Religious court condemns dog to stoning

Plutonium

Scholar
Joined
Jan 20, 2011
Messages
68
More from the "you couldn't make it up" department.

A Jewish rabbinical court in Jerusalem condemned a dog to death by stoning, believing it to be the reincarnation of a lawyer who insulted the judges two decades ago.

The dog had come into the court and was disturbing proceedings, so this was how the learned judges dealt with the situation. The court had cursed the lawyer to be reincarnated as a dog.

Fortunately the dog escaped before the sentence could be carried out, and the court was reported to the police by an animal welfare agency. It is not recorded what action, if any, was taken against the court.

Really, is there no limit to the bounds of religious barbarity and supersition? I reckon the sooner we all become rationalists, the better.

http://uk.news.yahoo.com/jewish-court-sentences-dog-death-stoning-170029405.html
 
I read about this on Pharyngula, and I couldn't believe it. Then I remember that these are people who think that every single thing they do, from their hairstyles to their clothing choices, to their sex lives, is monitored constantly by a god that must be obeyed. And that this world and all its inhabitants are just little pawns to the real reality, which is some big cosmic battle between good and evil. All the mundanities of life are given some supreme importance....so of course a dog wouldn't just wander into a courtroom. He must have been sent by a demon! Unless the courthouse had been on fire, in which case God sent him to alert them of the danger.

I wonder why they didn't ask the dog if a child had fallen into a well somewhere....
 
According to this link, the paper reporting on the "dog story", Maariv, has since printed a retraction and apology to Rabbi Levin (although the original story and reposts are getting so many hits on Google you have to sift through several pages to get to it). So not to worry about the reincarnated fleabitten lawyer; just another web howler run amuck, it appears. :werewolf:
 
Last edited:
"Certain schools of thought within Judaism believe in the transmigration of souls, or reincarnation."


This is a belief that is only held by the fringe. This is not part of normal Jewish teaching.
 
Oh well. As hoaxes go, that's a funny one.
 
Obviously bogus. A real lawyer wouldn't come back as a dog. A Jackal or a Hyena maybe, but not a dog...
 
Hang on.
Which part of the story is a hoax?
The stoning or the idea the dog was a reincarnated lawyer?
From the article linked above
After the original article was printed, Rabbi Levin issued a statement in which he wrote that there was no excuse for abusing animals, halachic or otherwise. He added that workers from a local animal shelter had come to collect the dog from his court room that day.
 
More from the "you couldn't make it up" department.

A Jewish rabbinical court in Jerusalem condemned a dog to death by stoning, believing it to be the reincarnation of a lawyer who insulted the judges two decades ago.

The dog had come into the court and was disturbing proceedings, so this was how the learned judges dealt with the situation. The court had cursed the lawyer to be reincarnated as a dog.

Fortunately the dog escaped before the sentence could be carried out, and the court was reported to the police by an animal welfare agency. It is not recorded what action, if any, was taken against the court.

Really, is there no limit to the bounds of religious barbarity and supersition? I reckon the sooner we all become rationalists, the better.

http://uk.news.yahoo.com/jewish-court-sentences-dog-death-stoning-170029405.html

Who determines what's rational. Moa, Stalin, and Pol Pot believed they were being rational while killing around 40 million.
 
Who determines what's rational. Moa, Stalin, and Pol Pot believed they were being rational while killing around 40 million.

This reply is completely out of proportion to the thread topic. How do you jump from stoning a dog to genocide?
 
It's half true.

The part about the rabbi ordering the dog to be stoned is true.

Other parts have been exaggerated.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom