Recommend a Smart Phone for Me

The 4S should also cost zero as well (or $1). At least at AT&T it is.

Also, I thought I was told that the 3G is no longer available (in another thread)...

Oops, you're right. The 3GS is not available anymore - could've sworn I saw it offered on Apple and AT&T recently.

The 16 GB iPhone 4S is on AT&T for $99 with two year commitment; The 8 GB iPhone 4 is available for 99 cents with a two year commitment.

Pretty much in-line with Apple.
 
Last edited:
I am considering a smartphone myself.... it'd be my first cell phone. Can I hijack this thread for advice? :D If not, then a mod can perhaps split my post into a new thread (and I apologize), but I think that's still on-topic. Sorry if I'm wrong.

Basically, I want a smartphone, but I have some specific needs. Here are my criteria:

- It cannot be an iPhone. That's because I want to be able to test some apps and games on it and I already have access to an iPod Touch, so I want something else. So I'm going for Android unless there's an obvious rival I'm unaware of...
- If I'm to get a smartphone, I might as well get the most hi-tech one available with all the bells and whistles, right? I'm guessing that's a Samsung Galaxy 3 or a Nexus 4?
- Ironically enough, I would not be using it often. I have little use for a cell phone... except that there are cases where I could have really used one, and had problems due to not having one, so I'm making the jump.
- I don't need that many minutes per month. I think 100 or even 50 is plenty. I wouldn't talk much on it. I might text more.
- I do want to be able to use GPS, Google maps and the Internet, so I need a data-compatible plan. But it doesn't have to be a monthly plan; a per-use plan would work, since I'd use it occasionally.
- I'd mostly use it when going out of town, to look up stuff on maps or GPS, and to meet up with people from outside. So roaming, at least for for texting, is a must. I don't leave town often though but when I do, a smartphone would be immensely useful.
- Being able to store music is nice, but not a must (since I can borrow my bf's iPod as a last resort). So aiming at maybe 16 gigs.
- Camera quality is entirely optional. I don't care much for that, and any pics taken would be more of the "oh lookie here something funny" *click* kind of thing. I have a digital camera after all.
- Video quality is slightly more important, as I don't have a video camera. I sometimes take short videos (5 min long at the most) with the iPod (quality is surprisingly decent, 720p), so that'd be nice if the videos looked decent.

Right now Radioshack is having some promotion where if you get a smartphone (a limited selection) and a 3-year contract (ugh) with Virgin Mobile, the phone is "free" (I was told it's actually just paid for by being spread across those 3 years... lol), and they give a $100 store credit. It's not that bad of a deal, but the 3 year contract bothers me, and they seem to only support lower-end phones, or at least I think that's what they are based on reviews, such as the HTC Desire C or the Motorola Razr V. Am I wrong or are those phones probably not worth it?

So I'm guessing, if I'm to get a better phone, might as well forget that store credit thing, go with a Galaxy III, and go with Virgin's $20/mo or $25/mo plan.

But, who knows, maybe there are other phones/plans out there better suited to what I want? I'm a total noob when it comes to cell phones. :P I was told that the pre-paid model of the past (where unused minutes would roll over the next month instead of expire) does not exist anymore, which is too bad cause I think it'd really suit me.
I live in Montreal, FWIW, so if anyone has suggestions I'm all ears.
 
So I'm going for Android unless there's an obvious rival I'm unaware of...

Windows? Can't really say how successful it's going to be in the long term, but the Nokia Lumia is generally rated as one of the best phones available at the moment.

- If I'm to get a smartphone, I might as well get the most hi-tech one available with all the bells and whistles, right? I'm guessing that's a Samsung Galaxy 3 or a Nexus 4?

Or Galaxy Note 2. That said, even cheaper phones generally come with plenty of bells and whistles, it's mostly processing power and screen resolution that they miss out on.

- Being able to store music is nice, but not a must (since I can borrow my bf's iPod as a last resort). So aiming at maybe 16 gigs.

Samsung phones have a microSD slot, so storage will never be an issue. But everyone makes phones with over 16GB, so as long as you don't need much you shouldn't have any issues here.

- Camera quality is entirely optional. I don't care much for that, and any pics taken would be more of the "oh lookie here something funny" *click* kind of thing. I have a digital camera after all.
- Video quality is slightly more important, as I don't have a video camera. I sometimes take short videos (5 min long at the most) with the iPod (quality is surprisingly decent, 720p), so that'd be nice if the videos looked decent.

Nokia Lumia apparently has the best camera, but other than that most high end phones have pretty similar picture and video quality now.

Since you're in the wrong country I can't really comment on data plans though. Over here, you could just pick whatever phone you liked on pretty much whatever contract or pay as you go setup you liked, but I understand it's generally rather more restrictive across the pond.
 
- If I'm to get a smartphone, I might as well get the most hi-tech one available with all the bells and whistles, right? I'm guessing that's a Samsung Galaxy 3 or a Nexus 4?

I'd rule out the nexus then If you want the latest and greatest. The nexus isn't an LTE phone and though it can run at speeds approaching LTE, it's not quite the same thing. My iphone 5 on LTE totally smokes my desktop and laptop, for instance.

Also, AFAIK, the nexus is currently sold unlocked without any contract. You be paying full price (299 for 16GB and 349 for 32) and it will only run on AT&T and T-Mobile's networks.
 
Please pardon my ghastly ignorance, but... what is LTE? I saw a bunch of buzzwords around when comparing phones but obviously a lot of those I'm unfamiliar with... :o Something to do with speed or performance, I take it?
 
The 16 GB iPhone 4S is on AT&T for $99 with two year commitment; The 8 GB iPhone 4 is available for 99 cents with a two year commitment.


Maybe they were just running a special around Thanksgiving, but I'm pretty sure I saw the 4S for $1 (with a 2-year or upgrade) at one of my local AT&T stores.

I'll check again when I go back.


- Ironically enough, I would not be using it often. I have little use for a cell phone... except that there are cases where I could have really used one, and had problems due to not having one, so I'm making the jump.
- I don't need that many minutes per month. I think 100 or even 50 is plenty. I wouldn't talk much on it. I might text more.


If you are only using 100 minutes a month, Net10 would be about $7 a month, you can't beat that!! (When you first get it you have to spend about $40 to build up a bunch of days, though there is a way around that, (this is because the best deal on minutes, the 900 minute /90 day card (which I usually get for $50 plus tax) only adds 90 days, and you want to use less minutes per day than that I take it; days and minutes roll-over.)

And there is no contract. No hidden fees what-so-ever. 1 minute per 1 minute, for calls and internet use, .3 minutes for a text.

You do have to buy the phone yourself though, and the best one they are compatable with right now is the S2. ($350) But from your post I think the S2 would be just fine...

http://www.net10wireless.com/#/phones


We've had a Net10 phone as a backup phone for several years, they are a good company. It's so cheap per month we don't even notice it.

Because you are getting a smart phone, and if you decide to go with a pay as you go like this, make sure you disable the internet when you aren't using it!! We hasn't used a smart phone with Net10 yet, but from what I hear they make this very clear and easy to do.
 

Back
Top Bottom