The American heresy
Of some relevence to this discussion, I picked up a book in the local secondhand shop a few weeks back called "The American Heresy", written by one Christopher Hollis in 1927.
Oddly, just inside the cover is a picture of Thomas Jefferson but the opening chapter begins:
A European returns from America witht he memory, no doubt, of a thousand kindnesses received and a thousand friends made, but also, if he is honest, with the feeling, perhaps defined, perhaps undefined, that here is a continent gone wrong.
He goes on to talk about "a jumble of bunkum metaphysics about One Man One Vote" and remarks that "[The American] has allowed a tenth-rate, sectarian, police-regulation to be imported into his constitution" - referring to seperation of church and state.
(Incidentally, on the very second page he talks about the Scopes "monkey trial". From the author's POV, apparently neither side of the debate was in the right, biblically speaking and both were equally heretical. The book now has pride of place in my collection of literary oddities next to a delightful collection of condescending and blatently racist anecdotes about an Englishman's vistit to "the Orient" in the latter part of the 19th century.)
Anyway, what I aimed to demonstrate by bringing this up was that, in order to decide whether or not the US was a nation based on Christian foundations, you would first have to decide
exactly which particular division of Christianity's foundations you were referring to.
The foundations of any one division's beliefs are almost certainly the antitheses of those of at least a half-dozen others.
IMO, therefore, saying "Christian Foundations" covers such a multitiude and such very wide variety of sins as to be almost completely meaningless.
I would use this as an argument against anyone defending the notion in question. No doubt they will descend into some babble about common core beliefs or some such but you should be able to knock off any specific references with counter-examples really quite easily.
Graham