Merged ReThink911 - a Richard Gage ad campaign

Well, I am glad you point out the strategy to tear down the official version. The big failing they have is that they don't create a comprehensive workable theory with a set of evidence first. This is a threefold flaw:

1. It reduces them to tactical sniping, which is more of a long fight guerrilla strategy than something they can build a critical mass of support around.
2. They are set up to fracture and fail because competing schisms will inevitably occur without a unified theory.
3. They do not have a good framework to cohesively create and validate hypotheses of what occurred, so their evidence structure is confusing and contradictory, i.e. no plane evidence vs. planes exist evidence.

Really, the whole strategy is disjointed and ad hoc.

agreed and i think that is why Gage and his group try to focus on the towers and not the entire days events.
 
agreed and i think that is why Gage and his group try to focus on the towers and not the entire days events.

But focussing on "details" and deliberately ignoring the "big picture" is a sure recipe to fracture and schism the "Movement".

ozeco47 has written a lot of posts about convergent vs. divergent thinking - the latter being a hallmark of CTists.
In the end, if the "Truth Movement" wants to replace the "Official Theory", they have to converge on a big picture theory that explains ALL the events and facts of 9/11 - that has to include what happened at the Pentagon and Shanksville.

If Gage chooses to ignore the big picture and make his only topic the "highrise building performance", a purely technical issue, he must tackle it on a technical level, especially if he claims to be representing technical professionals.

The "dumbing down" reveals that his objectives are not technical in nature, they are political; with this, he can't exclude the other events.
 
But focussing on "details" and deliberately ignoring the "big picture" is a sure recipe to fracture and schism the "Movement".

ozeco47 has written a lot of posts about convergent vs. divergent thinking - the latter being a hallmark of CTists.
In the end, if the "Truth Movement" wants to replace the "Official Theory", they have to converge on a big picture theory that explains ALL the events and facts of 9/11 - that has to include what happened at the Pentagon and Shanksville.

If Gage chooses to ignore the big picture and make his only topic the "highrise building performance", a purely technical issue, he must tackle it on a technical level, especially if he claims to be representing technical professionals.

The "dumbing down" reveals that his objectives are not technical in nature, they are political; with this, he can't exclude the other events.

agreed, and yes they are political..Gage claims he is trying to convince people to get a new investigation. That will have to be a legal/political thing to really carry any weight or have any chance of success. You would need money, subpoena power and the ability to put people under oath and that requires a legal framework, not just a meeting in a lecture hall.
Trying to tie the whole 911 event into a neat bow would take a huge amount of speculation and would invariably contain significant areas of doubt just due to the complexity of the event. No 1 theory could really eliminate 100% of that doubt in some people minds.
Reasonable doubt then must be considered. in a court case if a prosecuter was found to have withheld evidence that creates doubt until that evidence is presented and its merit weighed.
Arguably there is alot of things that have been hidden in the name of national security, others are inaccessible to Gage and crew. This leads to doubt. If you can then convince a jury/group of people that this causes reasonable doubt then they will acquit/follow.
It doesn't matter at that point if your argument was right or wrong, it matters how much doubt was introduced.
The government doesn't like conspiracy theorists because they cause alot of grief sometimes, but they also feed them. Most anti-government conspiracy theories would not exist if there was transparency.
 
Last edited:
agreed and i think that is why Gage and his group try to focus on the towers and not the entire days events.

That's not a cohesive strategy, that's an artificial partitioning of the day's events. In focusing on only one part instead of the whole, they again set up a schism and a message that is confusing to the target audience. Folks know that other events occurred that day, so leaving those events out of the theory gives rise to 'believers' creating their own theories.it also leads to theories that don't make sense when expanded to address the other events.
 
That's not a cohesive strategy, that's an artificial partitioning of the day's events. In focusing on only one part instead of the whole, they again set up a schism and a message that is confusing to the target audience. Folks know that other events occurred that day, so leaving those events out of the theory gives rise to 'believers' creating their own theories.it also leads to theories that don't make sense when expanded to address the other events.

agreed.
The basic premise being...if they can get a new investigation by casting doubt on the collapses, then the other events of the day can also be dealt with.
It's an all or nothing strategy and obviously isn't working too well depending on who you talk too.
 
let me put it this way...
the typical truther-debunker debate goes like this

Truther - here is a video showing wtc 7 and a controlled demo side by side..see the similarity?

The debunker - nonsense..didn't you read NIST?

Truther - nano thermite was found in the rubble. Here a picture and a bunch of people with letters after their name who say so.

debunker - nonsense didn't you read NIST? Didn't you go to some website called JREF and read Milletes technical paper?

Truther - here are videos and audio reports from fire fighters claiming they heard explosions and bombs going off. Heres 100 examples from the written and video record.

debunker - nonsense didn't you read NIST?


see the problem?...
I certainly do. I applaud you for characterising and explaining it. I agree with you and share the frustration implicit in your dismissal of the "attack, insult, disregard" response which dominates the typical debunker response.

And I never identified the scatter-gun blast of partial truths and irrelevant to the current topic little thought given fabricated from recycled bits of used boiler plate posts which have nothing to do with what is allegedly being rebutted. I won't even mention names - and there is at least one from each end of the polarised debate. ;)
Right or wrong, the 911 movement is actually presenting evidence that people can see and relate too.
Spot on.
The debunker is simply saying they lie, are frauds, it's nonsense and directing them to technical papers like NIST and Bazant and others...
I look forward to exchanging some thoughts - I'm short of time right now. BUT one or two "context setting factors":
1)_ The real explanatory discussions took place 2006-7-8--maybe 2009-10. It is all old hat. Few debunker side posters are true explainers - and those who are have largely moved on after having gone through the tedious explaining many times and with a lot of success.
2) what is left from both extremes are the mostly the hard liners - locked into their WW1 style trench warfare. Step back and look at this forum. 80% of the current activity is not truther v debunker it is trolling v "counter trolling". Stereotypical play and counter play with no new thoughts and certainly no new material.

lThe truther then shows why NIST Bazant and others are wrong (in their opinion)...
Correct - for the few "truthers' we see here. Remember my comments about "trolling".

...the debunker then says nonsense you're a nutcase go back to school...
Yes. Attack the person - don't even attempt explanation.

...Arguable this is a very technical issue. The collapses are not simple in the sense that these were large structures with tens of thousands of parts and connections and we don't have all the data such as the actual damage done, actual temperatures of the fires, etc
Yes - that is a big problem. The truther contributions to that being the false global insistence that "All the OCT is wrong" - they will never say what bits are wrong...more about that in another post.

...The debunkers have to rely on NIST and Bazant and the average guy has no clue what most of it is saying....
My own choice has been to never rely on NIST or Bazant - reasons later if you need them.

Then my career background was mostly water supply engineering - I may have to charge you royalties if you keep referring to my favourite bit of fun:
Again it goes back to the petition to ban dihydrogen monoxide...sounds technical..sounds bad..its added to most foods, it is in the rain and drinking water, it kills people..BAN IT!!!...

...I applaud Chris Mohr. He has probably done more to dumb down the debunker side then anyone i can think of really...he's had help..
Agreed - I comprehend and admire Chris's work. Only one aspect where I am upfront in disagreeing. Doesn't change my empathy with and admiration for his stance.
and i think he is probably doing a good job. He just isn't out there as much as Gage? [/QYUOTE] Agreed.

His message is only being seen by a select few.
Is he changing minds? i think he is. Will it matter? Who knows.
Agreed all four points. however the over-riders of "Is it enough?", "Does it matter?" etc etc

More to come....duty calls. :)
 
[My apology for the formatting error in my previous - pushed for time...:o]
agreed.
The basic premise being...if they can get a new investigation by casting doubt on the collapses, then the other events of the day can also be dealt with.
It's an all or nothing strategy and obviously isn't working too well depending on who you talk too.

That is the single point of guaranteed failure for the AE911Truth strategy. The possible genuine core of concerns lie in the political domain - anything from LIHOOI>>LIHOP>>>MIHOP. And at various organisation levels and inter-agency rivalries plus arse protection. Not an easy mess to even agree what is being discussed.

But the AE911Truth claims (and most others) are premised on technical claims. CD at WTC in the case of AE911Truth.

And those claims are easily rebutted in that sector of the population which can argue with reason based on valid evidence etc etc. And that is where the politicians and their advisors tend to be.

The winnable audience for Gage et al is at the other end of the spectrum. Those who "gut feel" their responses and do not argue with reasoning through the issues and evidence.

So Gage's winnable audience and the ones in government decision making power are on different planets. They will never meet in a conciliation setting.

Gage faced a no win situation when he defined the strategy. Option 1 - Try to get political interest in the political issues. A hard case to sell - remembering that it is asking politicians to criticise politicians and the political process. And if it is heavy enough set of issues that which side of politics will not matter. They will unite across the political divide to defend their institutions and processes.

Contrast Option 2 - if Gage targets the audience of gullibles who will accept the false technical claims and the source of gullibles will continue to decline as interest wanes. Plus he will never get enough to persuade, arguments based on false technical claims will lose anyway...etc etc

So you are right it is/was an "all or nothing strategy" and "obviously isn't working.."

The outcome was predictable -- he will be left with a small cell of loyals as he makes a living selling snake oil. And he knew that from the outset. The technical false claims including CD at WTC well and truly rebutted before he launched AE911Truth.

Sure there has been continuing discussion of CD etc on forums such as this. But only because truthers (and now the trolls) keep raising the issues and debunkers like showing how clever they are with parroted rebuttals. How long since we saw reasoned discussion of a 9/11 technical matter. On collapse explanation it is over a year. And the remnant active threads are only indirectly relevant to 9/11 -- e.g. dust studies >>> thermXte >>> the demolition which never was >>> so dust studies not relevant to 9/11 collapses. (Read carefully - the topic may may be of scientific interest - but I don't see why given no relevance to 9/11 realities.)

Bottom line is that these forums have near zero impact in the real world. All the significant technical questions answered long ago. This sub-forum on JREF would collapse in a couple of weeks if everyone stopped responding to trolling.
 
Last edited:
But focussing on "details" and deliberately ignoring the "big picture" is a sure recipe to fracture and schism the "Movement".

ozeco47 has written a lot of posts about convergent vs. divergent thinking - the latter being a hallmark of CTists.
In the end, if the "Truth Movement" wants to replace the "Official Theory", they have to converge on a big picture theory that explains ALL the events and facts of 9/11 - that has to include what happened at the Pentagon and Shanksville.

If Gage chooses to ignore the big picture and make his only topic the "highrise building performance", a purely technical issue, he must tackle it on a technical level, especially if he claims to be representing technical professionals.

The "dumbing down" reveals that his objectives are not technical in nature, they are political; with this, he can't exclude the other events.
thumbup.gif

Concisely stated - well done.


clap.gif

PS 47 Thanks for the attempted reduction of my age. BUT I will add 1 year on Saturday - overcoming part of your gift of 6 years youth. 2013 - 1941 is irresistible arithmetic :D
 
Truthers have several times, quite seriously, said that I must be a payed agent. Sometimes their main argument for this is that my arguments are so in depth and full of facts - clearly, a hobbyist couldn't dig up all that stuff!? :p


Know that one. I remember one particularly daft guy on a german board that even accused me of employing a whole team of assistants that were feeding me information just to make him look stupid. He didn't really need my help with that, though.
 
Cannot access the fundly page anymore. Looks like they moved the whole thing to rethink911.org now and the payment to Paypal. The goal has been reduced to $225,000 instead of the previous $600,000 and there are only 11 cities left. No mentioning of matching funds anymore - instead they moved what they claim to have collected already (which should include Building 7) to the 11 remaining cities to make their donation pools look half full. Wonder if anyone who donated so far will feel cheated.
 
Strrrrrraaaange! On fundly, the main page for rethink911 redirects you to the fundly homepage:
http://fundly.com/rethink911

But you can still access some sub-pages with the original data:
306 Donors
78 Teams
66 Fundraisers
576 supporters

ReThink911 is using the logo of "Remember Building 7", whose $75,000 AE has been holding since 2010 ("All contributions are 100% tax-deductible. 5% of your contribution go to Architects & Engineers for 9/11 Truth, one of Remember Building 7’s"). So presumably, RB7 has signed off on the campaign - it's their money, those 75K (or whatever the number is today).

Question? Who is responsible for RB7?
I have one insider who says "Ted Walters", has emailed Ted, and will, I hope, report back to me what Ted says. I don't know Ted. Does anyone of you?
 
Also, the sum of donations is down to $118,894 - was previously $ 315,176 - that's -196,282 :eek:
That's the 176,000 attributed to "ReThink911 Supporters" plus 20,282 from...???

Very very fishy.
I don't think anyone ever believed they had the initial $300K in hand.

The new total is likely what "Building 7" already had and what was raised in this campaign. (Likely $16/18K or so).

My feelings. The numbers raised were looking embarrassing. People were calling him on it.

Any bets he will never make an "offical" statement about this? Remember, "truther" memory is very short (when it comes to their heroes).
 
Last edited:
They also removed any reference to the previous incarnation of this campaign from their Facebook page without any explanation anywhere. Not on Facebook, not on ae911truth.org and not on rethink911.org. They apparently expect their donors and customers to simply accept this. From experience, it will probably work with many of them.

But you can still access some sub-pages with the original data:
306 Donors
78 Teams
66 Fundraisers
576 supporters


I see that Richard Gage generously donated $100 of the humble $85,000 plus rent, car and benefits he sucks out of AE911Truth every year to this noble cause of his. A true believer.
 
I see that Richard Gage generously donated $100 of the humble $85,000 plus rent, car and benefits he sucks out of AE911Truth every year to this noble cause of his. A true believer.

LOL. So did Dwain Deets. What would it take to get the tax-exempt status revoked from this scam?
 
LOL. So did Dwain Deets. What would it take to get the tax-exempt status revoked from this scam?
Very unlikely. It's more or less a church (educational foundation).

He's so small potatoes that it wouldn't be worth the effort. He's going to bury himself first.
 
And once again, AE911Truth announces the "launch" of ReThink911.

AE911Truth said:
As you will see on ReThink911.org, the campaign has decided to narrow the number of cities to eleven strategically selected markets due to the fact that a large source of pledged matching funds has not arrived as expected, and due to a revised strategy of concentrating our funds in fewer cities.


Oh really? :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom