Ed Responsible electric car driver jailed for stealing.

So self-righteousness aside, you think a night in jail was appropriate?

No one's arguing that he should be allowed to take whatever electricity he can, the issue is the arrest. I'm more concerned about the waste of resources represented by a cop with a bug up his ass than I am about plugging in a car.
Self righteousness aside?

Pointing out what I did is self-righteous?

Wow.
 
Theft is theft, but yeah, a night in jail seems ridiculous. Especially since it took them 11 days to arrest him. As others have said, a warning should have been sufficient.
 
Theft is theft, but yeah, a night in jail seems ridiculous. Especially since it took them 11 days to arrest him. As others have said, a warning should have been sufficient.

That settles it. Next time I see someone trying a grape without buying it in a fruit shop I'm dialing 911.

There are no better ways of dealing with this type of thing than tying up emergency resources.
 
That settles it. Next time I see someone trying a grape without buying it in a fruit shop I'm dialing 911.

There are no better ways of dealing with this type of thing than tying up emergency resources.

No one called 911. An officer witnessed the guy stealing. Yes a ticket and fine is probably better as a way of dealing with this but still.
 
No one called 911. An officer witnessed the guy stealing. Yes a ticket and fine is probably better as a way of dealing with this but still.
An officer witnessed the man using a publicly available power outlet at a public building that he had every right to be at. I still see no possible way that this act can be seen as theft.
 
Monkey's post, while sarcastic, actually brings up an extremely important point.

Part of my job involves inspecting the physical condition of various systems in buildings. I do a lot of work for several very large school districts and have inspected hundreds of schools. I have never seen a school building with an exterior outlet. In fact, I can not imagine why a school would even want an exterior outlet. The liability issues alone would dictate against that.

School buildings are not subject to the same codes that residences are.

Every school in town has numerous exterior outlets. They are found in the staff parking lots so that employees of the school can plug in their block heaters when it is very cold. These are areas where students are generally not expected to be, so it mitigates the danger somewhat. Of course, this is Canada, so perhaps people are not as litigious here.
 
Taking a drink is one thing, rolling up a 500 gallon tank and filling it another?

Correct. Even though a 100 mile charge appears to only take about $5 worth of electricity, there seems to be some moral relativity at work here. Would there be the same support if the guy had siphoned a gallon of gas out of the school lawnmower?
 
An officer witnessed the man using a publicly available power outlet at a public building that he had every right to be at. I still see no possible way that this act can be seen as theft.

So any exterior outlets are freely available to the public? I will have to remember that.
 
Correct. Even though a 100 mile charge appears to only take about $5 worth of electricity, there seems to be some moral relativity at work here. Would there be the same support if the guy had siphoned a gallon of gas out of the school lawnmower?

I'd still be shocked if the guy siphoned off a gallon of gas from the school lawnmower, was stopped by a police officer and was then arrested 11 days later and held overnight in jail.

IMO being held overnight should be done only if the suspect is dangerous and/or a significant flight risk.
 
So any exterior outlets are freely available to the public? I will have to remember that.

Well, on public property, yes. Do you ask before using a water-fountain at a school? Are you always sure to write a check for the electricity you used via the streetlamps lighting the sidewalks you walk on?
In a city park I do actually expect that available outlets are for public use. Moreso at a location where the outlet is accessible in a location normally used by secondary users, (the parents, as opposed to the children). Hell, I see the outlet exactly the same way I see the asphalt I park on: it's not mine specifically, but it is there for public use in many cases.
Please find any analogy where a publicly owned resource is often used by the public, but has sudden restrictions unknown to anyone which result in being detained.
 
Well, on public property, yes. Do you ask before using a water-fountain at a school? Are you always sure to write a check for the electricity you used via the streetlamps lighting the sidewalks you walk on?
In a city park I do actually expect that available outlets are for public use. Moreso at a location where the outlet is accessible in a location normally used by secondary users, (the parents, as opposed to the children). Hell, I see the outlet exactly the same way I see the asphalt I park on: it's not mine specifically, but it is there for public use in many cases.
Please find any analogy where a publicly owned resource is often used by the public, but has sudden restrictions unknown to anyone which result in being detained.

You keep saying "public property". Are school grounds where you live public property? They aren't in the USA. They are publicly owned but are private property.

Further, even if they were public property, that doesn't mean there's a free-for-all. You can't take water from the fire hydrants without permission, for instance. And if there's an electrical outlet as you'll find on some power poles, that's for the proscribed workers to use, not for you to run an extension cord to your back yard to power your electric char-be-cue. Power outlets in public parks may well be for public use. I'd expect they are. But the other uses I cite are not permitted.

Further, even in airports, if I'm using one of those sockets that you see along the floors (usually there for cleaning crew), I generally ask someone if it's okay to plug my computer in. In most cases I can't find anyone to ask, but since this is usually at a gate, I ask one of the airline staff if they know if it's okay. Usually they say, "Everyone does it, sure!" In one airport, I was told that the airport authorities were real jerks and I'd have to walk over to the public charging stations between C44 and C46. I have customers in my caffe all the time who ask for permission to recharge; never has anyone just assumed that they could do so because they're spending 50 baht on an espresso.

>>>>>>
(this portion not in response to your post)

But let's examine some of this stuff... Most of the comments are from the perp's POV, I'm bored and want to see if I can make a case for just how much embroidery this story has.

> He's a maximum 15 miles from his home at that location. Did he forget to recharge at home or does he do this regularly figuring he deserves free recharges. He certainly didn't need the power to get home if he left home charged. The Leaf gets considerably more than 30 miles on a charge.

> Why wouldn't he drive the eight blocks to the Nissan charging center a km away? Every e-car owner I know has all the charging stations within a 50 mi radius memorized, and this one's the company whose car it is. It would seem that since he was "waiting for his son", he'd have plenty of time to do it properly. He was, as he said, waiting for his son who was inside at sports practice.

> But wait... the tennis courts are outside. And this was about tennis as we learn from the police report.

> Oh, wait! Waiting for son? Why no. His son doesn't go to that school and a quick perusal of the school's website would show that they don't offer tennis as a sport, anyway. Whether he was getting lessons or not, it was Kaveh who was there to play tennis. And, in fact, the school had had a run-in with him for using the courts on school time in the past, so evidently he now plays on Saturday. Hey, it's free, just like the electricity. It's a public space. Make no never mind that he's not a resident of Chamblee and that his property taxes don't support the school.

> No one in the school to ask for permission? How's the building open, then? Timer triggered bank vault locks? If we're to believe that his son was inside (which we don't) then someone had to have let the kids in. Even if we are to believe that they were using the tennis courts without permission, which I believe, there's someone in most schools on a Saturday morning as there are all sorts of activities going on, plus custodial staff, watchmen/guards, etc...

So the story, as it's being forwarded around the world, is largely founded on bull droppings. Weasel who likes to take advantage of situations got caught. Is the penalty ridiculous? Hell, yeah. But apparently we're lucky he doesn't have Zimmerbot support or we'd be hearing that he was there saving people from burning cars.
 
You keep saying "public property". Are school grounds where you live public property? They aren't in the USA. They are publicly owned but are private property.

Further, even if they were public property, that doesn't mean there's a free-for-all. You can't take water from the fire hydrants without permission, for instance. And if there's an electrical outlet as you'll find on some power poles, that's for the proscribed workers to use, not for you to run an extension cord to your back yard to power your electric char-be-cue. Power outlets in public parks may well be for public use. I'd expect they are. But the other uses I cite are not permitted.

Further, even in airports, if I'm using one of those sockets that you see along the floors (usually there for cleaning crew), I generally ask someone if it's okay to plug my computer in. In most cases I can't find anyone to ask, but since this is usually at a gate, I ask one of the airline staff if they know if it's okay. Usually they say, "Everyone does it, sure!" In one airport, I was told that the airport authorities were real jerks and I'd have to walk over to the public charging stations between C44 and C46. I have customers in my caffe all the time who ask for permission to recharge; never has anyone just assumed that they could do so because they're spending 50 baht on an espresso.

>>>>>>
(this portion not in response to your post)

But let's examine some of this stuff... Most of the comments are from the perp's POV, I'm bored and want to see if I can make a case for just how much embroidery this story has.

> He's a maximum 15 miles from his home at that location. Did he forget to recharge at home or does he do this regularly figuring he deserves free recharges. He certainly didn't need the power to get home if he left home charged. The Leaf gets considerably more than 30 miles on a charge.

> Why wouldn't he drive the eight blocks to the Nissan charging center a km away? Every e-car owner I know has all the charging stations within a 50 mi radius memorized, and this one's the company whose car it is. It would seem that since he was "waiting for his son", he'd have plenty of time to do it properly. He was, as he said, waiting for his son who was inside at sports practice.

> But wait... the tennis courts are outside. And this was about tennis as we learn from the police report.

> Oh, wait! Waiting for son? Why no. His son doesn't go to that school and a quick perusal of the school's website would show that they don't offer tennis as a sport, anyway. Whether he was getting lessons or not, it was Kaveh who was there to play tennis. And, in fact, the school had had a run-in with him for using the courts on school time in the past, so evidently he now plays on Saturday. Hey, it's free, just like the electricity. It's a public space. Make no never mind that he's not a resident of Chamblee and that his property taxes don't support the school.

> No one in the school to ask for permission? How's the building open, then? Timer triggered bank vault locks? If we're to believe that his son was inside (which we don't) then someone had to have let the kids in. Even if we are to believe that they were using the tennis courts without permission, which I believe, there's someone in most schools on a Saturday morning as there are all sorts of activities going on, plus custodial staff, watchmen/guards, etc...

So the story, as it's being forwarded around the world, is largely founded on bull droppings. Weasel who likes to take advantage of situations got caught. Is the penalty ridiculous? Hell, yeah. But apparently we're lucky he doesn't have Zimmerbot support or we'd be hearing that he was there saving people from burning cars.

Regardless, it was not a crime worthy of being locked up.
Fine him, make him repay the debt, or just tell him not to do it again or more extreme action will be taken.

Also why call 911? And why arrest him 11 days later? It makes no damn sense.
 
Regardless, it was not a crime worthy of being locked up.

I agree, although as many have pointed out in this thread, being held overnight wasn't part of any punishment it doesn't seem a reasonable way to protect public safety.

Fine him, make him repay the debt, or just tell him not to do it again or more extreme action will be taken.

I agree.

Also why call 911? And why arrest him 11 days later? It makes no damn sense.

I don't understand the 911 call (as I pointed out upthread maybe it was because someone Middle Easter looking was fiddling around near a school with a cable.

As far as I can understand, if he hadn't been such an ass at the time then likely as not this would not have happened. It explains the situation (but does not justify it IMO)
 
Regardless, it was not a crime worthy of being locked up.
Fine him, make him repay the debt, or just tell him not to do it again or more extreme action will be taken.

Also why call 911? And why arrest him 11 days later? It makes no damn sense.

Oh, I agree that it's a ridiculous bust. I'd have made him clap the erasers after school for a week or some other minor community service.

I'm just pointing out that the self-serving nature of his "tale" is pretty obviously quite a bit fabricated. So extrapolate that to the details in the police report. He wasn't waiting in his car, he was on the tennis courts. He didn't notice the cops, his playing partner did. And how long was he actually charging his car? Twenty minutes is his version. Do we think that from the time it was plugged in, the cops came over with sirens and flashing lights, or that they likely strolled on over when they had some time?

I think the cop didn't like that the guy wasn't respecting he uniform and all apologetic and when their follow-up checks came back and they found he was already warned by the school about using the tennis courts, they decided to make an example of him.

I don't agree with it. But I understand it. It happens all the time.

My issue is that we fall for this kind of unsupported story all the time and when you do a little digging you find that it's not quite so black and white as the original teller makes it out to be. In this case, one of the headlines even reads "Father arrested for...." He played up the daddy of a student bit... and it was a lie. He was there because he found someplace he could play tennis for free (on somebody else's dime), so I think it's quite likely he has that attitude about a lot of things, including stealing electricity from someone under the guise of "oh, I just needed to top it up". Isn't he one of those guys that Rush and Hannity were warning us about.... "Where's my free stuff?"
 
I think you've misplaced a couple of zeros there. A car drawing 1000 watts from a standard 115v outlet is only 200 times more than an iPhone drawing 5 watts. It's not 20,000 times the difference.

As I noted in my first post, I was comparing a 24kWh battery in the Nissan Leaf with a 1Wh battery in a phone. Admittedly that's towards the smaller end of phone batteries, so maybe saying 10,000 would have been more accurate, but it's certainly the right order of magnitude.

Of course you're quite correct. IMO his treatment to date was certainly out of kilter with the alleged crime. The arrest warrant, being held overnight while the paperwork is processed sounds more like the way in which a dangerous suspect would be treated or someone who is a significant flight risk.

Oh, I certainly don't disagree that his treatment seems a bit over the top assuming his story is correct. But if people want to complain that something has been done wrong, I think it's important to correctly state what has actually been done.

And as Foolmewunz notes, his side doesn't seem to be the whole story. This article provides the police departments statements.
Eventually, a man on the courts told the officer that the man playing tennis with him owned the vehicle.

The officer's initial incident report gives a good indication of how difficult and argumentative the individual was to deal with.

Instead he continued being argumentative, acknowledged he did not have permission and then accused the officer of having damaged his car door. The officer told him that was not true and that the vehicle and existing damage was already on his vehicles video camera from when he drove up.

Sgt. Ford showed a photo to the school resource officer who recognized Mr. Kamooneh. Sgt Ford was further advised that Mr. Kamooneh had previously been advised he was not allowed on the school tennis courts without permission from the school.

So we have a man who uses facilities without permission after being explicitly told not to, who lies to the police, who then lies to the press, and who appears to have been aggressive and accusatory throughout the whole thing. Far from being a huge overreaction on the police's part, it appears to be a simple example of a very old rule - when you're the one in the wrong, even if only in a relatively minor way in the grand scheme of things, being a dick to the police probably isn't the best idea.
 
I think you've misplaced a couple of zeros there. A car drawing 1000 watts from a standard 115v outlet is only 200 times more than an iPhone drawing 5 watts. It's not 20,000 times the difference.

As I noted in my first post, I was comparing a 24kWh battery in the Nissan Leaf with a 1Wh battery in a phone. Admittedly that's towards the smaller end of phone batteries, so maybe saying 10,000 would have been more accurate, but it's certainly the right order of magnitude.

Of course you're quite correct. IMO his treatment to date was certainly out of kilter with the alleged crime. The arrest warrant, being held overnight while the paperwork is processed sounds more like the way in which a dangerous suspect would be treated or someone who is a significant flight risk.

Oh, I certainly don't disagree that his treatment seems a bit over the top assuming his story is correct. But if people want to complain that something has been done wrong, I think it's important to correctly state what has actually been done.

And as Foolmewunz notes, his side doesn't seem to be the whole story. This article provides the police departments statements.
Eventually, a man on the courts told the officer that the man playing tennis with him owned the vehicle.

The officer's initial incident report gives a good indication of how difficult and argumentative the individual was to deal with.

Instead he continued being argumentative, acknowledged he did not have permission and then accused the officer of having damaged his car door. The officer told him that was not true and that the vehicle and existing damage was already on his vehicles video camera from when he drove up.

Sgt. Ford showed a photo to the school resource officer who recognized Mr. Kamooneh. Sgt Ford was further advised that Mr. Kamooneh had previously been advised he was not allowed on the school tennis courts without permission from the school.

So we have a man who uses facilities without permission after being explicitly told not to, who lies to the police, who then lies to the press, and who appears to have been aggressive and accusatory throughout the whole thing. Far from being a huge overreaction on the police's part, it appears to be a simple example of a very old rule - when you're the one in the wrong, even if only in a relatively minor way in the grand scheme of things, being a dick to the police probably isn't the best idea.
 
So we have a man who uses facilities without permission after being explicitly told not to, who lies to the police, who then lies to the press, and who appears to have been aggressive and accusatory throughout the whole thing. Far from being a huge overreaction on the police's part, it appears to be a simple example of a very old rule - when you're the one in the wrong, even if only in a relatively minor way in the grand scheme of things, being a dick to the police probably isn't the best idea.

Really ? Can you please explain what part of his behaviour warrants an arrest warrant being issued 11 days after the offence and being held in custody overnight ?

If his behaviour was threatening and he presented a risk to the public then he should have been taken into custody at the scene. Arresting him 11 days later and holding him overnight smacks of retribution for his asinine behaviour to me.

I don't disagree that he should have been charged with theft, trespassing (if this was appropriate) or indeed a public disorder offence (if his behaviour warranted it), I don't understand why he was so dangerous or so much of a flight risk that he had to be held overnight.
 
Add to that the fact that your electric car likely runs on coal, if you look at the source of the electricity.
You might as well drive a steam train from the 1800's.

Well no; this is a rather common misconception. It's true that you're charging your car by plugging it into the fossil fuel grid; but you don't actually cause the utility to need to burn more fuel than it's already burning to supply the few amps you draw into your car battery. I've seen many groups with dubious intentions break down the wattage that charging an electric car costs in terms of fossil fuel emissions, and this is fine by itself - however, it becomes misleading when they try to insist that this emissions total is extra and added onto current fossil fuel emissions totals by your vehicle. It isn't. The fact that your vehicle does not produce its own emissions, on the other hand, does make a real-life impact.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom