Quotes Concerning the Foundation of the US as a Christian Nation

Nyarlathotep said:


In fact, many of them aren't filed by us mean ol' atheists thrying to keep religion out of governemnt, they are often filed by emembers of one religion who feel that their rights ar being trampled upon. Fundies often conveniently forget this fact when they go on their (untrue) tirades about how we atheists are trying to supress all mention of God in public.

Yes, but that's not the real point.

Luke, dude, sorry, but on this one you're just wrong. The history is clear. The history of the founding fathers and their participation in the "Enlightenment" movement is quite clear.
 
I just got through re-reading John Locke's second treatise of goverment. It surprised me how much of his rationale is rooted on his biblical interpretation. He however did not support theocracy or state religion.
 
jj said:


Yes, but that's not the real point.

Luke, dude, sorry, but on this one you're just wrong. The history is clear. The history of the founding fathers and their participation in the "Enlightenment" movement is quite clear.

It depends on which founding father you are talking about. Some were deists, deism being one of the ideals of the Enlightenment, and some where Christian. These religious beliefs influenced their political beliefs.

And just to complete a thought I meant to complete earlier, the whole idea of separation of church and state was not to preserve the state, but to preserve the church.
 
I am curious to know what motive is behind trying to prove or disprove the U.S. has a Christian foundation.

What fears are at work?

edited to add: My personal opinion is that there is a Christian "pillar" in the foundation of the U.S., not that it is the sole foundation. As has been pointed out, there were non-Christian founding fathers. So perhaps it would be more accurate to say there is a foundation based on the belief in a "higher power" which guided the moral and political character of the U.S.

I think there is an important difference between the influence of a belief and the patronage (for want of a better word at the moment) of a belief.

I would think that since Christians believe we are all sinners, that even a State which sponsors and is run by Christians is going to commit the occasional boneheaded move or outright atrocity. And these errors would smear every Christian on the planet the way the atrocities committed by Muslim States smears every Muslim on the planet today. Most Muslims are innocent of these atrocities, and are unjustly marred, and that is why I say a Christian religion does not have the right to assume State power and hold every Christian around the world hostage that way.

There are enough examples of Christian powers run amok. The Inquisition comes to mind, as does the Children's Crusade.

It is also worth remembering our Christian forefathers f**cked over the red man, and went out of their way to go to Africa to bring the black man here so they could ◊◊◊◊ him over, too. Do we really want such things to be remembered as perpetrated by a "Christian America?" It's bad enough they are remembered as perpetrated by America.

The answer to the Muslim Nations is not to respond with an equal wrong and imperil not only the good name of America but the Church, too. The answer is to lay back and let them learn the lessons Europe and the U.S. learned the same hard way.
 
I'm currently reading, but not fininshed, a printout from the rationalrevolution.net website entitled, "History of the Separation of Church and State in America." On page 8 Thomas Jefferson, in a speech to the Virginia Baptists in 1808, states, "State churches that use government power to support themselves and force their views on persons of other faiths undermine all our civil rights." This sure seems applicable today.
As a Xian myself, it saddens me that people of my own faith don't have a view of the big picture, and they use politics to "strong-arm" others who don't share their views.
 
Tony said:
Does anyone know of a website that has quotes by the founding fathers that would debunk the alleged christian foundation of the US?
What does the Constitution say?
1st Amendment: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion,.....

10th Amendment: The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.
The power to regulate religion was a power granted to the States. Most States wrote a separation of church and state clause in to their state constitutions. Massachuset was the last State to give up its state sponsored religion in 1833. Since each State was free to declare a state religion, anyone of the 13 states could have declared Islam, Judaism, Paganism or even Atheism as their state religion. America was settled by the Christian nations of Europe, there was little chance of that happening.

Actually we were founded on the principles and philosophy of Greece and Rome and not the Bible. What makes us a Christian nations is, we have tempered the harsh law of man with mercy and compassion as preached by Jesus Christ, Lord and Savior, in the New Testament.
 
The American heresy

Of some relevence to this discussion, I picked up a book in the local secondhand shop a few weeks back called "The American Heresy", written by one Christopher Hollis in 1927.

Oddly, just inside the cover is a picture of Thomas Jefferson but the opening chapter begins:

A European returns from America witht he memory, no doubt, of a thousand kindnesses received and a thousand friends made, but also, if he is honest, with the feeling, perhaps defined, perhaps undefined, that here is a continent gone wrong.

He goes on to talk about "a jumble of bunkum metaphysics about One Man One Vote" and remarks that "[The American] has allowed a tenth-rate, sectarian, police-regulation to be imported into his constitution" - referring to seperation of church and state.

(Incidentally, on the very second page he talks about the Scopes "monkey trial". From the author's POV, apparently neither side of the debate was in the right, biblically speaking and both were equally heretical. The book now has pride of place in my collection of literary oddities next to a delightful collection of condescending and blatently racist anecdotes about an Englishman's vistit to "the Orient" in the latter part of the 19th century.)

Anyway, what I aimed to demonstrate by bringing this up was that, in order to decide whether or not the US was a nation based on Christian foundations, you would first have to decide exactly which particular division of Christianity's foundations you were referring to.

The foundations of any one division's beliefs are almost certainly the antitheses of those of at least a half-dozen others.

IMO, therefore, saying "Christian Foundations" covers such a multitiude and such very wide variety of sins as to be almost completely meaningless.

I would use this as an argument against anyone defending the notion in question. No doubt they will descend into some babble about common core beliefs or some such but you should be able to knock off any specific references with counter-examples really quite easily.

Graham
 
Luke T. said:

edited to add: My personal opinion is that there is a Christian "pillar" in the foundation of the U.S., not that it is the sole foundation.

Only a few founding fathers were the true architects of the articles of confederation and/or the constitution.

Yes, christianity philosophy was the foundation of John Locke's theories of government. So yes, the government was partially founded on christian philosophy (note I didn't say principle).

However, america was not founded as a christian nation.

If you read Locke's writing closely, you will notice his christian philosophy is just that. He extrapolates rights and duties and from biblical interpretation. On other words, he didn't base the democratic republic on the ten commandments; he based on a higher extrapolation of the passages that supported his viewpoint.

Ever notice that there are christian socialists who believe the bible also supports their point of view?

The next time someone wants to put the ten commandment in the courtroom. Instead demand they post 10 quotes from the Federalist Papers or the Second Treatise of Government. How about Common Sense? Or hey, maybe the goold ole Bill of Rights will do.

That some founding fathers were christian does make it tasteful to honor their faith since its highly secularized these days anyway ("who doesnt know at least 3 of the ten commandments?"), however there are more relevant documents you be putting up excerpts of in a courtroom.
 
Re: The American heresy

Graham said:


Anyway, what I aimed to demonstrate by bringing this up was that, in order to decide whether or not the US was a nation based on Christian foundations, you would first have to decide exactly which particular division of Christianity's foundations you were referring to.

The foundations of any one division's beliefs are almost certainly the antitheses of those of at least a half-dozen others.

IMO, therefore, saying "Christian Foundations" covers such a multitiude and such very wide variety of sins as to be almost completely meaningless.

Graham

Excellent point. Luke T likes to reference the puritans (I guess they were the first Europeans to seriously colonize so they get "firsties"?), but in fact the puritans were not only Christian, but highly intolerant of other religions, including just about every other variety of Christianity. Guess we need to start cracking down on all the heretics, if we're going to stay true to the countries "foundations".
 
Luke T. said:
My personal opinion is that there is a Christian "pillar" in the foundation of the U.S., not that it is the sole foundation. As has been pointed out, there were non-Christian founding fathers. So perhaps it would be more accurate to say there is a foundation based on the belief in a "higher power" which guided the moral and political character of the U.S.

Which goes to support the statement that this is not a Christian Nation, or nation founded in Chrisitanity. Because then if any of the founding fathers was an atheist then you could say this is an Atheist Nation, or founded on Atheism with the same justifications as saying it is a christian nation. A Deist Nation, a Rational Nation, a European Nation, or whatever other classification you can choose to attribute to some of the FF.
 
There was a lot of flight from established religion in American history--first from Europe, later from settled areas (Roger Williams, Mormons, Jim Jones, &al.).
 
Re: Re: The American heresy

Renfield said:
Excellent point. Luke T likes to reference the puritans (I guess they were the first Europeans to seriously colonize so they get "firsties"?), but in fact the puritans were not only Christian, but highly intolerant of other religions, including just about every other variety of Christianity. Guess we need to start cracking down on all the heretics, if we're going to stay true to the countries "foundations".

Many of the people who insist that this is a Christian nation want to do exactly that.
 
Just cause the founders happen to be Christains doesnt mean its a christian nation. They were also European white males. Would that then make aparthied, sexism, and zenophobia OK??? After all the country was founded as a white male nation.




Notice they use the broad term "christian", even though there are many subsets of christianty. You never hear "Prodestant Nation" or "Catholic Nation"
 
I was going to start a thread on this subject, but then I did a search and found this one. Since it never even made it into page 2, maybe I can be allowed to resurrect it long enough to add my thoughts, and then if it dies again, it dies with one more post than it had the first time.

This is not a Christian nation, and it doesn't matter if all of the founding fathers were Christians. All of the founding fathers were male, and white, and this is not a white male nation.

The founding principles of this nation came more from the ancient Greeks by way of the Renaissance and the Enlightenment than from ideas espoused in the New Testament. The Greeks gave us constitutional government; Jesus never mentions it. They gave us the rights of the individual, including freedom of expression, freedom of assembly, and freedom of religion. Separation of political and religious authority was a Greek idea before Christ expressed it. By developing the idea that all men were equal before the law, the Greeks provided the true foundation for Western democracy. It was the Greeks who pioneered civilian control of the military. Greek institutions and practices were unique in the ancient world in the protection they afforded to individual property rights. The political independence of Greece's city-states is the forerunner of the Republican system which has been our model since the nation was founded. Free scientific inquiry also has its roots in ancient Greece.

I confess, I'm not familiar with how Locke may have derived his theories from Christian doctrine, but I suspect they were less derived than retro-fitted, and that the principles he espoused owe more to Greece than to Galilee.

This is just a small bag of ideas. Rather than accepting arguments from authority, depending on quotes (whether from founding fathers, Supreme Court justices, or Hollywood heartthrobs) making pronouncements that this is or is not a Christian nation, I think it would be useful to press the claimants to state exactly WHICH foundational principles were derived from Biblical sources (chapter and verse). I don't expect the resulting list would be a long one.
 
My favorite quotation of the Founding Fathers is found in the Constitution, Article VI, Section 3:

...no religious Test shall ever be required as a Qualification to any Office or public Trust under the United States.

My second favorite quotation from the Founding Fathers is from the First Amendment of the Bill of Rights:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof;...

I don't think it could be much more clearer than that.
 
My favorite quotation of the Founding Fathers is found in the Constitution, Article VI, Section 3:



My second favorite quotation from the Founding Fathers is from the First Amendment of the Bill of Rights:

I don't think it could be much more clearer than that.
1. I think you meant "much clearer than that." Redundancy for fifty, Alex.

2. Please demonstrate where Congress has established a national religion, or prohibited the free exercise of religion. (Freedom of religion/worship and freedom from compulsory religion all in one sentence. Nice writing, as I see it.)

Merry Christmas. ;)

DR
 
2. Please demonstrate where Congress has established a national religion,


They don't have to actually _establish_ a "national" religion. The constitution forbids _respecting_ the establishment of _religion_. That is clearly NOT the same as "establishing a national religion." Two aspects:

1) "respecting the establishment" =/= establish
2) religion =/= "a religion"

Now, do you want an example of "respecting" the establishement of religion? How about passing a law to add "under God" to the pledge of Allegiance as they did in the 1950s? It cannot be denied that the purpose of that was to establish that the US was a religious state. That is respecting the establishment of religion.

Of course, from that is the 14th amendment that applies the federal restrictions to the rest of the government.
 
Now, do you want an example of "respecting" the establishement of religion? How about passing a law to add "under God" to the pledge of Allegiance as they did in the 1950s? It cannot be denied that the purpose of that was to establish that the US was a religious state.
Really? Intersting thought, that, the assertion that the purpose was to establish the US as a religous state, rather than to tap the sentiments of a vast majority of the populace of said state. CT much? Or, do you have a source, or a reference work, I can wander through?
That is respecting the establishment of religion.
That is indeed the grounds for the challenge.
Of course, from that is the 14th amendment that applies the federal restrictions to the rest of the government.
I'll quibble on your word choice, but yeah, generally so. The opener was an explicit move toward federal authority at the expense of state's rights, which seems to have been rooted in ensuring slavery, and the societal wreckage floating in the wake of that institution's demise, was stamped out.

Needless to say, it was some decades before the loatter aim was even partly achieved.

Equal protection under the law was a significant amendment, and improvement, on the original document.
Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside. No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.



Comment: You are using, as I understand it, "respecting" as "regarding." Close? That is how I read that usage.

DR
 
Last edited:
Really? Intersting thought, that, the assertion that the purpose was to establish the US as a religous state, rather than to tap the sentiments of a vast majority of the populace of said state.

I think we have different usages of the word "establish" here. It was certainly not an attempt to create a religious state. However, it was clearly an attempt to declare to the world that the US IS a religious state, as opposed to those godless commies.

see http://www.religioustolerance.org/nat_pled1.htm

In 1953, the Roman Catholic men's group, the Knights of Columbus mounted a campaign to add the words "under God" to the Pledge. The nation was suffering through the height of the cold war, and the McCarthy communist witch hunt. Partly in reaction to these factors, a reported 15 resolutions were initiated in Congress to change the pledge. They got nowhere until Rev. George Docherty (1911 - ) preached a sermon that was attended by President Eisenhower and the national press corps on 1954-FEB-7. His sermon said in part: "Apart from the mention of the phrase 'the United States of America,' it could be the pledge of any republic. In fact, I could hear little Muscovites repeat a similar pledge to their hammer-and-sickle flag in Moscow." After the service, President Eisenhower said that he agreed with the sermon. In the following weeks, the news spread, and public opinion grew. Three days later, Senator Homer Ferguson, (R-MI), sponsored a bill to add God to the Pledge. It was approved as a joint resolution 1954-JUN-8. It was signed into law on Flag Day, JUN-14. President Eisenhower said at the time: "From this day forward, the millions of our schoolchildren will daily proclaim in every city and town, every village and rural schoolhouse, the dedication of our nation and our people to the Almighty." 4 With the addition of "under God" to the Pledge, it became both "a patriotic oath and a public prayer...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom