK’s head. This is supported by other witness statements, particularly those of Boris Yaro and Juan Romero who had been very close to RFK during the shooting. Boris Yaro stated RFK was shot at ‘point blank range.’ Romero, who had been shaking hands with RFK when the shots rang out initially said the gun was a ‘yard away’ but in a 2003 LA Times interview he said, “(Sirhan) put out his hand to the Senator’s head. . . . Then I see the guy put a bullet in the senator’s head.…”
If Di Piero is right, and Sirhan did reach around Uecker, as RFK had his head turned to his left, then that is a valid explanation for why shots seem to be coming from side to rear on not from directly in front.
The statements of Yaro, Romero and DiPierro can now be supported by a previously overlooked statement in the ‘Kensalt’ files by the wife of writer George Plimpton. Freddy Plimpton “….saw an arm go up towards Senator Kennedy’s head, but did not see a gun, heard shots and it was obvious to her that Senator Kennedy had been shot….She saw Sirhan very clearly. She saw his arm up toward Senator Kennedy’s head ….”
Source: https://historynewsnetwork.org/article/50532
Your assertion that Juan Romero testified that the shots began just after when RFK continued walking facing forward in the direction of Sirhan conflicts directly with his statements elsewhere, so that must be discounted.
4. That all witnesses reported two initial shots, a paus when Sirhan gets wrestled down on the steam table, and then all hell broke loose with shots tightly spaced while Sirhan is pressed down on said table.
Clearly not all of them, see above.
This assertion is also debunked.
For your fantasy scenario to work. RFK, Sirhan and everyone else near to them have to stand perfectly still while Sirhan looses of four shots at RFK. This clearly did not happen..
https://www.dropbox.com/s/zwx8eo1247jjo00/rfkaut1.png?raw=1
https://www.dropbox.com/s/06rx2b8cwmzh6gb/rfkaut2.png?raw=1
https://www.dropbox.com/s/pzmm9otum0lt4r3/rfkaut3.png?raw=1
