Recovering the 18.5 Minute Gap - Can They Do It?

boloboffin

Unregistered
Joined
Aug 10, 2006
Messages
4,986
No, not the actual audio. Haldeman was also taking meticulous notes during the famous 18.5 minute gap on the tape where Nixon was discussing the Watergate break-in. Someone noticed that the notes are also missing that period of time, and they are using some new technology to perhaps discover the imprint of Haldeman's pen on the paper to figure out what's on the missing pages.

A gap in the notes matching the gap in the tape? Had no researcher, historian, or archivist noticed this before? (Apparently not.) And if there were missing pages, was there a way to find out what had once been on them? Mellinger had an idea: electrostatic detection analysis. That's a proven forensic technique used to capture indentations and impressions on a piece of paper—such as the marks made on a page in a pad by a pen writing on the pages above it. As the book Forensics Demystified describes the procedure, a sheet of paper is subjected to an electrostatic field: "Charged electrons from this static field are attracted to the damaged or impressed fibers in the paper where the indentations have been made." Then toner can be placed on the paper—or on a thin cellophane sheet—and it will adhere to areas that have indentations: "The writing becomes pronounced." Voilà, notes can return from the shredder. The original is not harmed.

Days after his eureka moment, Mellinger emailed David Paynter, the archivist in charge of the Watergate records, requesting that the Archives submit the two pages of Haldeman notes to this procedure. Attached was a nine-page analysis laying out his case. "I believe we now may have an approach to resolving the infamous 18 ½ minute gap," Mellinger wrote.

The Archives doesn't mess with its holdings lightly. But it has for years contemplated if anything could be done to bring back those 18 ½ minutes. In 2001, it established a panel to determine if new technology could salvage what had been on the erased tape. Audio experts were provided tapes with erasures similar to the Nixon gap, while the original remained safe in a vault. None of them could demonstrate that the destroyed conversation could be reclaimed. "We will continue to preserve the tape in the hopes that later generations can try again to recover this vital piece of history," then-United States archivist John Carlin said in 2003.

Now the Archives, thanks to Mellinger, is once again hopeful. After he filed his request, a document forensics expert at the Archives examined the Haldeman notes, found indented writing on the second page, and concluded that electrostatic detection analysis could work on this document, according to Paynter. So Paynter recommended to higher-ups at the Archives that the Haldeman notes be tested. At press time, Paynter was awaiting the green light from his superiors. "The reason we're going forward with this," Paynter says, "is that we've already tried with the tape itself. Here's another avenue to shed light on an important episode in history. It's very exciting."

Lots of caveats, and Mellinger discovered this while trying to prove his own hypothesis that Hunt was feeding information to Felt.

But even if all of it isn't recovered, it's possible to recover some of the information. Interesting stuff!
 
I read the article yesterday. Certainly it's interesting, but it's like Al Capone's secret vault; how about telling me if there's anything there after they've checked.

Not criticizing you, Bolo, just pointing out that this test is not very difficult and the idea that the writer's pushing the story before doing the test seems silly.
 
Plus, Nixon resigned. I don't think it's a big mystery that he ordered --or at least okayed--the Watergate break-in.
 
Oh, at this point it's really nothing more than a curiosity.

However, I'm reminded of a pair of lines I'd never heard in Back To The Future II. A lot was made of not letting people meet themselves in the past or the future. Marty's girlfriend finally ran across her older self in the future. They circled around each other, shrieked something, and fainted. Obviously the universe had not blown apart and the movie continued, so I could deal with it, but it took years and several viewing before I finally caught the lines that I had been frustrated by for so long.

The younger said, "I'm OLD!" at the same time the older said, "I'm YOUNG!"

It chaffed my hide to think I'd been stymied by something so banal. It's just as likely to be the same here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom