Questions

I suppose by "conspiracy theorist" you are referring to anyone who questions the official story, anyone who considers both the official story, as well as alternative theories.

This labeling and invective (not that the OP has such a tone) really degrades the level of discourse on jref.

Like many who post in this forum, I consider myself a skeptic, a critical thinker who strives for objectivity.

I think we landed on the moon, I don't believe aliens ever visited us, and I don't know that much about the JFK assassination so I don't have an opinion. I don't even have an opinion about global warming because I simply haven't spent enough time researching it.

If the question is what do people hope to get out of researching 9/11, we might start with proof that Flights 93 and 77 crashed in their respective crash zones. Without serially charged plane parts, you do not have proof that the "evidence" at those sites corresponds to the flights. Planes are not absorbed by dirt, and they are not vaporized by crashing into steel reinforced concrete. Add to that the "phenomena" of WTC 7 and what you have is curiosity.

It has nothing to do with fame, or peer acceptance. You people are really stretching. It's not a crusade for a lot of us. It's simply a scientific research journey, and a damn complex one at that.

I could give a damn about space beams or holocaust denial. I'm much more interested in official explanations and how they stack up to science.
 
If the question is what do people hope to get out of researching 9/11, we might start with proof that Flights 93 and 77 crashed in their respective crash zones.


What proof do you have that ANY plane has ever crashed?

I'm much more interested in official explanations and how they stack up to science.


Well, then it might interest you to know that the overwhelming majority of the scientific community (especially those in the required fields of discipline) agree with the official story.
 
I know this will sound like a weird answer to the OP, but I really don't believe that the majority of them have thought things all the way through as far as why they do things. They may take certain "actions" without regard to the consequences of those actions. It is sort of a pack mentality thing, where one of them starts yelling about something, so they all start yelling the same thing. What may come as a result of their yelling, intended or otherwise, just doesn't register with a lot of them.

Oh, and welcome!

Thank you for the welcome Hokulele!

You very well may be right, but I thought that at some point that someone had to ask themselves "Why am I doing this?" I mean, for your average person posting on the LC forums, the answer may be as simple as "to fit into a group," but that explanation I don't think really covers the people that have been in the group for a while. IMHO, of course.
 
If the question is what do people hope to get out of researching 9/11, we might start with proof that Flights 93 and 77 crashed in their respective crash zones.

You consider yourself a critical thinker who believes in science yet you doubt that (with the exception of a small child) all the victims of Flight 93 were 100% positively identified on a DNA basis? Is this correct?[/quote]
 
I could give a damn about space beams or holocaust denial. I'm much more interested in official explanations and how they stack up to science.
1. "Couldn't give a damn." Giving a damn means you actually care. Sorry, one of my pet peeves.

2. You say you're interested in how science gets stacked next to the official story as if this is some radical right-wing board instead of one that relies on science and logic. If the numbers didn't add up, the people here would be the first to question it. Unfortunately for the movement, science stacks up a heck of a lot better to the "official version" than it does against ANY 9/11 conspiracy theory, or even any element of a 9/11 conspiracy theory.
 
I suppose by "conspiracy theorist" you are referring to anyone who questions the official story, anyone who considers both the official story, as well as alternative theories.

This labeling and invective (not that the OP has such a tone) really degrades the level of discourse on jref.

Sorry, I really didn't mean to offend anyone with that label. In the future, I will try to avoid using it.

Like many who post in this forum, I consider myself a skeptic, a critical thinker who strives for objectivity.

I think we landed on the moon, I don't believe aliens ever visited us, and I don't know that much about the JFK assassination so I don't have an opinion. I don't even have an opinion about global warming because I simply haven't spent enough time researching it.

Pretty much the same here.

If the question is what do people hope to get out of researching 9/11, we might start with proof that Flights 93 and 77 crashed in their respective crash zones. Without serially charged plane parts, you do not have proof that the "evidence" at those sites corresponds to the flights. Planes are not absorbed by dirt, and they are not vaporized by crashing into steel reinforced concrete. Add to that the "phenomena" of WTC 7 and what you have is curiosity.

It has nothing to do with fame, or peer acceptance. You people are really stretching. It's not a crusade for a lot of us. It's simply a scientific research journey, and a damn complex one at that.

I could give a damn about space beams or holocaust denial. I'm much more interested in official explanations and how they stack up to science.

I understand and respect that, but I wish to know (at least for now) is why do you reject the current investigation? There has to be a reason to reject the generally accepted evidence, even if the reason is as simple as "I just don't think the investigative bodies are capable of studying an event as large as 9/11." If you hadn't really thought about it quite that way, that's fine, too.
 
right, then learn how to apply scientific principles. Vaporized? Really?

I suppose by "conspiracy theorist" you are referring to anyone who questions the official story, anyone who considers both the official story, as well as alternative theories.

Like many who post in this forum, I consider myself a skeptic, a critical thinker who strives for objectivity.

If the question is what do people hope to get out of researching 9/11, we might start with proof that Flights 93 and 77 crashed in their respective crash zones. Without serially charged plane parts, you do not have proof that the "evidence" at those sites corresponds to the flights. Planes are not absorbed by dirt, and they are not vaporized by crashing into steel reinforced concrete. Add to that the "phenomena" of WTC 7 and what you have is curiosity.

It has nothing to do with fame, or peer acceptance. You people are really stretching. It's not a crusade for a lot of us. It's simply a scientific research journey, and a damn complex one at that.

I could give a damn about space beams or holocaust denial. I'm much more interested in official explanations and how they stack up to science.
This is funny stuff. If it was a scientific journey you would find an expert in aircraft accident investigation who would tell you 11, 175, 77, and 93 are all exactly what a crash at 470, 590, 536, and 600 mph look like hitting a building, a building, a concrete building, and dirt. That is what someone interested in science would do, ask an expert. (The plane impacts on 9/11 were just what they should look like. I am an expert in accident investigation. Now find another one, or two, or get some education quick)

Or the person would, if really into scientific stuff, study physics and see the energy involved in the impact was what we saw on 9/11. They would seek out the years of study to learn physics and the math to learn to understand. But no, they make up nonsense like vaporized planes, like in this post. They also post a cover story saying they are not CT minded people, they believe we went to the moon, etc, hiding behind some veiled attempt at pretending to be scientific while just pushing an agenda of fraud.

People looking for scientific proof do not ignore fire damaged steel. They do not grasp on to unrelated damaged out of control fire ridden buildings and say see an "inside job".

If one wants to see how 9/11 stacks up to science they need to learn how to apply physics and math, or find real facts to support the idiot ideas of "Planes are not absorbed by dirt, and they are not vaporized by crashing into steel reinforced concrete". These are typical statements by 9/11 truth followers who are to challenged to get the needed skills to think logically or apply scientific principles. But they sure do latch on to real crazy ideas.
 
Sorry, I really didn't mean to offend anyone with that label. In the future, I will try to avoid using it.



Pretty much the same here.



I understand and respect that, but I wish to know (at least for now) is why do you reject the current investigation? There has to be a reason to reject the generally accepted evidence, even if the reason is as simple as "I just don't think the investigative bodies are capable of studying an event as large as 9/11." If you hadn't really thought about it quite that way, that's fine, too.

That's a fair question and I appreciate the civility.

I was just like you or anyone else after 9/11. I believed the official story, but even later that day when I talked to the friends and family who live and work in NYC (I was born in Manhasset and grew up in Queens and Jersey, went to college in NY), I was very curious how the operation was pulled off. What an audacious operation. I figured the story would eventually be told.

I had no reason to doubt the official story and even rejected the first hints of conspiracy theories.

First, a very close friend of mine who lives in Manhattan and filmed the towers burning from the roof of the building he was editing in, asked me to check out a website about Flight 93. It raised many significant questions.

Then after the 2004 election a DVD was floating around and the drummer of the band I was playing in at the time asked me to watch it. I looked at the cover and said, I'm not interested in internet conspiracy theories. No, he said watch it. The four hour plus DVD raised many significant questions.

I immediately read the 9/11 Commission Report and anything I could get my hands on, both official and alternative explanations. The official story changes frequently, is not supported by evidence and leaves many questions unanswered.
 
with some truthers, CTers, it is peer pressure and not being an individual

That's a fair question and I appreciate the civility.

I was just like you or anyone else after 9/11. I believed the official story, but even later that day when I talked to the friends and family who live and work in NYC (I was born in Manhasset and grew up in Queens and Jersey, went to college in NY), I was very curious how the operation was pulled off. What an audacious operation. I figured the story would eventually be told.

I had no reason to doubt the official story and even rejected the first hints of conspiracy theories.

First, a very close friend of mine who lives in Manhattan and filmed the towers burning from the roof of the building he was editing in, asked me to check out a website about Flight 93. It raised many significant questions.

Then after the 2004 election a DVD was floating around and the drummer of the band I was playing in at the time asked me to watch it. I looked at the cover and said, I'm interested in internet conspiracy theories. No, he said watch it. The four hour plus DVD raised many significant questions.

I immediately read the 9/11 Commission Report and anything I could get my hands on, both official and alternative explanations. The official story changes frequently, is not supported by evidence and leaves many questions unanswered.
You fall for false ideas. So? You need to use some of that scientific reasoning you alluded to.

Please list the changes in the official story. Please show the lack of evidence to support 19 terrorist in 4 planes doing what happen on 9/11.
The truth is 9/11 truth has no facts or evidence to support the truther ideas you now brandish around with out regard for their validity.
 
Last edited:
I immediately read the 9/11 Commission Report and anything I could get my hands on, both official and alternative explanations. The official story changes frequently, is not supported by evidence and leaves many questions unanswered.


Thank you for your reply. If you don't mind I'd like to ask another question. Let's say hypothetically, the evidence doesn't stack up. Because of this, what comes next? Do you think that there will be a new investigation? Or perhaps an investigation into the questions that were not answered satisfactorily? Any option I have not listed is fine as well.
 
RedIbis,

Please list your unanswered questions here. I'm sure, collectively, we can answer them for you. If that were to happen, would you consider accepting what the evidence proves?

Thanks,
HyJinX
 
1. "Couldn't give a damn." Giving a damn means you actually care. Sorry, one of my pet peeves.

Thanks. I share the affliction of close proofreading for accuracy.


2. You say you're interested in how science gets stacked next to the official story as if this is some radical right-wing board instead of one that relies on science and logic. If the numbers didn't add up, the people here would be the first to question it .

The lack of skeptical questioning and objectivity is the most disappointing and surprising aspect of this forum. If anything, a lot of the posters here rely on bluster, appeal to authority, and ad hominem. Skepticism, ironically, is in short supply.

Unfortunately for the movement, science stacks up a heck of a lot better to the "official version" than it does against ANY 9/11 conspiracy theory, or even any element of a 9/11 conspiracy theory.

I disagree where is the proof that science supports Flight 93 absorbed by dirt, yet still spreading debris up to eight miles?

How does science support the sudden collapse of WTC 7 (spare me the quotes how "the word" got out to firefighters that the bldg would collapse)?

How does science support TWO very rapid, symetrical building collapses after burning for 56 and 110 mins? Even NIST admitted that no core column it tested reached temps above 250C.

How does science support the presence of eutectic reaction in a gravity driven collapse?

I'm still waiting on NIST to explain that one.
 
OP answer - peer pressure causes truthers to pop up

I disagree where is the proof that science supports Flight 93 absorbed by dirt, yet still spreading debris up to eight miles?

How does science support the presence of eutectic reaction in a gravity driven collapse?

I'm still waiting on NIST to explain that one.
Flight 93 is what high speed impacts are like into the ground. Ask any one who is not a flaming truther. Give me a list of all the debris found away from the impact of 93. List every thing you have please. In a high speed impact many things are ejected. But you will find the debris found far, over 2500 feet, away from the impact are papers and light objects. Show me the list, or get your truther friends to show them.

You do not even understand what a eutectic reaction is. Show me the pieces that had it? Then explain what it means to 9/11. Explain why you think it means something?

If you did not see his post, his reason for dropping rational thought is peer pressure. His buddies are CTers so he is a CTer. So after seeing your posts, you have fallen into a fact less peer pressure reason for being a truther with no facts.
 
Thank you for the welcome Hokulele!

You very well may be right, but I thought that at some point that someone had to ask themselves "Why am I doing this?" I mean, for your average person posting on the LC forums, the answer may be as simple as "to fit into a group," but that explanation I don't think really covers the people that have been in the group for a while. IMHO, of course.


I think RedIbis' responses to your questions in this thread (or avoidance of the same) demonstrates my theory pretty well. ;)
 
I disagree where is the proof that science supports Flight 93 absorbed by dirt, yet still spreading debris up to eight miles?

Where is your proof that the plane was "absorbed by dirt".
Also have the airlines who have the remains of the planes ever asked why they're not the "right one".
 
Hello, TheRedWorm. Sorry to see that the RedIbis is still at it. I have him on "ignore" but can see his quoted posts.

That's quite an honor!

Think about it for a minute. The great Gravy refuses to engage in discussion with me.

Have I been rude? Have I been grossly inaccurate?

I don't think I can be accused of being unreasonable.

Perhaps my statements are clear and my questions are valid. I suspect that is why there is so much vitriol and juvenile behavior.
 
Thank you for your reply. If you don't mind I'd like to ask another question.

Thank you for proving that there are calm, respectful people who are interested in rational discussion here.

Let's say hypothetically, the evidence doesn't stack up. Because of this, what comes next? Do you think that there will be a new investigation?.

No. I'm too cynical to think that an independent, thorough comprehensive investigation can ever take place. For one thing, Each crime scene has been destroyed, scoured, cleansed, gone.

I am, however, optimistic that there is still enough photo, videographic, forensic, and eyewitness testimony to corroborate the theory that the WTC was a CD.

Or perhaps an investigation into the questions that were not answered satisfactorily? Any option I have not listed is fine as well.

Those are ongoing, independently. A lot of the people that get mocked on these threads are actually doing the hard research, interviews, FOIA requests, steel samples.

You can't expect that if the "Inside Job" theory is true that the perpetrators would conduct a thorough investigation. No, they would stall, underfund, refuse to testify under oath, etc.

Honestly, have you read the 9/11 Commission Report? Does it answer all of your questions specifically about the day of 9/11?
 
you should try some facts one day

That's quite an honor!

Think about it for a minute. The great Gravy refuses to engage in discussion with me.

Have I been rude? Have I been grossly inaccurate?

I don't think I can be accused of being unreasonable.

Perhaps my statements are clear and my questions are valid. I suspect that is why there is so much vitriol and juvenile behavior.
You never answer questions. You never presented the list of debris in PA. You are very inaccurate, saying vaporized plane is very inaccurate. You never use facts and evidence just talk. Go ahead try to answer some question today. But you will not, why?

You statements are fact less and show extreme immaturity or lack of experience and knowledge. You have been peer pressured, as you told us, in to the land of lies known as 9/11 truth.

You flood bs ideas on 9/11 without one single piece of evidence. Your lack of facts and your persistence to spew false ideas is tiresome. You have no facts and you can't even back up a single statement you make with evidence. You just make up stuff and talk about it, no facts included. It may work with people who are dumb enough to believe, but most rational people are not fooled by your junk on 9/11.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom