Questioninggeller
Illuminator
- Joined
- May 11, 2002
- Messages
- 3,048
Creationist, and Kirk Cameron sidekick, Ray Comfort is giving away 100,000 copies of Charles Darwin's Origins of Species at schools around the United States in November 2009. But a few important details:
1) Comfort's version of Origins is incomplete. Comfort's first pressing excludes four chapters that discuss the evidence of evolution. The second pressing is still missing diagrams and epigraphs, which Darwin used to detail his arguments.
2) Then there is Comfort's 50 page creationist introduction. The introduction, described by Dr. Scott, as "a hopeless mess of long-ago-refuted creationist arguments, teeming with misinformation about the science of evolution, populated by legions of strawmen, and exhibiting what can be charitably described as muddled thinking." (For example, Comfort believes evolution claims male and female evolved separately.)
3) Aside from the creationism in Comfort's introduction, Scott did say Comfort's "first eight pages of the introduction, which is a reasonably accurate, if derivative, sketch of Darwin's life." Now it turns out Comfort plagiarized that part. AIGBusted reports:
See more examples of plagiarism in that link.
So Comfort raised hundreds of thousands of dollars to re-print Darwin's book in order for Comfort, who has no college education, to write a creationist introduction. He then plagiarized basic facts about Darwin's life and misrepresented science in that introduction. I wonder if Comfort really thinks that helps his cause?
1) Comfort's version of Origins is incomplete. Comfort's first pressing excludes four chapters that discuss the evidence of evolution. The second pressing is still missing diagrams and epigraphs, which Darwin used to detail his arguments.
2) Then there is Comfort's 50 page creationist introduction. The introduction, described by Dr. Scott, as "a hopeless mess of long-ago-refuted creationist arguments, teeming with misinformation about the science of evolution, populated by legions of strawmen, and exhibiting what can be charitably described as muddled thinking." (For example, Comfort believes evolution claims male and female evolved separately.)
3) Aside from the creationism in Comfort's introduction, Scott did say Comfort's "first eight pages of the introduction, which is a reasonably accurate, if derivative, sketch of Darwin's life." Now it turns out Comfort plagiarized that part. AIGBusted reports:
Ray Comfort: Plagiarist
Wednesday, November 4, 2009
I recently had a look at Ray Comfort's "special introduction" to Origin of Species, and, I got to thinking that the first part of the introduction sounded a little too smart to be Ray Comfort. So I did some googling and found that Ray's introduction looks suspiciously like "A Brief History of Charles Darwin" by Dr. Stan Guffey. Here are some quotes from Ray's intro followed by their parallels in Stan Guffey's work:
...
Ray Comfort said:On returning to England in 1836, Darwin set to work examining and disseminating the extensive collection of specimens he acquired during the voyage. He quickly established a reputation as an accomplished naturalist on the London scene. In 1839 he married his cousin, Emma Wedgwood. That same year he published his journal of the voyage of the Beagle, which brought him immediate celebrity among London’s intellectuals. In 1842 he and Emma moved to Down House in Kent. It was there that she bore ten children and she and Charles spent the rest of their lives.
andStan Guffey said:On returning to England in 1836, Darwin set to work examining and disseminating the extensive collection of natural history specimens acquired during the voyage. He quickly established a reputation as an accomplished naturalist on the London scene. In 1839 he married Emma Wedgwood, and saw his journal of the voyage of the Beagle published. In 1842 he and Emma moved to Downe house, Kent where Emma would bear 10 children and she and he would live for the rest of their lives.
Ray Comfort said:During his great adventure as the Beagle’s naturalist, Darwin had studied certain aspects of the morphology and biogeography of the many species of plants and animals that he had observed. He eventually concluded that species exhibited varying degrees of similarity because they were to varying degrees related.
...Stan Guffey said:On his great adventure as the Beagleʼs naturalist Darwin had noted and begun to ponder certain aspects of the morphology and biogeography of the many species of plants and animals that he had observed. In particular, he had begun to explore the possibility, and eventually concluded, that species exhibited varying degrees of similarity because they are to varying degrees related.
See more examples of plagiarism in that link.
So Comfort raised hundreds of thousands of dollars to re-print Darwin's book in order for Comfort, who has no college education, to write a creationist introduction. He then plagiarized basic facts about Darwin's life and misrepresented science in that introduction. I wonder if Comfort really thinks that helps his cause?