RFK Jr. suspects a second gunman killed his dad.

Since when and according to whom are Buddhist meditation concidered ”woo-woo” practiced by ”fruitcakes”?

As soon as an MD, someone I expect to ply his trade according to rigorous scientific principle, starts meddling in spiritual woo-woo, his credibility takes a big hit in my book.

There is a growing scientific consensus on its benefits to the human psyche in a number of areas, psychological well-being, being one of the more prominent. Evidenced by your ”MRI” among other techiniques of measuring psychological/neuroligical benefits from meditation/mindfulness.

Rubbish. Spirituality has ZERO basis in science.

And, how about Browns actual credentials? Did you skip over these in order do paint him as a ”fruitcake”?

If so, who is the real ”fruitcake”?

No, I read them, but for mine, they are somewhat undone by his penchant for the woo-woo.

Also, I am not seeing any of the peer reviewed research papers on Sirhan Sirhan that I asked for.

As to Brown's declaration, it makes interesting, if somewhat confused and contradictory reading. (my comments in red)

6.2 Mr. Sirhan regularly practiced self-hypnosis with fellow stable boys at the local race track where he worked. (hardly surprising then that Brown assessed him as vulnerable to hypnosis)

It was obvious to his co-workers that Mr. Sirhan’s hypnotic behavior was highly unusually. Mr. Sirhan was observed to quickly enter very deep state of hypnotic trance state and to then respond compulsively and uncritically to suggestion then behave in certain ways for which he subsequently became amnesic. (so he could have hypnotised himself into shooting RFK!)

Shortly thereafter he was hired at a high-end race track in Corona and was told that he could ride the thoroughbred horses. Shortly, thereafter he had a fall from a horse he was riding. The medical record of the hospital shows that
he was treated for a minor eye injury and discharged the same day. His mother and best friend both states that he was missing for two full weeks. Mr. Sirhan recalls being in the hospital for several weeks. (well, which is it, the same day, two weeks or several weeks. This is contradictory. Brown needs to make up his mind

Sometime thereafter he was taken to a military firing range and trained to shoot upon command at vital human organs while in an hypnotic state. (Where is the evidence that this happened. Brown was able to determine that Sirhan went to a firing range how exactly? By showing him some ink blots? This is laughable.)

On more than one occasion. I was able to find the cue to induce “range mode,” wherein upon hypnotic cue, Mr. Sirhan takes his firing stance, hypnotically hallucinates that he is shooting at circle targets at a firing range, automatically starts shooting, and subsequently is completely amnesic for the hypnotically induced behaviour. (how do we know that Sirhan wasn't recalling something he hypnotised himself to so. After all, Brown said he was very good at it, and said that Sirhan's friends practised self-hypnosis with him).

This altered personality state only occurs while Mr. Sirhan is in a hypnotic or self-hypnotic state, and only in response to certain cues. This state never spontaneously manifests. (hardly surprising)

While in this altered personality state Mr. Sirhan shows both a loss of executive control and complete amnesia. The fact that this distinctive self-state is cue specific and state-dependent is also quite unlike a psychiatric condition, namely dissociative identity disorder, wherein alter personality states manifest spontaneously, and is likely the product of coercive suggestive influence and hypnosis. (none of this is evidence of anything)

Also, you'll have to help me out here. I have read through the document a few times, but I can't seem to find the part where Brown says the CIA hypnotised Sirhan Sirhan to assassinate RFK.
 
I have already mentioned the most resent expert evaluating Sirhan’s medical case, Dr. David Brown, and his sworn declaration to Sirhan’s 2016 parole hearing.

Read it and weep: http://sirhanbsirhan.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Brown-2016-declaration.pdf

There are more experts coming to similar conclusions, but lets take them one at the time.

So how many of his professional colleagues agree with his assessment? Or do you believe if one person says something that you like it then becomes fact?

So if I come over to somebodies house and shoot them can I then insist I was hypnotized and therefore I get to go free?

lol
 
As soon as an MD,
He’s not an MD, he has a Ph.D in psychology.


someone I expect to ply his trade according to rigorous scientific principle, starts meddling in spiritual woo-woo, his credibility takes a big hit in my book.

Rubbish. Spirituality has ZERO basis in science.
1. Bhuddist meditation techiques has solid scientific support from clinical studies in mindfulness and a growing body of neorological MRI testing among other solid scientific testing: https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2011/01/eight-weeks-to-a-better-brain/

2. A persons religion/philosophy/form of spirituality has nothing to do with scientific rigor, if not clearly stated and in opposition to scientific method. Would you have reacted with the woo-smear if he was a devoted Christian?

Didn’t think so.

No, I read them, but for mine, they are somewhat undone by his penchant for the woo-woo.

Also, I am not seeing any of the peer reviewed research papers on Sirhan Sirhan that I asked for.
Moving the goal posts again are we? I stated that almost all the expertise that have examined Sirhan and/or looked in to his case are convinced of him being the victim of more or less coerced hypno programming and mind control when shooting at RFK.

I said nothing of peer reviewed scientific papers.

As to Brown's declaration, it makes interesting, if somewhat confused and contradictory reading. (my comments in red)

6.2 Mr. Sirhan regularly practiced self-hypnosis with fellow stable boys at the local race track where he worked. (hardly surprising then that Brown assessed him as vulnerable to hypnosis)

It was obvious to his co-workers that Mr. Sirhan’s hypnotic behavior was highly unusually. Mr. Sirhan was observed to quickly enter very deep state of hypnotic trance state and to then respond compulsively and uncritically to suggestion then behave in certain ways for which he subsequently became amnesic. (so he could have hypnotised himself into shooting RFK!)

Shortly thereafter he was hired at a high-end race track in Corona and was told that he could ride the thoroughbred horses. Shortly, thereafter he had a fall from a horse he was riding. The medical record of the hospital shows that
he was treated for a minor eye injury and discharged the same day. His mother and best friend both states that he was missing for two full weeks. Mr. Sirhan recalls being in the hospital for several weeks. (well, which is it, the same day, two weeks or several weeks. This is contradictory. Brown needs to make up his mind

Sometime thereafter he was taken to a military firing range and trained to shoot upon command at vital human organs while in an hypnotic state. (Where is the evidence that this happened. Brown was able to determine that Sirhan went to a firing range how exactly? By showing him some ink blots? This is laughable.)

On more than one occasion. I was able to find the cue to induce “range mode,” wherein upon hypnotic cue, Mr. Sirhan takes his firing stance, hypnotically hallucinates that he is shooting at circle targets at a firing range, automatically starts shooting, and subsequently is completely amnesic for the hypnotically induced behaviour. (how do we know that Sirhan wasn't recalling something he hypnotised himself to so. After all, Brown said he was very good at it, and said that Sirhan's friends practised self-hypnosis with him).

This altered personality state only occurs while Mr. Sirhan is in a hypnotic or self-hypnotic state, and only in response to certain cues. This state never spontaneously manifests. (hardly surprising)

While in this altered personality state Mr. Sirhan shows both a loss of executive control and complete amnesia. The fact that this distinctive self-state is cue specific and state-dependent is also quite unlike a psychiatric condition, namely dissociative identity disorder, wherein alter personality states manifest spontaneously, and is likely the product of coercive suggestive influence and hypnosis. (none of this is evidence of anything)

Also, you'll have to help me out here. I have read through the document a few times, but I can't seem to find the part where Brown says the CIA hypnotised Sirhan Sirhan to assassinate RFK.
As I said, I’m saying that almost all experts that have examined Sirhan and/or looked in to his case are convinced that he was under some sort of hypno mind control when shooting at RFK.

The declaration is a short summary and doesn’t present all the minutiae of all the investigations performed by Brown. But, I’m sure he is prepared to present this if a real investigation of the assassination is initiated or, at least an evidentiary hearing.

Remember, Sirhans ’defense’ didn’t challange any of the ’evidence’ allegedly proving Sirhans sole guilt. That is still waiting to be done, half a century later, still counting.

Here is a presentation by Brown in a new documentary. Maybe this can more fully explain his conclusions: https://youtu.be/lCU2MCxjAJ0

Here is Browns sworn declaration to the 2011 parole hearing. A bit more detailed and developed: http://sirhanbsirhan.com/dr-brown/
 
Last edited:
So how many of his professional colleagues agree with his assessment?
Almost everyone that has examined Sirhan and/or looked in to his case.


Or do you believe if one person says something that you like it then becomes fact?
Where do I state this?

So if I come over to somebodies house and shoot them can I then insist I was hypnotized and therefore I get to go free?

lol
Your ’logic’ is as impaired as your ability to read concise text. No, but if you can find support in the expertise, it certainly should be taken under consideration in a judicial process.
 
He’s not an MD, he has a Ph.D in psychology.

Makes no difference. I still expect scientific rigour

1. Bhuddist meditation techiques has solid scientific support from clinical studies in mindfulness and a growing body of neorological MRI testing among other solid scientific testing: https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2011/01/eight-weeks-to-a-better-brain/

Woo-woo, mumbo-jumbo and witch-doctory

2. A persons religion/philosophy/form of spirituality has nothing to do with scientific rigor, if not clearly stated and in opposition to scientific method. Would you have reacted with the woo-smear if he was a devoted Christian?
I would if he started confusing his Christianity with real science. He can believe what he likes, just don't try foisting it off as science... it isn't.


Moving the goal posts again are we? I stated that almost all the expertise that have examined Sirhan and/or looked in to his case are convinced of him being the victim of more or less coerced hypno programming and mind control when shooting at RFK.

They're your goalposts, I haven't moved them.

I said nothing of peer reviewed scientific papers.

I did, and I expect that as a minimum if you are going to quote scientific expertise and studies of Sirhan Sirhan as a case study. I make no apologies for setting a high bar for you, given your track record of running away from hard questions.

As I said, I’m saying that almost all experts that have examined Sirhan and/or looked in to his case are convinced that he was under some sort of hypno mind control when shooting at RFK.

These experts don't always get it right.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wo...ler-released-from-mental-health-hospital.html

Remember, Sirhans ’defense’ didn’t challange any of the ’evidence’ allegedly proving Sirhans sole guilt. That is still waiting to be done, half a century later, still counting.

I can understand why they found it difficult to overcome the fact that their client was apprehended while firing a gun at the murder victim, and that the bullets removed from that victim matched the gun their client was firing.

Yes indeed!
 
The way to prove it is to reopen the investigation and a new trial. Sirhans defence has been trying to do that for almost half a century, but to no avail. Not even an evidentiary hearing.

The problem is that he shot RFK. The other problem is that he won't allow his defense to plead the insanity defense, which is what should have happened way back when. He'd rather be thought of as a murderer than insane.


Until this happens, there will be no truth and justice in the assassination of Robert Kennedy.

Sirhan will die in prison. That is justice.

I’m here to point out all the evidence of Sirhans innocense, of a conspiracy to assassinate RFK, the conspiracy to frame him for the assassination and the ongoing conspiracy to cover it up.

And doing so well;)
 
I don’t know this doctor, but dismissing meditation as witch doctor woo woo is just ignorant. There are plenty of evidence-based studies on the benefits of meditation, and most mindfulness meditation is pretty much the same as the Buddhist stuff.

None of this establishes fantasies like programmable hypno-assassins as reality, obviously.
 
How much did the war in Vietnam cost the American taxpayers? The war in Iraq? Proven lies from the sitting adminstrations as pretext for invasions.

Trillions of hard earned tax dollars litterally blown to pieces mixed with the blood and body parts from millions of innocent women and children.

Who’s the fool? Who’s the suckers?

What does Vietnam have to do with the murder of RFK?

What does Iraq have to do with the murder of RFK (other than it's proximity to Palestine)?

Also, we didn't invade Vietnam, we were invited in, and the RVN didn't want us to leave, so how about reading a few more books?
 
I don’t know this doctor, but dismissing meditation as witch doctor woo woo is just ignorant. There are plenty of evidence-based studies on the benefits of meditation, and most mindfulness meditation is pretty much the same as the Buddhist stuff.

None of this establishes fantasies like programmable hypno-assassins as reality, obviously.

I agree with that.

Here's Daniel Brown's bio:

Dr. Daniel Brown, Ph.D.
The Center for Integrative Psychotherapy
Dr. Brown received his undergraduate degree at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst MA in molecular biology and his Ph.D. in Religion & Psychological Studies at the University of Chicago. He received a Danforth Fellowship given for promise in teaching excellence, and as part of that fellowship received specialized training in how to teach. While in graduate school he was particularly interested in interdisciplinary studies. At the University of Chicago he worked in religion & psychological studies, the history of religions, anthropology, human development and clinical psychology. Erika Fromm, Ph.D. a noted hypnoanalyst, served as his primary clinical mentor–a relationship that spanned 35 years. Dr. Brown has taught hypnotherapy for 38 years. His books on hypnosis include a standard textbook on clinical hypnosis, Hypnotherapy and Hypnoanalysis (with E. Fromm), Hypnosis and Behavioral Medicine (with E. Fromm), and Creative Mastery in Hypnosis and Hypnoanalysis, on the permissive style of hypnotherapy. While in graduate school in Chicago he commuted to the University of Wisconsin, Madison for part time studies in the Buddhist studies program, where he learned Tibetan, Buddhist Sanskrit, and Pali.

He's no slouch...but he's not an MD.

I learned a long time ago that a psychologist is not the same as a psychiatrist. To be a psychiatrist you have to have 4 years of medical school before pursuing your major. It's the difference between a guy who washes dishes and a plumber. Yes, that guy can get the plates clean, but he can't fix the faucet.

Has anyone put Sirhan through an MRI machine yet to look at his brain?

There are plenty of case studies about people who had severe personality changes after a concussion. The real tragedy of Sirhan is that he should have been rules mentally incompetent to stand trial...assuming he's not just lying, which is more likely.
 
The problem is that he shot RFK. The other problem is that he won't allow his defense to plead the insanity defense, which is what should have happened way back when. He'd rather be thought of as a murderer than insane.
Sirhan tried to fire his ’defense’ when they insisted on insanity defense, but the judge didn’t alowe it. Turns out, Sirhan was right, he is NOT a paranoid schizophrenic according to three independent doctors examining him after the trial. The last one, Brown, also remitted Sirhans test results blinded to additional reviewers and got the same result.

Sirhan was and is not mentally ill in any way. The diagnosis was contrived by his ’defense’ allegedly in order to save him from the death penalty. It didn’t work.

Sirhan will die in prison. That is justice.
Edited by Agatha: 
Edited for rule 12


Talking of, ”justice”?

And doing so well;)
Edited by Agatha: 
Edited for rule 12

You can’t buy that.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don’t know this doctor, but dismissing meditation as witch doctor woo woo is just ignorant. There are plenty of evidence-based studies on the benefits of meditation, and most mindfulness meditation is pretty much the same as the Buddhist stuff.
Ah, reason at last.

None of this establishes fantasies like programmable hypno-assassins as reality, obviously.
And back again. So, when the chief of CIA’s Project ARTICHOKE, Morse Allen, in an internal CIA memo is stating that they have successfully hypnotized two female voluntary members of their own staff to a state where one of them ’assassinates’ the other with a pistol, not remembering anything of it when out of the hypnosis, you are saying ”fantasies”? A woman assassinating her friend and colleague against her own strong convictions against killing people and using guns?

Fantasies?
 
What does Vietnam have to do with the murder of RFK?
Well, he runned his whole campaign on ending it. In comes Tricky Dick and an additional almost 30 000 young American boys killed and countless more innocent women and children in Indo-China.

What does Iraq have to do with the murder of RFK (other than it's proximity to Palestine)?
The argument was that ”conspiracy theorists” are making money on their ”conspiracy theories”. My counter argument is that no, not much, it is the conspirators that are making the real money.

Trillions of dollar, still counting.

Also, we didn't invade Vietnam, we were invited in, and the RVN didn't want us to leave, so how about reading a few more books?
Lol.
 
I love it that the government/CIA/et al are a bunch of dirty rotten murderers that can't be trusted and lie in every word...unless an internal document comes to light that bolsters a conspiratorial argument - then the gov/cia/et al are a solid gold source of information.
 
I love it that the government/CIA/et al are a bunch of dirty rotten murderers that can't be trusted and lie in every word...unless an internal document comes to light that bolsters a conspiratorial argument - then the gov/cia/et al are a solid gold source of information.
Helms ordered the illegal destruction of all documents of CIA’s illegal mind control programs.

That is a fact.

A couple of boxes of documents survived and published after FOIA’s.

That is a fact.

These documents contains information of CIA’s illegal experiments in creating Manchurian candidates for illegal assassinations of among others, American officials.

That is a fact.

Some of these experiments where reported successfull.

That is a fact.


Now, why would CIA falsify incriminating documents of its own transgressions and abuses against its own people?

Any idea?
 
I don’t know this doctor, but dismissing meditation as witch doctor woo woo is just ignorant. There are plenty of evidence-based studies on the benefits of meditation, and most mindfulness meditation is pretty much the same as the Buddhist stuff.

I have no problem with meditation, and it is not what I am dismissing as woo-woo witch doctory, its the spirituality side of what Brown touts that I dismiss.

New Age Spirituality is nothing more than religious faith dressed up in marketing clothes, and has no place in science. I rank it right there alongside the BS espoused by woomeisters such as Deepak Chopra and Wayne Dyer. They espouse (or in Dyer's case, espoused) crap indistinguishable from random babble. In fact...

"Throughout history, humans have been interacting with the infinite via chaos-driven reactions. Humankind has nothing to lose. Who are we? Where on the great mission will we be guided?

We are in the midst of a heroic condensing of non-locality that will amplify our connection to the stratosphere itself. We are at a crossroads of complexity and delusion. Reality has always been full of travellers whose brains are transformed into wisdom."


...sounds so profound doesn't it? Well, these are randomly generated phrases from here - NABS

Have fun with it.
 
Sirhan tried to fire his ’defense’ when they insisted on insanity defense, but the judge didn’t alowe it. Turns out, Sirhan was right, he is NOT a paranoid schizophrenic according to three independent doctors examining him after the trial. The last one, Brown, also remitted Sirhans test results blinded to additional reviewers and got the same result.

Sirhan was and is not mentally ill in any way. The diagnosis was contrived by his ’defense’ allegedly in order to save him from the death penalty. It didn’t work.

Brown is not an MD.

Today, Sirhan would undergo MRI's to determine the extent of his brain injury, and at the very least it could be possible that he lacked emotional control as a result of falling of the horse.


Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove response to moderated content
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Helms ordered the illegal destruction of all documents of CIA’s illegal mind control programs.

Goverments all over the world destroy documents all the time

That is a fact.

A couple of boxes of documents survived and published after FOIA’s.

And?

These documents contains information of CIA’s illegal experiments in creating Manchurian candidates for illegal assassinations of among others, American officials.

And?

Some of these experiments where reported successfull.

So?

Now, why would CIA falsify incriminating documents of its own transgressions and abuses against its own people?

Any idea?

How about, to try to prevent them falling into the hands of an enemy (or into the hands of idiot conspiracy theorists).

I am not seeing anything here that is valid evidence of the Alphabet Soup using coercive persuasion on Sirhan Sirhan to make him assassinate RFK. All I see is innuendo and unbridled speculation.

You can speculate all you like that Sirhan Sirhan was coercively persuaded to assassinate RFK, but you haven't proved it, and you can't. Your musings, inneundo and speculations are not evidence.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom