This may be "BS" situation but it did happen.
Did it, or was it just a story that McDonald cooked up that a jury believed? This was the 1800s after all, and there were still people around who believed in witches! In the 1830s a prosecution for witchcraft was commenced against a man in Fentress County, Tennessee named Stout, based upon his alleged influence over the health of a young woman.
This needs a reference. A better word may be "unwittingly" instead of "unwilling".
Derry Cooke, Certified hypnotherapist in private practice since 2015.
No. People can have their minds altered by force e.g ‘brainwashing’, indoctrination, but this is not hypnosis.
Hypnosis is a consent state which requires the hypnotic subject to give their attention to the hypnotist. Even the so-called shock inductions require a certain compliance before the response can be fired through the subject’s neurology.
Constant exposure to hypnotic recordings may have an influential effect similar to exposure to advertising. Whether it effects you or not will depend on whether you give it your attention.
As an analogy, consider the same scenario, only this time you are kidnapped, tied up and forced to listen to a genre of music you absolutely hate. How likely are you to ever become a raving fan of that style of music?
He did not learn how to shoot under hypnotism;
No-one was claiming this
he ended up being a better shot.
This is what was claimed, and it is not possible. A physical skill such as shooting, playing a sport, operating machinery etc cannot be improved through hypnosis. Hypnosis cannot turn you into a "Hail-Mary" throwing, highly accurate NFL starting quarterback even if you can already throw a football 50 yards.
This could be due to a number of factors with one of them possibly being he was not nervous due to his being under the influence. I do not the reasons for his better marksmanship but it is a matter of record that he was observed to be a better shot... after being hypnotized.
No, this has not been demonstrated, and it is not a matter of record. It was claimed, but not proven. Just because some hicktown jury accepted his story doesn't make it the truth... ever heard of Orenthal James Simpson?
So now that there is proof that an individual can shoot while under hypnosis; the claim (of hypnosis) by manifesto has a precedent.
No there is not. There is no proof that McDonald was actually hypnotised, only his claim that he was.
If you want to prove that it is possible, you are going to have to do a LOT better than referencing some newspaper reports from 120 years ago. You will need to conduct a proper controlled, scientific experiment, using circumstances that match as closely as possible to what you are trying to prove. e.g
1. Test to see if the premise, "A person may be hypnotised to kill an other individual", is valid.
a. Use a person who does not wish to participate.
b. Hypnotise them against their will.
c. Plant a post hypnotic suggestions (with a trigger) to go out shoot a particular person.
d. Test them under safe conditions to see if they do it.
2. Test to see if the premise, "A person may be hypnotised improve their skill and accuracy in shooting", is valid.
a. Use a person known to be a below average shooter.
b. Test them at a firing range.
c. Hypnotise them and plant a post hypnotic suggestion that they are a sharpshooter.
d. Bring them out of the hypnotic state and repeat the firing range test under identical conditions.
You will have to repeat both experiments several times with different subjects (to make sure its not a one-off). You will also need to repeat the test with controls such as test subjects who are willing, or who are already good shooters.
You should also perform some sort of double-blind test e.g.
a. Use subjects to whom you fully explain before hand what you are going to ask them to do.
b. Use subjects to whom you do not explain the test at all.
c. Use subjects to whom you lie about what you are going to ask them to do.
Only when I see proper study something like what I have explained above, will I accept it is possible to hypnotise an unwilling person to shoot someone, or to use hypnosis to turn someone with a poor physical skill into someone who is a expert in that skill.
And its important to remember that the technique (incorrectly) known as
brainwashing, is not the same as hypnosis. It may well be possible to condition someone to kill, but is a process that has to be carried out intensively over a long period of time. For Sirhan Sirhan to be the subject of a mind control, you would have to prove that this was done, and it would almost certainly involve large tracts of time - months on end, where no-one would know his whereabouts. Sirhan Sirhan was a regular attendee at meetings of his Rosicrucian branch for two years leading up to the assassination, and prior to that, at different times, he had been Baptist and a Seventh Day Adventist; also a regular attendee at church. Its difficult to see how he could have gone missing for the lengths of time necessary to do some sort of "Jason Bourne" style conditioning to turn him into an assassin.